Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To counterfeit my daughters Christmas presents?

259 replies

Wazzitnow · 24/10/2023 21:21

OK, so she's into some obscure person ATM. Shes autistic and her people of interest changes bi yearly.

Right now it's this person who has a clothing range that is only available in the USA and is crazy expensive. $100 for a hoodie "$40 for a Tshirt type thing.

She's never seen his merch in real life and it's really cheap iron on kind of stuff.

And his inside label tag is very simple.

I have a printing machine and could very easily forge the items and make the label for inside the collar too.

I don't want to spend that much money on some obscure Tshirt with 1 word on just for the label.

But in true autistic teen style this is all she wants.

I'd get charged import fees too.

It's unlikely she would ever know because ei doubt she will ever come across a real piece of merch from him

And the style he has along with the label he has means it would be super easy to make and there would really be no way for her to know.

I wouldn't be selling them obviously. Just a few items, couple of Tshirts and a hoodie for her.

Would be around £35 quid instead of £200+!

And I know she won't be into him by summer either which makes me even more reluctant.

OP posts:
CreativeNeurodivergent · 27/10/2023 21:41

Tbh I would ask her if she'd be cool with a version you've made - if she's already made her own posters etc she may not care if it's the actual merch or just looks like it (I'm autistic and wouldn't have cared either way). Might even be a good precedent to set!

Allinadayswork80 · 27/10/2023 16:54

If they didn’t want people to replicate they shouldn’t make them so bloody expensive! Especially for the naff quality they probably are. I bought my niece a original merch T-shirt for Xmas last year for a singer she loves which was crazy expensive for just a cheap tshirt with a simple print on it. Wish I’d have had the ability to replicate.

DarklySparkly · 27/10/2023 15:19

Totally do it! I love that you can!

Manthide · 27/10/2023 15:07

You do know these items are made in factories in China or Vietnam etc and the celebrity has nothing to do with them. I'm pretty sure they wouldn't individually touch each item or visit the factory - they just allow their name to be used for a price!

Manthide · 27/10/2023 15:02

Would your dd mind if you told her you made it yourself? My autistic ds wouldn't mind in the least if he was getting the same thing basically. Of course if the t shirt was actually designer and had entailed creative input then I would say no but sticking a word on a t-shirt! My dd3 had a thing about Billy Eilish a few years ago and most of the merc was just something basic with her name on it.

NicolaPower64 · 27/10/2023 13:07

If I was you I would do it, but I would tell her I can't afford it and so I made her it.

Ineke · 27/10/2023 11:24

I would do it but, be warned, if she thinks she is getting the really expensive stuff, T shirt, and the cake you made, where will she learn about financial planning and that money does not grow on trees. You could tell her, after she had got the T shirt, loved it and couldn’t tell the difference, that actually you had made it yourself as you really wanted her to have the trainers too as well as the art stuff and you didn’t have the money for everything. She will need to appreciate the cost of living one day, and if she thinks that you can afford to get all that she wants, she will have a rude awakening!

Lavender14 · 27/10/2023 11:18

I think you'd need to be really confident in your ability to make it look really good. It does feel a bit ick for me in the copyright respect, I know it's just words etc but someone has still put the work into designing that.

If it were me, I'd get her one of the cheaper items and then other things for Xmas. I don't think the alternative would sit quite right with me and I'd feel a little guilty when I saw her wearing it.

Plus boundaries are still boundaries, if she asks for something super expensive its reasonable to say no it's too expensive and we can't afford it, or you can have some of it but not all because that's too much money. That's a good life lesson for her to learn.

Isthisrealorjustfantasy · 27/10/2023 11:17

I have fallen for this before when dd was younger & prob ND but still waiting for now adult dd to start the diagnosis process. I’d prob say that the items can’t be sent here tbh - I wouldn’t be able to replicate - or be arsed to do it!!

