Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I or is DH Christmas

187 replies

SouthGate7 · 24/10/2023 17:04

We have previously rotated Christmas days so one year with my family following year with DH. He only has SIL with family extended family don't get together. I have 2 sis brother lots of children. Whoever we haven't spent Christmas day with we see boxing day so see both families over Christmas.

MIL passed away early January after 6 weeks in hospital. So very difficult december for all involved. Christmas Day was at ours apart from DH and SIL visiting mil -who was ill but they weren't aware of seriousness then. Boxing day at my sister's in afternoon although DH then went to hospital in afternoon.

DH had an extremely emeshed relationship with MIL and to a certain extent SIL. He is still having counseling now 9 months later.

All families live fairly close. This year we would be due to visit my family for Christmas Dinner then boxing day with SIL her husband and two children. My Dsis is hosting and asked us to let her know by next week.

DH has then said he needs to check what SIL is doing and whether she is seeing her in laws, I said about boxing day he then said they would be going to football as they are season ticket holders, he thinks as Christmas last year doesn't count and SIL can't do boxing day we should see them Christmas day.

I feel aggrieved, I understand this year will be hard but I feel I am now doing what I have done most of my marriage with DH and MIL. He put her first the majority of the time and we still are working through this. I can see this pattern being repeated with SIL. They see each other a lot even prior to mil passing

I also think it's not my fault SIL is going to football ?

I didn't see my family much last year due to everything going on and would like a break.

Our DC love seeing either family.

Any suggestions !?

OP posts:
sandyhappypeople · 25/10/2023 15:27

BIossomtoes · 25/10/2023 14:56

You can really tell which posters here have experienced bereavement.

Herein lies the problem with a post like this, I lost my mum at Christmas a few years ago and can’t imagine my partner digging his heels in the following year saying well we did ‘your family’ last year now it’s my turn!

but OPs problem seems to be a long standing one, and rather then her feeling resentful because of this one thing, it’s the culmination of years of feeling this way and it’s definitely clouding the issue.

IMO it’s unreasonable to offload all this resentment at a time when your partner is still grieving, the time to raise it is literally ANY TIME up to the point that MIL died, you’ve had years to put yourself and especially the kids first, but you’ve allowed them to play second fiddle (god knows why!), so why make a stand now at the ONLY time you could actually be considered unreasonable for doing so?

SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 15:18

mindutopia · 25/10/2023 14:56

It's your family this year, but I think it would be okay for dh to pop over later and see SIL, if he wants. That said, honestly, if my mum had just passed away and it was the first year without her and trying to find a new normal, I can't say I'd be thrilled at the thought of hosting my sibling and his whole family for Christmas. I'd be grateful it wasn't my year and to get to focus on something I really enjoy (football on Boxing Day) instead of tidying up the post-Christmas chaos.

Dh isnt saying for sil to host it would be me again dh doesn't do it

OP posts:
dcsp · 25/10/2023 15:15

IDontLoveTheWayYouLie · 24/10/2023 17:19

I'd do his family this year and then yours for 2 years running.

This may be a sensible compromise.

It's clearly your family's turn. But given that this is his (and his sister's) first Christmas since the death of his mother, it'd be reasonable to offer to swap this year and next year.

What's not reasonable is to say that last year doesn't count.

BIossomtoes · 25/10/2023 14:56

You can really tell which posters here have experienced bereavement.

mindutopia · 25/10/2023 14:56

It's your family this year, but I think it would be okay for dh to pop over later and see SIL, if he wants. That said, honestly, if my mum had just passed away and it was the first year without her and trying to find a new normal, I can't say I'd be thrilled at the thought of hosting my sibling and his whole family for Christmas. I'd be grateful it wasn't my year and to get to focus on something I really enjoy (football on Boxing Day) instead of tidying up the post-Christmas chaos.

Onabench · 25/10/2023 14:55

If my OH wanted to se his family on Xmas day the year following the death of a parent i would absolutely do that, no question.

SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 14:51

Pezdeoro41 · 25/10/2023 14:43

This. And they didn’t really have last year did they, as you said it was at yours but they were both at the hospital for much of it? Personally I’d say that one count didn’t count either way and that they should have this one together.

Also I just think compassion should come over the rota here.

i don’t know your situation obviously but is it possible you’re being influenced by your feelings about your DH’s family? I don’t think it’s crazy he’s having counselling 9 months on, it’s ok to be hit hard by the loss of your mother (as it to be close to your sister and mum).

Counselling is for emeshed and unhealthy relationship on his mother. Not just bereavement. Anxiety and OCD lots of issues.

There are many many ways I given in and i have spent much of my life being second best to mil andso have children sometimes I won't have that transferred to sil.

SIL husband feels similar
Christmas day they spent and hour at lunchtime and an hour in the evening otherwise here. Boxing day I was at my families DH was at hospital most of afternoon

OP posts:
SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 14:48

Gymnopedie · 25/10/2023 14:15

You’re making this all about you and aren’t coming across well. It seems to be all about what you want you and to hell with anyone else.

But it seems like the DH has been doing this for himself and his mum for the last 20 years. The OP has always had to come second to what his mum wants, no plans made unless they fit in with what his mum is doing. And now that is being transferred to SIL so his attitude isn't going to change.

OP if this Christmas is what's finally made the scales fall from your eyes and you now realise just how much you've bent over backwards for DH and MIL and will have to keep doing with SIL, then maybe it's done you a favour. Start standing up for yourself, and maybe even think about whether you want to stay in a relationship with someone who will never put you first.

Edited

@Gymnopedie i think this the issue and counselling made me realise what a soft touch i have been over the years. DH does pretty even more what he wants how long do you use grief as a reason to be selfish?

OP posts:
SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 14:46

DaisyMaisyFaisy · 25/10/2023 14:10

You’re making this all about you and aren’t coming across well. It seems to be all about what you want you and to hell with anyone else.

DH and SIL lost their mother. Of course he doesn’t want to leave her alone. Plus he will probably struggle being around a big group without her. My ex husband would’ve struggled to have had Christmas with my family a few months after his mum died, it was all too raw and reminded him of what he’d lost.

Why don’t you host for everyone but get everyone to help? Someone cooks the main, someone else desert, and someone else on clearing up duty.

You sound very bitter about things, it doesn’t always work out that you spend one year with one and one with the other. I didn’t spend Christmas Day with my family for about eight years when I was married. It’s about compromise

I hosted last year. SIL wont be alone she has family and an in laws offer to. I am not worried about how it comes across. There's always what ifs etc. Why is it my family and children that does the budging for a football match too ?

I have forgone previous christmas days covid etc we had his DM and didn't see my family at all that was a hard decision

OP posts:
Pezdeoro41 · 25/10/2023 14:43

UndercoverCop · 24/10/2023 17:09

So this is your DHs and SILs first Christmas without their mother? I'd prioritise them spending it together tbh. You can see yours boxing day, and Christmas day 2024

Edited

This. And they didn’t really have last year did they, as you said it was at yours but they were both at the hospital for much of it? Personally I’d say that one count didn’t count either way and that they should have this one together.

Also I just think compassion should come over the rota here.

i don’t know your situation obviously but is it possible you’re being influenced by your feelings about your DH’s family? I don’t think it’s crazy he’s having counselling 9 months on, it’s ok to be hit hard by the loss of your mother (as it to be close to your sister and mum).

indigovapour · 25/10/2023 14:29

Cas112 · 25/10/2023 13:58

I would really let it slide, its there first Christmas without there mum. Stop being selfish, would you not want the same consideration for yourself if it was vice versa?

This would be my view - you risk making a rod for your own back. We'll all lose someone at some point and Christmas is an important time for a lot of families.

If you won't flex you can expect absolute rigidity in return when it's your go I guess.

