Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that men (and women) should be careful with their interactions with children?

111 replies

Kala24 · 24/10/2023 09:53

I always just thought it was common sense that if you don't know a child, don't do anything that could seem weird! But maybe it's just my cynical mind?

Just got back from holiday with my boyfriend and another couple. On one of the days there was a girl in the pool playing on her own. She was throwing something to the other end of the pool and then swimming over to get it. She was about 6. The man from the other couple we were with got in the pool and started playing with her.. she wasn't English so they didn't speak to each other, he just took it upon himself to join in with her game. As she threw whatever it was she was throwing, he would swim over and reach it before her and then start laughing. He did this over and over for ages. It annoyed me because I just thought.. leave her alone? This young girl doesn't know you and is just happily playing by herself I doubt she wants some random 40 year old man coming over to her spoiling her game!

At one point her parents came over and also got into the pool so part of me is wondering if they also found it odd and wanted to keep their eye on her.

I don't know why he would do this. I'm not accusing him of anything at all, I genuinely think he was just trying to be friendly and make her laugh. But it can look creepy because unfortunately we do live in a world where there's sick people around and even I, as a woman wouldn't randomly start playing with a little girl I don't know, without asking her. It's weird!

Is it just me? When I was a kid my mum always told me not to talk to strangers and I would've felt scared if this happened to me as a kid. Although I appreciate not all kids are the same. I know that lots of people might say not everything is so negative and wrong, and he was just being friendly and nice and it's sad that people can't do something so innocent without it being misconstrued or seen as dodgy. But kids and parents have no way of knowing which people are just being nice and friendly and which have more sinister motives, so I would just never do this and would always be overly cautious. And I DEFINITELY wouldn't do it as a man. Is this not just common knowledge? I'm shocked that he didn't think it was inappropriate. I asked my boyfriend and he didn't see anything wrong with it although said he'd never do it himself.

Is this just me being OTT?

OP posts:
Ellie1015 · 24/10/2023 12:50

As a parent if i came to the pool to find my child playing with an adult she didnt know I would be creeped out. Your friend did nothing wrong but as a parent i would be worrying about possible motives. Child would have a talking to about strangers and i would be keeping an eye out for him appearing near her again.

HappinessForBeginners · 24/10/2023 12:50

But, @HappinessForBeginners , one very plausible explanation for the man’s behaviour is rooted in the possibility that the girl’s parents weren’t watching her carefully enough. Playing with her may have been a covert way of watching over her. No contortions required.

Then he could have kept a discreet eye on her, better still asked one of the women in his group to, spoke to a lifeguard if one was on duty. Literally anything that didn’t involve him inviting himself to play. Confused

She wasn’t struggling to swim, she was swimming from one side to the other over and over, I don’t believe he was worried for her. So yes, contortions required. Anything to justify inappropriate male behaviour from many posters.

LakeTiticaca · 24/10/2023 12:47

It was quite likely perfectly innocent. However, thinking back to my childhood, I think I would have been pissed off if some random bloke had decided to join in my game !!

Insommmmnia · 24/10/2023 12:46

HappinessForBeginners · 24/10/2023 12:38

Where did I say that they cant just be sitting on loungers?

How do you want them to behave to satisfy your need for them to be ‘obvious’. 😬

Once again you gave literally ignored the bit where I said I wouldn't have got in the pool myself in that situation I.e. I am offering a possible explanation for the behaviour not a justification, there is a difference, at no point have I said his behaviour was correct.

Offering explanations which are so unlikely that it comes across as justifying a man with no boundaries.

In general, the combination of being keen to explain away men’s inappropriate behaviour, the social conditioning of girls to be polite and the willingness to blame others is dangerous and wrong.

How do you want them to behave to satisfy your need for them to be ‘obvious

Glancing over on a fairly regular basis

Offering explanations which are so unlikely that it comes across as justifying a man with no boundaries.

And again, I have literally said I don't think getting in the pool was the right thing to do. If you think that means I am saying getting in the pool was the right thing to do then that's your issue tbh

Insommmmnia · 24/10/2023 12:44

On average 25 people from the UK die in hotel pools every year and there are about 500 serious incidents (I.e. near drownings) in hotel pools every year. That's mostly kids and just ones from the UK so the total numbers could be much higher. 350 children under the age of 5 (so not much younger than the age of the child in the OP) drown in pools every year.

There are plenty of reasons to be worried about a 6 year old playing in a pool by herself especially if you have witnessed one of those deaths/near drownings before

When serious accidents like this happen people sometimes ask "why did no one nearby help?" - these comments are why no one nearby helps.

