Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is the most stupid advice anyone's ever given in the history of giving advice

108 replies

IncompleteSenten · 24/10/2023 15:41

Or am I being a twat?

Yanbu - wtf kind of dumb advice is that?

Yabu - it's good advice, get off your arse and try it.

To think this is the most stupid advice anyone's ever given in the history of giving advice
OP posts:
ThreeRingCircus · 24/10/2023 17:40

I think he's worded it badly but he means well.

Nothing he says will help, he's probably feeling completely lost, concerned and helpless. It's not the worst suggestion in the world to be honest, even if worded clumsily. Exercise and changing your physical state can be a useful tool.....putting an ice cube on your skin or listening to really loud music can sometimes be a temporary distraction too.

I'm really sorry you're going through this, and I really feel for your husband. It's terrible for both of you. I would reach out to your MH team and try to get some more support.

321user123 · 24/10/2023 17:24

Was.. that an attempt to make you laugh?

Ihope you start feeling better soon OP 💐

Ponderingwindow · 24/10/2023 17:09

It seems poorly stated but well intentioned.

exercise can help with mental state. It’s not a cure, but a bit of adrenaline and dopamine to interrupt your spiral can be a healthy way of dealing with a mild crisis.

If you are with the children and unable to go out for a good walk or go to the gym, walking the stairs is actually a pretty good idea for a quick burst of exercise if you don’t happen to own a treadmill or other equipment.

the best thing would be to come home and take over so you can take care of yourself. Im guessing there are practical constraints and that is why you didn’t just ask for that.

CharlotteBog · 24/10/2023 17:08

OP, you're not wasting our time by posting here. Posters are choosing to read and respond.

If you want to drop off the thread for other reasons then of course you should, but do it for yourself not for MN readers.

WowOK · 24/10/2023 17:05

@IncompleteSenten everything is different when it's someone you love. In his professional life he's detached.

sollenwir · 24/10/2023 17:04

Whataretheodds · 24/10/2023 15:43

Did you send the message in green? If so I'm really sorry you're feeling this way - please do contact somewhere like the Samaritans who have people trained to listen in circumstances like this

Exactly this.

MushMonster · 24/10/2023 17:04

A PP has told ypu how a bit of exercise made them feel better.
For me, is a cup of tea or coffee, maybe with a treat. I just sit there, hold a warm cup, enjoy the smell and the taste. I try to empty my mind of whatever is racing through it.
It is not as bonkers as you think.
When everything is going wrong, grab something you can control and do easily, to get your mind steady and stop racing.
It may not work for you, though....

truptantripping · 24/10/2023 17:03

It's shit and I'm sorry you are there in that place. I've been there many times.

It's a bit blunt. the tone of the two lines are so incongruent. It's a bit like he had a paragraph in between the first and last sentence that got deleted....

While there is method in exercise for emotional dysregulation, it needed softening a bit.

Overall though his intentions aren't bad- he sounds like a good egg generally so perhaps he's questioning himself for writing that right now!

Years ago I finally admitted similar to my now ex H and he went nuts shouting at me for being selfish and how he couldn't handle that right now. Never mentioned it again to him despite being very unwell he however used it as stick every time he wanted to dig at me.

Hope you feel different soon

Notwhatyouwanttohear · 24/10/2023 17:03

What do you expect him to do?

He has tried to empathise with you and you come on here and post his message

You need serious professional help unless I've missed that he's a medical professional.

WowOK · 24/10/2023 17:02

Your husband is a prat. Did his advice work? It would have most definitely distracted me. I would have been shocked, a bit confused and probably angry. He's a sap.

I do this guided meditation and it really helps. I have intrusive thoughts and suffer from suicidal ideology.

It would also help to create a safety plan so you have something to follow when you are feeling overwhelmed or like you want to die/ suicidal.

Guided Meditation for Detachment From Over-Thinking (Anxiety / OCD / Depression)

This meditation encourages a calm awareness of the breath, and also a gentle detachment from the habits of rumination (ie. over-thinking). This session is us...

https://youtu.be/1vx8iUvfyCY?feature=shared

CharlotteBog · 24/10/2023 17:00

BlueEyedPeanut · 24/10/2023 16:56

That's the kind of useless advice my GP gives. Yeah, exercise helps your mood, but when you are feeling that low it is impossible to find the energy to do it.

Have you found something that did help you?

CharlotteBog · 24/10/2023 16:59

BlueEyedPeanut · 24/10/2023 16:56

That's the kind of useless advice my GP gives. Yeah, exercise helps your mood, but when you are feeling that low it is impossible to find the energy to do it.

It's usually given as a suggestion, as something that is known to help many, many people, and worth trying.

MichelleScarn · 24/10/2023 16:59

are you at home alone now with the dc? How old are they and is he out at work? For how long and how far away?
Have you voiced your ideation to him like this before while in sole charge of them?
I feel bad as missed the bit about the dc being there before.

Bandolina · 24/10/2023 16:57

Well that's the example given in the DBT training I did. Run up and down stairs or do squats. It's just whatever you can manage to get your heart rate up which is different for different people. If you have to go on a 10 mile run it's not going to be accessible to most people.

BlueEyedPeanut · 24/10/2023 16:56

That's the kind of useless advice my GP gives. Yeah, exercise helps your mood, but when you are feeling that low it is impossible to find the energy to do it.

porridgeisbae · 24/10/2023 16:54

@Pertangyangkipperbang 'A few times' is not going to get those results.

porridgeisbae · 24/10/2023 16:53

I think he is suggesting the 'intense exercise' part of TIPP. It's evidence based and does work

Intense exercise is not going up and down stairs a few times for most people, though, getting any lift in mood at all takes a bit more than that.

Pertangyangkipperbang · 24/10/2023 16:52

It's actually very very good advice.. might help until you can seek better help or until your husband comes home. It's NOT bonkers at all.
Going up and down stairs will boost your mental state, as the physical exertion releases pain-killing endorphins – the feel-good hormones that help to relieve tension and lift the spirits. The regular exercise will raise your energy levels, making you feel generally better about the world.

AnneValentine · 24/10/2023 16:51

I don’t think it is. It’s a small manageable target. Lying around in bed thinking thoughts like that won’t help. He’s trying to get you out of your head.

Do not underestimate how draining this will be. You might like what he’s said but really, what can he do? You’re messaging him suicidal thoughts.

Fairyliz · 24/10/2023 16:49

Well it does sound stupid but hasn’t exercise been shown to help depression?
Okay I know it’s a bit more than running up and down stairs a few times, but if you can manage anything some walking in the fresh air on a regular basis might help if only a little.

PinkRoses1245 · 24/10/2023 16:49

I wouldn’t have a clue how to reply to a message like that. You need to seek a professional

WonderingWanda · 24/10/2023 16:49

I don't think it's quite the right reply to the message you sent him but I wonder if this has been an ongoing issue he is feeling out of ideas or feeling a bit helpless. In this thread op you've been reluctant to seek help because you found the help overwhelming and don't want to be admitted anywhere but proper medical help is really what you need when you are constantly feeling suicidal.

I've been the support person for someone feeling the way you are and it's actually quite tough for that person too. I get that you want him to soothe you with some magic words to make it all go away but the reality is all that will do is keep it at bay slightly. You need some proper help to be able to get better.

Bandolina · 24/10/2023 16:48

footprintscommunity.org.au/resources/introduction-to-dialectal-behavioural-therapy-the-tipp-skill/#:~:text=One%20of%20our%20favourite%20DBT,are%20going%20to%20consume%20you.

I think he is suggesting the 'intense exercise' part of TIPP. It's evidence based and does work

I suspect he would have been better had it been preceded with some validation of how you are feeling but this is a snippet of a convo so maybe he did also do that.

CharlotteBog · 24/10/2023 16:43

When you're in the depths if despair ANY sort of advice isn't going to help in that moment. Although you didn't ask him for advice, it's natural for people who care for you to want to help.

It's for this reason I find phoning Samaritans helps me. Sometimes I just need to cry and cry, dump a load of stuff out of my head onto someone who isn't judging, doesn't know me and isn't meant to dish out advice. And I can call them the next day and say the same thing.

Do you never get any time to talk when the children won't hear?

I actually think him suggesting something small (i.e. achievable) and physical (distracting and gets you moving) wasn't too bad. You have nothing to lose.

FlyingUnicornWings · 24/10/2023 16:42

OP you’re not wasting anyone’s time. I’m so sorry you’re feeling like this, and I can understand your reluctance to get the crisis team involved if you’ve had a bad experience with them before.
I know you don’t want to go through that again, but you deserve to be okay, and that might mean seeking out help from the professionals.
You aren’t being ridiculous or wrong for wanting more from your husband. Sometimes you need to be clear on what you need and what he can do to help and support you. If you feel like you could have a calm chat about it, which it sounds to me like you can, it might help you both.
I wish you all the best and please don’t be afraid to reach out to services. I’m a crisis worker and I promise you we aren’t all bad 💐

Swipe left for the next trending thread