Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To decline induction/c section for baby measuring small?

234 replies

imalreadythere · 24/10/2023 14:26

40+2 today. Baby measuring small but also engaged so maybe that's why?

Midwives offered induction or c section but I want to wait.

Aibu? The midwife wasn't that pleased I don't think.

OP posts:
Caerulea · 24/10/2023 22:03

JhsLs · 24/10/2023 18:14

This is actually not necessarily true. The attached image shows 4 columns: gestation in weeks, number of births that year, number of still births, % of stillbirths. As you can see, there is no more risk at 42 weeks than there is at 40 weeks (and that year, there were in fact fewer stillbirths at 42 weeks than full term). I am not suggesting OP should ignore medical professionals but I believe there are some myths surrounding stillbirths and going over 40-41 weeks which leads women to make decisions which are not based on facts.

Firstly - why did you go to 2017 which had a very low birthrate. Lowest in 10ys! Why not use the latest data?

Secondly - that is NOT how to read or present data. Especially on this matter. It's incredibly misleading to oversimplify. Births at 42+ weeks are far far more likely to have been closely monitored with 'at risk' births already being induced or c-sectioned.

That data is absolutely not evidence that you can simply wait to 42wks & be less at risk & it's dangerous to present it as such.

phoenixrosehere · 24/10/2023 21:44

clappyjay · 24/10/2023 19:33

I don’t really think the OP is wrong to consider all her options.

I didn’t blindly follow advice without seeking to know all the facts. Different hospitals often recommend completely different things as well. My local hospital routinely induced at 7 days overdue, however the hospital 10 minutes down the road waited until 12 days. So which ‘professional advice’ was correct?

Some hospitals will offer a planned caesarean in situations where others will not. There are a lot of examples. Unfortunately in many cases it’s not as clear-cut as there being one obvious correct proper choice that every health professional would agree on. So for me it makes so much obvious sense for a woman to try and know all her options, the pros and the cons, her own personal risk factors and preferences before she makes her decision.

Agree.

My last trust coerced me into an induction, using stillbirth stats that didn’t apply to my specific situation. They did several tests that said things were normal including one to check my placenta because they thought baby looked big (wasn’t even 7 lbs). The induction failed because my body wasn’t ready and I had even asked my bishop score which gives chances of success so I could make an informed decision and was never told, only told they had to start the induction process first. Reported them and notes were looked through and there was nothing there to support that it was needed or should have been recommended in the first place. My placenta was healthy and showed no signs of issues.

Had my youngest at a different hospital and they asked me my history. When I told them about my first pregnancy, they immediately rolled their eyes when they heard about the stillbirth stats and said those stats are meaningless for most women and aren’t even based on specific cases. I was overdue for a few days, planning for a vaginal birth until they told me how the baby was positioned. They had no issues with me asking questions, gave me my options, explained the risks and left me to think about it. I even asked if something else was possible and they were unsure. They went and asked another doctor. The options were to wait until I naturally labour, planned cs, or induction. Induction was out easily due to it being of high risk to both baby and me and them worried about my cs scar. I decided for an elective cs instead because the way baby was moving there was no guarantee she would remain in the right position during labour. She had already been shifted into a favorable position 12 hours before by one doctor and had shifted several times before that within 3 minutes during the ultrasound surprising the new doctor. If she were to have done that in labour at the wrong time it could easily turn it into an em cs situation and risky for both of us. I didn’t want to risk a vaginal birth that could end up in an em cs.

My planned cs was a few hours after I made my decision. It was really calm, able to use the music I had planned for labour, those working on me introduced themselves and we chatted while some prepped me and while others were performing the procedure. I had everything I had hoped for in my birth notes, just not the exit. I was happy with that and content in knowing it was an informed evidence-based decision I made myself, not told to me or forced upon me. Procedure was barely an hour, she has a healthy set of lungs, 10 apgar, and I was able to have skin to skin and start to establish bf. Milk came in day 2.

