Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried DS will start school without being potty trained

258 replies

Doitproperly · 24/10/2023 12:54

I’m becoming concerned for September.

DS just isn’t interested in potty training. He won’t tell you if he needs a wee or poo (not even sure if he knows) and refuses to sit on the potty. Feeling really embarrassed and like a bit of a failure. Not sure if anyone’s got any tips?

OP posts:
RonObvious · 01/11/2023 07:04

We had the same worry - my son was just not interested. He would sit there and poo or wee himself, and then just sit in it, utterly unconcerned. If you asked him about it, he would deny it. Nothing the books or general advice said applied to him. We had used washable nappies, and kids are supposed to hate the feeling of being wet or soiled - nope. He didn't care one bit. And rewards do not work with him. At all. Never have (tbf, he is now waiting an assessment for autism).

Anyhow, we got there in the end, but I think it took pretty much until the summer before school started. What never helps is that there was a lack of consistency between home and pre-school - if he had an accident at pre-school, they would simply put a nappy on him afterwards. So, not. much advice here - just a little solidarity!

lifehappens12 · 01/11/2023 06:55

Hello. Friendly response here. I left training with my son til he was 3 and half so would have been about October and he started school the following September. He showed no signs of being ready but we went for it!

I used the methods in the oh crap book which is basically stay in the house bare bum for about 4 days. Potty went in each room we played in and set a timer on alexis to ring every 30 mins to get him to sit down.

What really worked though was a reward chart. As he was older he understood what that was

caringcarer · 01/11/2023 06:48

I didn't know DC could start school in a nappy. It wouldn't be fair to expect teachers or TA to change nappies. Sit DC on the potty 5-10 mins after he eats. Give him a book and read him a story. If he wees give him a Smarty. If he poos Give him a Freddy Frog choc bar if he poos. I used to clap my hands and do a little cheer if DC went on the potty.

AnneofRedGables · 01/11/2023 04:11

@Doitproperly Seriously, don’t worry about it. DS2 wasn’t reliably potty trained for wees until around 3.6. At 4.2 he’s only just now starting to use the potty/toilet reliably for poos and still has accidents. He’s a September baby so also doesn’t start school until next year.

interested to know how pp’s suggest grabbing the child and sitting them on the potty when they start weeing, if said child goes rigid and refuses to sit?

We also panicked and tried to force the issue. All it’s done is made DS hold his poos in for up to 11 days at a time so that now he needs daily meds to help him go.

DS1 was a different kettle of fish and was completely done within 2 days just after turning 3, so I suspect some of the ‘advice’ from pp’s is from parents of children like him. I’d have probably given the same advice if I hadn’t gone through the ringer with DS2 to be fair.

Just keep encouraging but don’t over-focus on it or it can become a massive issue. He will get there in his own time, I promise. You’re doing great 💐

Yesyoucant · 01/11/2023 03:10

LoveTheDetectorists · 24/10/2023 15:35

I’ll admit here that I never did potty training.
Mine (3) were at nursery from a young age, 5 days a week, all day.
Nursery did the potty training and asked us to keep with it at the weekend.
We didn’t.
Neither did our other full time working friends.
Thats all besides the point really and makes me sound neglectful but hayho.

How the nursery did it.
Sit on potty for a short while on the hour every hour. Read them a book whilst sat there or give them something to do.
Ask if they’ve done anything.
It was obvious when our eldest son needed a poo as he’d hide behind the sofa, so we just took him to the toilet. He got the idea. But we didn’t do the sitting on the potty thing for ages at home. That was at nursery when they began training them.

There’s lots of time, don’t worry.

This is interesting.. our nursery suggested we go for it as mine had been asking to go etc.

So at home I'm trying to encourage regularly to sit but they don't seem to do this and instead she has multiple "accidents " a day. I don't think they ever ask her despite me telling them this. Result: 4 changes of clothes yesterday alone and binned pants ( not spending a 2nd evening scraping shit off them!)

This weekend I'll need to have a proper run at it again. It's been absolutely exhausting this week and it's not even half way through. ( also now awake thanks to my snoring husband and worrying about it! )

OP - how are you getting on?

flagwaver · 29/10/2023 16:09

enchantedsquirrelwood · 24/10/2023 15:41

Oh if only life were so easy. I assume your child(ren) trained themselves at 18 months.

I wonder if you'd be so rude and judgey in real life?

No, lovey, I potty trained them but that was when we didn't have the never ending convenience of disposable nappies, being potty trained was a relief for all!

