Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Non resident parent's obligation to support their children

317 replies

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 11:25

Another day, another thread about an unmarried woman separating from the father of her children.

This gets discussed a lot on here, but I can see the logic for why unmarried couples should not necessarily have any financial obligation towards each other when they separate. People should have the right to live together without being considered a single financial unit in the eyes of the law, and enforcing marriage-like obligations on people who have not chosen to get married seems wrong to me. Even if this results in some unmarried people, particularly women, making themselves financially vulnerable.

What I don't understand is why the non resident parent's financial obligation to support their children is so small. If the parents of two preschoolers separate, for example, how is the resident parent, who is most likely the mother, supposed to keep a roof over their children's heads if they can't work, and how can they work if they can't afford to pay two sets of childcare fees with the piss-poor contribution she is getting from the children's other parent?

I realise that even claiming the minimum that non resident parents are obliged to pay via CSA can be impossible sometimes - and that's a separate issue - but who on earth decided it was fair or reasonable that the non resident parent's obligation to pay should be limited to an amount which doesn't even touch the sides of the actual cost of raising their children?

I know it's another argument in favour of getting married, but that doesn't help resident parents in this situation, or indeed their children.

Does anyone have any bright ideas about how things could be changed to make the system fairer?

This is purely theoretical for me, but the injustice of it just grates. I've tried to use the gender neutral "resident parent" and "non resident parent" throughout, but we all know the reality, which is that it is usually women who get screwed over in this way, and I assume that is why the problem hasn't been addressed.

OP posts:
yogasaurus · 24/10/2023 17:13

I didn’t have children until I knew I was able to support them myself, worst case. I wouldn’t be able to sleep at night otherwise.

Sayitaintso33 · 24/10/2023 17:10

In the 1980S & 1990s middle-class/middle-income women usually did better out of divorce than their husbands, so I think it is wrong to say that women always got the shitty end of the stick.

But even if that is right that is in the past and the present situation of CMS sounds farcical.

Society now demands and expects that both parents work, so there should be state provided, free childcare. Once child care costs are met, the modest figures suggested by CMS might not seem so absurd.

FairyMaclary · 24/10/2023 17:02

Self assessment for Child maintenance. The Nrp should have to complete a full disclosure of income and declare what has been paid as CM. Any payment due should be paid by the tax deadline.

If the self assessment is falsified or not completed it should carry the same penalties as not declaring your income to HMRC for tax purposes. The self assessment system is already set up. It was amended to include covid 19 gov help. They could easily tweak it for CM for all employed and self employed people. If the government gave a shit this would be an easy thing to do.

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 16:48

Reugny · 24/10/2023 16:44

You have just reminded me of something - if the father was loose with his sexual behaviour there may be two or even more children who need childcare at the same time with different mothers.

Forcing him to pay one lot of childcare fees will deprive the other(s). Alternatively the state (us) would have to pick up the bill which is never paid off.

I like the suggestion a PP made about the state picking up the bill and then treating it as a debt that needs to be paid off as soon as he is solvent enough, with interest. It needn't be more complicated than the system of student loan repayment, or recovering care costs from the proceeds of sale of someone's house after they have died.

OP posts:
Reugny · 24/10/2023 16:44

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 14:58

If the NRP is working, why shouldn't they be contributing to nursery fees? Particularly when the alternative, if they don't contribute, is that the RP can't work.

As a PP said, the NRP has huge earning capacity because their ability to work is completely unencumbered by childcare responsibilities. The RP can't just increase their income to pay for childcare by working more hours, because they would also need to find childcare to cover those hours. The NRP can, actually, increase their income to pay for childcare by working more hours.

You have just reminded me of something - if the father was loose with his sexual behaviour there may be two or even more children who need childcare at the same time with different mothers.

Forcing him to pay one lot of childcare fees will deprive the other(s). Alternatively the state (us) would have to pick up the bill which is never paid off.

BatshitAndBrazen · 24/10/2023 15:00

I was a single mother to my eldest child and always worked. I used to get 70 percent of her childcare paid by tax credits and she went to private nursery. When I went to university, they helped me pay my childcare also. I was completely able to further my career and work, even when she was small.

