Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is the most stupid advice anyone's ever given in the history of giving advice

108 replies

IncompleteSenten · 24/10/2023 15:41

Or am I being a twat?

Yanbu - wtf kind of dumb advice is that?

Yabu - it's good advice, get off your arse and try it.

To think this is the most stupid advice anyone's ever given in the history of giving advice
OP posts:
Citrusandginger · 24/10/2023 16:40

OP, please reach out to the Samaritans or a mental health professional. You need the right support from the right person.

I wonder how many times your DP has received a version of your message? He must be terribly worried. He is probably trying to give you the advice he has been told to give you and has been clumsy in the way he did it. But it doesn't matter. You need intervention from professionals. Please don't let yourself be distracted by judging the response of someone who isn't a professional.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 24/10/2023 16:40

Tempnamechng · 24/10/2023 15:44

I think you are asking the wrong person for advice. They obviously aren't a professional, and don't really know what to suggest or say or have run out of ideas on what to say. I feel sorry for both of you in this situation.

Edited

This. Yes it is stupid advice. But if you can’t talk to him what is he supposed to do? You need professional help. Go to the GP

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 24/10/2023 16:38

You know something 10 years ago I'd have called him the twat of all twats but as someone who's supported a family member with their MH problems and seen first hand the constant trauma dumping and threat of suicide hovering as had on her poor (( Saint)) of a husband as well as all the other stuff lumped on us I'm sad to say I think you're being bang out of order and completely unfair towards someone who's probably constantly searching for the right answer, any answer in fact but doesn't always have them.

porridgeisbae · 24/10/2023 16:35

Exercise can help boost mood so it isn't entirely stupid advice, but it isn't going to do it singlehandedly. That sort of depression can benefit from professional help and/or meds. 'Going up and down stairs a few times' isn't likely to cut it anyway. The person should've told you to see/go back to your GP or consultant. x

Fink · 24/10/2023 16:34

I had a suicidally depressed spouse for a number of years. I tried my best to help him in every way I could. But if you'd taken just one of my messages in isolation, it's possible that I would have suggested something a bit useless or insensitive. I was trying, and once I also had a child to care for I didn't necessarily have the time to phrase everything in the best way and think through every idea.

EmptyYoghurtPot · 24/10/2023 16:34

Seems like mad advice but I think it comes from a place of kindness . I’m guessing he is at work and you are at home? As others have said, he’s not a MH professional and probably doesn’t know what to say for the best. I put my DH through it when I was in ‘that place’. And at least it’s taken your mind off things whilst you posted on here. I hope you can get some proper help soon 🌹

monicagellerbing · 24/10/2023 16:34

If he used to work in mental health I'm surprised he didn't just tell you to have a cup of tea and a hot bath. That's their normal advice in crisis teams

IncompleteSenten · 24/10/2023 16:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Horriblewoman · 24/10/2023 16:32

I don’t think it’s awful - you mention wanting to stay in bed and shut the door so maybe this is him suggesting an incremental way for you to get yourself focusing on something else in a non pressured way.

I say that as someone who lived with another person who was actively suicidal for months and the tools we used to try and support.

TheNoodlesIncident · 24/10/2023 16:32

My son (who also has autism) has paced relentlessly back and forth around our holiday apartment while listening to YouTube videos of planes taking off when he couldn't cope... Keeping moving and the sensory input of the aircraft noise helped him get back into a steadier state of mind. Knowing that, the stairs thing is the kind of thing I might have suggested if I was otherwise at a loss for what to say. Don't be hard on yourself for dismissing it nor hard on him for suggesting it, it's a very difficult situation for you both and I do feel for you.

I hope you can get some outside help lovely Flowers

Sallyh87 · 24/10/2023 16:29

Why do you feel that you can put your emotions on someone else and expect them to deal with it? Talk to a professional, you can’t expect perfect advice unless you do.

I also, think it’s really bitchy to post someone’s messages on an online forum.

Thatladdo · 24/10/2023 16:26

Exercise is proven to help with depression.
Not sure Doctors mean goin up an down the stairs a few times though!
Fresh air, out and about and something a little more than up and down a few steps.

dammit88 · 24/10/2023 16:24

While I can understand you may feel frustrated, I agree with those saying it's not terrible advice. It can get you into a bit of a meditative state, rhythmically going up and down the steps, and can be calming for some people. It must be very hard for him to receive that message and I think many people would be lost what to say when really wanting to help, so they come up with something, anything, to try and do that. I hope you get the help you need soon.

tolerable · 24/10/2023 16:24

actually.......tho unlikely to follow it-theres a method in the madness in -excercise-even up\down stairs triggers a seratonin release-whilst its not gona cure you,it may actually help a little. .....

Fionaville · 24/10/2023 16:23

It is bonkers as a reply. Has going up and down the stairs helped you with anxiety attacks in the past or something?
I only ask because when I've been in the grip of an anxiety attack, doing things like sorting the junk drawer has brought me out of it.

Catapultaway · 24/10/2023 16:23

Did you try going up and down the stairs a few times? Did it help?

Cerealkiller4U · 24/10/2023 16:21

IncompleteSenten · 24/10/2023 15:41

Or am I being a twat?

Yanbu - wtf kind of dumb advice is that?

Yabu - it's good advice, get off your arse and try it.

There are people who advise to ‘ground’ yourselves

so when you feel awful you need to see what around you…what colour the walls are…how many stairs…..what marks in the walls etc. I wonder if he’s googled something and come across this grounding advice?

5 things yoh can see. 5 things you can hear. 5 smells

I do think it might be something like that? I love grounding myself but maybe he’s read it wrong 😂

DisquietintheRanks · 24/10/2023 16:19

I'm sorry that youre feeling this way but that's a hell of a message to lay on the shoulders of anyone but a trained professional. No wonder he struggled to respond.

Dweetfidilove · 24/10/2023 16:19

Going out on a limb here, but is he thinking that as you can’t leave the children to go for a walk, some up and down the stairs might get your endorphins going.

It reads like well-intentioned bad advice 🤦🏾‍♀️

Prettypaisleyslippers · 24/10/2023 16:19

I think he means get some exercise, as per pp, walking up and down stairs as an alternative to taking a walk/run. During lockdown this was suggested to people to get blood pumping and endorphins when they couldn’t leave the house.

you said that you couldn’t talk to him, are you able to get done talking therapy or see GP??

Lovemusic82 · 24/10/2023 16:17

To be fair his advice is similar to the advice I got on the phone from the mental health crisis team when I felt suicidal. I got told to put a bag of frozen peas on my forehead or go walk up and down the garden a few times 😬. It might feel like shit advice at the time (I felt like telling them to f#ck off) but I guess it’s kind of like mindfulness where you distract your brain. Distraction can be good, trying to focus on other things, trying to look for positive things…but it’s easy for someone who’s not feeling low to suggest these things, not so easy for us to see that they may help.

Lastchancechica · 24/10/2023 16:15

Can you at least see a counsellor op?

I know you are fearful but this is your life we are talking about. It’s too precious. Please get some help

CalistoNoSolo · 24/10/2023 16:14

I can't imagine how your husband must be feeling while you tell him about your suicidal thoughts, but possibly scared for you, helpless, sad, maybe a bit angry? Possibly really confused and at a loss on how to help you. Just cut him some slack and get proper help rather than ridiculing him on a public forum.

istolethetalisker · 24/10/2023 16:14

It’s not great advice, but it’s not absolutely stupid. As PP have said, it’s a start.

It is proof your partner is not professional mental health support, and you shouldn’t be using him as such. He may want to help, but he can’t be your therapist, and it’ll kill your relationship if he’s your only source of support. I know it’s easier to trust him than a stranger, but you mustn’t put this on him.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 24/10/2023 16:12

IncompleteSenten · 24/10/2023 16:01

I'm reluctant because last time the crisis team got involved and they were so overwhelming and I thought they would force me into hospital (I've been placed in a mental health unit in the past, but not for many years) and it took ages to shake them off. I still have a nurse from the GP who comes to see me every month and I don't want to start all that up again.

I am unreasonable in this, he is very supportive and this is my fault not his. It was unfair of me to think it was stupid.

What advice would you have liked him to give? Is it just a listening ear and not actual advice as it doesn't sound like you'd have been happy if he'd actually acted on your words and contacted the crisis team.
Can you call your nurse in-between sessions?

Swipe left for the next trending thread