Now I still think a random man should be more aware of what it looks like when he jumps in to a pool to play ball with a young girl but nevertheless it either "takes a village" or it doesn't. So next time there is a thread on MN moaning about the lack of "village" as there often is, this is where the village is, sat at the side terrified to help because they will be labelled a pedophile or groomer.

IsThereABarUpThere · 24/10/2023 12:43

TooBusyLiving · 24/10/2023 10:27

In his mind, he couldn’t imagine the girl not wanting him involved in her game. He didn’t ask, he just assumed he was wanted. Some men just don’t get it, it’s entitlement.

And yes, we should all be aware of our behaviour around children. I would be suspicious, especially of a man, engaging overly with my children. Most people realise this and just don’t do it.

No, it doesn’t mean he’s definitely a creepy fucker, but it does show a real lack of judgment and understanding of the issues and a level of self importance that’s off putting.

It was entitled of him to interact from a distance with a little girl whilst her own parents didn't bother and just let her play on her own in the pool for ages?

Give over.

The parents are entitled. They wanted a holiday where they didn't want to play with their child.
The man in question was doing a nice thing.

IsThereABarUpThere · 24/10/2023 12:42

AlwaysPrettyOnTheInside · 24/10/2023 10:21

Is this just me being OTT?

Yep. Other nations don't see paedo motives in every interaction with children, ime.

This.

HappinessForBeginners · 24/10/2023 12:38

Where did I say that they cant just be sitting on loungers?

How do you want them to behave to satisfy your need for them to be ‘obvious’. 😬

Once again you gave literally ignored the bit where I said I wouldn't have got in the pool myself in that situation I.e. I am offering a possible explanation for the behaviour not a justification, there is a difference, at no point have I said his behaviour was correct.

Offering explanations which are so unlikely that it comes across as justifying a man with no boundaries.

In general, the combination of being keen to explain away men’s inappropriate behaviour, the social conditioning of girls to be polite and the willingness to blame others is dangerous and wrong.

Kala24 · 24/10/2023 12:37

Mamma2017 · 24/10/2023 12:31

Paedos and creeps have ruined things for everyone. This was clearly an innocent friendly interaction which the child enjoyed. It’s a shame that a minority of perverts means everyone has to stop being friendly. Most men wouldn’t do this for fear of being seen as a creep which I get but in his culture it probably wasn’t seen the same way. As long as he’s in view of the parents there’s no problem here and the child knows that if she’s without her parents/adult she knows she mustn’t speak to strangers.

Yes this is the thing. I feel sad that I feel this way and wish I didn't, because I know that he was only trying to be friendly and make her laugh. I'm not accusing him of anything, I was just shocked that he did it that's all because I'm not used to seeing people act like this with strangers children. I thought everyone was in some sort of unspoken agreement that you don't do this sort of thing just to be on the safe side because people could see you as creepy.

I know male teachers that won't be alone with female students if they can help it (obv hard to avoid sometimes) or they used to be a fun jokey teacher but now they aren't and are more careful just in case anything gets misconstrued. It's not the exact same thing but I'm just making the point that even if you're a good person and your intentions are harmless, sometimes it's just better not to do something because of how it may come across or be seen. It is a shame. And it would be different in my eyes if the child had come over to him with and wanted to play. It's the fact that he went over to her unprompted that I think could be seen as a bit iffy

Also I don't know if she was 6, I don't know her age. She just looked roughly that age

OP posts:
justjeansandanicetop · 24/10/2023 12:35

If she was happily playing by herself I can't understand why he would do this.

W0tnow · 24/10/2023 12:34

Not OTT at all. As a parent I think its extremely odd to start playing with a random child in that way. I don't know any man of that age who would do it? Well, any age, really!

Binkie98 · 24/10/2023 12:31

AlwaysPrettyOnTheInside · 24/10/2023 10:28

I think you have a sad view of the world.

My DH is the type that if he was in the pool playing with nieces/nephews, all the kids in the place would end up joined in by the end, of their own accord. I would be sitting in peace away from all the children 😂There would be nothing untoward about it and he'd be careful to ensure there was no touching that could be misconstrued etc, he'd probably ask the parents if it was ok for them to play, he's very conscious of appropriate behaviour.

But, my point is, not every man that interacts with children has ulterior motives and to see them all havin so is a sad, sad, view.

Obviously safeguard and remove people that set your senses off or give cause to, but dont see it round every corner.

This. It's sad that in the UK, adults are automatically classed as perverts if they dare to interact with a child.
The parents were nearby.

poetryandwine · 24/10/2023 12:31

HappinessForBeginners · 24/10/2023 12:23

I noticed you left out the part where I said "not obviously being watched"

You think to watch properly, they can’t just be sitting on loungers? Why do they have to be ‘obvious’. 😬

It took ages for the parents to come and join in by the sounds of the OP. So either they had no issue with it, or, they weren't actively supervising. And I've been to plenty of places where the latter is an issue.

