Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To bin DP's junk while he's away?

165 replies

LittleRayTheCat · 24/10/2023 12:53

DP collects junk. And I mean junk. He collects stuff because he doesn't sort his bag or pockets out enough; because he intends to do something with this junk later on; because he hates throwing stuff out which has some kind of meaning to us however fleeting; because he saves things for me to craft with at some point in the future.

Our under-stairs cupboard currently houses:
>A cracked refill coffee cup that DP intends to superglue and use as a plant pot in his office. He'll unlikely ever get around to super gluing it and never ever to getting a plant for it (unless I do it, which I absolutely won't).

>A backpack with a huge rip that DP intends to sew up or get professionally repaired. He's never sewed anything in his life and he'll likely not get around to finding a repair shop. Again, I'm not doing either of these things for him.

>A power bag for weightlifting which is leaking sand which DP intends to repair with duct tape. He won't get around to this and we bought a replacement bag so why bother anyway?

>A carrier bag full of papers, broken pens, scrolled up tissues, chocolate wrappers, train tickets, empty blister packs etc. that DP took from his old work bag when he got a new one. This has been on a shelf in the cupboard for two fucking years without any moves to get sorted out.

He's away for three days with work. AIBU to bin/recycle/rehome everything while he's away and then just never mention it? I very much bought he'll ever notice.

OP posts:
statetrooperstacey · 24/10/2023 15:46

My DH did this to me, after my initial brief outrage I was secretly quite relieved . Mine was also ‘projects’ that I was never going to get around to🤣 that list of things is absolute shite so yes , do it.

ASimpleLampoon · 24/10/2023 15:45

Do it but don't tell him.

Is it possible this is hoarding? If so he needs therapy/ treatment just throwing it out will not solve the problem

Littlelucas · 24/10/2023 15:44

I did this x 100. Dh is a collector of junk and always says “it may come in handy” or “il repair that”… knowing full well he never will and also seems to have an aversion to taking things to the tip (lazy!) so once when I was pregnant and sick to the back teeth of all his crap piled up in the garage (our 2nd fridge freezer is in there and all our outdoor coats/boots as well as having to get to things like the water/electric meter so it’s not like I didn’t have to see it regularly and could just ignore it) I got a house clearance company to come whilst he was away overnight and just take it all!

He was slightly miffed when he returned but seeing the nice clear, organised garage space mollified him and he got over it.

Unfortunately it is now back to the state it was before!!

OhComeOnFFS · 24/10/2023 15:42

No need to text him. He's not even going to notice those things are missing and if he does, in years to come, just deny all knowledge.

LittleRayTheCat · 24/10/2023 15:39

ClarkGablesMoustache · 24/10/2023 15:28

OP, why not text him and say you're doing a clear out for him while he's away? That way if there's something he feel strongly about keeping, he can tell you, but otherwise you've got carte blanche to bin all the junk.

Yes, I think I'm going to go with something like this.

I'm going to get all his junk out, send him a list of everything there is and say "I am binning everything unless you say otherwise. If you do say otherwise, repair work needs to be done by end of October otherwise it's for the bin"

OP posts:
LittleRayTheCat · 24/10/2023 15:38

JaneFarrier · 24/10/2023 15:35

I would bin it all except the rucksack, but then I know how to sew and would be able to mend that. I've a tendency to keep things that need mending myself but the rest of it sounds like things that really won't ever be as good again, fixed or not (I picture the weight thing leaking sand even if duct-taped).

I hate throwing out other people's stuff but this really does sound like junk.

I'm okay at sewing but I get precious little free time in my life anyway. I'm not spending a minute of it on DP's repair projects 😂 DP has never sewed anything in his life.

And, yes, the power bag will still leak if its taped. I have told DP this.

OP posts:
LittleRayTheCat · 24/10/2023 15:36

spitefulandbadgrammar · 24/10/2023 15:32

How precious can a carrier bag full of rubbish be if it’s been stuffed in a cupboard and ignored for two years.

