Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To decline induction/c section for baby measuring small?

234 replies

imalreadythere · 24/10/2023 14:26

40+2 today. Baby measuring small but also engaged so maybe that's why?

Midwives offered induction or c section but I want to wait.

Aibu? The midwife wasn't that pleased I don't think.

OP posts:
HouseofGods · 24/10/2023 19:58

Induction (early) saved DC1. I'd had double figure scans including one the day before he was born showing that there were "no issues with placenta" and I was induced due to PE. It turned out the placenta had failed, it was gritty and falling apart and DC was under 4lbs needing a few weeks in NICU. I can't understand why anyone would go against the advice of medical professionals.

JustAMinutePleass · 24/10/2023 19:58

imalreadythere · 24/10/2023 14:37

How did you know that about the placenta?

You don’t unless you know what you’re looking for.

DS was measuring large for his age but his kicks weren’t consistant after 30 weeks. I kept a diary, plotted it in a chart, and showed it to a consultant to force them to give me an induction (the sporadic heart rate monitoring they did was ‘fine’. I had weekly scans, nothing came up.

Eventually I forced the issue and they gave me an induction on my due date. Law and behold his heart started failing during labour & after I gave birth the surgeon said the placenta was riddled with clots that were too small to be picked up in the scans. DS was born fine but he would have died had I trusted the midwives & consultant.

TeaKitten · 24/10/2023 19:57

ReadingSoManyThreads · 24/10/2023 19:42

On another comment, OK, I couldn't see where my other comment was, but I wrote "when", as in she knows her own situation, so if she knows her baby is perfectly safe and well, then in that scenario spontaneous labour is safe. The "when", meant if that's how it is in her situation. I wasn't stating that factually her baby "IS" safe, because I don't know the information to determine that.

From what the OP has written the medical professionals haven't actually stated what risks they believe the baby has, measuring small at full-term is not an indication that baby is 'at risk', measurements once babies are engaged are notoriously inaccurate and cannot be relied upon. Nothing the OP has written suggests that baby is "at risk". OP can request can request specific tests such as on the umbilical cord/placenta and then decide what is best. The medics clearly do not think baby is in any immediate danger, otherwise, baby would have already been born by now via immediate induction or emergency c-section. As I said, them thinking baby is measuring small at full-term is not a good medical reason to be pressuring for induction or c-section.

No baby wouldn’t have been born immediately by induction or c section, because OP has declined this. They can’t decide for you if they think the risk is high enough, it’s 100% OPs choice at every stage. OP also hasn’t said she’s been pressured, she said she’s been offered it.

TwinkleDinkleStarDar · 24/10/2023 19:56

TwinkleDinkleStarDar · 24/10/2023 18:19

I was induced with my 3rd as my DS had IUGR....... it ended up being my easiest / least traumatic labour!

I felt uneasy about being induced because of the epidural...... I went ahead with the induction without the epidural at first and it was brutal 😂

As soon as I has the epidural it was plain sailing and pain free.

If their saying induction or C-section I'd take the option of an induction now before it's too late and you might end up needing a c-section which is a lot harder to recover from

Also - your rarely induced on the day they tell you to come in, I had to wait 2 days to be induced as they had a waiting list, so your baby will most likely still have a few extra days in the womb whilst your waiting in hospital

Just adding as I've seen lots of posters saying they were wrong about the babys weight

DS2 was 4lb 9oz, induced at 37 weeks. He was smaller in length than my DS1 who was born prematurely at 24 weeks.

DS1 was 33cm and weighed 1lb 5oz
DS2 was 29cm and weighed 4lb 9oz

ActDottie · 24/10/2023 19:56

I think it’s fine to decline this at the moment and perhaps reconsider in a week or so. My understanding anything up to 42 weeks is generally fine. I think after 42 weeks the risks to baby increase but it’s still very small in absolute terms.

clappyjay · 24/10/2023 19:54

Anonymouslyposting · 24/10/2023 19:51

I don’t think this is true. The risk of an emergency c section goes up if you have an induction rather than going into labour naturally but I’m pretty sure “almost always” is a significant exaggeration. Certainly out of the people I know well who have had babies in the last 5 years or so none of those who had inductions (4) ended with a c section - anecdotal obviously and I’m sure you can find the real statistics if you want.

It’s very dependent on personal circumstances. I looked at statistics for my local hospital and 50% of inductions for first-time mothers end up as an emergency c-section so I would personally be unsure whether to accept in that scenario or go for a planned section. No idea on OPs personal circumstances (unless I’ve missed a post where she’s explained more). Really they should be offering all this discussion with her at hospital.

