Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is the most stupid advice anyone's ever given in the history of giving advice

108 replies

IncompleteSenten · 24/10/2023 15:41

Or am I being a twat?

Yanbu - wtf kind of dumb advice is that?

Yabu - it's good advice, get off your arse and try it.

To think this is the most stupid advice anyone's ever given in the history of giving advice
OP posts:
Stomacharmeleon · 24/10/2023 16:10

@IncompleteSenten I would be encouraging you to speak to the crisis team.
My son was seriously mentally unwell and sectioned for long periods of time. Sometimes I just run out of the right words.
Hugs

All2Well · 24/10/2023 16:09

It's actually something my son's been recommended by his OT, for when he is feeling disregulated and distressed. We even remind him of it when he feels like that.

It wasn't recommended to me, but I think the idea behind it is changing your physiological state to change the emotional response.

Crazily enough, one of the best things for instantly helping my depression was a cold shower and Wim Hoff breathing exercises...I think he actually invented the method when his wife died and he was in unbearable emotional pain. I remember the first week I tried it saying it was better than Sertraline and wishing the nurse had told me about it while I was waiting for medication to kick in.

At the time though, when I was suicidal, I could barely get in the shower so it would have been a terrible suggestion and I might have thought she was nuts and trying to make me more miserable.

It is difficult to know the right thing to say when someone is so low...but the way the OPs DH has phrased it seems so dismissive, even if he thinks it would help.

INeedAnotherName · 24/10/2023 16:09

On the surface it sounds weird but when you think about it then it's not. Its the indoor equivalent to go for a walk. You are focused on external things eg not tripping up, you are getting air into your lungs, you are getting the exercise feel good sensation. Its quite clever really.

I also think you need further support from someone who is able to give it. Maybe your husband has hit his limit. Go back to your GP etc. Sounds like it's time Flowers

OneTC · 24/10/2023 16:08

Seems a bit simplistic but could have been worse, you could have posted on here and someone would certainly have suggested that you listen to your gut

CaroleSinger · 24/10/2023 16:08

Well did you try it? If going up and down the stairs a few times is good for depression I think I've been taking the wrong pills for years 😳

Schlurp · 24/10/2023 16:07

Lovely empathetic reply from @Whadda .

It's not your fault OP. hope tomorrow is better. If you can, maybe reach out to your MN nurse?

MCOut · 24/10/2023 16:05

I’m sorry you’re feeling like this OP. Don’t be too upset, it is a very clumsy response but he’s probably just a bit lost. He’s not a professional and it is good advice. I know it’s really hard to motivate yourself to move when you’re feeling like this but exercise really does help.

Instead of the crisis team, can you go and see your GP?

Stephisaur · 24/10/2023 16:04

Gosh, I thought my husband was emotionally dense - this takes the biscuit!

I'm sorry you're having a shit time of it OP. Have you considered counselling? Private counselling is around £45/hour and easier to access (and more private) than NHS services.

Have a proper sit down chat with your DH and remember to suggest he go up and down the stairs a few times next time he needs some advice ;)

IsleofDen · 24/10/2023 16:03

It’s really, really not bad advice. It might not work for you, but it’s one of the techniques I use, along with putting on music and dancing in the kitchen when I cannot face leaving the house.

Depression sucks the life out of you and sometimes a short period of exertion and the resulting endorphins can get you through to bedtime.

Take care of yourself.

All2Well · 24/10/2023 16:03

WTAF?! That is horrendous!!!

Do you have any real help with this? I.e a nurse practitioner or therapist? I'm so sorry you feel this way (I've been there). My family weren't much support either but not as bad as your husband...but as awful as it was, I had to understand they weren't equipped to deal with my emotions and couldn't give me what I needed but professional help was a lifeline. Do you have IAPT in your area that you can self refer to if you aren't already being seen? Or do you have any women's or other free mental charities in your town that you can access? The Samaritans were a bit of a lifeline for me while I was waiting for help but when I was as low as you, I called the GP and was honest about the thoughts of harming myself and they got me in to see a Nurse Practitioner within a couple of hours. She was amazing and between medication and talking therapy things improved fairly quickly. I hope you can get similar support. Please keep talking about it, with people who really can support you. I'm sorry you're going through this.

AlizeeEasy · 24/10/2023 16:02

Always assume best intentions….but Jesus Christ. I have a friend with suicidal ideation, I would never say something like that to her. We both know I cannot ‘fix’ things, all I can do is be an open ear and open heart to her. I think your partner may have been in ‘find solution’ mode, which there isn’t an immediate solution to what you are going through.