Going forward, I’d speed up your “do something with this or it’s binned” deadlines. And stuff like carrier bags of rubbish don’t even go in the cupboard, do not pass go, straight into the bin. Because he’s not going to change wanting to keep this stuff, but you can change how long it lurks before you snap. And he knows what the agreed hoarding length is – hash it out between you, because currently I’d guess you want it to be “zero, stop putting stuff aside to mend that you’ll never mend” and he wants “indefinitely, forever”, so you both need to compromise.

Yeah, I get this totally. I will absolutely do this.

When he said about the cracked cup (that he'd use it as a plant pot), I thought "No you won't because you'll never get around to super gluing it and then you'll never go and buy a plant. So what you mean is that you'd like to use it as a plant pot but you've basically given me a job to make it into a plant pot or else given me another bit of clutter for the understairs cupboard". I wish I'd said this and just binned the fucking thing.

I'm not making excuses for him but.... With the current carrier bag of doom, he actually put it in the cupboard one morning when he swapped work bags. He was pushed for time to sort the stuff out so he put it in a carrier bag, said he'd sort it the weekend, put it in the cupboard out of the way and left for work. That was two years ago.

OP posts:
JaneFarrier · 24/10/2023 15:35

I would bin it all except the rucksack, but then I know how to sew and would be able to mend that. I've a tendency to keep things that need mending myself but the rest of it sounds like things that really won't ever be as good again, fixed or not (I picture the weight thing leaking sand even if duct-taped).

I hate throwing out other people's stuff but this really does sound like junk.

LittleRayTheCat · 24/10/2023 15:32

lavenderlou · 24/10/2023 15:28

Just to say there are no mental health or anxiety issues here. DP has good intentions to mend/repair/re-purpose stuff but never does the nitty gritty of actually doing it. So the stuff he intends to men/repair/re-purpose just sits in drawers and cupboards for years.

Have you thrown any of his stuff away before? What was the reaction? I didn't realise my DH was a hoarder until the reaction when I first cleared out some of his "junk".

Yes, I've done it before.

If I don't mention it, he just doesn't notice. If I do mention it, he's ranged from "Ok" to "Ah, thanks, sorry I didn't get around to it", to "Oh, I was going to repair that". But never been really pissed off, sulked, angry etc.

OP posts:
spitefulandbadgrammar · 24/10/2023 15:32

How precious can a carrier bag full of rubbish be if it’s been stuffed in a cupboard and ignored for two years.

Going forward, I’d speed up your “do something with this or it’s binned” deadlines. And stuff like carrier bags of rubbish don’t even go in the cupboard, do not pass go, straight into the bin. Because he’s not going to change wanting to keep this stuff, but you can change how long it lurks before you snap. And he knows what the agreed hoarding length is – hash it out between you, because currently I’d guess you want it to be “zero, stop putting stuff aside to mend that you’ll never mend” and he wants “indefinitely, forever”, so you both need to compromise.

ClarkGablesMoustache · 24/10/2023 15:28

OP, why not text him and say you're doing a clear out for him while he's away? That way if there's something he feel strongly about keeping, he can tell you, but otherwise you've got carte blanche to bin all the junk.

lavenderlou · 24/10/2023 15:28

Just to say there are no mental health or anxiety issues here. DP has good intentions to mend/repair/re-purpose stuff but never does the nitty gritty of actually doing it. So the stuff he intends to men/repair/re-purpose just sits in drawers and cupboards for years.

Have you thrown any of his stuff away before? What was the reaction? I didn't realise my DH was a hoarder until the reaction when I first cleared out some of his "junk".

LittleRayTheCat · 24/10/2023 15:09

potatoheads · 24/10/2023 15:05

@LittleRayTheCat I've done this in the past. I've asked, I've told, I've given him deadlines. Nothing happens. He has good intentions and then no time or inclination to actually follow up on them.

But YOU didn't follow through. You give a deadline and say anything he hasn't dealt with you are planning to throw away as you need the space

Sorry - I wasn't clear at all. I mean that when I've given deadlines, I absolutely have followed through on them. I meant nothing happens as in he doesn't actually do anything about the junk - he doesn't actually men or fix any of it, just lets the time lapse and I bin it.