As for 'judgey' I gather the only opinions which are judged, er, non-judgey are those which fit the MN mantra. C'est la vie.

CarrotsAndCheese · 25/10/2023 12:25

I asked this exact question during a primary school open day last week. The head teacher was very reassuring and said they have a few children in Reception class who are still in nappies, some with SEN but some without.

Our 3.5 year old is partially potty trained. Attempt at the start of summer was disastrous and our child was extremely distressed and was withholding for such a long time that we were worried about a UTI developing. So we backed right off.

A couple of weeks later, our child suddenly said they wanted to use the potty! We didn't push it but tried again a few weeks later and they were in pants after a couple of days with only a couple of accidents since then. Slight regression since starting nursery. Our child is extremely stubborn and has unbelievable bladder control so can hold on for 6 hours!

They still poo in their nappy at nap time though. And night dryness depends on when their brain reliably produces enough anti-diuretic hormone, so not in anyone's control. So I'm not worried about their continuing to wear night nappies for a long while yet.

Don't feel bad. All you can do is try and if it doesn't work, back off for a month or two to give them more time to develop, then try again, and repeat as necessary. The Princess Polly/Pirate Pete book worked well and lots of stickers.

Good luck! And remember there's nearly a year before they start school next September and a lot can happen in a year at that age.

Orchidbloom79 · 24/10/2023 18:45

Not read the other replies so sorry if repeated info!

I work in education. It’s illegal to refuse a child for not being toilet trained. We HAVE to change them. Some schools say otherwise - they are not allowed! But we will be taking steps to support toilet training with the parent/carers. Look at info on the ERIC website.

So many still in nappies in pre school, 3/4 year olds, some still in reception 4/5 year olds. But peers may comment. So it’s not massively unusual tbh. Especially children in school with Sen. And children have accidents to just pack spare clothes.

But you do need to stick to it when you start. Nappies are an issue as they are now so well designed children don’t feel when they’ve been. If going to school it will mostly be the toilet with the little seats and a step. We start by changing in the toilet. Change in here only where possible. Get them to pull everything down and sit on the toilet, change from here. Particularly first thing on a morning, 20/30 mins after main food, drinks etc. lots of positive praise. Have toilet toys, only for the toilet. Or read. Find what works, sticker chart, choosing their own new pa to etc. Get them used to the toilet. Remove nappies. They might need to feel the sensation to realise.

Lizzieregina · 24/10/2023 18:44

Oh I do have one “incentive” that some boys like! Throw a couple of cheerios in the toilet and let him try to hit them! You’re probably going to have to do a bit of cleaning and also maybe get dad to show how it’s done, but might be worth a try!

surreygirl1987 · 24/10/2023 18:42

Buy the 'Oh Crap" potty training book. Ignore the bit about the ideal age window. Worked for my kids.

Lizzieregina · 24/10/2023 18:41

I didn’t read all the comments, but my two older kids were 3.5 and 3y 4m when they announced that today they were using the potty. They were done instantly. No accidents, poo and pee in the potty and dry at night (although I used a nappy for a couple of weeks). I had tried “training” when they were younger and they weren’t interested. When I gave up and ignored the whole thing, they did it themselves. I did have potty books and fancy underwear, so it was mentioned as background noise now and again, but I never tried to force it.

So, I’d say for you to not try and force it right now, but maybe still read the potty books and have the fancy undies ready to go and he might get there if there’s no pressure. You have 11 months!

Doitproperly · 24/10/2023 18:29

@AfterWeights posts like that are where people really don’t understand. Some posters who have replied have had similar experiences to me, where their DC just won’t sit on the toilet / potty or if they will won’t wee or poo. Replying to me in an exasperated tone as if you’re speaking to a particularly irritating child isn’t helpful. Maybe you thought it was: it wasn’t.

OP posts:
AfterWeights · 24/10/2023 18:12

Oh and its bloody myth they all show signs "they want to" or "are ready". Loads of kids don't give a fuck and can't be bothered because its boring and they don't mind being dirty. You as the parent make the decision.

AfterWeights · 24/10/2023 18:10

What do you mean, "how do i do it?"

You take off the nappy and leave him bare bum.

You take him to the potty every 30 mins.

You accept he will wet himself/the floor etc. You use language "oh look DS your legs are wet you've done a wee/ you needed a wee".

Eventually over a few days watching him like a hawk, you recognise the signs he needs to go and you manage to get him on the potty when a wee comes out, at which point you celebrate loads, show him the wee in the potty and give him a chocolate button.

