Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Non resident parent's obligation to support their children

317 replies

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 11:25

Another day, another thread about an unmarried woman separating from the father of her children.

This gets discussed a lot on here, but I can see the logic for why unmarried couples should not necessarily have any financial obligation towards each other when they separate. People should have the right to live together without being considered a single financial unit in the eyes of the law, and enforcing marriage-like obligations on people who have not chosen to get married seems wrong to me. Even if this results in some unmarried people, particularly women, making themselves financially vulnerable.

What I don't understand is why the non resident parent's financial obligation to support their children is so small. If the parents of two preschoolers separate, for example, how is the resident parent, who is most likely the mother, supposed to keep a roof over their children's heads if they can't work, and how can they work if they can't afford to pay two sets of childcare fees with the piss-poor contribution she is getting from the children's other parent?

I realise that even claiming the minimum that non resident parents are obliged to pay via CSA can be impossible sometimes - and that's a separate issue - but who on earth decided it was fair or reasonable that the non resident parent's obligation to pay should be limited to an amount which doesn't even touch the sides of the actual cost of raising their children?

I know it's another argument in favour of getting married, but that doesn't help resident parents in this situation, or indeed their children.

Does anyone have any bright ideas about how things could be changed to make the system fairer?

This is purely theoretical for me, but the injustice of it just grates. I've tried to use the gender neutral "resident parent" and "non resident parent" throughout, but we all know the reality, which is that it is usually women who get screwed over in this way, and I assume that is why the problem hasn't been addressed.

OP posts:
gotomomo · 24/10/2023 13:35

Remember though that only one parent can claim benefits and that is usually mum. You can claim help with nursery fees on average incomes

CornishGem1975 · 24/10/2023 13:34

I'm not sure that childcare costs should be split 50/50. How does that work, for instance, when NRP has the kids but doesn't actually require childcare? Childcare on a day-to-day basis should be the responsibility of the person who needs it to cover the children on their own time.

(I say that as a parent and a step-parent who has lived this situation)

I'd certainly not be happy having to pay half the childcare costs to enable my ex to go to his job if I don't need childcare on my own time.

FrippEnos · 24/10/2023 13:33

Blahblahaha · 24/10/2023 13:32

@FrippEnos no don't think it has to do with society as I say I think it is because ex doesn't prioritise DC because he doesn't benefit from it...it's a selfish thing, not a society thing

That could well be the case.

Octavia64 · 24/10/2023 13:33

I quite like the American system, or at least the penalties of it,

www.justice.gov/criminal/criminal-ceos/citizens-guide-us-federal-law-child-support-enforcement

Pay or go to jail.

Blahblahaha · 24/10/2023 13:32

@FrippEnos no don't think it has to do with society as I say I think it is because ex doesn't prioritise DC because he doesn't benefit from it...it's a selfish thing, not a society thing

airofkfoeksowlwomfo · 24/10/2023 13:27

Peepshowcreepshow · 24/10/2023 12:54

My xh did not want 50/50 or even 70/30. You don't foist a child on a person who does not want them and then, as the 'rp' (mum) it's very hard to try to coparent amicably with someone who does not want to parent your shared children.
In the case of my xh, an expectation that CM would be paid by him even if that meant his new wife paying would have been the only route to getting him to step up. He quit his job to look after her DC meaning he did not have to pay for his own. New children should not trump existing children and women who facilitate that are bad women.

Exactly the same situation for me.

My ex-husband quit his decent paying job after I left and then moved in with OW to provide her childcare.

She’s built a successful business off the bacl of him being home to provide childcare for her child.

He has no income (won’t even claim benefits) so hasn’t paid a penny towards our children in almost 10 years) Nor has he ever done the school run despite at one point living 2 minutes away and driving past my house to take his new wife’s 12 year old to school.

He is a disgrace, but I can’t help but wonder how she can live with herself too knowing that she is enabling him to not provide for his own two children.

Because if he didn’t live with her, he’d have to fund himself somehow and a measly proportion would be given to my children.

FrippEnos · 24/10/2023 13:26

@Blahblahaha and @defi

How much of this is down to the expectations of society?
They get away with not parenting because they can get away with it.
If is was actively discouraged then maybe they would step up to the plate as it was required of them.

FrippEnos · 24/10/2023 13:23

@Heelenahandbasket

Women do a huge amount of unpaid work when it comes to children- this should be valued and shared regardless of marital status.

Do you mean parenting?

Reugny · 24/10/2023 13:22

MintJulia · 24/10/2023 13:19

'Ah. But were you married to your ex?'

No, thank goodness. Ex morphed into weird controlling person the day I brought ds home from hospital. Thankfully I was able to pick up my possessions and leave when it got too bad, without a legal battle.

