Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Non resident parent's obligation to support their children

317 replies

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 11:25

Another day, another thread about an unmarried woman separating from the father of her children.

This gets discussed a lot on here, but I can see the logic for why unmarried couples should not necessarily have any financial obligation towards each other when they separate. People should have the right to live together without being considered a single financial unit in the eyes of the law, and enforcing marriage-like obligations on people who have not chosen to get married seems wrong to me. Even if this results in some unmarried people, particularly women, making themselves financially vulnerable.

What I don't understand is why the non resident parent's financial obligation to support their children is so small. If the parents of two preschoolers separate, for example, how is the resident parent, who is most likely the mother, supposed to keep a roof over their children's heads if they can't work, and how can they work if they can't afford to pay two sets of childcare fees with the piss-poor contribution she is getting from the children's other parent?

I realise that even claiming the minimum that non resident parents are obliged to pay via CSA can be impossible sometimes - and that's a separate issue - but who on earth decided it was fair or reasonable that the non resident parent's obligation to pay should be limited to an amount which doesn't even touch the sides of the actual cost of raising their children?

I know it's another argument in favour of getting married, but that doesn't help resident parents in this situation, or indeed their children.

Does anyone have any bright ideas about how things could be changed to make the system fairer?

This is purely theoretical for me, but the injustice of it just grates. I've tried to use the gender neutral "resident parent" and "non resident parent" throughout, but we all know the reality, which is that it is usually women who get screwed over in this way, and I assume that is why the problem hasn't been addressed.

OP posts:
Housesellingnightmare · 25/10/2023 07:57

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Housesellingnightmare · 25/10/2023 07:55

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Beezknees · 25/10/2023 07:13

My parents were married and my father did not provide for me financially after they divorced?

Baconisdelicious · 25/10/2023 07:12

I said I wouldn't put any obligations on unmarried men. Nor would they have any rights. So if an unmarried woman became pregnant, if she decided to keep her baby then she would be solely responsible for it

What aboutvtge rights of the child? To a relationship with both parents? To receive adequate financial support? Why is this being ignored in favour of a man's right not to parent, at any point whatsoever, if that's what they choose?

Beezknees · 25/10/2023 07:12

Being married doesn't mean they have to financially take care of the children after divorce either unless I'm missing something?

MargotBamborough · 25/10/2023 06:57

Sayitaintso33 · 24/10/2023 23:41

I agree, but that is a different point.

A man can choose whether to attempt to impregnate a woman (sorry I don't like that term but I can't think of better wording), but it is entirely the woman's choice whether the child is born (assuming abortion is legal, which happily it is my country).

Even if a man is actively trying to conceive he has no legal say in whether the child is born. I can see the argument that as it is the woman's decision whether to have the child, she should be responsible for the child.

I disagree. At some point you have to hold the man responsible.

Women have had zero choice about whether to bring a child into the world for most of hunan history and still have zero choice in many parts of the world. Nobody ever tells them they shouldn't be responsible for any children they produce.

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 25/10/2023 06:42

Riverlee · 24/10/2023 22:34

Student loans only get paid if the person earns over a certain limit. If the same principle applied, , then many nrp would work just below the cut off limits.

Not many people want deliberately earn less than the student loan repayment cut off just so they don't have to pay though.

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 25/10/2023 06:23

TUCKINGFYP0 · 24/10/2023 23:38

That figure is the allowance to pay for out of pocket expenses. Many get a wage / salary on top. It’s not related to their employment or marital status.

Of course most foster carers of young children are not working full time outside the home, they have work to do ( meetings , paperwork ) on top of caring for the children. many of the children have emotional and behavioural problems and wouldn’t cope in Ft childcare or even school.

But I’m not sure how that affects the fact that most local authorities accept that these are reasonable out of pocket costs for raising a child.

Of course they are not taking account of school fees /nursery fees / keeping a pony / whatever. It’s a starter for 10. Not a maximum that any parent in the Uk will ever spend on raising their kids.

Sorry if I am not understanding your point.

I guess the point I was making is that although the figures currently used for foster children could be a useful starting point in terms of how much it costs to feed/clothe/house a child, if a foster parent stays at home then they won't have the additional expense of paid childcare, so that is something that would need to be added in to the calculation for child support.

OP posts:
LondonInsomniac · 25/10/2023 06:07

54isanopendoor · 24/10/2023 13:40

I appreciate you putting in the caveat re special needs.

I am a parent to two children (now 16 & 18) who have Autism. I am now their Carer & the DWP allows me £70p/w in respect of my not being able to work around their needs. My exH was never willing to split work / any care duties.
I have 'lost out' on around 16 years of salary & pension contributions.
exH walked out 2 years ago. He never has the children & he paid £200p/m maintenance until he decided to retire early & now therefore has to pay nowt.
It's a lousy situation which leaves the kids (& I) in poverty.
Society should shame men who walk out on kids as much as they do women.

