Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For stopping schizophrenic uncle from seeing newborn?

214 replies

Emily19932 · 24/10/2023 15:56

Hi
My newborn daughters uncle (her dads brother) is schizophrenic. He has been hospitalised for the past 2 years in psychiatric ward but he is now allowed out every Saturdays under the observation of his mum. He has to be in hospital full time as his anti psychotic medication is injected. He hears voices and often talks to himself and about spirits etc.

A few months ago when he came home he pushed his mum down the stairs which put her in hospital as “the voices told him to” he also pulled a kitchen knife out on his brother again because the voices told him to. He will often talk to himself and when asked who he is talking to he will say the voices. He sent me a very nasty text a few weeks ago telling me to kill myself, I messaged him back asking why on earth he’d say that and he said and I quote “sorry that wasn’t me, the man in my head wrote that I’m really sorry I hope you’re ok”

Please don’t get me wrong I understand schizophrenia is a serious mental illness and that this is not his fault, but even so I feel like he could pose a very real risk to newborn daughter and that he could suddenly turn on the flick of a switch. When he has had episodes it’s as if he develops super human strength so if he was to do something I don’t believe his mum, dad or brother could stop him because he is so strong in these episodes and is very large stature wise.

My partner (her dad) is in the marines and he’s currently not in the country. His mum has been having the baby for the day on Saturdays. She’s recently asked if it’s ok if uncle see’s her this coming Saturday as he has day release. I’ve told her due to his past actions I don’t want him to but when or if he starts getting better I am happy for him to. He is clearly not better hence the text he sent me the other day. I am very terrified that if he is in the same place as my daughter he could turn on her and try to harm her and his mum would be powerless to stop him.

Shes told me I am being unreasonable because he’d never hurt a child, I understand that in a sane state of mind he wouldn’t harm anybody but he’s already tried to harm his family because of these voices so what’s to say these voices won’t command him to harm my baby.

AIBU?

OP posts:
rainbowsparkle28 · 24/10/2023 16:49

I was ready to respond to say the diagnosis doesn't in itself mean it would be a risk and is context dependent. However, in this circumstance I would say no YANBU it would not be appropriate or safe for your baby to be around him and I would not allow this given the safety concerns and what has happened previously.

FortofPud · 24/10/2023 16:49

Of course he wouldn't want to hurt your child. Same as he wouldn't want you to kill yourself. It's the voices in his head that you don't trust as they've previously proven that he can be provoked to violence. Its not hia fault but the poor nloke clearly isnt safe to be arouns right now. His mum is desperately concerned for her own baby (understandable) but it's causing her to wear blinkers when it comes to the safety of your baby. You need to say no, obviously. But everyone should also want that for the benefit of the brother - God forbid something awful happened, surely he would feel tortured forever and his recovery would be massively compromised. He needs to be kept safe situations too.

porridgeisbae · 24/10/2023 16:48

Someone has to be very ill to be permanently in a unit. @Emily19932 Lots of people have the injections, a nurse comes out to give them or they pop in somewhere to get them, but they live in the community. So he must be pretty ill.

cakecoffeecakecoffee · 24/10/2023 16:46

Yanbu at all.

like you say, he can meet the baby when he is more stable. It’s just too risky at the moment. It would take a split second to act on a voice and hurt a baby seriously.

TillyTrifle · 24/10/2023 16:45

Not in a million, billion years would I allow him near my baby.

More to the point, I wouldn’t dream of allowing the mother to have any further unsupervised contact with the baby - she clearly has inadequate judgement when it comes to keeping your baby safe. Her love for her son, and probably her wish for some normality around him, clouds her ability to keep your baby safe. How long until you find out she has had him there while caring for your baby and not told you? The fact that she has even asked this, that she would be ok with him being around your baby, would be for me the immediate end of the trusting arrangement you have with her now. She isn’t realistic about the risk her son poses.

FictionalCharacter · 24/10/2023 16:45

Very few people with schizophrenia are violent or threaten people, but he is one of those few. YANBU. It’s not worth the risk. His mother has no idea what he could or would do if he has a psychotic episode.

Catza · 24/10/2023 16:45

Astonymission · 24/10/2023 16:30

Disagree. They would need a sizeable team of strong adults around. The average man could overpower an older woman - I assume his mum isn’t super young compared to him /and another woman ie. The OP.

Also OP said this :

“When he has had episodes it’s as if he develops super human strength so if he was to do something I don’t believe his mum, dad or brother could stop him because he is so strong in these episodes and is very large stature wise”

Seems far too risky, sometimes women just need to say no and not he railroaded into “be kind” which can have catastrophic effects for all. I’m sure the brother would be horrified if he harmed the baby too so it’s a bad idea all around.

I wasn't suggesting the "older woman" to be "another adult present" in this scenario. I am just pointing out that there are ways to manage risks if all parties wanted for this visit to happen. It has nothing to do with saying no or being kind, there is no need to bring feminist angle to this at all.
For what it's worth, I would be uncomfortable to have elderly mother to be looking after the baby at all given her poor awareness of risks and potential for her to override OP's decision.

Binkie98 · 24/10/2023 16:44

I really wouldn't want him anywhere near a baby.
Maybe when he is more stable, he could have supervised visits but it's too early for that.

porridgeisbae · 24/10/2023 16:44

@Emily19932 I wouldn't even let the mum have the child on a Saturday on her own, as she could just let him come round and you wouldn't know or be able to do anything about it.

