Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried DS will start school without being potty trained

258 replies

Doitproperly · 24/10/2023 12:54

I’m becoming concerned for September.

DS just isn’t interested in potty training. He won’t tell you if he needs a wee or poo (not even sure if he knows) and refuses to sit on the potty. Feeling really embarrassed and like a bit of a failure. Not sure if anyone’s got any tips?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AhBiscuits · 02/11/2023 06:27

Both of mine were just over 3 once they cracked it and I didn't worry at all. Once they were ready it was sorted in a weekend. Park it for a month then try again. He's not motivated by chocolate, can you think of something that might motivate him? What does he like?

AnneValentine · 02/11/2023 06:19

Doitproperly · 01/11/2023 08:07

Just turned 3, yeah, so I have been stressing over nothing. (I didn’t do so intentionally, just. Ulti tasking!)

It would have been really helpful if you had clarified his age much earlier because it’s a complete non thing. If he’s just turned 3 he isn’t going to school for nearly two years and this definitely is a non issue. What a waste of everyone’s time.

KookyAndSpooky · 01/11/2023 20:55

I agree with @TheLoveIsReal. Three year olds are so much more strong-willed than two year olds. We trained our DS at 22 months for this reason. My friends that trained later were very hit and miss with their success. The ones that trained later but without pull-ups had a much easier ride.

spottygymbag · 01/11/2023 20:29

I had similar with DS. Not interested. Fine hanging out in wet pants etc.
We took the nappies away and he would hold on all day and then eventually just wee in the bath and get out 😩
At daycare he was going through multiple changes and refusing to sit on the toilet. I had no idea how to move forward as he was not motivated by sweets or toys or anything.
I stuck at it, plowing through mountains of washing and pumping as much liquid into him as I could (not a big drinker).
It's taken close to 7months of continuous effort (after a few earlier attempts from age 2 onwards). Such a different journey from DD who was done and dusted just after her 2nd birthday.

MigGirl · 01/11/2023 17:19

@AnneofRedGables yep my son was exactly the same, had tried him a number of times and really didn't care about been wet or dirty. You know what was worse is that both my kids where in cloth nappies and they say it helps them learn as they do feel when they are wet. It helped DD she wasn't quite 3 when she potty tranined but made not a jot of difference with DS he just really didn't care.

AnneofRedGables · 01/11/2023 14:22

@ChilliNoodleGoodness the trouble is though, some (like my ds2) couldn’t care less about being wet. We did away with the nappies, put him in the pants… and he would happily just wee/poo himself and merrily carry on!

curlydiamond · 01/11/2023 12:54

Hi OP

I've been where you are, I've had those same worries, I promise this isn't forever! Those who are saying you 'just' need to do x, y, z havent experienced this problem so think it's easy - I was probably just as ignorant until I had DS2 and discovered they are all different. My eldest was so easy to train, I simply did the bare bum thing and told him to sit every 30 mins or so (tried from 20 months but he wasnt ready, potty as a permanent feature in the room from 18 months and we just tried every couple of months until one day he was ready) . He was a biddable child, once he'd figured out how to wee on demand he was dry within days, at 2 and a half. One of his friends was dry day and night at 18 months, her older brother wasnt ready until nearly 4 years old.
Middle boy was far more resistant, refused to use the potty and no amount of praise, rewards, stickers charts, frequent sitting, books, wet pants etc worked. Eventually he decided to wee on demand at 3 and a bit, but only in the toilet never a potty (poos were another story, would withold until nighttime nappy was on then go, this continued until he turned 4) - he never had accidents whereas big brother had needed frequent reminders and would often have wee accidents until he was 4 as life was just too excitingto stop for a wee.
Littlest I was so worried about, far too busy to sit on a potty or toilet, actually impossible to get to sit for more than 5 mins at a table or in front of telly nevermind on a potty or loo, had potty out from around 18 months but always refused to sit. Tried when he turned 3, did a week of no nappies, a hideous nightmare with no improvement, went back to nappies.
Tried again 2 months later, having found he loved Sonic the Hedgehog (discovered through a nursery friend). This time he would agree to sit for 10 mins if given a tablet with Sonic on - eventually we caught wees and gave lots and lots of praise. He was reliably dry 7 days later.
Poos however are still an issue a year on, and we've only just got rid of the potty as he absolutely refused to go in the toilet and would scream blue murder and withhold for days on end.
11 months is a long way off, you do have plenty of time. Look for something he likes (programe he likes, toy he really wants, computer game, book, chocolate whatever) and only offer when he is sat (I would skip potty and go straight to toilet with a little seat but onvs your LO will guide this). I know you've tried this before but if you give it a break for a bit you may find he developes an interest that you can use, then perhaps try again between Christmas and New Year, if not ready then February, if not then try Easter. Just because you've tried something before doesn't mean it's not worth trying again in a few months time. This is a tough nut for some kids to crack, you will get there.
My youngest (just turned 4) has accidents at school once or twice a week, his brothers never once needed a change of clothes at school. Reception teachers are used to this, they are very understanding and it's not an issue.

Good luck OP.

ChilliNoodleGoodness · 01/11/2023 11:50

I agree with @Overloadimplode

I think you just have to throw out the nappies (apart from night time). It is stressful, the amount of wee you have to clean up but they will get there

ChilliNoodleGoodness · 01/11/2023 11:48

Oh OP its so stressful isn't it!

We paused ours because he just wasn't ready. Then when we tried again we explained that the binmen have taken his nappies and watched lots of potty cartoons on youtube.

He loved Go Jetters so I bought a potty training sticker chart of them from Etsy for £1. Explained that when he has a pee every day, at the end of the week he gets a prize.

I bought a fancy cup for him (peppa pig) and kept it filled with lovely juices and squashes and made sure he drank a lot (more opportunity to put him on potty)

Put his pants on, he wont like feeling wet.

we even just got him to sit on the potty fully clothed, every time he sat on it he would have a treat.

We were lucky in that it only too us about a week to crack it.

cupofdecaf · 01/11/2023 11:27

Doitproperly · 24/10/2023 13:24

@FunkyFangtooth i hope things improve. DS just pees in his pants and doesn’t seem fussed.

We have one of those. He is getting better but it's taking ages. We have to insist on regular toilet trips and it's exhausting.
First born was much easier so it's not us.

nowordsforthis · 01/11/2023 11:22

My son is also EXTREMELY stubborn and was also a similar age (almost 3) when trained. Like you I was also super stressed about it as he started government preschool, was the only one in nappies and I was basically given an ultimatum.

Meanwhile my DS never showed the remotest bit of interest in potty, books, rewards, praise etc, but I had to bite the bullet for preschool. One thing that did help him and was less pressured than the toilet was peeing outdoors - pee on a rock, pee on a plant etc. He still only pees standing up (in the toilet with a step stool). Other than that, I just went for it one day, put underpants on him, tried my best to hide my stress and act disinterested, at every accident I just reminded him that peepee goes in the toilet, and he got a small praise (good job!) if he went on the toilet. No rewards, but that week we did (with no reference to toilet training) a couple of "big boy" things - first meal in a sit-down restaurant, a new "big boy" toy. No returning to nappies even when he asked. It worked way better than I had anticipated - really after 2-3 days he was pretty much trained.

I recommend taking a month out if you just had a failed attempt, but then do try again as it's horrible training with a deadline.

Q2C4 · 01/11/2023 11:09

My DD is 3 yrs 8 months and very similar. No interest in potty training at all. Completely resistant to reward charts. Got all the books, read them with her, nothing. All her nursery friends are out of nappies but peer pressure doesn't seem to affect her. Next step GP I think.

Overloadimplode · 01/11/2023 11:08

I trained 3 kids at ages 28 months, 20 months and 24 months.
For each, I just took nappies away. The first and last had loads of accidents but got it within 2 weeks, having the odd accident every now and again for around 6 months. Much preferable to changing nappies. The middle one never had an accident.
I never used any bribes.

Doitproperly · 01/11/2023 11:02

The thread has moved on, though. I don’t know why people are getting annoyed - I thought people were getting annoyed with me rejecting advice (I’m not, just that most of it has been tried already) but apparently explaining this is still wrong!

OP posts:
Oliotya · 01/11/2023 11:01

Doitproperly · 01/11/2023 10:51

Honestly, I’m not here wanting to argue and the last thing I want is for people to write long, long posts with step by step instructions which aren’t helpful. That’s not to say that they might not help others I suppose but in our particular case not helpful.

I definitely don’t think he’d have understood or complied six months ago and even if he had we didn’t do a bit pointless having that argument!

It has been helpful knowing we aren’t the only ones and that we aren’t doomed for a lifetime of nappies.

Your Op literally asked for tips.
Have you actually tried a sustained period without nappies?

Ohforfox · 01/11/2023 10:56

Apologies for my long, step by step post. I thought that was exactly what you were looking for. I hope you find something that works.

Doitproperly · 01/11/2023 10:52

@TheLoveIsReal thats quite funny though as all his friends trained outside that window with no problems! I guess it shows different children are different. Imagine! Wink

OP posts:
Doitproperly · 01/11/2023 10:51

Honestly, I’m not here wanting to argue and the last thing I want is for people to write long, long posts with step by step instructions which aren’t helpful. That’s not to say that they might not help others I suppose but in our particular case not helpful.