JustAMinutePleass · 24/10/2023 19:52

A small baby is often a sign of placental failure. I wouldn’t go over a day past 40 weeks in that position.

clappyjay · 24/10/2023 19:52

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 24/10/2023 19:49

If it helps, in France they consider 41 weeks as the limit they’ll allow women to go to spontaneously, rather than 42 as here.

Some hospitals here will routinely offer induction at 41 weeks as well. Others won’t until closer to 42 weeks. Just shows how even different NHS hospitals have completely different ‘professional guidelines’ about what is the safest thing to do.

Anonymouslyposting · 24/10/2023 19:51

Tulips78 · 24/10/2023 14:41

I'd go for the c section, wouldn't have an induction under any circumstances, its basically making your body give birth before it's supposed to, they almost always fail or turn into emergency c sections and it's just drawn out misery and sometimes worse (fear, trauma etc)

I don’t think this is true. The risk of an emergency c section goes up if you have an induction rather than going into labour naturally but I’m pretty sure “almost always” is a significant exaggeration. Certainly out of the people I know well who have had babies in the last 5 years or so none of those who had inductions (4) ended with a c section - anecdotal obviously and I’m sure you can find the real statistics if you want.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 24/10/2023 19:49

If it helps, in France they consider 41 weeks as the limit they’ll allow women to go to spontaneously, rather than 42 as here.

clappyjay · 24/10/2023 19:49

It’s not necessarily about ‘wanting’ a ‘certain kind of birth’ but understandably OP may be cautious of interventions like induction or caesarean section that can come with their own increased risks of an adverse outcome. I would want to be more informed of risks/benefits/accuracy that was relevant to my own personal circumstances.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/10/2023 19:48

Just to say I had a sweep with Dd ( 40 +9 - cheeky monkey) then went into labour spontaneously over the next day. It is quite a gentle " intervention" would you consider that ?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 24/10/2023 19:47

I had a baby measuring small and he was induced on his due date. Came out bigger than they thought at 6.6 lbs though.

He did come out very “over done”’looking - wrinkley and without any of that vernix (?) stuff, so perhaps he was ready to come out.

momonpurpose · 24/10/2023 19:45

therealcookiemonster · 24/10/2023 18:30

@Ohhbaby I'm a medic with over 10 years of experience in the labour ward. that's where I get my ideas from. where do you get yours from?

Thank You. Sure everyone has their ideal way to give birth. I wanted the same as OP. But had I not listened to medical professionals neither of us would be here. It could be fine but why on earth would you take the chance

TMess · 24/10/2023 19:45

I had a C-section at 37 weeks with one of mine because of measuring small for dates which was very out of character for me as I’d had all my others spontaneously and unmedicated at 40+ but I trusted my midwife implicitly. DS would’ve died if I’d not done it. The placenta was barely functional when he came out. Not something I would ever recommend risking personally.

Ecnerual · 24/10/2023 19:45

You are probably best off talking to your care team about your next steps, it's fine to ask to speak to another midwife or obstetrician if you don't feel your mw will support you. Agree with the PP who suggested the BRAIN decision making tool, also consider:

How was the baby measured? Was it a fundal height measurement or a scan measurement? (Or both?) Was the tailing growth based on a single measurement? Or has this been an ongoing trend over several measurements? Fundal height measurements should be done by the same person, scan measurements in late pregnancy are less accurate, and single measurements don't tell us a lot, that's not to say there isn't something going on though. Was a Doppler scan also done? Do you have any additional risk factors for still birth?

If you decide not to go for an induction/ c-section you will probably be offered daily CTG monitoring. Continue to monitor your baby's movements, any changes or concerns at all go into your unit for a CTG.

Wishing you all the best OP.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 24/10/2023 19:42

TeaKitten · 24/10/2023 19:26

Actually you said

Stop scaremongering the OP, she is not putting her baby or herself at risk by awaiting spontaneous labour when her baby is perfectly safe and healthy in her womb.

how is that not referring specifically to the OPs baby? The medical professionals believe her baby could be at risk as it’s measuring small. Yet you've decided it’s perfectly healthy and safe.

On another comment, OK, I couldn't see where my other comment was, but I wrote "when", as in she knows her own situation, so if she knows her baby is perfectly safe and well, then in that scenario spontaneous labour is safe. The "when", meant if that's how it is in her situation. I wasn't stating that factually her baby "IS" safe, because I don't know the information to determine that.

From what the OP has written the medical professionals haven't actually stated what risks they believe the baby has, measuring small at full-term is not an indication that baby is 'at risk', measurements once babies are engaged are notoriously inaccurate and cannot be relied upon. Nothing the OP has written suggests that baby is "at risk". OP can request can request specific tests such as on the umbilical cord/placenta and then decide what is best. The medics clearly do not think baby is in any immediate danger, otherwise, baby would have already been born by now via immediate induction or emergency c-section. As I said, them thinking baby is measuring small at full-term is not a good medical reason to be pressuring for induction or c-section.