Repeat ad nauseam and it clicks.

If you are trying to do it wearing pull ups etc to avoid mess, give up.

lamalamalamasquirrel · 24/10/2023 17:30

flagwaver · 24/10/2023 13:11

If you don't bother to toilet train him then I hope you'll be available to go into school every day to deal with his nappy, it's not reasonable to expect the staff to do your job.

No need for that. OP has come here to ask for help to try and prevent exactly that!

Startyabastard · 24/10/2023 17:28

Sorry if this has been mentioned but show him how you go to the toilet and wipe yourself.
Tell him you are going to the toilet because you need a wee/poo etc.
It can't be the most pleasurable experience* *having someone watch you do that, but if you can stomach that, do it, I'd say.

Mulhollandmagoo · 24/10/2023 17:18

Oh, and once they do start training, it doesn't take long so don't worry too much, September is a long way away

Mulhollandmagoo · 24/10/2023 17:17

I am going to get absolutely shredded for this on Mumsnet, but we had a tub of chocolate buttons, and she got one for using the potty! Worked a treat 😂

Also, my daughter wasn't arsed for the potty, but we got a ladder come toilet seat thing from Amazon and she much preferred that.

PansyP · 24/10/2023 16:53

Dont worry, mine was nearly 4 and it happened practically overnight. You've got ages

WowOK · 24/10/2023 16:35

He's not ready. I'd just wait until summer. It's so much easier to potty train in the summer. It's easier to dry stuff if he has accidents. It's also warm enough to leave him just in pants.

You could read potty training books in the meantime and leave a potty out with a towel underneath in case he wants to try.

Take the pressure off entirely.

WowOK · 24/10/2023 16:26

How old is he?

Pickingmyselfup · 24/10/2023 16:22

You have tons of time so don't worry yet, once it clicks it clicks. Both of mine were hard work to potty train, I can't even remember how we started now. My eldest would happily sit on the potty aged 3 but was very hit and miss until more like 3.5 and still had the odd accident at 4 when he started school but I think he was fine in school. I didn't do anything for the night time, just took off his pull up when it was dry for a while consistently.

My youngest was so stubborn, wouldn't even entertain the potty until he was 3.5 and came round to the idea. Once he did it all just fell into place, I took his nappies away completely for the day and he was fine, tried to put one on at night and he refused so I crossed my fingers and toes but he was fine. That was it, done! He started school last year when he was nearly 5 and he started going a bit backwards, having lots of accidents for a while but once he settled in he was fine.

I remember tearing my hair out thinking we would never be ready for school but it doesn't take as long as you think once they are ready. There is a ton of stuff on the Internet to try but if you need to take a break for a while then that's fine, it will all fall into place in the end.

Iwasafool · 24/10/2023 16:12

WhereYouLeftIt · 24/10/2023 15:59

I sometimes think that modern nappies are so good at absorbing moisture and not letting the child's skin feel wet / get nappy rash, that children ARE "completely disengaged from the process".

When I tried to get DS out of nappies (one summer long, long ago), it really wasn't working. I was so paranoid about him getting sore skin (he had eczema) that as soon as he had 'an accident', I'd be whisking him straight into clean dry clothes. 'Accidents' continued unabated.

One day, he wet himself 10 seconds after we sat down for lunch, and - I didn't whisk him straight into dry clothes. The seat was plastic, so I just told him to eat his lunch and then we'd go and get him cleaned up and into fresh shorts. He experienced a wet bottom for about 15 minutes, I think. This was genuinely the last 'accident' he had. Feeling wet (and undoubtedly uncomfortable as the urine cooled) connected him to the process of going to the toilet! He'd have been about three and a half at the time.

I think you make a very good point.

WimbyAce · 24/10/2023 16:10

My daughter is 3 and not potty trained yet. Perhaps I am a bit lazy but I'm not too concerned.....yet! She kind of gets the idea of it and knows when she wants a poo/wee but doesn't seem to like the potty. I just know that for child 1 when she was ready it was easy so I'm happy to wait a bit longer.

Cakeandcardio · 24/10/2023 16:09

flagwaver · 24/10/2023 13:11

If you don't bother to toilet train him then I hope you'll be available to go into school every day to deal with his nappy, it's not reasonable to expect the staff to do your job.

Maybe you could offer some tips, as the OP is asking for, rather than judgement?

Swipe left for the next trending thread