I definitely don’t think he’d have understood or complied six months ago and even if he had we didn’t do a bit pointless having that argument!

It has been helpful knowing we aren’t the only ones and that we aren’t doomed for a lifetime of nappies.

OP posts:
KnottyKnitting · 01/11/2023 10:39

Just turned three isn't too much to worry about. DD2 was dreadful at this age. She wasn't reliably toilet trained till nearly 4 and even then still quite a few accidents. She was in pull ups at night till 6and then still had lots of bed wetting incidents.

I seem to remember she got to a certain age where she noticed that lots of her childminder and preschool friends used the toilet and were in "big girl knickers" so that was an incentive for her and the staff really helped with it.

As others have said- 11 months is a long time! He might surprise you one day and just suddenly get it. If he is feeling your stress that might be putting him off. Good luck!

Dahlia444 · 01/11/2023 10:38

I had trouble with 1 (of 4) of my DSs. Started at 3 at the same time as his twin, who was fine. He just freaked out, hated it, refused to do it, this was after all the 'prep' months of sitting on potty at bathtime etc. After about a week we just stopped altogether. Didn't mention it. Backed absolutely right off 100% and tried again in about 6 months - he wasn't particularly showing any other signs we just thought we'd give it another go and he got it. So based on my experience I would back off completely for a bit, no more comments, questions, trying etc and hopefully that will reset whatever mental block he has going on. And then try again, playing it really cool and casual. Something will work for him, try not to worry too much (I worried massively). Really try and avoid it being a battle of wills. Good luck.

TheLoveIsReal · 01/11/2023 10:35

Jellycats4life · 01/11/2023 10:26

the reality is you put it off and have missed your golden window

Huh, @TheLoveIsReal?

Are you seriously saying there’s a “golden window” for all children, and if you miss it, they are incapable of toilet training?

Give over.

I mean, if you enjoy feeling superior and shaming mothers who are struggling, you do you, but please stop pretending that there’s a universal approach that works for all kids.

I didn’t say they were incapable Confused No need to make stuff up 😂

There is a golden window yes, between 20-30 months. Before that they are too young to fully understand and after that they are too stubborn and strong willed.

So yes, if you leave it too long you are going to struggle, exactly like OP is doing. Even more so if you have a casual approach.

AfterWeights · 01/11/2023 10:32

And agreed re the trousers.

Toilet training means using the toilet and not wearing nappies any more.

It doesnt mean never having any adult support in the process ever again. Its perfectly fine if they're still being reminded, or taken to the loo before car journeys, or being helped with clothes l, having help to wipe properly. They don't have to be able to hold for endless amounts of time or tell you with half an hour or warning before they'll need to go.

Autumndreamsz · 01/11/2023 10:30

@Doitproperly my DD is an august baby, she’s just started school but wasn’t potty trained until October last year. DS was 3 in the March and didn’t grasp it until the July…: it will come in time. dS came home from nursey one day and said I want to wear pants this was after months of trying every thing under the sun.
it will come , I promise

AfterWeights · 01/11/2023 10:27

If he doesn't care about chocolate buttons, you find what he does care about, and that's what you use as a bribe.

It might be screen time, it might be a favourite character - whatever gets him excited and engaged.

You don't give him a choice to refuse to toilet train. Of course he doesn't want to. Its boring, it interrupts play, its easier to just go without thinking in a nappy. There's a reason lots of experts recommend doing this around age 2 and not later - its because children between about 2.5 & 4 get very very stubborn and resistant to change and this can make it a lot harder to toilet train.

The choices you give to give him some control are things like:

  • choosing some pants
  • a choice of potty or loo
  • choosing a reward, would he like a sweet or a sticker etc

It is really difficult but you have to make not using the loo more annoying than using it. Which means no nappies, having to stop playing and go get cleaned up and changed if you wee/poo in your pants.

InTheRainOnATrain · 01/11/2023 10:27

Doitproperly · 01/11/2023 10:15

@InTheRainOnATrain i think saying nappies are for babies is quite shaming. But we can agree to disagree, I just personally don’t feel comfortable with that.

I see… I think posters were trying to suggest ways he might be motivated since chocolate buttons very clearly don’t do it!!

Wanting to wear ‘big boy pants’ and not ‘baby nappies’ might do it for some kids and it is true that big kids don’t wear nappies and babies do. And there’s always going to be some level of shame involved- if you pooed yourself I expect you’d be embarrassed, it’s normal that a sense of shame develops. But obviously you don’t have to say that if you don’t think it’s right for him! Mummy has run out of nappies so you’re going to wear pants and use the potty like your friend Sam also works. Or my DD was quite into character pants and keeping Elsa clean and dry was a big thing for her. I don’t think it matters what you do so much as just pick a way, when you’re ready, and stick to it clearly and consistently.