Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To counterfeit my daughters Christmas presents?

259 replies

Wazzitnow · 24/10/2023 21:21

OK, so she's into some obscure person ATM. Shes autistic and her people of interest changes bi yearly.

Right now it's this person who has a clothing range that is only available in the USA and is crazy expensive. $100 for a hoodie "$40 for a Tshirt type thing.

She's never seen his merch in real life and it's really cheap iron on kind of stuff.

And his inside label tag is very simple.

I have a printing machine and could very easily forge the items and make the label for inside the collar too.

I don't want to spend that much money on some obscure Tshirt with 1 word on just for the label.

But in true autistic teen style this is all she wants.

I'd get charged import fees too.

It's unlikely she would ever know because ei doubt she will ever come across a real piece of merch from him

And the style he has along with the label he has means it would be super easy to make and there would really be no way for her to know.

I wouldn't be selling them obviously. Just a few items, couple of Tshirts and a hoodie for her.

Would be around £35 quid instead of £200+!

And I know she won't be into him by summer either which makes me even more reluctant.

OP posts:
WhyteGoodnite · 25/10/2023 17:28

Flickersy · 25/10/2023 17:12

No it isn't.

Copying something for your own use is legal.

Ripping off someone's design to sell and make a quick buck absolutely is illegal.

Cakes are the best example - a child wants a particular mermaid cake (or whatever), parent can't afford it so makes their own mermaid cake. Child wants a particular character costume, parent can't afford it so makes their own version.

Completely legal and above board.

Incorrect. It is illegal to manufacture OR sell counterfeit goods. Obviously no-one is going to bother to prosecute OP for making a one-off knockoff for her kid, but it's still thievery.

BethDuttonsTwin · 25/10/2023 17:26

PostItInABook · 25/10/2023 16:31

I’m autistic and think this is an appalling, horrible thing to do.
Just don’t get it if you can’t afford it but don’t fucking go out of your way to deceive and trick her.

Absolutely this. Genuinely surprised at how many think this is ok.

jhy · 25/10/2023 17:18

As a parent of a child with autism, she will know!
My Dc recognises every single detail it's insane. I also remember when I was younger, I brought my sister a replica item and when she found out she was so disappointed it ruined the gift and the thought; she wish I had got her nothing instead.
As it's Christmas I would say, get the original thing for a gift. Regarding the price, I'd explain if she wants other things then she has to pick what she really wants and maybe not have Nike trainers for example.

newdad2023 · 25/10/2023 17:14

Good for you! She will love them I'm sure.

Flickersy · 25/10/2023 17:12

WhyteGoodnite · 25/10/2023 01:57

Would you break into a shop and steal the desired items if you knew you would get away with it?
What you are suggesting is no different. This is someone else's work, however ‘simple’ you may deem it to be.

No it isn't.

Copying something for your own use is legal.

Ripping off someone's design to sell and make a quick buck absolutely is illegal.

Cakes are the best example - a child wants a particular mermaid cake (or whatever), parent can't afford it so makes their own mermaid cake. Child wants a particular character costume, parent can't afford it so makes their own version.

Completely legal and above board.

H007 · 25/10/2023 16:59

I think you can make it yourself, but you have to be honest with her about it too. You can’t give someone a fake and tell them it’s real. It’s just morally wrong. You can however tell them you’ve made it to look exactly like the real deal.

Fran2023 · 25/10/2023 16:53

Yes, do it. But don’t do what my mother did - sent me a Valentines Card when I was in Primary School and all the popular girls were getting them - then told a neighbour all about it. Her daughter was in my class and I was teased for months.

Her parenting didn’t improve.

LaurieStrode · 25/10/2023 16:48

This thread is bonkers.

she wants a shirt with a banana on it, make her a banana shirt. No angst necessary.

It's a good opportunity to teach her that paying an absurd (if not obscene) markup to get a celebrity logo or Disney brand or designer marque on a product isn't smart. It's gullible.

There is no way I would allow my child to be sucked into the 'branded' consumerism that makes so many people easy targets of marketing that induces money-wasting worship of branded merchandise.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 25/10/2023 16:45

Why not? Good idea.

As you (and other pps) already said: Use the same amount of money you would usually spend and buy her some other presents as well.