landbeforegrime · 24/10/2023 21:29

I was advised to have an induction at 40 weeks due to my age at the time of birth (40). I was really unhappy with the idea and looked into the research and discussed it with the consultant. The risk of still birth starts to increase after 38 or 39 weeks (I cannot remember which but it starts to increase before even the 40 week threshold). Measuring small increases the risk further. Yes, the odds are in your favour, but there are on average 8 still born babies every day in the UK. I went with an induction because I would never be able to get over ignoring the advice and being solely responsible for taking a decision which led to an otherwise avoidable still birth. I was terrified of induction - everyone (apart from the medics) said to go for an elective c section. I had really bad DRAM and the advice is to avoid a c section where possible if you have this. I also know of a few bad c section recovery stories. Nothing with child birth is fool proof or perfect. I can however try to reassure by sharing my positive induction story. My labour post induction was quick, too quick for any pain relief - baby came 6 hours after the first pessary, and within an hour of my waters breaking - natural delivery with no intervention. Healthy baby. The contractions were intense and strong but it was over quickly and I coped. My first labour (without induction) was also intense until I was drugged up with pethidine. Then labour slowed right down and lasted for hours. Pros and cons to both. Do not regret my decision at all for the induction. I have no doubt that I would be suffering and struggling for the rest of my life if I had given birth to my DD still born. Not a risk I would be prepare to take. The induction was fine. The risk of need for intervention is higher with induction (not by a huge amount) but it's impossible to say whether there would have been a need for intervention without induction and if the reason for the pregnancy needing an induction is also an underlying reason for the intervention being needed as well. The point being there are so many unknowns and the data just does not exist to explain or confirm any of this when it comes to induction and the probability of intervention/ emergency c section. What they do know however is the increased risk of still birth given various factors and in those higher risk situations induction is advised. Gambling on the odds with something as precious as my baby's life was not for me.

babybythesea · 24/10/2023 21:15

My baby measured small. I was advised that they’d keep an eye on her but not recommend induction just yet (38 weeks). We attended a couple more check ups - keep an eye on her. We were due the next check up on 40+6. At 40+3 my very active baby went still. Suddenly and completely. I went to my midwife who checked her heart was still beating, which it was but recommended that I was induced. Now. it was a vaginal birth but the cord was wrapped round her neck so it was tense for a while. She was 7lb so not tiny but she had stopped growing.
But that drive to the hospital desperately prodding her and willing her to move is the worst I’ve ever done. It turned out the placenta had calcium deposits on it which is apparently seen in smokers although I’ve never smoked, and it means the placenta isn’t working properly. We were lucky because she stopped moving which meant I got help. If she’d continued to fidget I might have left it and I might not have a teenager telling me I’m “so not cool, just stop,ok?”

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 24/10/2023 20:57

Flittingaboutagain · 24/10/2023 20:52

I didn't listen to the midwife or the consultant when I was told I "had" to be induced - they couldn't give me any specific reasons beyond increased risks. I have my two gorgeous babies to show for it without a traumatic birth....so how patronising are you?

Randoms on MN are simply suggesting some questions she can ask to clarify.

There aren't any medals love. Let's just all be happy things turned out well and stop getting annoyed at others having a different opinion to you.

Changedmymind99 · 24/10/2023 20:53

if you can wait. The less intervention the better for you.
get bouncing on your ball

Flittingaboutagain · 24/10/2023 20:52

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 24/10/2023 20:48

How patronising are you? I don't give a shit if my comment annoys you, it's my opinion. I'd listen to a midwife over some random on mumsnet every time. Oh and I was induced by the way and had a fairly traumatic birth with my first, but I have a gorgeous 13 year old daughter to show for it now and I'd do it again in a heartbeat.

I didn't listen to the midwife or the consultant when I was told I "had" to be induced - they couldn't give me any specific reasons beyond increased risks. I have my two gorgeous babies to show for it without a traumatic birth....so how patronising are you?

Randoms on MN are simply suggesting some questions she can ask to clarify.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 24/10/2023 20:48

Lelophants · 24/10/2023 20:15

These comments always annoy me. It’s not about wanting the ‘perfect birth’ and actually there’s more than just being alive. 1 in 3 women have birth trauma. Getting a baby out early via interventions isn’t always best. That’s why second opinions from different professionals is really important.
The NHS doenst always get things perfectly right, you might be surprised to know.