Gymnopedie · 25/10/2023 14:15

You’re making this all about you and aren’t coming across well. It seems to be all about what you want you and to hell with anyone else.

But it seems like the DH has been doing this for himself and his mum for the last 20 years. The OP has always had to come second to what his mum wants, no plans made unless they fit in with what his mum is doing. And now that is being transferred to SIL so his attitude isn't going to change.

OP if this Christmas is what's finally made the scales fall from your eyes and you now realise just how much you've bent over backwards for DH and MIL and will have to keep doing with SIL, then maybe it's done you a favour. Start standing up for yourself, and maybe even think about whether you want to stay in a relationship with someone who will never put you first.

DaisyMaisyFaisy · 25/10/2023 14:10

You’re making this all about you and aren’t coming across well. It seems to be all about what you want you and to hell with anyone else.

DH and SIL lost their mother. Of course he doesn’t want to leave her alone. Plus he will probably struggle being around a big group without her. My ex husband would’ve struggled to have had Christmas with my family a few months after his mum died, it was all too raw and reminded him of what he’d lost.

Why don’t you host for everyone but get everyone to help? Someone cooks the main, someone else desert, and someone else on clearing up duty.

You sound very bitter about things, it doesn’t always work out that you spend one year with one and one with the other. I didn’t spend Christmas Day with my family for about eight years when I was married. It’s about compromise

Cas112 · 25/10/2023 13:58

I would really let it slide, its there first Christmas without there mum. Stop being selfish, would you not want the same consideration for yourself if it was vice versa?

Dishee · 25/10/2023 13:48

Go to your sister's. For my lovely Mum we had a feeling it might be her last Christmas (cancer) for my lovely MIL we had no idea that the last Christmas was indeed her last Christmas.

So on that basis alone, spend your Christmas with the people you actually want to spend it with. It is the turn of your family. Go there.

Your SIL is prioritising the footbal on Boxing Day so she can make arrangements to see you all either Christmas eve or 27th or whenever she is free after that. You are always coming third, now you are coming second, so choose to put yourself first. Go be with your Mum who has lost her Dad.

Anabella321 · 25/10/2023 13:44

My MIL died in February. I told DH we'd do whatever he wants this Christmas even though I really want to spend it with my family as it's my baby's first Christmas.

But I thought it will be a hard day for him and it's not about me. We'll have plenty more Christmases but this is a particularly sad one for him so he should do whatever gives him the most comfort.

Willyoujustbequiet · 25/10/2023 13:36

Its his first Christmas without his mum. It will be incredibly difficult for him.

Yabvu.

SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 13:32

LifeExperience · 25/10/2023 13:31

My mum and dad had this problem. My dad was enmeshed with his mother. After years of frustration on my mum's part it all came to the head the night after my brother's funeral. He had died unexpectedly and we were all distraught. That night my grandmother called my father and told him that he needed to come stay with her because she was upset. He was going to go and leave my mother alone grieving for her dead son.

Mum told my dad that if he went to stay with her he could stay there forever and she would be filing for divorce the next day. He wisely chose to stay with his wife.

The moral of the story is don't let it get that far. Yes, your dh is grieving, but grief doesn't mean that he gets to put his wife second. If he is allowed to transfer his enmeshment to his sister, you will never come first, and a wife has the right to come first in her husband's life.

Thank you for understanding and i am sorry for your loss.

OP posts:
SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 13:31

RobinStrike · 25/10/2023 13:26

It's really sad you feel so angry about Christmas arrangements. It sounds as though whatever is decided, you and your husband will both be angry and upset on the day and resentful of whatever has been arranged.
I would want to help your husband cope with his first Christmas without his mother, but not want to have the children have a miserable Christmas with lots of adult reminiscences and tears. If you explain this to DH, and suggest he sees his DS and then comes across to your sister's to join you and DC after he has seen them as this would be better for your children would he accept it? He has to take some responsibility for ensuring his own children have a good Christmas. Maybe you could invite SIL family to a brunch before the football?
I don't really know how you solve this but the overriding emotions in your replies are anger and resentment, rather than any love and concern for your husband. I feel you need to let some of this go or your marriage won't last beyond Christmas.

