Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I or is DH Christmas

187 replies

SouthGate7 · 24/10/2023 17:04

We have previously rotated Christmas days so one year with my family following year with DH. He only has SIL with family extended family don't get together. I have 2 sis brother lots of children. Whoever we haven't spent Christmas day with we see boxing day so see both families over Christmas.

MIL passed away early January after 6 weeks in hospital. So very difficult december for all involved. Christmas Day was at ours apart from DH and SIL visiting mil -who was ill but they weren't aware of seriousness then. Boxing day at my sister's in afternoon although DH then went to hospital in afternoon.

DH had an extremely emeshed relationship with MIL and to a certain extent SIL. He is still having counseling now 9 months later.

All families live fairly close. This year we would be due to visit my family for Christmas Dinner then boxing day with SIL her husband and two children. My Dsis is hosting and asked us to let her know by next week.

DH has then said he needs to check what SIL is doing and whether she is seeing her in laws, I said about boxing day he then said they would be going to football as they are season ticket holders, he thinks as Christmas last year doesn't count and SIL can't do boxing day we should see them Christmas day.

I feel aggrieved, I understand this year will be hard but I feel I am now doing what I have done most of my marriage with DH and MIL. He put her first the majority of the time and we still are working through this. I can see this pattern being repeated with SIL. They see each other a lot even prior to mil passing

I also think it's not my fault SIL is going to football ?

I didn't see my family much last year due to everything going on and would like a break.

Our DC love seeing either family.

Any suggestions !?

OP posts:
BIossomtoes · 25/10/2023 22:14

SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 22:04

@blossomtoes

I think everyone deals with grief differently. How could you tell from replies who has lost anyone and what it means

Because those people who understand the pain of losing someone close, particularly a parent, expressed empathy with your bloke. It’s not about how you deal with grief, everyone who’s ever really felt it knows it’s like having a layer of skin removed, those who haven’t just don’t get it.

CrazyHedgehogLover · 25/10/2023 22:11

@SouthGate7 i have read your replies, hence me saying losing a grandparent is nowhere near like losing a parent..

I lost my grandfather before losing my dad, it in no way compared to the hurt I felt when losing my dad, I loved my grandfather obviously! Adored him, but it completely hit me differently..

your family should surely understand him wanting to see his family this year instead of them? Considering you mentioned your mum lost her dad.. (your grandfather) if I’m correct, she should be more than accommodating and understanding to the fact that yes, this year his family will naturally want to be together on there first Christmas after the loss.

yes the children understandably had a shitty December, your husband didn’t ask for his mum to pass away at that time of year? He didn’t ask to have to go up and down to the hospital? He didn’t ask for the complex situation between him and his mother either did he? Because who would ask for all these things exactly?

your kids will still equally have a good time, you can’t hide them from grief, it’s normal for people to show emotions, if that means your husband or SIL having a cry then so be it, the kids will understand that they are naturally missing someone🤷‍♀️

also the football, if they are season ticket holders then they quite clearly attend a lot of the football games, I don’t really see a huge issue just for this year to allow this tbh, they need each other right now.. I think it’s nice there giving each other the support.

SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 22:04

BIossomtoes · 25/10/2023 21:03

I got piled on for saying that but you definitely can.

@blossomtoes

I think everyone deals with grief differently. How could you tell from replies who has lost anyone and what it means

OP posts:
BIossomtoes · 25/10/2023 21:03

StampOnTheGround · 25/10/2023 21:02

Tbh you can tell the difference between people who have lost someone close and those that haven't.

Let him have this one OP.

I got piled on for saying that but you definitely can.

StampOnTheGround · 25/10/2023 21:02

Tbh you can tell the difference between people who have lost someone close and those that haven't.

Let him have this one OP.

SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 20:59

CrazyHedgehogLover · 25/10/2023 20:45

Sorry but you sound extremely selfish, my dad passed away 11yrs ago, it still hurts now having Christmas without him! You can’t compare losing a grandfather (although it’s still truly awful) to losing a parent and I can’t honestly believe your trying to compare the two of them.

his mum passed away less than a year ago and your honestly choosing now to battle about Christmas plans?

i actually think he has a valid point, this year should be his year, his mother was clearly very ill last Christmas so he obviously didn’t get much of a break either, going up and down to the hospital especially at that time of year is exhausting! I went up to my dad three times a day and he was in hospital for months!

you came on here and asked for opinions, a lot of people have said you should accept that his family will come first this year due to the loss and it being there first Christmas without there mum, however you’ve only listened to the people on here who are insisting he’s apparently no longer allowed to grieve and should be over it by now!

you both don’t sound very happy with each other, I would be devastated if I was in your DH situation and was told “naa you got to see your family last Christmas it’s my turn now” umm no, he was going to visit his poorly mother in hospital most of last Christmas or does that get forgotten about? He and his family probably couldn’t rest easy or actually have a good time because they might have been on edge waiting for the phone..

yes he should have this year, it makes no difference if his sister has in-laws/a husband? It’s not the same as having a brother/dad etc there with you who can completely understand the loss of a loved one in this way..

I am not insisting his grief is over but you are missing the complexity and like I have explained no it's not a happy relationship. However if sil doesn't or won't forgoe a football match how is that fair either ?

My children had a pretty crappy December too which I won't be repeating.
You clearly haven't read all my replies regarding my family amf grandad

It absolutely makes a difference she has her own children to consider too husband

OP posts:
SpudleyLass · 25/10/2023 20:49

Personally, I'd be happy to switch back to his year for this one and stand my ground the following year.

But we don't have this system in place, which really does cause a lot of arguments I feel. Both our families stay at home for Christmas Day and then work together to make it work for the rest of the season.

Your feelings are likely very justified, but I also can't imagine caring that it was ''my turn'' the year following a parental death.

You and the kids to your family and him to his sister's this year, would keep the rotation in place

CrazyHedgehogLover · 25/10/2023 20:45

Sorry but you sound extremely selfish, my dad passed away 11yrs ago, it still hurts now having Christmas without him! You can’t compare losing a grandfather (although it’s still truly awful) to losing a parent and I can’t honestly believe your trying to compare the two of them.

his mum passed away less than a year ago and your honestly choosing now to battle about Christmas plans?

i actually think he has a valid point, this year should be his year, his mother was clearly very ill last Christmas so he obviously didn’t get much of a break either, going up and down to the hospital especially at that time of year is exhausting! I went up to my dad three times a day and he was in hospital for months!

you came on here and asked for opinions, a lot of people have said you should accept that his family will come first this year due to the loss and it being there first Christmas without there mum, however you’ve only listened to the people on here who are insisting he’s apparently no longer allowed to grieve and should be over it by now!

you both don’t sound very happy with each other, I would be devastated if I was in your DH situation and was told “naa you got to see your family last Christmas it’s my turn now” umm no, he was going to visit his poorly mother in hospital most of last Christmas or does that get forgotten about? He and his family probably couldn’t rest easy or actually have a good time because they might have been on edge waiting for the phone..

yes he should have this year, it makes no difference if his sister has in-laws/a husband? It’s not the same as having a brother/dad etc there with you who can completely understand the loss of a loved one in this way..

SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 19:35

PizzaInThePiazza · 25/10/2023 17:14

Not all bereavement reactions are the same though. Not at all. Difficult relationships can result in a complex grief reaction.

I 🤔 the is true too

OP posts:
SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 17:30

PizzaInThePiazza · 25/10/2023 17:09

Relationships are complicated. This is clearly about much more than the death of the mother-in-law.

OP, I expect that all your life you have been last and left out of peoples consideration. When you were a child growing up in foster care and throughout the marriage. You have probably had many years having to compromise for his mum and sister.

Now his mum has died. It will bring all sorts of emotions to the fore. You don’t want the pattern continuing with his sister.

Last Christmas was difficult and I understand that you don’t want another difficult Christmas for your kids again this year. I expect most people with healthy family relationships Will see you as selfish. However, having worked in mental health for many years, I know that nothing is a simple as it seems within families.

And despite grieving, your husband and his sister seem to be able to prioritise themselves pretty well. I hope therapy brings you some answers. The thing is, if you decide to spend your Christmas with his sister, I expect it will be forgotten about and taken for granted like everything else you have done in your marriage. The gain from yet another sacrifice from you will probably not even be appreciated

I don’t know what the solution is, but I think it will be hard to find a compromise here. I don’t think there is anything wrong with prioritising yourself. I would not judge you.

(formatting all over the place on this post. Stupid phone).

@PizzaInThePiazza thank you for this. I guess this is what i am trying to write but not very well. Counselling helped initially in the weeks after mil passed but the dynamics have changed a lot. DH has changed and not for the better. He has become more selfish and rightly so wants the children to be ok and priorities them. However our relationship has and is not right and I know i should be much more empathetic. But i am resentful or some of the time I have wasted. But because I met DH very young he was a constant that stuck too.

We love each other but i think safe to say he doesn't really care about me like a husband should either. We have tough decisions to make as Christmas is just another disagreememt

OP posts:
TomatoSandwiches · 25/10/2023 17:22

BIossomtoes · 25/10/2023 14:56

You can really tell which posters here have experienced bereavement.

And you can tell the ones who have been taken advantage off because they've given in the majority of the time.

Ops mother is grieving this year as well and over a much more recent passing.
I would prioritise her over DH and his sister ( who is so traumatised she's distracting herself with a football game 🙄 )

Op you don't need your husbands agreement to plan something, he isn't your boss, make it what you want and leave him to his own devices.

PizzaInThePiazza · 25/10/2023 17:14

BIossomtoes · 25/10/2023 14:56

You can really tell which posters here have experienced bereavement.

Not all bereavement reactions are the same though. Not at all. Difficult relationships can result in a complex grief reaction.

PizzaInThePiazza · 25/10/2023 17:09

Relationships are complicated. This is clearly about much more than the death of the mother-in-law.

OP, I expect that all your life you have been last and left out of peoples consideration. When you were a child growing up in foster care and throughout the marriage. You have probably had many years having to compromise for his mum and sister.

Now his mum has died. It will bring all sorts of emotions to the fore. You don’t want the pattern continuing with his sister.

Last Christmas was difficult and I understand that you don’t want another difficult Christmas for your kids again this year. I expect most people with healthy family relationships Will see you as selfish. However, having worked in mental health for many years, I know that nothing is a simple as it seems within families.

And despite grieving, your husband and his sister seem to be able to prioritise themselves pretty well. I hope therapy brings you some answers. The thing is, if you decide to spend your Christmas with his sister, I expect it will be forgotten about and taken for granted like everything else you have done in your marriage. The gain from yet another sacrifice from you will probably not even be appreciated

I don’t know what the solution is, but I think it will be hard to find a compromise here. I don’t think there is anything wrong with prioritising yourself. I would not judge you.

(formatting all over the place on this post. Stupid phone).

thinkfast · 25/10/2023 16:51

I think your SIL is being inflexible if she won't change football to see you guys. I'd say go with seeing SIL ok Xmas eve and seeing your family on Xmas day.

Hibiscrubbed · 25/10/2023 16:47

UndercoverCop · 24/10/2023 17:09

So this is your DHs and SILs first Christmas without their mother? I'd prioritise them spending it together tbh. You can see yours boxing day, and Christmas day 2024

Edited

I disagree. It’s OP’s family’s turn. And she’s spent her entire marriage playing third fiddle to the MIL and SIL as it is.

Pheasantplucker2 · 25/10/2023 16:45

I would say to your DH - I think it would be best to keep the kids with my family for Christmas. I understand that it will be a tough time to be having Christmas without your mum for the first time, and therefore I want you to feel you and SIL can spend whatever time together that you need without worrying about us.