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 14:58

SleepingStandingUp · 24/10/2023 14:51

The difficulty is if I can't afford nursery fees, I might choose to use my Mom or quit work and rely on benefits. But of DH were the resident parent and could afford half, this would be forcing me to pay half regardless of my preferences. Now I could go for 50/50 and therefore not used paid care for my half but that's often not best care for a young child.

As a resident parent, only money that exists can be spent but as a non resident parent, you're saying well tough, of the other parent chooses to spend this money you have to find half. Tough of its your rent money, love on the streets. Only the resident parent and child matter.

If DH and I together decide to pay for full time childcare or use my mother that's OUR choice for our money.

You're talking about ONE PERSONS CHOICE being forcibly enforced using another person's money.

If the NRP is working, why shouldn't they be contributing to nursery fees? Particularly when the alternative, if they don't contribute, is that the RP can't work.

As a PP said, the NRP has huge earning capacity because their ability to work is completely unencumbered by childcare responsibilities. The RP can't just increase their income to pay for childcare by working more hours, because they would also need to find childcare to cover those hours. The NRP can, actually, increase their income to pay for childcare by working more hours.

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 24/10/2023 14:51

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 12:24

Well to take nursery costs, as a big thing. Could it not be a legal requirement for both parents to be billed separately for their contribution to nursery fees, and to have an expedited debt collection process to enforce any debts against a NRP who failed to pay their share?

The difficulty is if I can't afford nursery fees, I might choose to use my Mom or quit work and rely on benefits. But of DH were the resident parent and could afford half, this would be forcing me to pay half regardless of my preferences. Now I could go for 50/50 and therefore not used paid care for my half but that's often not best care for a young child.

As a resident parent, only money that exists can be spent but as a non resident parent, you're saying well tough, of the other parent chooses to spend this money you have to find half. Tough of its your rent money, love on the streets. Only the resident parent and child matter.

If DH and I together decide to pay for full time childcare or use my mother that's OUR choice for our money.

You're talking about ONE PERSONS CHOICE being forcibly enforced using another person's money.

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 14:49

BibbleandSqwauk · 24/10/2023 14:43

A simple way to cut through some of the very complex and varied circumstances would be simply to raise the rate of CMS. The % is a joke. I don't get to ring fence 18% of my salary and then tell the kids halfway through the month they've had their allocation and that's it. Something like 25% or a minimum amount whichever is higher which actually reflects at least a basic real attempt to contribute a meaningful amount. That figure could be based on ONS numbers of average costs and reviewed annually. If the NRP cannot pay it, the state does, as an additional benefit to the RP and it accrues as a debt to the NRP (Unless the NRP is in receipt of PIP or sickness benefits etc) . The higher amount and the state guarantee allows the RP a more meaningful contribution and might go toward some more fairness with regard to childcare costs
. CMS should be a dept of HMRC with all records available instantly and heavily invested in so cases are handled in a timely fashion.
For those saying 25% is too high, NRPs have huge earning capacity that RPs don't. They can do extra shifts, night shifts, more than one job. They can retrain, get promoted, go on overnight trips. None of which are usually possible for an RP. If they can't afford more kids with a new partner, tough.

Great post.

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 14:48

JustAMinutePleass · 24/10/2023 14:21

Mandatory CCJs for non-payment of child maintenance would definitely help as it would impact the ability of these pondscum to build new lives. It should be classed as a formal debt and if you’re unable to pay debt collection proceedings should take place. I do not believe how many resident children living with the nrp should matter either - it’s just based on sexist principles that men are always the breadwinner & encourages these pieces of filth to have more children.

Yes, surely this would be easy enough to implement?

Fuck up their credit ratings if they refuse to pay.

OP posts:
BibbleandSqwauk · 24/10/2023 14:43

A simple way to cut through some of the very complex and varied circumstances would be simply to raise the rate of CMS. The % is a joke. I don't get to ring fence 18% of my salary and then tell the kids halfway through the month they've had their allocation and that's it. Something like 25% or a minimum amount whichever is higher which actually reflects at least a basic real attempt to contribute a meaningful amount. That figure could be based on ONS numbers of average costs and reviewed annually. If the NRP cannot pay it, the state does, as an additional benefit to the RP and it accrues as a debt to the NRP (Unless the NRP is in receipt of PIP or sickness benefits etc) . The higher amount and the state guarantee allows the RP a more meaningful contribution and might go toward some more fairness with regard to childcare costs
. CMS should be a dept of HMRC with all records available instantly and heavily invested in so cases are handled in a timely fashion.
For those saying 25% is too high, NRPs have huge earning capacity that RPs don't. They can do extra shifts, night shifts, more than one job. They can retrain, get promoted, go on overnight trips. None of which are usually possible for an RP. If they can't afford more kids with a new partner, tough.