It's not anger aboit Christmas itself just the lack of acknowledgment about any body esles feelings. I asked about Christmas a month ago too to not leave it till last minute but it's not fair to say last year was a right off. And I have had many years of bending over to accommodate him and his family but yes our marriage isn't in a good place at all.

OP posts:
LifeExperience · 25/10/2023 13:31

My mum and dad had this problem. My dad was enmeshed with his mother. After years of frustration on my mum's part it all came to the head the night after my brother's funeral. He had died unexpectedly and we were all distraught. That night my grandmother called my father and told him that he needed to come stay with her because she was upset. He was going to go and leave my mother alone grieving for her dead son.

Mum told my dad that if he went to stay with her he could stay there forever and she would be filing for divorce the next day. He wisely chose to stay with his wife.

The moral of the story is don't let it get that far. Yes, your dh is grieving, but grief doesn't mean that he gets to put his wife second. If he is allowed to transfer his enmeshment to his sister, you will never come first, and a wife has the right to come first in her husband's life.

RobinStrike · 25/10/2023 13:26

It's really sad you feel so angry about Christmas arrangements. It sounds as though whatever is decided, you and your husband will both be angry and upset on the day and resentful of whatever has been arranged.
I would want to help your husband cope with his first Christmas without his mother, but not want to have the children have a miserable Christmas with lots of adult reminiscences and tears. If you explain this to DH, and suggest he sees his DS and then comes across to your sister's to join you and DC after he has seen them as this would be better for your children would he accept it? He has to take some responsibility for ensuring his own children have a good Christmas. Maybe you could invite SIL family to a brunch before the football?
I don't really know how you solve this but the overriding emotions in your replies are anger and resentment, rather than any love and concern for your husband. I feel you need to let some of this go or your marriage won't last beyond Christmas.

SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 13:06

cheddercherry · 25/10/2023 10:48

To be honest I think it sounds like the kids would be better spending it as planned at your family’s. You said upthread there’d likely be lots of tears and upset (understandably) between DH and SIL and I think the kids have also gone through a loss and it’s only fair to try and give them a happier Xmas than last year. They don’t need to be sat sullen with all the grown ups in bits.

Your husband can go and spend time with his sister if that’s what he needs this year. And if I’m being honest if sister is already firm in her plans without a flex then i don’t see why your entire family has to bend to suit? She’s obviously ok enough to be making her own plans for how she’s doing Christmas moving forward.

I think this might be the option really. They have had a tough start to year and home life hasn't been great so it might be a suggestion I make. Although dh wouldbt allow it Idont think

OP posts:
Themerrygoround · 25/10/2023 10:53

This

cheddercherry · 25/10/2023 10:48

To be honest I think it sounds like the kids would be better spending it as planned at your family’s. You said upthread there’d likely be lots of tears and upset (understandably) between DH and SIL and I think the kids have also gone through a loss and it’s only fair to try and give them a happier Xmas than last year. They don’t need to be sat sullen with all the grown ups in bits.

Your husband can go and spend time with his sister if that’s what he needs this year. And if I’m being honest if sister is already firm in her plans without a flex then i don’t see why your entire family has to bend to suit? She’s obviously ok enough to be making her own plans for how she’s doing Christmas moving forward.

SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 10:26

CurlewKate · 25/10/2023 08:37

I don't think it's "enmeshed" to want to spend the first Christmas without your mum with your sister...

This isn't but other behaviours are, it isn't just grief counselling hes having it's anxiety and emeshed behaviours.

Texting and calling each every day, despite living 10 minutes away, seeing each other on school runs etc. Making out they don't see each other much. Having to check what his sister is doing/if its OK with her before any commitments. This is just a surface glimpse of what life was like with MIL too

OP posts: