Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To decline induction/c section for baby measuring small?

234 replies

imalreadythere · 24/10/2023 14:26

40+2 today. Baby measuring small but also engaged so maybe that's why?

Midwives offered induction or c section but I want to wait.

Aibu? The midwife wasn't that pleased I don't think.

OP posts:
Sapphire387 · 24/10/2023 19:25

Oh, for the love of God.

Women and babies died in pregnancy and childbirth - frequently - before we had modern hospitals and interventions.

Ignore medical advice at your own peril. I suggest you speak to them to get a full explanation as to why they think induction or c-section is necessary. Then at least you are making an informed decision.

I speak as someone who had a 'natural' delivery with my second that culminated with some hefty and necessary interventions to save my life, and that of my daughter, at the end. I am grateful that we live in a time and place where that was possible.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 24/10/2023 19:22

SaveMeFromMyBoobs · 24/10/2023 18:50

You have not assessed OP yourself, nor are you likely a medical professional or an actual clairvoyant. You have zero ability to assure anyone, OP especially, that the baby is healthy and safe in her womb.

The womb is not automatically safe. Pregnancy complications happen.

I did not say that, I said "when a baby is perfectly safe", and I was talking in general terms, not specifically the OP's baby. The OP has not mentioned any actual risk factors here, nevertheless, I was not assessing via the internet, for goodness sake, way to twist things 🙄

Teapot13 · 24/10/2023 19:22

Surely the midwife is also trying to avoid interventions, and she has proposed this intervention because she believes it's necessary?

Anonymouslyposting · 24/10/2023 19:21

I haven’t read the full thread but have read all of the OPs posts.

OP, the decision is yours of course. However, my view is that the current emphasis on having a birth with as few interventions as possible is putting babies at risk by encouraging mothers to ignore medical advice. It’s right that we’ve had a backlash against the old ways where a mother’s opinions about her own birth process weren’t respected but we should be careful that we don’t go to the other extreme of rejecting expertise.

When I was pushing with my first I was advised to have either forceps or ventouse because DD was starting to struggle. Because I’d been convinced that interventions were bad I argued (pretty incoherently!) with the midwives and then the doctors. In the end I had an episiotomy and the ventouse delivery and it was 100% fine, everyone was healthy and the physical recovery was easy.

However, I felt like I’d massively failed because I hadn’t been able to get DD out unassisted and had “let them” do the intervention. I was not mentally well after the birth and it was quite a long time before I could think about it clearly.

Now my view is that I was absolutely mad not to take their advice straight away. DD would probably have been fine either way and I’d have probably got there in the end but I can’t imagine how I’d have felt if she hadn’t been ok because I hadn’t listened in pursuit of an intervention free birth. Of course there’s nothing wrong with asking questions and wanting to understand the reason they are recommending a particular course of action. However, in no other area of medicine would I argue with a professional’s opinion just because I didn’t want an “intervention”. There is a reason they make recommendations and it’s not because they think it’s fun to do unnecessary medical procedures.

Now, in your position I would take the advice and have the induction or c-section. If I was in doubt I might ask to talk it through with a doctor rather than the midwife to see if there are other options like closer monitoring and checks on placental blood flow that might be appropriate. However, I wouldn’t just ignore medical advice. Aside from anything else, I would feel much worse if something went wrong and I’d ignored the advice than if I’d followed it.

Best of luck whatever you decide!

Frisate · 24/10/2023 19:18

And in my case my baby was indeed small: weight at birth was 2.490Kg.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 24/10/2023 19:18

therealcookiemonster · 24/10/2023 18:43

@ReadingSoManyThreads Happy to hear it. until you update our guidelines however, I will carry on practising our current guidelines if that's OK.

I shouldn't have to remind you on your code of conduct though, scaremongering and not respecting informed consent are not ok.

Frisate · 24/10/2023 19:17

My baby was measuring small and I was advised to have a C-section (he was breech) and went for it as I wouldn’t go against medical advice. After the delivery the doctor saw my placenta and it was fully calcified and therefore could not provide for the baby anymore. In my case having kept him for longer would have been fatal. I would suggest you do some research and listen to medical advice and try doing the best possible decision. All the best to you and your baby 🌸

Rosieposy89 · 24/10/2023 19:15

Declining interventions that could potentially save the life of your baby is utter madness. In what other scenario would you decline life saving treatment

Maryamlouise · 24/10/2023 19:04

Was over 41 weeks with both of mine but I didn't agree with the estimated dates given when I knew I must have conceived so I don't think I was really as far along as that. And am another who got a growth scan which was way off - thought baby was small but was nearly 10lb! I agree with trying to talk it through with someone else and discuss risks etc of all options

scrunchmum · 24/10/2023 19:04

The OP hasn't given much information here, and certainly not enough for some of the hurtful suggestions that they are willingly putting their baby's life at risk.

Contrary to the common trope, the health of the baby is not the only thing that matters from birth. Clearly and unequivocally it is the MOST important thing, but the wishes and birth experience for the mother are also so so important. If that wasn't the case then we would all be having planned c sections at 39 weeks as it is the safest thing for the baby.
Birth trauma is real and is a real cause of PND.

At the very least the OP is right to ask her questions, and has every right to have her wishes and decisions respected and her questions answered. Birth professionals have guidelines, and they have them for a reason, but they can and do get things wrong sometimes - and women don't all fit into neat boxes as the guidelines would suggest.

321user123 · 24/10/2023 19:02

beautifulbrothers · 24/10/2023 14:45

https://www.rcog.org.uk/for-the-public/browse-our-patient-information/having-a-small-baby/

There is some helpful information on this website.

And use the B.R.A.I.N acronym = Benefits, Risks, Alternatives, Intuition, Nothing.

What are the benefits? What are the risks? Are there any alternatives? What does your instinct/intuition tell you? What happens if you do nothing?

I would have this conversation as soon as possible.x

This above OP.

ignore those talking about “going against medical advice” .
If I got money every time a doctor was wrong with me, or a family member or a friend, I’d be rich.

Research benefits and cons and go with your gut feeling

ZombieBoob · 24/10/2023 18:57

I've had 3 inductions all for various reasons and I didn't end up with a section or any instruments. Like you I've been told baby was small at 5lb on scan born 7lb 7oz so perfectly healthy wieght.
I've had different varying degrees of induction so 1st was just popping my waters and nature took over. 2nd was 1 pessary and off labour went. 3rd was the drip. Last baby was 9lb and was the only baby that was right on scans.

See if you can get to speak to someone else and talk it all through then make a plan with that.

Tisfortired · 24/10/2023 18:57

I was advised baby was measuring small with my second and to have a section too, I was against it initially but my babies safety and health was more important to me than the kind of birth I had in my head. Turns out the cord was wrapped around his neck multiple time so supply had been restricted from the placenta. If I’d gone into labour naturally I was told it would have been quite dangers with him tangled up in the cord like that. He was born 5lb 6 at term, his birth weight measured exactly with the growth scan I’d had which triggered the section recommendation.

I understand your reluctance (I’d be the same) but the health professionals are dealing with these cases all day long and have yours and your babies best interests.

Narwhalsh · 24/10/2023 18:55

At this stage the scans are notoriously unreliable for size…

SaveMeFromMyBoobs · 24/10/2023 18:50

ReadingSoManyThreads · 24/10/2023 18:33

Oh give over, you are either incredibly misinformed or you're completely brainwashed.

40 weeks is a manmade date made up by obstetricians. Full-term is 37-42 weeks and even then, if a woman wishes to await spontaneous labour, she can go over 42 weeks.

And a pregnant woman is NOT "a patient". She's not sick, she's pregnant. Interventions come with risks, this is why when a baby is perfectly safe in the womb that women often choose less intervention, because it's safer.

Stop scaremongering the OP, she is not putting her baby or herself at risk by awaiting spontaneous labour when her baby is perfectly safe and healthy in her womb.

You have not assessed OP yourself, nor are you likely a medical professional or an actual clairvoyant. You have zero ability to assure anyone, OP especially, that the baby is healthy and safe in her womb.

The womb is not automatically safe. Pregnancy complications happen.

Anyflippingname · 24/10/2023 18:46

therealcookiemonster · 24/10/2023 18:35

@ReadingSoManyThreads yep brainwashed. 100%. that's medical school and postgraduate training for you. much better if labour units were run by people from mumsnet. I'll suggest in our next audit meeting.