JustAMinutePleass · 24/10/2023 14:21

Mandatory CCJs for non-payment of child maintenance would definitely help as it would impact the ability of these pondscum to build new lives. It should be classed as a formal debt and if you’re unable to pay debt collection proceedings should take place. I do not believe how many resident children living with the nrp should matter either - it’s just based on sexist principles that men are always the breadwinner & encourages these pieces of filth to have more children.

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 14:13

Notamum12345577 · 24/10/2023 14:08

But if the contact is 50/50, and one parent has GPs to help with their childcare, and the other doesn’t, how is that the responsibility of the one who does? I could agree if it was say 75/25 as the costs of raising that child will not be even, but when it is 50/50 the costs will be straight down the middle.

If grandparents were helping with the NRP's portion of the childcare, then provided the arrangement with the grandparents fit in with part-time childcare to cover the RP's portion, and provided the NRP picked up the slack on any days the grandparents were unavailable, that would be OK?

For example, the grandparents agree to have the child two days per week and the RP manages to find a nursery place to cover the other three days. Even if the RP then had to cover the whole cost of nursery, it would still be cheaper than having to pay for five days. The grandparents would need to be reliable though.

OP posts:
Coyoacan · 24/10/2023 14:12

JustALittlePotatooo · 24/10/2023 12:27

I think it would be a good start if nursery was affordable even for those on minimum wage. And I mean genuinely affordable, so people could still have a decent standard of living after paying nursery fees. That way the vast majority of resident parents would be able to afford to go back to work. Obviously not everyone would want to, but it would make it a feasible option.

The same should go for after school club - it should be affordable. If these things were affordable the resident parents wouldn't be as reliant on their exes.

This

Notamum12345577 · 24/10/2023 14:08

Phonedown · 24/10/2023 12:41

50/50 contact also does not allow for a fair split of costs. If one parent has child care support in the form of a grandparent but one parent doesn't, this might prevent that parent from working if they can't access child care. Should.nursery fees in this instance be split?

In my experience in 50/50 arrangements one parent is usually still left with more of a financial burden. It is usually still one parent who buys the children's clothes, takes them to the hairdresser's, organises birthday parties, etc and that's not to mention the time that parent spends doing these things instead of working.

Research has shown that 50/50 works well for all parties only when the parenting was being split 50/50 within the original relationship.

But if the contact is 50/50, and one parent has GPs to help with their childcare, and the other doesn’t, how is that the responsibility of the one who does? I could agree if it was say 75/25 as the costs of raising that child will not be even, but when it is 50/50 the costs will be straight down the middle.

Housesellingnightmare · 24/10/2023 13:59

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 13:58

CornishGem1975 · 24/10/2023 13:47

If the child is the RP they are the one who needs the childcare to be able to work but the NRP should still be contributing.

I still don't agree that it's that clean-cut.

RP could be earning £150k a year, working and putting the child in childcare so that they can earn. NRP could be earning £30k but is expected to pay half of the childcare bill to enable RP to work? Nope. That's why it's not a straightforward answer. And that's what we have CMS.

There's always an assumption that NRP is a higher earner than RP and that's not always the case.

I mean, it would be fairer for parents to pay in proportion to their earnings, and let's face it, that would usually benefit the mother/RP more than the NRP.

But even in that situation, the NRP still needs to be contributing to the upkeep of the children they have brought into the world. The RP probably isn't working just for the fun of it, but to provide for those children, and the fact that they earn 150k still doesn't mean they should be liable for all costs.

OP posts:
Baconisdelicious · 24/10/2023 13:50

There's always an assumption that NRP is a higher earner than RP and that's not always the case

agreed. However, I do think that society - broadly - will label a female RP as ‘grabby’ or ‘gold digger’ or something equally unpleasant if she dares expect a lower RP to support their joint child.

CornishGem1975 · 24/10/2023 13:47

If the child is the RP they are the one who needs the childcare to be able to work but the NRP should still be contributing.

I still don't agree that it's that clean-cut.