Robotik · 24/10/2023 19:36

Sorry but the midwives and doctors have years of training and experience and they wouldn’t recommend intervention unless it was needed. I sound blunt but I think you’ve been stupid and it’s even more foolish asking randoms on mumsnet after you’ve declined to follow professional guidance

Suckingalemon · 24/10/2023 19:34

After my first was born they examined the placenta and said it was gritty and that she had needed to be born, she was a week early. The day before they had been mulling over whether to induce because she was measuring small. I can't remember why they decided to give it another couple of days before inducing, but mother nature intervened in the meantime and I went into spontaneous labour.

In your shoes I would go for the induction.

clappyjay · 24/10/2023 19:33

I don’t really think the OP is wrong to consider all her options.

I didn’t blindly follow advice without seeking to know all the facts. Different hospitals often recommend completely different things as well. My local hospital routinely induced at 7 days overdue, however the hospital 10 minutes down the road waited until 12 days. So which ‘professional advice’ was correct?

Some hospitals will offer a planned caesarean in situations where others will not. There are a lot of examples. Unfortunately in many cases it’s not as clear-cut as there being one obvious correct proper choice that every health professional would agree on. So for me it makes so much obvious sense for a woman to try and know all her options, the pros and the cons, her own personal risk factors and preferences before she makes her decision.

TeaKitten · 24/10/2023 19:32

itsmyp4rty · 24/10/2023 19:29

Yes but measuring small means nothing. It can be well out.

Yea, but It’s clearly a risk factor or they wouldn’t be recommending intervention. If they thought the baby certainly was healthy and safe were it was, they wouldn’t be recommending a c section.

itsmyp4rty · 24/10/2023 19:29

TeaKitten · 24/10/2023 19:26

Actually you said

Stop scaremongering the OP, she is not putting her baby or herself at risk by awaiting spontaneous labour when her baby is perfectly safe and healthy in her womb.

how is that not referring specifically to the OPs baby? The medical professionals believe her baby could be at risk as it’s measuring small. Yet you've decided it’s perfectly healthy and safe.

Yes but measuring small means nothing. It can be well out.

itsmyp4rty · 24/10/2023 19:27

I had a terrible time with the NHS, too many people who just want to tick boxes and couldn't really care less about what you as an individual, they shouldn't be getting annoyed with you it's so unprofessional, they should be giving you all the information and letting you decide. It's probably more convenient to them if you just agree to a c section.

I couldn't recommend an independent midwife enough, I felt I had to get one in the end as I had such an appalling experience with the NHS. Not fit for purpose sadly. The independent midwife was expensive but worth every penny, all the care was centred around me and my wants and needs, it was a completely and utterly different experience and was the first time I felt listened to in any way, shape or form.

The NHS made me have extra scans because I have a low weight even though that is completely normal for me and my family. The told me my baby was going to be small - he was over 9lbs - and they told me that I couldn't give birth in the unit where I'd had my care because I'd gone over my dates. I hadn't gone over my dates, they just wouldn't listen to me when i said I had very long cycles and that I'd charted my temps so knew exactly when I had conceived. They would only go on my LMP which was 10 days out.

Honestly I found them completely and utterly useless, there was no patient centred care and I was completely stressed out by the end of it. After they told me I couldn't give birth at the unit they said I'd have to travel well over an hour away to get to hospital as the nearest one was full.

So if you can afford it get an independent midwife and enjoy a completely different experience.

TeaKitten · 24/10/2023 19:26

ReadingSoManyThreads · 24/10/2023 19:22

I did not say that, I said "when a baby is perfectly safe", and I was talking in general terms, not specifically the OP's baby. The OP has not mentioned any actual risk factors here, nevertheless, I was not assessing via the internet, for goodness sake, way to twist things 🙄

Actually you said

Stop scaremongering the OP, she is not putting her baby or herself at risk by awaiting spontaneous labour when her baby is perfectly safe and healthy in her womb.

how is that not referring specifically to the OPs baby? The medical professionals believe her baby could be at risk as it’s measuring small. Yet you've decided it’s perfectly healthy and safe.

therealcookiemonster · 24/10/2023 19:25

@ReadingSoManyThreads not sure what your problem is? I am finding your attitude quite bullying. I have given my personal opinion as this is what this forum is for. I am not advising as a clinician because OP is not my patient. i would like to remind you that you are not my trainer or my boss. so not really your place to tell random strangers off? I could go on and about what you are saying but am choosing not to because quite frankly clinical debate is for colleagues and peers. let's agree to disagree like civilised adults.

Swipe left for the next trending thread