How patronising are you? I don't give a shit if my comment annoys you, it's my opinion. I'd listen to a midwife over some random on mumsnet every time. Oh and I was induced by the way and had a fairly traumatic birth with my first, but I have a gorgeous 13 year old daughter to show for it now and I'd do it again in a heartbeat.

LovelyGreenCushions · 24/10/2023 20:38

My 'small' baby was born at just short of 42 weeks. Advice was to wait as the baby was small

weighed 12lbs- largest baby born in hospital for a year

usererror99 · 24/10/2023 20:23

Depends if you can live with the guilt if the worst happens doesn't it? I personally couldn't.

You aren't a trained medical professional presumably so I don't understand why you'd go against their advice. Got to be the only medical profession I know where the patient insists they know more than them. Must be incredibly frustrating for midwives

TeaKitten · 24/10/2023 20:16

ReadingSoManyThreads · 24/10/2023 20:12

@TeaKitten yes of course indeed it is the OP's decision, but I have never heard of any woman who has declined NECESSARY intervention when their baby is at serious risk. This clearly isn't the case here, they don't appear to have given OP any actual detailed information as far as we know to make any decision and from what the OP has written, baby is not at any "serious risk", meaning an immediate birth is necessary. Not sure I'm being very clear, I'm very tired right now.

You are just so determined to be right and have the last word with everyone, that you are making less and less sense. Pointless talking to you any further at this point.

Zanatdy · 24/10/2023 20:15

I don’t blame you for not wanting intervention, as inductions often lead to assisted births and emergency C sections. Can you go in and be monitored daily instead? Or set a date in which you will be induced. It’s your choice and often they are wrong about size and if scans etc have shown it to be ok. Growth can slow / stop though and that in itself can be risky, but I think the professional do jump to induction etc as they need to ensure they are managing the risk and at 40+2 obvious answer is induction, especially as they induce early now (not 2wks like when I had my kids)

Lelophants · 24/10/2023 20:15

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 24/10/2023 18:25

Why would you go against the advice of a medical professional? I'm sure everyone has an idea of what their perfect birth is but ultimately it doesn't matter how the baby is delivered as long as it's safe.

These comments always annoy me. It’s not about wanting the ‘perfect birth’ and actually there’s more than just being alive. 1 in 3 women have birth trauma. Getting a baby out early via interventions isn’t always best. That’s why second opinions from different professionals is really important.
The NHS doenst always get things perfectly right, you might be surprised to know.

Whatelsecouldibecalled · 24/10/2023 20:13

I'm not sure I would ignore professional advice at the risk of you and your baby. I would ask for a placenta scan and make sure that is working fine.

For what it's worth I have had an induction for DS 1 and it was absolutely fine. 17 hours from Pessary in to birth. I did have a nasty tear but I had previous complications so I don't think totally related to inductions And a planned section with DS2 whixh was an absolute dream

ReadingSoManyThreads · 24/10/2023 20:13

AhBiscuits · 24/10/2023 20:12

I think you're insane personally. Aren't you constantly worried that your placenta is failing and your baby will die? I doubt I'd think about anything else in your shoes.

Oh jesus, dramatic much??

AhBiscuits · 24/10/2023 20:12

I think you're insane personally. Aren't you constantly worried that your placenta is failing and your baby will die? I doubt I'd think about anything else in your shoes.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 24/10/2023 20:12

@TeaKitten yes of course indeed it is the OP's decision, but I have never heard of any woman who has declined NECESSARY intervention when their baby is at serious risk. This clearly isn't the case here, they don't appear to have given OP any actual detailed information as far as we know to make any decision and from what the OP has written, baby is not at any "serious risk", meaning an immediate birth is necessary. Not sure I'm being very clear, I'm very tired right now.

Bournetilly · 24/10/2023 20:11

My DC2 was measuring small throughout the whole pregnancy (2nd percentile), he was born on the 50% percentile so the measurements were wrong the whole way through, possibly due to him lying in an awkward position. The predictions aren’t always right (just something to consider).

Imuptoolate · 24/10/2023 20:08

The decision is yours and I do get the fear of having interventions and potential birth injuries, but you could have those with a ‘natural’ birth anyway or you could wait and still end up having to be induced or end up with EMCS.