You're not wrong to think he could physically hurt the baby. He's already physically hurt people. I wouldn't even be happy if he was more well, as he could get more ill again at any time (unless maybe it's, like, a year stable on a new dose of the meds.) His comment to you proves he's still quite unstable.

I say this as someone who has a severe MH condition myself.

The child's safety has to be your first/only responsibility and their wellbeing your only consideration rather than the family's/the uncle's feelings etc.

OnlyFannys · 24/10/2023 16:42

I'm sure your MIL would have said he would never hurt his own mother until he did

Poppydieu · 24/10/2023 16:41

No, absolutely not.
Ensure mil follows your rule too.
I had to do a stint on a psychiatric ward and a tiny old lady ripped my dress from the neck to the waist in her confusion.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 24/10/2023 16:39

In this instance, I would only allow him to see my baby if I were there with her.

Nonibaloni · 24/10/2023 16:38

I know 2 people with schizophrenia, well I know their relatives who have been in the same position as you.

first and foremost talk to his medical team. They are the people that know him best and see him all day every day. Depending on how his day release works his mum should have easy contact. - whether you believe what she tells you is a different matter.

one Family, the baby visit the aunt, but with mum dad granny and grandad. It’s stage managed and she doesn’t get to hold the baby or hold anything while the baby (who is 5 now) is there. I know the parents felt terrible in the early days but now the aunt gets huge amount from these very brief visits and lots and lots of photos.

the other it’s been back and forward, when he’s well everything is fine, when he’s not well he can’t have contact with the children until his doctors says he’s been stable for a while.

femfemlicious · 24/10/2023 16:37

Just NO. He can see the baby on a video call. He can't control himself

Spambod · 24/10/2023 16:37

The babies needs need to come first. He should have no contact at all. It’s not in the baby’s best interests. Your mil has unsafe boundaries if she thinks this is ok and I would seriously reconsider letting her look after the baby in case she puts her at risk. On another note he sounds very risky to be out each week and this should be urgently reviewed before he kills his mother or actually stabs someone.

Susuwatariandkodama · 24/10/2023 16:37

YANBU, I think a video call would be the best option, it’s not his fault but it’s just too great of a risk to take and you have a duty of care to your child.

Strugglingmumof3 · 24/10/2023 16:35

@Pccleaner what an odd response! Cancer doesn’t pose a threat the same way schizophrenia does.
@Emily19932 I would keep your baby away until his meds are controlling his mental health properly

Sallyh87 · 24/10/2023 16:34

Not a hope in hell would I let this man see my child.

Heronwatcher · 24/10/2023 16:34

No YADNBU. As you say once it’s under control and your partner is back in the country then maybe some supervised visits could start but definitely not while he is showing some very strong signs that he’s very unstable.

And I personally would not trust your MIL to respect your wishes on this- I’d bet good money that if you keep sending your DD then her uncle will “just happen to pop by” for some reason. She sounds like she’s minimising it and saying he’s never hurt a child before is little comfort. I would be surprised if he was in regular contact with kids plus there’s always a first time. I think I’d find an excuse to stop unsupervised visits with your MIL too- isn’t there a swimming class on a Sat you now want to do? She can of course visit you at your house any time, so long as you are there.

Vinrouge4 · 24/10/2023 16:31

Maybe you should look after your baby yourself on Saturdays from now on. It sounds like your M in law has enough on her plate. You can still visit at another time

Astonymission · 24/10/2023 16:30

Catza · 24/10/2023 16:03

I would say it's a high risk situation. Not because your uncle has schizophrenia or hears voices but because there is a history of recent violent behaviour. I would be inclined to seek advice from his psychiatrist on the ward and would consider him seeing the baby but discussing with him beforehand that he needs to be maintaining a safe distance and won't be allowed to hold the baby.
Usual risk precautions would have to be made, like you not being alone with him in a room, all risky objects being removed and you staying close to the door with another adult present.
It's possible to manage this situation without exposing yourself or the baby to risks, it would just need a lot of planning.

Disagree. They would need a sizeable team of strong adults around. The average man could overpower an older woman - I assume his mum isn’t super young compared to him /and another woman ie. The OP.

Also OP said this :

“When he has had episodes it’s as if he develops super human strength so if he was to do something I don’t believe his mum, dad or brother could stop him because he is so strong in these episodes and is very large stature wise”

Seems far too risky, sometimes women just need to say no and not he railroaded into “be kind” which can have catastrophic effects for all. I’m sure the brother would be horrified if he harmed the baby too so it’s a bad idea all around.

Floralnomad · 24/10/2023 16:30

Why is she having your baby on Saturdays ? It would be a no from me whilst he’s still so unstable . Could you visit him in the hospital so there would be staff / more people supervising .

Whatthefuck3456 · 24/10/2023 16:30

If you posted in a few weeks that the uncle hurt your daughter the response would be: well you knew he was unwell why did you let him near!

i personally would not let him near at all and I work in mental health, especially if his diagnosis is command schizophrenia. Which it sounds like it is if he is doing as the voice says! Stick to your guns your daughter is more important than your relationship with anyone.

Emily19932 · 24/10/2023 16:27

No, but I would if someone with cancer had tried to stab their brother, pushed their mum down the stairs and told me to kill myself for no reason because voices told them to.

OP posts:
bracemyselfagain · 24/10/2023 16:26

LaLoba · 24/10/2023 16:00

Cancer doesn’t cause people to push others downstairs or threaten them with a knife. What a stupid comparison.
OP, never mind anyone else’s feelings, trust your gut and keep your child safe.

This.

Swipe left for the next trending thread