PostItInABook · 25/10/2023 16:31

I’m autistic and think this is an appalling, horrible thing to do.
Just don’t get it if you can’t afford it but don’t fucking go out of your way to deceive and trick her.

Paperpurple · 25/10/2023 16:31

I'd feel too guilty to do this. You'd be lying to her basically.
I get that it makes sense financially though. Could you get just 1 real t-shirt plus the other gifts?

LanaL · 25/10/2023 16:25

100% yes do it! I don’t see how you are hurting anyone if you aren’t selling them , or buying fakes . These people shouldn’t be able to get away with the prices they charge for such basic things !

My son is autistic and he’s the same - he has fads and it’s always something in America ! There was one show he was into and I paid loads for a T shirt of it from America one Christmas and he wore it about 3 times as a new fad started just after !
I used to have a cricut machine and he wanted a T-shirt that sounded just like you describe - it was a phrase just in a basic font and another was a brand , again a basic font so I made them myself - they looked exactly the same ! He knew no different, he loved them and I saved myself about £100!

BethDuttonsTwin · 25/10/2023 16:23

My Mum used to do similar to this. I’d want one bag, one expensive bag or item of clothing but she’d refuse to buy it, but would buy loads of bits of crap that she thought were similar and spend near on the same amount. I hated it, I always knew and would never use the stuff. The only person who felt good about my gifts was my Mum and she would just have completely wasted her money.

I also have an autistic teen dd, she’d know and your dd probably will too.

SchadenfreudeIstMeinMittelname · 25/10/2023 16:18

It's perfectly ok to tell a child 'no, I won't be buying you X because I can't afford to/it's overpriced'.

LovelyGreenCushions · 25/10/2023 16:10

what range is it?In the Usa next week and could pick up a t-shirt?

Goodornot · 25/10/2023 13:59

OP has decided to do it so moot now. One other point to consider is the DD will think her mum spent hundreds on this rubbish merch and also bought the Nike trainers etc.

She'll be upping her budget of what she asks for next.

Sennelier1 · 25/10/2023 13:25

Make the "merchandise" yourself, I know I would. Over £200 is a lot for a few basic Tshirts and a hoodie. If you can afford so then give her the art supplies she asks for too, but then you can really see how much you get for your money.

Goodornot · 25/10/2023 12:04

Pezdeoro41 · 25/10/2023 11:54

If you ever gave your kids things from Santa Claus, you have already “tricked your child”.

Yes but this child is older and knows santa doesn't exist.

She is old enough to be told that hundreds of pounds is not being spent on poor quality clothes just because.

Bellaboo01 · 25/10/2023 12:03

Who is the obscure person? I am assuming that they arent that obscure as they have merch etc etc.

I personally wouldn't. She will be embarrassed as a fruit of the loom t-shirt with Mum printing the copy logo on the front will be so different to the real thing. £40 for a t-shirt is quite normal for merch so i would just by the real thing or not.

But, you know your daughter so if you think that she will be happy with it then, thats great and go for it.

I also agree that it is a stupid amount to pay for these people's merch!!

Natbro · 25/10/2023 11:57

Also what are you going to do for the packaging and labels? Unless she is under the age of 10 she is going to know... this just seems a great way to embarrass her 🤦‍♂️

Pezdeoro41 · 25/10/2023 11:54

Candymay · 24/10/2023 22:40

I totally agree with this. I am surprised that so many people are saying do it. I could not trick my child. Especially as she would be so excited.
could you explain that you are happy to make her the same items? So that she can wear the clothes she wants without having to import them?
if it were me I’d buy them for her.

If you ever gave your kids things from Santa Claus, you have already “tricked your child”.

backtowinter · 25/10/2023 11:51

Merch is such a rip off I would absolutely do it.

As long as others don't notice and pick on her though - that's be my only worry

Natbro · 25/10/2023 11:46

I personally wouldn't do it... i would be concerned she would find out or someone else would realise and tell her.

thegreylady · 25/10/2023 11:42

Definitely do it it will give her the same pleasure as a real one and she will be none the wiser. What a lovely mum you are to go to all that trouble to make her Christmas.

Private1980 · 25/10/2023 11:32

Why don't you explain like someone else has said on here that they don't ship to the UK and if they did it would be to expensive and offer to do it instead say to her I think we could print these together and see if she'd like that