Or they were watching, thought it was odd, but as a pp said, they didn’t want to make a fuss for fear of being told they were OTT.

It’s a situation they shouldn’t have had to deal with because other people should behave normally. Although I would have just called my child out of the water, I know I’d have thought wtf, and I can imagine lots of people would have watched and waited, not because they were happy with the situation, but because they may feel awkward.

If the parents were not watching their child then obviously that’s not responsible behaviour and they’re idiots. The thread isn’t about that though, it’s asking about the mans behaviour.

Maybe we should discuss whether the girl should have been throwing things in the pool as she might have been disturbing others, or whether OP flew to her holiday destination and the effects on the planet or anything else to deflect from the issue of this man having no boundaries. People are desperate to justify the mans behaviour, even turning it to somehow be the fault of the parents.

But, @HappinessForBeginners , one very plausible explanation for the man’s behaviour is rooted in the possibility that the girl’s parents weren’t watching her carefully enough. Playing with her may have been a covert way of watching over her. No contortions required.

Mamma2017 · 24/10/2023 12:31

Paedos and creeps have ruined things for everyone. This was clearly an innocent friendly interaction which the child enjoyed. It’s a shame that a minority of perverts means everyone has to stop being friendly. Most men wouldn’t do this for fear of being seen as a creep which I get but in his culture it probably wasn’t seen the same way. As long as he’s in view of the parents there’s no problem here and the child knows that if she’s without her parents/adult she knows she mustn’t speak to strangers.

Insommmmnia · 24/10/2023 12:30

HappinessForBeginners · 24/10/2023 12:23

I noticed you left out the part where I said "not obviously being watched"

You think to watch properly, they can’t just be sitting on loungers? Why do they have to be ‘obvious’. 😬

It took ages for the parents to come and join in by the sounds of the OP. So either they had no issue with it, or, they weren't actively supervising. And I've been to plenty of places where the latter is an issue.

Or they were watching, thought it was odd, but as a pp said, they didn’t want to make a fuss for fear of being told they were OTT.

It’s a situation they shouldn’t have had to deal with because other people should behave normally. Although I would have just called my child out of the water, I know I’d have thought wtf, and I can imagine lots of people would have watched and waited, not because they were happy with the situation, but because they may feel awkward.

If the parents were not watching their child then obviously that’s not responsible behaviour and they’re idiots. The thread isn’t about that though, it’s asking about the mans behaviour.

Maybe we should discuss whether the girl should have been throwing things in the pool as she might have been disturbing others, or whether OP flew to her holiday destination and the effects on the planet or anything else to deflect from the issue of this man having no boundaries. People are desperate to justify the mans behaviour, even turning it to somehow be the fault of the parents.

You think to watch properly, they can’t just be sitting on loungers? Why do they have to be ‘obvious

Where did I say that they cant just be sitting on loungers?

People are desperate to justify the mans behaviour

Once again you gave literally ignored the bit where I said I wouldn't have got in the pool myself in that situation I.e. I am offering a possible explanation for the behaviour not a justification, there is a difference, at no point have I said his behaviour was correct.

Valerianandfoxglovesoup · 24/10/2023 12:29

Two things I take from the wisdom posted so far. Girls are conditioned to be polite even if they are uncomfortable and to go with your gut feeling. I'm not saying he's a weirdo, he might just be a blithering idiot but either way, yuck, it would feel creepy. We have a very dear friend who means no harm and is a genuinely kind, good man but he sometimes creeps women out. Just that kind of engaging with them in queries when he doesn't know them, starting a random conversation etc. And I tell him he's yuck too 😀

slothfeatures · 24/10/2023 12:25

I asked my DP his opinion because he’s Iranian and I’ve often seen him approach kids to entertain them, he wouldn’t go up to just any random child but he kept a toddler occupied on a plane sat behind him. The little girl was on her mothers knee and kept standing up and passing him toys and wanting his attention, it was actually driving me mad as it was a night flight and I wanted to sleep. DP said it was better then the toddler bored and crying.

He saw a boy of about 9 kicking a football alone (parents were there but not playing with him) whilst we were waiting to pick up my nephew from school and went to join him and had a kick about with him.
The boy loved it and wanted to keep playing when they left!
My partner wouldn’t have done this if I wasn’t there or the child’s parents.

We were at Pizza Hut a few months ago and a little girl (about 3) was wandering round the restaurant unattended, DP thought it was dangerous and led her back to her parents, they let her walk off again so DP showed her cat videos on his phone so she wasn’t abducted or had hot food dropped on her by staff. We were also at the top of a steep staircase she kept running and playing on the stairs so DP was keeping her away from the stairs as well.