👏👏👏👏👏👏

Bizjustgotreal · 24/10/2023 18:45

Tulips78 · 24/10/2023 14:41

I'd go for the c section, wouldn't have an induction under any circumstances, its basically making your body give birth before it's supposed to, they almost always fail or turn into emergency c sections and it's just drawn out misery and sometimes worse (fear, trauma etc)

This isn't a very balanced opinion. They do not almost always fail. Please discuss any concerns with your midwife.

Fwiw -I had an induction and despite it not being a walk in the park, I would have one again we're I to be in circumstances to require it (for me it was HBP and pre-E, but there were no concerns about baby's size or health.)

Wishing you all the best.

therealcookiemonster · 24/10/2023 18:43

@ReadingSoManyThreads Happy to hear it. until you update our guidelines however, I will carry on practising our current guidelines if that's OK.

SpookyMumster · 24/10/2023 18:41

i was offered an induction at 41 weeks just for being overdue. My baby was measuring fine. I was really reluctant but after a lot of thought I went ahead with it. I ended up having an emergency c section. During the surgery they said that I would never have delivered my baby naturally due to the position she was in. 7 weeks later I’ve got a healthy baby girl. My birth plan went down the toilet. I didn’t get to have a single thing I had asked for for various reasons. But I’m glad I listened to the midwives, they honestly know what they are doing. It really is your choice and only you can decide what you will be happy with. The way I decided was thinking about what would happen if I went for it and x happened and what would happen if I didn’t go for it and y happened.

congratulations on your little one and best of luck with your delivery, whatever you end up deciding just remember it was the right decision for you at the time and you’re doing what you believe is best for your baby

ReadingSoManyThreads · 24/10/2023 18:40

therealcookiemonster · 24/10/2023 18:35

@ReadingSoManyThreads yep brainwashed. 100%. that's medical school and postgraduate training for you. much better if labour units were run by people from mumsnet. I'll suggest in our next audit meeting.

Yep, thought as much. The UK is very behind with maternity care. And I really do have a lot of experience and technical knowledge with childbirth and UK maternity care. I do work closely to help update their practices but they are slower than snails to do this and even slower to infiltrate updates down through to the 'frontline', frustrating as hell to read scaremongering outdated bullshit that some of you lot spout.

BiffandChip1 · 24/10/2023 18:38

Tulips78 · 24/10/2023 14:41

I'd go for the c section, wouldn't have an induction under any circumstances, its basically making your body give birth before it's supposed to, they almost always fail or turn into emergency c sections and it's just drawn out misery and sometimes worse (fear, trauma etc)

Not necessarily. I had 3 inductions (3 chn) and none resulted in c-sections. I might have been one of the lucky ones...

MrsPepperpotspickles · 24/10/2023 18:36

These measurements (estimations) can be way off, told me my baby weighed over 9lb at 38+6, she was born at 40w exactly and weighed 8lb 3oz.

therealcookiemonster · 24/10/2023 18:35

@ReadingSoManyThreads yep brainwashed. 100%. that's medical school and postgraduate training for you. much better if labour units were run by people from mumsnet. I'll suggest in our next audit meeting.

PenguinRainbows · 24/10/2023 18:35

YABU and are risking your baby’s life.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 24/10/2023 18:33

therealcookiemonster · 24/10/2023 17:29

you are over 40 weeks. the baby needs to come out and your midwife is a trained professional and knows you as a patient. they gave you the correct advise. Trust me no one is booking unnecessary sections, we don't have the resources for it.

not sure where you are getting the "less intervention" is good approach. if intervention is needed, its needed. I would choose section over induction any day but that's a personal choice. if it goes on much longer, you will be putting yourself and baby at risk.

Oh give over, you are either incredibly misinformed or you're completely brainwashed.

40 weeks is a manmade date made up by obstetricians. Full-term is 37-42 weeks and even then, if a woman wishes to await spontaneous labour, she can go over 42 weeks.

And a pregnant woman is NOT "a patient". She's not sick, she's pregnant. Interventions come with risks, this is why when a baby is perfectly safe in the womb that women often choose less intervention, because it's safer.

Stop scaremongering the OP, she is not putting her baby or herself at risk by awaiting spontaneous labour when her baby is perfectly safe and healthy in her womb.

Swipe left for the next trending thread