He initially said he wanted 50:50 but that lasted precisely one weekend. He hasn't mentioned it since. I think it was the reality of changing nappies and lack of sleep that changed his mind. 😀

We've coexisted relatively calmly ever since (13 years). He sees ds 6 hours a week during which time he watches sport and ds plays computer games. Then they ignore each other for the rest of the week. It's odd but it works.

I hope your DS has better male role models and is learning how not to be a dad.

anniegun · 24/10/2023 13:22

Any couple who have a baby should be put into the same legal framework as civil partners, automatically. Once they share a child they need to share finances

Blahblahaha · 24/10/2023 13:21

50/50 is not fair for the child imo

defi · 24/10/2023 13:21

The quickest and easiest way to sort this would be mandatory 50/50.
But I can't see many "resident parents" going for that.

^^ I've asked this several times and he's not interested. Happy two night a month and paying a whopping £25 a week

FrippEnos · 24/10/2023 13:20

Willyoujustbequiet · 24/10/2023 13:08

That sounds eerily like the nonsense that the idiots from Father's 4 Justice come out with.

It's just another attempt to control women.

Op I think childcare costs being split would be a good start. NRPs with EOW get to work unencumbered by childcare and its patently unfair.

I would raise the percentage payable under CMS to more accurately reflect living costs and make unearned income such as property assets and inheritance be taken into account. Too many self employed deadbeat fathers fiddle the figures.

I would remove driving licences and passports for wilful non payers.

Unless you want to live in a sounding chamber it is a valid point. You may not like how it sounds but that's life.

The problem with raising percentage payment is that many NRPs are on the breadline as it is. What do you do if they can't pay the amount?

I agree with removing passports but if you remove driving licences you run the risk of the NRP not being able to work at all.

Blahblahaha · 24/10/2023 13:20

Sadly you can't make someone parent well if it's not their highest priority.
If picking a child up from nursery/school is less of a priority for them than their job so that person is unreliable at best what you going to do?
If someone's own lifestyle (ie time and money) is more important than the child getting socialisation at nursery or the child finding a hobby they enjoy, what are you going to do?

Riverlee · 24/10/2023 13:19

Coffeerum · 24/10/2023 12:59

Unless it was state provided childcare this doesn’t really work though. I could put my kids in a nursery that cost £1200 a month or £2000 a month in my area. Who gets to make that decision? Does the resident parent get to make it and they other parent has to pay when they’ve had no say?
What if the non resident parent’s relative would provide childcare but resident parent didn’t want that offer?
What about having children in nursery that is longer than the working hours?
It’s not an easy solution.
Ultimately 50/50 contact would be the most fair financially but again many parents don’t actually want that for various reasons.

i was thinking along similar lines. It’s never that straight forward.

MintJulia · 24/10/2023 13:19

'Ah. But were you married to your ex?'

No, thank goodness. Ex morphed into weird controlling person the day I brought ds home from hospital. Thankfully I was able to pick up my possessions and leave when it got too bad, without a legal battle.

He initially said he wanted 50:50 but that lasted precisely one weekend. He hasn't mentioned it since. I think it was the reality of changing nappies and lack of sleep that changed his mind. 😀

We've coexisted relatively calmly ever since (13 years). He sees ds 6 hours a week during which time he watches sport and ds plays computer games. Then they ignore each other for the rest of the week. It's odd but it works.

femfemlicious · 24/10/2023 13:19

FrippEnos · 24/10/2023 11:46

The quickest and easiest way to sort this would be mandatory 50/50.
But I can't see many "resident parents" going for that.

I agree 50/50 is best 👌🏿

Reugny · 24/10/2023 13:16

Willyoujustbequiet · 24/10/2023 13:08

That sounds eerily like the nonsense that the idiots from Father's 4 Justice come out with.

It's just another attempt to control women.

Op I think childcare costs being split would be a good start. NRPs with EOW get to work unencumbered by childcare and its patently unfair.

I would raise the percentage payable under CMS to more accurately reflect living costs and make unearned income such as property assets and inheritance be taken into account. Too many self employed deadbeat fathers fiddle the figures.

I would remove driving licences and passports for wilful non payers.

Sorry but the childcare cost split doesn't work.

Say there is a nursery and a CM, both OFSTED registered good, but the CM is £20 more expensive a day.

The NRP is going to argue for the nursery to be used and the law will back the NRP. However the nursery has done something of concern e.g. giving the child food the child is allergic too, forced the child to eat all their food, that OFSTED refuses to recognise as a concern. (These are real examples.) The NRP doesn't care about these matters.