It would be lovely to spend Christmas Eve with your sister and her family, maybe by changing the routines it won't feel so awful for you both. And I think BIL feels that it would also be good for their kids to be with his family on Christmas Day.

How about we open presents in our own homes Christmas morning, then you and SIL can go and spend some time at MIL's grave. Then, when you're ready, come to spend the rest of Christmas Day with us.

I understand that SIL wants to go to the football on Boxing Day - why don't you go with her and we'll make our own plans (stay with your family!)

Then, if you'd like to, we can get the kids looked after and you, SIL, me and BIL all spend the day together on the anniversary of her death, and you guys can plan that as you see fit.

I really want to support you but am mindful that you don't want the kids to see you being unhappy, and also probably don't want to have to deal with them being exuberant when you'd feeling sad. So hopefully this gives you and SIL the time and space to grieve and not have to worry about us.

Mummyofbananas · 25/10/2023 16:25

We do a similar christmas and swap it round each year. The year my mum was ill (she passed away February) we swapped and had an extra year with my mum. Then the next year we went to his families. We swapped again the year his gran was ill and had an extra year with them and then back to mine the yera after. I think it's fair for you to see your family this year- but I understand it's difficult for him.

Suchapain · 25/10/2023 16:23

The first Christmas after a major bereavement is very hard and for that reason I would try to humour DH and SIL this time. Boxing Day with your family.

BIossomtoes · 25/10/2023 16:19

Gymnopedie · 25/10/2023 16:12

You can also tell the posters who haven't read the full thread, or at least the OP's posts.

You can read her posts and disagree with her 🤷‍♀️

Gymnopedie · 25/10/2023 16:12

BIossomtoes · 25/10/2023 14:56

You can really tell which posters here have experienced bereavement.

You can also tell the posters who haven't read the full thread, or at least the OP's posts.

SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 15:55

Pezdeoro41 · 25/10/2023 15:50

She didn’t say they expected it? And families are all different. I speak to my mum every day, especially as they’re getting older, I like to check they’re alright. They don’t expect it though.

Sil messages or phones several times a day l. Mil lived 5minutes away was not decript or I'll until hospital admission. But DH would call in every day. Phone too message. It's a long story

OP posts:
SouthGate7 · 25/10/2023 15:54

I would need a day to give examples if past issues and it has been bought up when mil was alive it's been a deep rooted complicated issue on DHs behalf hence the counselling.

I grew up in Foster care lost my alcoholic birth father at 11 and i never saw my birth mother from age 5 until she died in 2021. So perhaps I do lack empathy but i also know from earlier in the year that I have allowed a unhealthy pattern due to my inability to see healthy relationships.

Mils bday is 28 December, fil passing anniversary is 23 Dec although he passed 20 years ago. Where do I draw any line and spend any time with my family and my children need

OP posts:
Pezdeoro41 · 25/10/2023 15:50

OhmygodDont · 25/10/2023 15:48

I’d feel suffocated if my family expected daily check ins and had to be in contact every day tbh it doesn’t sound healthy between actual healthy adults.

She didn’t say they expected it? And families are all different. I speak to my mum every day, especially as they’re getting older, I like to check they’re alright. They don’t expect it though.

OhmygodDont · 25/10/2023 15:48

I’d feel suffocated if my family expected daily check ins and had to be in contact every day tbh it doesn’t sound healthy between actual healthy adults.

Pezdeoro41 · 25/10/2023 15:41

It is quite normal for family to speak on a daily basis - and to see each other often - not saying there isn’t enmeshment but the examples provided don’t really seem to be to me?

I have to say, if my partner insisted on having their Xmas turn the year after my mum died leaving me and my sibling the only family, I think I might reconsidering the relationship. This really isn’t about getting what you’re entitled to. If this is an ongoing issue then deal with that afterwards, this is not the hill to die on IMO.