I really hope you are ok and can find a positive way through this, there are a lot of sources you can try, Samaritans are great and if you can’t talk on the phone you can email or text them.

Schlurp · 24/10/2023 16:01

It's actually something my son's been recommended by his OT, for when he is feeling disregulated and distressed. We even remind him of it when he feels like that.

Terrible reply to your previous message though. Talk to him about it, or it'll eat you up.

IncompleteSenten · 24/10/2023 16:01

I'm reluctant because last time the crisis team got involved and they were so overwhelming and I thought they would force me into hospital (I've been placed in a mental health unit in the past, but not for many years) and it took ages to shake them off. I still have a nurse from the GP who comes to see me every month and I don't want to start all that up again.

I am unreasonable in this, he is very supportive and this is my fault not his. It was unfair of me to think it was stupid.

OP posts:
RubyBoozeDay · 24/10/2023 15:58

It sounds like he is suggesting a practical way of distracting yourself from your suicidal ideation. It doesn't sound hugely empathic but it's coming from a caring place.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 24/10/2023 15:56

Whadda · 24/10/2023 15:51

I think a lot of people in crisis mistakenly believe that those around them know all the answers, when often they’re as helpless and at as much of a loss as the person they’re trying to support.

His message doesn’t sound like there’s bad intent. is he generally kind and supportive?

I’ve been on the receiving end of messages like those and it’s not like you can magic up the right words to say to someone, especially in a marriage where you’re likely to be impacted by what’s going on too.

Supporting a spouse through a mental health crisis is exhausting- he doesn’t have all the answers and may not be capable of thinking entirely rationally right now.

I agree with this, is he maybe at the stage where he doesn't know what to do and has said the first thing that's popped into his head?
Have you got other professional support?

saveforthat · 24/10/2023 15:56

See I don't think it's that bad. Because exercise, whilst not a miracle cure, really does help and if you can't leave the children or get them ready with you to go for a walk, why not the stairs?

IncompleteSenten · 24/10/2023 15:54

Oh yes he is lovely and supportive and very caring.

I know I'm being unfair. I just feel so alone and empty and it's so hard pretending I don't feel this way in RL all the time and putting on fake smiles and pretending everything is fine when really what I want is to close my eyes and never open them again.

OP posts:
Pccleaner · 24/10/2023 15:53

You know when you press the middle button on your phone? This is what this seems like.

eg finish the sentence - I want using the middle button.

bathrobeandpie · 24/10/2023 15:52

it's an alternative of the go walk outside to get fresh air

It's not meant nastily, especially after you said you cannot talk to anyone at that moment because of the children around

Another way to look at it: you thought that was so bonkers, gave you a little bit of energy back, so somehow it worked

ToWonderWhyIBother · 24/10/2023 15:51

I'm so sorry that you are going through this, but your husband went to the same school my husband did as his advice would be to "gie your heid a bang", I know its so wrong of me but I did have a little chuckle at his advice.

I have no idea what you are going through at this time, but I will offer to listen should you want to write it down and send in a message, I have been to hell and back more than once and even If I can't offer any advice on your situation just offloading sometimes helps.

Whadda · 24/10/2023 15:51

I think a lot of people in crisis mistakenly believe that those around them know all the answers, when often they’re as helpless and at as much of a loss as the person they’re trying to support.

His message doesn’t sound like there’s bad intent. is he generally kind and supportive?

I’ve been on the receiving end of messages like those and it’s not like you can magic up the right words to say to someone, especially in a marriage where you’re likely to be impacted by what’s going on too.

Supporting a spouse through a mental health crisis is exhausting- he doesn’t have all the answers and may not be capable of thinking entirely rationally right now.

Sparkletastic · 24/10/2023 15:50

Is he definitely replying to your last message and not a previous one saying you've got stiff knee joints? <grasps at straws to try and make it make sense>

Iwasafool · 24/10/2023 15:50

That advice is so ridiculous the only possible thing I can think of to justify it is if he was trying to make you laugh by saying something so ridiculous but that's a bit of a stretch.

I'm hoping that it might have at least distracted you a bit from how you were feeling. Hope you feel better soon.

IncompleteSenten · 24/10/2023 15:49

@spitefulandbadgrammar ha! That made me smile.

@TotalOverhaul good point I hadn't really thought of it like that.

OP posts:
romdowa · 24/10/2023 15:48

That's the most ridiculous advice ever, it would be laughable if the situation wasn't so serious. I understand he's not a trained professional but surely he could have formulated a more empathetic reply than that. I'm so sorry op. 😞