OP posts:
LittleRayTheCat · 24/10/2023 15:08

Just to say there are no mental health or anxiety issues here. DP has good intentions to mend/repair/re-purpose stuff but never does the nitty gritty of actually doing it. So the stuff he intends to men/repair/re-purpose just sits in drawers and cupboards for years.

I would, of course, never throw out anything that's sentimental to him in any way. An old power bag, a broken cup and a ripped backpack are not sentimental - they are junk.

When I said he has 'paper' in his work junk carrier bag, I don't mean important papers. I mean scraps of paper with shit like "John, 10:30am, Office 201". Even the papers which do look important, haven't been so much as glanced at for two bloody years so they can't be that vital.

OP posts:
potatoheads · 24/10/2023 15:05

@LittleRayTheCat I've done this in the past. I've asked, I've told, I've given him deadlines. Nothing happens. He has good intentions and then no time or inclination to actually follow up on them.

But YOU didn't follow through. You give a deadline and say anything he hasn't dealt with you are planning to throw away as you need the space

TheCatterall · 24/10/2023 15:05

Ahh aspirational junk. The stuff that will one day be fixed when we suddenly become crafters/doers and expert darners.

if stuff has been there untouched, unfixed for longer than 6 months - get rid.

going forward he has a month or so to fix things and do these jobs - or stuff is binned. and hold him to it. Add it to a visible calendar etc.

if he wants to go off for hobbies etc just remind him he has to fix/repair x and y and maybe he should spend hours doing that rather than an enjoyable hobby. oh he doesn’t want to miss out on enjoyable time in the pub/football etc - then he has to prioritise what he’s doing with his junk.

Agapornis · 24/10/2023 15:05

You gave him deadlines, but when he missed them there were no consequences?

extrasushiplease · 24/10/2023 15:02

I'll just say this as a well-intentioned caution: Please base what you do on who your husband actually is rather than what would be satisfying right now. Some people (I struggle with this, for the record) are a bit on the lazy and messy side and, while we can make excuses about using things in the future, once sense comes through and we see how nice everything is after junk is thrown out, we're fine and do our best to keep things that way.

On the other hand, hoarding can be a true sign of a mental issue (usually anxiety-related), and having everything suddenly gone can cause them to truly panic and possibly experience anger or even a type of grief. You're the only one here who knows how your husband is in this department. I hope he's just silly and messy, but if he's had more serious mental or emotional struggles lately, I'd maybe lean toward a serious talk about the larger issue beforehand. Good luck either way!

Paperbagsaremine · 24/10/2023 14:57

OP the point is, he's told the junk will be binned by X date and then on day X the junk is taken to the tip by the person who wants to use the space.

Talk us through where this process is going awry and maybe we can suggest something.

MereDintofPandiculation · 24/10/2023 14:54

It’s his property. YABU to dispose of his property without his permission.

ManagedMove · 24/10/2023 14:49

AnaisMae · 24/10/2023 12:55

I came here to say YABU off the title alone, but when I read it you are definitely not being unreasonable and yes I'd throw it all.

Exactly this! If he asks you could say there were mice

caringcarer · 24/10/2023 14:47

This type of small item hoarding, just in case mentality, would drive me mad. Bin it and don't mention it. He'll probably not even notice it missing.

RosyappleA · 24/10/2023 14:46

I think he won’t notice and if he does he will likely be secretly relieved! I have hoarded in the past and when I finally get rid of the stiff this huge weight is lifted.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/10/2023 14:35

Oh Mr Monkey does this. I just tip it all in to the bin every few months. He never notices.

We have a rule that there are boxes in the hall cupboard to store anything that is to be kept.

purplecorkheart · 24/10/2023 14:35

The bag yes I would have throw out the next bin collection after he changed bags. The mug, the bag and weight I would tell him I am getting rid of in two weeks etc so he can either bring them to be repaired before then or else they are gone. And if they are still in the house in two weeks then do throw them out.