For what it’s worth, I was induced with my first and only needed the pessary before going into natural labour. Baby was here only a few hours later, no interventions during actual delivery stage and no birth injuries. Not all inductions are a horror story or end in a c section.

ThatMrsM · 24/10/2023 20:04

I had an induction (which was a very positive experience for me and I had no other interventions apart from the induction) with my first baby. He was measuring small and also the blood flow measurements from the placenta were too low, indicating that the placenta wasn't working as it should.

I think if baby was just measuring small and everything else looks good then I would maybe ask to wait another week. I think if there was a real medical need they wouldn't just be offering an induction/C section - they would tell you it was needed.

NortieTortie · 24/10/2023 20:03

Yabu. Interventions are there to lower the risk of infant and maternal mortality.

crazyaginglady · 24/10/2023 20:02

So tricky. Both mine measured small - on the 10th centile, then went up, then went down and I was induced for both. Neither were small and were both born 50th centile. Scans were wrong. I knew second time round they were wrong but I was too scared to go against medical advice though in both cases the measurements were incorrect.

Robotik · 24/10/2023 20:00

ActDottie · 24/10/2023 19:56

I think it’s fine to decline this at the moment and perhaps reconsider in a week or so. My understanding anything up to 42 weeks is generally fine. I think after 42 weeks the risks to baby increase but it’s still very small in absolute terms.

Pregnancies that continued to 41 weeks—currently still considered normal term gestation —had a small but significant increase in the risk of stillbirth compared with those delivered at 40 weeks, with no difference in neonatal mortality.

From the British medical journal: https://www.bmj.com/content/366/bmj.l4487

why on Earth would you take a risk - however small - of increased still birth when the medical professionals are saying they will deliver baby now and she could have him or her safely in her arms?? All in the name of not wanting ‘intervention’. I wonder how many women in the Victorian era would have survived with intervention!

Risk of stillbirth increases after 41 weeks, study finds

The risk of stillbirth increases with every week that a pregnancy continues past 37 weeks, according to an analysis of more than 15 million pregnancies.1 Pregnancies that continued to 41 weeks—currently still considered normal term gestation —had a sm...

https://www.bmj.com/content/366/bmj.l4487

VORE · 24/10/2023 20:00

So I am saying this as someone who was planning to have a water birth at birth centre, with no medical intervention and was dead set on having this super low intervention woo woo birth. But I actually ended up being induced with an epidural and had an absolutely wonderful birth experience. In fact I actually say that out of our nct group I had one of the best birth experiences especially in comparison to the ‘all natural’ mothers.

I think there is a huge push on social media etc to go for this woo woo birth with no intervention because doctors are all idiots, your body knows what it’s doing, you are empowered by ancient wisdom blah blah and this is how all those hypnobirthing courses etc make their money.

But the truth of the matter is (that no one wants to mention) is that A LOT of babies used to die before and during childbirth and we are incredibly lucky that we now have the medical means to deliver babies safely that 100 years ago would have perished.

OP I am saying this (and only because I’ve been on both sides of the fence) you do not get a medal at the end for having low intervention birth and you will hate yourself every singe day for the rest of your life if something were to happen to the baby because you didn’t listen to the professional because you had all these dreamy ideas about ‘low intervention’.

Second time round I’ve asked for an early epidural and actually have an appointment next week to see if they will induce me at 38 weeks because my PGP is so bad and I had such a good experience with both last time!

The birth is a tiny blip in your life and will be over before you know it, having your healthy child is the thing that’s forever.

8misskitty8 · 24/10/2023 19:59

Is there a reason you’ve had extra scans ? Have they been concerned previously about the baby size ?

When I had Dd1 the only scan you got was the 12 week one. I measured fine for dates and she was born at 41+4, the day before I was booked for induction.
She was just over 6lb and the placenta was all gloopy and runny when it came out, so it had begun to break down and rot.
Had I had a scan near due date they might have picked that up.

If you’ve had extra scans and it’s showing the baby is small and they are suggesting induction or section then they must be concerned about letting baby stay in.