DP said if he saw a 6 year old unattended in a pool he’d almost certainly get in just for safety reasons. He said he’d probably interact with the child and watch to see if they were happy with that or preferred playing alone, if they weren’t keen to play he’d leave them to play alone but stay in the pool and keep an eye on them.

DP is from a completely different culture though where it’s not unusual to keep an eye out for children or amuse them if they are bored. He said he wouldn’t approach a child in this country without their parents present or if I wasn’t there as that can give the wrong impression.

It takes a village to raise a child in Iran which is an outdated concept in the UK, most parents wouldn’t appreciate a strangers help or interaction.
I can understand why some people think a man getting into a pool to play with a random child is unusual, in a lot of cultures it’s completely normal though and the parents might have left their child in the pool expecting others to watch her.

HappinessForBeginners · 24/10/2023 12:23

I noticed you left out the part where I said "not obviously being watched"

You think to watch properly, they can’t just be sitting on loungers? Why do they have to be ‘obvious’. 😬

It took ages for the parents to come and join in by the sounds of the OP. So either they had no issue with it, or, they weren't actively supervising. And I've been to plenty of places where the latter is an issue.

Or they were watching, thought it was odd, but as a pp said, they didn’t want to make a fuss for fear of being told they were OTT.

It’s a situation they shouldn’t have had to deal with because other people should behave normally. Although I would have just called my child out of the water, I know I’d have thought wtf, and I can imagine lots of people would have watched and waited, not because they were happy with the situation, but because they may feel awkward.

If the parents were not watching their child then obviously that’s not responsible behaviour and they’re idiots. The thread isn’t about that though, it’s asking about the mans behaviour.

Maybe we should discuss whether the girl should have been throwing things in the pool as she might have been disturbing others, or whether OP flew to her holiday destination and the effects on the planet or anything else to deflect from the issue of this man having no boundaries. People are desperate to justify the mans behaviour, even turning it to somehow be the fault of the parents.

webster1987 · 24/10/2023 12:20

Bellsandthistle · 24/10/2023 10:10

How many of us, as grown women, have done or said things when we were uncomfortable in order to “be nice”?

THIS.

PinkRoses1245 · 24/10/2023 12:14

Coffeerum · 24/10/2023 10:02

Surely if she didn't want him to play she wouldn't keep throwing it?

I don't think it looks creepy at all.

You sound like you live in quite an insular world.

This is what I thought. If she hasn’t wanted to play she could have moved or got out. You have a weird mindset round this

Tapasita · 24/10/2023 12:12

Maybe he felt sorry for her, and wanted to give her some friendly interaction - and that's all. I do also think you are coloured by your own experiences with the man in the pub.

Why weren't the parents in the pool playing with their child? That's the question

Onethingatatime23 · 24/10/2023 12:04

Or is it absolutely fine for strange men to go up to little girls they don't know and play with them without asking?

It definitely isn't, and not for women either. You just wouldn't, would you?

GalaApples · 24/10/2023 12:00

YANBU. As a very minimum this man was being insensitive. He should have realised he needed to take other people's feelings into account - the child's, her parents and anyone else who saw it who felt they might need to keep an eye on it.

As was said upthread girls are conditioned to be nice and polite and compliant. So how does anyone know whether or not she liked a 40 year old man interrupting her game. Men are sometimes crassly unaware - no excuse.

Insommmmnia · 24/10/2023 12:00

HappinessForBeginners · 24/10/2023 11:52

But I also find it interesting that the man playing a ball game and actually engaging with the child is getting more judgement than the parents letting a 6 year old play by themselves in a pool OP

Probably because there is nothing to suggest the child wasn’t being watched. In fact, quite the opposite, the parents got in the pool when the man invited himself to play her game with her. If they were not watching her, then of course they were wrong but OP hasn’t said that was the case. My children could swim very well at 6 and I was perfectly capable of watching them properly from the side of the pool.

I noticed you left out the part where I said "not obviously being watched"

It took ages for the parents to come and join in by the sounds of the OP. So either they had no issue with it, or, they weren't actively supervising. And I've been to plenty of places where the latter is an issue.

HappinessForBeginners · 24/10/2023 11:52

But I also find it interesting that the man playing a ball game and actually engaging with the child is getting more judgement than the parents letting a 6 year old play by themselves in a pool OP

Probably because there is nothing to suggest the child wasn’t being watched. In fact, quite the opposite, the parents got in the pool when the man invited himself to play her game with her. If they were not watching her, then of course they were wrong but OP hasn’t said that was the case. My children could swim very well at 6 and I was perfectly capable of watching them properly from the side of the pool.