RP could be earning £150k a year, working and putting the child in childcare so that they can earn. NRP could be earning £30k but is expected to pay half of the childcare bill to enable RP to work? Nope. That's why it's not a straightforward answer. And that's what we have CMS.

There's always an assumption that NRP is a higher earner than RP and that's not always the case.

EmeraldTheSeahorse · 24/10/2023 13:43

My ex only needs to pay £7 a week, he wouldn’t do 50/50 as he doesn’t see them through his own choice. It’s funny as there was a thread on here recently where someone was getting over £400 a month for one child and it got pages and pages of posters saying how disgusting it was and how low it is yet I get £7 a week for more than one child and I got about 10 comments telling me to be grateful for it as at least it’s an ice cream once a week or a takeaway once a month 🤦🏻‍♀️

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 13:43

Willyoujustbequiet · 24/10/2023 13:39

Unusual/rare/hypothetical childcare circumstances is no justification whatsover for one parent to shoulder the entire burden of childcare costs whilst the other, who already abdicates most of their parental responsibilities, gets off scot free.

It simply perpetuates a cycle of poverty, burden on the tax payer and gender pay gap.

This.

If there is a disagreement over childcare settings, for example, with the RP wanting a more expensive setting than another one in roughly the same location which is cheaper, the RP could pay the difference in cost.

But I think the RP does still need to have the final say about which childcare setting should be used, given that they will be responsible for most or all drop offs and pick ups.

OP posts:
54isanopendoor · 24/10/2023 13:40

I appreciate you putting in the caveat re special needs.

I am a parent to two children (now 16 & 18) who have Autism. I am now their Carer & the DWP allows me £70p/w in respect of my not being able to work around their needs. My exH was never willing to split work / any care duties.
I have 'lost out' on around 16 years of salary & pension contributions.
exH walked out 2 years ago. He never has the children & he paid £200p/m maintenance until he decided to retire early & now therefore has to pay nowt.
It's a lousy situation which leaves the kids (& I) in poverty.
Society should shame men who walk out on kids as much as they do women.

MargotBamborough · 24/10/2023 13:40

CornishGem1975 · 24/10/2023 13:34

I'm not sure that childcare costs should be split 50/50. How does that work, for instance, when NRP has the kids but doesn't actually require childcare? Childcare on a day-to-day basis should be the responsibility of the person who needs it to cover the children on their own time.

(I say that as a parent and a step-parent who has lived this situation)

I'd certainly not be happy having to pay half the childcare costs to enable my ex to go to his job if I don't need childcare on my own time.

If the NRP only has the child one evening a week and every other weekend they don't need childcare.

If the child is the RP they are the one who needs the childcare to be able to work but the NRP should still be contributing. If the RP just said, "fuck this, you have them" and drove off into the sunset, the NRP would become the RP and would need to provide childcare.

OP posts:
Baconisdelicious · 24/10/2023 13:40

If these things were affordable the resident parents wouldn't be as reliant on their exes

sorry…but how can you even think that, let alone say it? I have been single for 15 years. I’ve brought up 3 kids alone, without a penny of support from their so-called father (who has seen them weekly, minimally). I don’t know of any women in my position who fit the ‘reliant on their ex’ description. Children, however, are reliant on their parents, both of them, or it should be both.

It isn’t helpful to portray women as helpless, passive creatures who need a man to provide. Statistics on child maintenance in the UK show that literally millions of women cope perfectly well.

Willyoujustbequiet · 24/10/2023 13:39

Reugny · 24/10/2023 13:16

Sorry but the childcare cost split doesn't work.

Say there is a nursery and a CM, both OFSTED registered good, but the CM is £20 more expensive a day.

The NRP is going to argue for the nursery to be used and the law will back the NRP. However the nursery has done something of concern e.g. giving the child food the child is allergic too, forced the child to eat all their food, that OFSTED refuses to recognise as a concern. (These are real examples.) The NRP doesn't care about these matters.

This means the RP will still end up paying more and actually could end up with crap in Court for not sending the child to the agreed childcare provider.

Unusual/rare/hypothetical childcare circumstances is no justification whatsover for one parent to shoulder the entire burden of childcare costs whilst the other, who already abdicates most of their parental responsibilities, gets off scot free.

It simply perpetuates a cycle of poverty, burden on the tax payer and gender pay gap.

Swipe left for the next trending thread