Hear hear.

LondonInsomniac · 25/10/2023 06:01

Sayitaintso33 · 24/10/2023 22:37

Because it is solely their choice whether to have a child.

A man can't decide to have a child, only a woman can.

People’s circumstances change. Women cannot send their children back to the shop when they are five, six, seven.

Society depends on the propogation of the species.

Women shouldn’t carry the whole can, like I am doing, especially not on a long term basis.

People like my ex should be forced to work and contribute.

LondonInsomniac · 25/10/2023 05:56

A non resident parent who is on benefits gets to put in £7 per week for two children.

My highly educated ex, educated at a top red brick university, was giving me this and not working.

TUCKINGFYP0 · 25/10/2023 01:58

It’s interesting to see the men ( or second wives / GF ) on this thread tying themselves up in knots trying to think of reasons why men shouldn’t have to pay for the kids they made. And why the tax payer / the kids themselves / the other parent should have to pay so a man doesn’t have to face the consequences of his own choices.

” Wah wah wah “ they cry “ Biology is so unfair. Men should be allowed to force women to have abortions before birth / kill their children after birth, if that’s what the man wants “.

Next they will be suggesting a return to workhouse for any children no longer wanted by their fathers Hmm .

Terfosaurus · 25/10/2023 01:46

But that "bit of paper" should have no bearing on a parents financial obligation to their children.

CM is no more enforceable just because the parents were married.

79Beastie · 25/10/2023 01:43

Well if only you had that piece of paper that loads of women refuse to have because it's just a bit of paper.... Well that piece of paper is the biggest tool a woman can have to fight with. Makes me laugh when people say it's just a bit of paper

Terfosaurus · 25/10/2023 01:32

Sayitaintso33 · 25/10/2023 01:17

But what if neither of you had wanted children and toy said that you would have an abortion if you got pregnant, but you then changed your mind and kept the baby?

But that isn't what happened. We did want children. So he shouldn't have to not pay just because we weren't married.

If it had been a one night stand, or I'd lied about contraception, or said I'd have an abortion and then changed my mind then maybe, and it's a slim chance, but just maybe I'd agree with you.

But just because someone isn't married it doesn't mean their baby isn't planned and doesn't deserve support from the nrp.

Sayitaintso33 · 25/10/2023 01:17

Terfosaurus · 25/10/2023 01:07

But I didn't become pregnant by myself. My ex and I decided jointly to "try for a baby" (twice).

While the decision to keep the baby was ultimately mine, at no point did he even consider is not having it. He wanted the babies as much as I did. Why should he then get to decide a few years down the line that actually he didn't want them and shouldn't have to pay?

But what if neither of you had wanted children and toy said that you would have an abortion if you got pregnant, but you then changed your mind and kept the baby?

Terfosaurus · 25/10/2023 01:07

Sayitaintso33 · 25/10/2023 00:50

It is disingenuous to say that you both made the choice not to have an abortion - or to use your words we made 'the choice together'. What he says can influence your choice, but it is your choice.

I had earlier said I would put full obligations on married men for exactly the reasons you gave.

The bit of my argument I was uncomfortable about was that I said I wouldn't put any obligations on unmarried men. Nor would they have any rights. So if an unmarried woman became pregnant, if she decided to keep her baby then she would be solely responsible for it.

But I didn't become pregnant by myself. My ex and I decided jointly to "try for a baby" (twice).

While the decision to keep the baby was ultimately mine, at no point did he even consider is not having it. He wanted the babies as much as I did. Why should he then get to decide a few years down the line that actually he didn't want them and shouldn't have to pay?

Sayitaintso33 · 25/10/2023 00:50

SleepingStandingUp · 25/10/2023 00:21

So having got married and chosen to have a family, if we split up he shouldn't have any responsibility for them because I didn't choose to have an abortion when we were happily married and had made that choice together?

It is disingenuous to say that you both made the choice not to have an abortion - or to use your words we made 'the choice together'. What he says can influence your choice, but it is your choice.

I had earlier said I would put full obligations on married men for exactly the reasons you gave.

The bit of my argument I was uncomfortable about was that I said I wouldn't put any obligations on unmarried men. Nor would they have any rights. So if an unmarried woman became pregnant, if she decided to keep her baby then she would be solely responsible for it.

Simonjt · 25/10/2023 00:38

Ponderingwindow · 24/10/2023 23:59

Why even go down this path of argument. Most child maintenance is not from one night stands or short relationships. People plan to have a child together and then the relationship ends. The men absolutely made the choice to have these children.