This means the RP will still end up paying more and actually could end up with crap in Court for not sending the child to the agreed childcare provider.

dcsp · 24/10/2023 13:15

Why should either party need to get married so that the other takes proper financial responsibility for their children?

@Heelenahandbasket I didn't suggest getting married. I suggested something which would ensure they'd take responsibility without getting married.

dcsp · 24/10/2023 13:13

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 12:57

Perhaps then there needs to be a system where child maintenance is deducted from a non resident parent's income at source like PAYE where possible, and the amount should be based on their income but subject to a floor which assumes working 40 hours per week for minimum wage, and being in arrears makes you ineligible to claim any benefits.

I'd agree that collection via PAYE (just like how Student loan isn't tax, but is collected via PAYE) would be sensible for child maintenance.

I'm not sure about basing it solely on their income - it could lead to unintended consequences in some edge cases.

Heelenahandbasket · 24/10/2023 13:13

dcsp · 24/10/2023 12:51

I know it's another argument in favour of getting married, but that doesn't help resident parents in this situation, or indeed their children.

Does anyone have any bright ideas about how things could be changed to make the system fairer?

Civil Partnerships are now available to mixed-sex couples. I think that they should be actively promoted to those who choose to have children together - they give the legal protection of marriage with none of the societal baggage or cost.

Why should either party need to get married so that the other takes proper financial responsibility for their children?

we need a better system that ensures men take financial and personal responsibility for their children. Marriage should be irrelevant. We need a better maintenance system which allows assets to be transferred if needed. At the moment, the children’s act does allow this in limited circumstances but it’s too difficult to use. The cms is useless.

imo we should also be moving away from “marriage as a meal ticket” idea for women too. It’s hugely regressive that women are told to marry for “security” (well on mn anyway). We need enforceable pre nuptials etc so that people who want to can protect their assets. women who did get married but are higher earners end up doing the childcare and housework and paying out feckless exes. Split of assets should only be other than as contributed if the other part has genuinely contributed in kind. There should not be a windfall for being married

Women do a huge amount of unpaid work when it comes to children- this should be valued and shared regardless of marital status.

dcsp · 24/10/2023 13:12

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 12:55

That still relies on people making the choice to do it. I can't see that men who refuse to get married because they don't want the mother of their children to "steal all their money" are going to want a civil partnership any more than they want to get married.

That's why I think there needs to be a rethink of the system to ensure that people who don't use condoms pay for their damn kids.

Choosing* to have children requires the agreement of both parties - so the woman can make her agreement conditional on the man agreeing to enter into a civil partnership.

(* I deliberately said "choosing", I know that accidents do happen, and this won't cover that scenario - but the majority of children are planned)

Reugny · 24/10/2023 13:10

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 13:07

Doesn't that only apply in the case of a divorce though?

It also applies to very high earners who you have to take to Court to get a true proportion of their income for child maintenance.

Also with divorce after 12 months, unless stated in the financial order, it reverts to the CMS.

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 13:08

MintJulia · 24/10/2023 13:05

'Did your ex actually pay 50% of the childcare bill though?'

Yes. I have ds about 345 days a year, but ex pays half of all bills, probably because he knows if I took him to court it would cost him more - he's a high earner.

The good (and bad) thing is that ex is a completely inept and lazy parent. The upside is that I get to decide schooling, care, everything that matters, without him interfering.

The downside is I get to decide everything - even when some practical support would be useful.

On the whole, I'm happy how it is. DS & I have a calm happy home/routine. We've done ok.

Ah. But were you married to your ex?

OP posts:
Willyoujustbequiet · 24/10/2023 13:08

FrippEnos · 24/10/2023 12:19

Both yours and pointythings points are the reason why there is no easy solution.

Take too much money and the NRP cant afford to live, take too little and the RP finds it hard.

It should be a legal requirement to pay for your children (whether NRP or RP). But how much is not going to be easy to find unless you have a way of finding a solution for everybody on a case by case basis, and this won't work due to the cost of implementation.

Then there is the problem of what the money for the child/ren actually goes towards how do you make sure that its not spent frivolously?
If there is a legel requirement to pay for the child/ren that you have then there should be a legal requirement/responibility that only the child benefits from the money.

That sounds eerily like the nonsense that the idiots from Father's 4 Justice come out with.

It's just another attempt to control women.

Op I think childcare costs being split would be a good start. NRPs with EOW get to work unencumbered by childcare and its patently unfair.

I would raise the percentage payable under CMS to more accurately reflect living costs and make unearned income such as property assets and inheritance be taken into account. Too many self employed deadbeat fathers fiddle the figures.

I would remove driving licences and passports for wilful non payers.