Bushgirl · 27/10/2023 11:12

This is a bad thing to do for so many reasons. First of all your child will know. The majority of people with ASD will have likely researched the item of clothing down to the last detail. Possibly including thread count, what the label is made of etc , to the tiniest detail. You said your DD is not on social media, but clearly is able to research what she wants online. I don't claim to know your daughter, but I do know mine, and even if I've got this wrong, if she ever finds out what you did at best you are going to look very sheepish but at worst you will have lost your DD's trust. I understand your reasoning but honestly, if you don't want to buy these for her because of the costs ( which is a perfectly good reason) then you should explain that, rather than try to trick her.
I'm not even going to start on design theft etc. You may (justifiably) feel that the items are overpriced - many things are, but that IS the price, and making a counterfeit copy is morally and legally wrong.
Maybe you should discuss this with your DD, and if you do decide to make fake copies for her at least do it with her knowledge and agreement. Trust me, if you don't, and it backfires you will regret it.

JaneFarrier · 27/10/2023 10:12

I had a not dissimilar situation last year and would advocate being open with the daughter. My children are both ND.

DD was desperate for a costume of a specific Marvel character. Official versions are only marketed in child sizes and while she's a preteen, she's very tall. I explained to her that we could not buy one in her size and would a homemade one be OK? She said yes, and we had fun putting the finishing touches on the outfit (she got all the parts to unwrap). It helps that in the comics the costume is meant to be improvised by the character too, so we were able to get pretty close.

DS (autistic) would actually rather have a cheapo version of something as he hates to waste money and will get anxious if he thinks people are spending a lot on him. He's been very happy with secondhand computer games and plain T-shirts or baseball caps with sew-on patches representing his interests (you often can't buy clothing for these specific things, but Etsy has tons of patches available). He knows what they are and where they come from.

pollymere · 27/10/2023 09:11

Mine wanted a pink hoodie with a weird piece of artwork and the words tax evasion on. I bought the original because of the artwork. A hoodie with just tax evasion written on it though? I'd have probably got it done locally.

I'd say you wanted to make sure it had a nice fabric if questioned... Nothing worse than scratchy fabric.

WillimNot · 27/10/2023 06:56

Vinted may help?

My DD is hyper-fixated on clothes from Hot Topic in the US but from that whole MySpace era 2006/2008. They also like some modern stuff and some Skelanimals that you can't even buy anymore
Bought a fake bag off eBay and Vinted has been a godsend for the tops. I would not have an issue copying some if it made her happy and I had the skills.

AuntMarch · 27/10/2023 00:45

Wazzitnow · 24/10/2023 22:26

OK :) Thanks for your input :)

Very valid input at that. Amazed how may people are so comfortable lying to their kids.

ActDottie · 26/10/2023 22:59

Oh I’d totally do it!

Goldbar · 26/10/2023 22:08

I would give her money towards it so she can save up for it. If she's still obsessed by the time she has the money, then she can buy it. But she may think twice if actually it's going to cost all her Christmas money and her pocket money for a while.

Goodornot · 26/10/2023 21:58

A big part of it will be knowing it came from them. Knowing they made it and touched it. Mums counterfeit is shit in comparison and she'd probably rather not have it at all.

RainbowNinja77 · 26/10/2023 21:58

Did you mind?

RainbowNinja77 · 26/10/2023 21:57

Why would she be doing it because the daughter is autistic? That explained the revolving interests, not the reason for making an item. Just don’t lie if ever asked directly.

RainbowNinja77 · 26/10/2023 21:55

I say do it - definitely. She wants the item not the authenticity. However, if she ever asks you directly, tell her the truth. Don’t lie to an autistic person - it could make her not trust you for a very long time.

timesaretight · 26/10/2023 20:39

Hmmm

Yeetpetite · 26/10/2023 20:16

My daughter is autistic and has asked for ridiculously overpriced stuff from her favourite you tubers (also changes regularly) and I did the same as you or I found ‘reps’ as the kids call them, and she was super happy with her presents and I wasn’t super skint. And Im sure the quality will be better too if you do it yourself. Good luck 😊

kazlau · 26/10/2023 19:14

Absolutely do it - but don’t get caught by your DD actually doing it!!!

Baba197 · 26/10/2023 12:26

Do it! My friend did similar she got it printed onto a hoodie via one of the online places that put photos onto hoodies etc and her 10 yr old can’t tell the difference. Is it wrong- yes maybe but I also think it’s wrong that these so called influencers are allowed to charge so much for what will no doubt be made of rubbish material! There are certain things i would pay out for but not these

Ilovesmesomefriedchicken · 26/10/2023 10:39

Also this