You forget that some people hate women so much that absolutely everything is their fault. It’s only okay for an unmarried man not to be responsible for his child if an unmarried mother isn’t responsible for her child.

SleepingStandingUp · 25/10/2023 00:21

Sayitaintso33 · 24/10/2023 23:41

I agree, but that is a different point.

A man can choose whether to attempt to impregnate a woman (sorry I don't like that term but I can't think of better wording), but it is entirely the woman's choice whether the child is born (assuming abortion is legal, which happily it is my country).

Even if a man is actively trying to conceive he has no legal say in whether the child is born. I can see the argument that as it is the woman's decision whether to have the child, she should be responsible for the child.

So having got married and chosen to have a family, if we split up he shouldn't have any responsibility for them because I didn't choose to have an abortion when we were happily married and had made that choice together?

Terfosaurus · 25/10/2023 00:05

There are many steps CMS can take to get money out of a non paying parent, from putting a charge on property owned by NRP to forcing its sale to removing their driving license and even prison. I looked on CMS website today and posted about it earlier.

They technically have those powers but don't bother using them.

Ponderingwindow · 24/10/2023 23:59

Sayitaintso33 · 24/10/2023 23:41

I agree, but that is a different point.

A man can choose whether to attempt to impregnate a woman (sorry I don't like that term but I can't think of better wording), but it is entirely the woman's choice whether the child is born (assuming abortion is legal, which happily it is my country).

Even if a man is actively trying to conceive he has no legal say in whether the child is born. I can see the argument that as it is the woman's decision whether to have the child, she should be responsible for the child.

Why even go down this path of argument. Most child maintenance is not from one night stands or short relationships. People plan to have a child together and then the relationship ends. The men absolutely made the choice to have these children.

K4tM · 24/10/2023 23:57

I actually think CMS calculation of 20% of income works provided NRP works and pays tax so is economically visible. This can be enforced through CMS Collect and Pay or Direct Pay. The NRP also has to keep a roof over their own head and put food on table in order to stay economically active.

There are many steps CMS can take to get money out of a non paying parent, from putting a charge on property owned by NRP to forcing its sale to removing their driving license and even prison. I looked on CMS website today and posted about it earlier.

The problem is where a NRP hides their income or is on benefits. In the case of hiding income I guess this would be fraud but proving it is very difficult. I know many RPs in this position. In the case of benefits the maximum amount NRP is liable for is £7 pw as obviously they have to have something to live on.

TUCKINGFYP0 · 24/10/2023 23:55

A man can choose whether to attempt to impregnate a woman (sorry I don't like that term but I can't think of better wording), but it is entirely the woman's choice whether the child is born (assuming abortion is legal, which happily it is my country)

Even if a man is actively trying to conceive he has no legal say in whether the child is born. I can see the argument that as it is the woman's decision whether to have the child, she should be responsible for the child

You do realise that not every woman agrees with abortion? While others don’t find out they pregnant until that opinion is no longer open to them.

and how exactly do you propose to decide when a child is , say 5 years old, whose “ choice “ it was to have them?

But most of this is beside the point. Most of the NRP who don’t support their children were in a relationship / married / when their children were conceived and born . Most of these men actively wanted these children - while it was convenient to them.

Then when it no longer suits, they get to walk away.

My kids were teens when their father left and stopped paying for them and - how does abortion help them now ? Do they not deserve support from their father because he changed his mind about wanting them?

Are you arguing that more children should live in poverty so men can have consequences free sex ?

SleepingStandingUp · 24/10/2023 23:49

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 14:58

If the NRP is working, why shouldn't they be contributing to nursery fees? Particularly when the alternative, if they don't contribute, is that the RP can't work.

As a PP said, the NRP has huge earning capacity because their ability to work is completely unencumbered by childcare responsibilities. The RP can't just increase their income to pay for childcare by working more hours, because they would also need to find childcare to cover those hours. The NRP can, actually, increase their income to pay for childcare by working more hours.

Not everyone has huge earning capacity just because they don't have kids. It doesn't mean you can work 20 hour days 7 days a week or just go off and retrain as a surgeon or you'll what? Go to jail? Send the baliffs round.

I'm not saying something shouldn't change, and I like a pps idea about raising the amount, the govt paying any defect and it becoming a debt for the NRP.

BUT I don't think as it stands that as the RP I should be able to make financial decisions on the basis that I can afford half of it and if he can't he can just register as homeless or work 20 hour days.

If my wages don't stretch to stuff, my kids don't get it. If I have ten kids, that means each of them gets less. No one says well the first child must continue to get the same.

Swipe left for the next trending thread