Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that men (and women) should be careful with their interactions with children?

111 replies

Kala24 · 24/10/2023 09:53

I always just thought it was common sense that if you don't know a child, don't do anything that could seem weird! But maybe it's just my cynical mind?

Just got back from holiday with my boyfriend and another couple. On one of the days there was a girl in the pool playing on her own. She was throwing something to the other end of the pool and then swimming over to get it. She was about 6. The man from the other couple we were with got in the pool and started playing with her.. she wasn't English so they didn't speak to each other, he just took it upon himself to join in with her game. As she threw whatever it was she was throwing, he would swim over and reach it before her and then start laughing. He did this over and over for ages. It annoyed me because I just thought.. leave her alone? This young girl doesn't know you and is just happily playing by herself I doubt she wants some random 40 year old man coming over to her spoiling her game!

At one point her parents came over and also got into the pool so part of me is wondering if they also found it odd and wanted to keep their eye on her.

I don't know why he would do this. I'm not accusing him of anything at all, I genuinely think he was just trying to be friendly and make her laugh. But it can look creepy because unfortunately we do live in a world where there's sick people around and even I, as a woman wouldn't randomly start playing with a little girl I don't know, without asking her. It's weird!

Is it just me? When I was a kid my mum always told me not to talk to strangers and I would've felt scared if this happened to me as a kid. Although I appreciate not all kids are the same. I know that lots of people might say not everything is so negative and wrong, and he was just being friendly and nice and it's sad that people can't do something so innocent without it being misconstrued or seen as dodgy. But kids and parents have no way of knowing which people are just being nice and friendly and which have more sinister motives, so I would just never do this and would always be overly cautious. And I DEFINITELY wouldn't do it as a man. Is this not just common knowledge? I'm shocked that he didn't think it was inappropriate. I asked my boyfriend and he didn't see anything wrong with it although said he'd never do it himself.

Is this just me being OTT?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ididivfama · 24/10/2023 20:08

Coffeerum · 24/10/2023 10:02

Surely if she didn't want him to play she wouldn't keep throwing it?

I don't think it looks creepy at all.

You sound like you live in quite an insular world.

Actually children, especially girls, want to please.

Zebedee55 · 24/10/2023 17:39

All sounds quite normal. 🙄

Dogrough · 24/10/2023 17:37

@Kala24 I think it’s creepy, why would a middle aged man want to play with a 6 year old girl he doesn’t know and can’t even talk to? What’s in it for him?

My nieces would be confused, uncomfortable and embarrassed, and not know what to do in that situation. They would look for their adult to tell him to go away, they would worry about getting told off for being rude if they walked off from or told an adult to go away.

Speedweed · 24/10/2023 17:33

Paedophiles and groomers push their way into situations.

So in the pool scenario, a normal man who wanted to swim would get in the pool and start swimming. He might smile at the girl, or acknowledge her, just to be polite (as he would with anyone he might pass in the pool). He wouldn't join in her game, and he probably wouldn't swim near her to avoid being hit with what she was throwing or crashing into her. Other than that initial smile, they would have no other interaction, no do they need to. He wanted to swim, not play with a kid he doesn't know.

Dubious men push themselves forward. So in the pool example, he would say hello, try and start a conversation (where are you from, who are you here with, didn't they want to swim with you?). He'd swim too close, interrupt her game, encroach on the bit of the pool she was playing in, maybe even stopping her game by taking up too much space. He'd try and keep her attention. He'd probably stop swimming, or he might get her to start swimming with him. Either way, she would have stopped doing her thing, and started doing his.

There's a big difference when you know what to look for.

ginasevern · 24/10/2023 14:50

@theduchessofspork

There's nothing telling about my words, it is genuinely how I and many others think. A random lone man would make me wonder why he was showing such an interest in my child and I would keep a close eye on the situation. Does that make me paranoid or anti social? My reply to @CornishGem1975 related specifically to her comments rather than a generalisation on my part. She and her child were invited to a birthday party. During the party a little girl (unknown to Cornish, but a guest at the party with her parents) approached her and they spent some time engaging with one another. So no, I would not view Cornish as a potential paedophile under those circumstances. However, had a completely strange man wandered in off the street and started talking to one of the kids, alarm bells would ring!

Anniewestest · 24/10/2023 14:10

@Kala24 i think your past experiences have everything to do with this post and why you’ve been so ott about this

ginasevern · 24/10/2023 14:10

@CornishGem1975

No, I don't know your situation. I do however know that female paedophiles exist although in vanishingly small numbers compared to males. The stats don't lie and neither do criminal records. However, to get back to the point. You are a woman and a mother who arrived at the party with her own child, no? Your child was invited to this party and so although you didn't know the other parents, you had a specific reason to be there. Although you didn't technically know the other mums, you would have been identifiable as "Jane's mum", right? You You were not a random stranger who just strolled in off the street and spent the rest of the afternoon talking to a little girl? Because if that was the case (paedophile or not) I would hope that someone might have asked you what you were doing there and who you were.

theduchessofspork · 24/10/2023 14:06

ginasevern · 24/10/2023 13:38

@CornishGem1975

Are you a man and were you a complete and utter stranger to everyone at the party? If you are a woman and were known to at least some of the other guests you would not be viewed as a paedophile. The OP said this man was a complete stranger to a random child in a hotel swimming pool. There was no party going on or any specific reason to engage with her. The child did not invite him to play, she wasn't even near him, and she didn't speak English. Your situation was totally different and your point is rather silly.

It’s not silly at all, the PP is exploring the contexts in which we might be suspicious and those in which we wouldn’t.

Your comment that she ‘would not be viewed as a paedophile’ is telling though, in that I think you are saying that anyone who is male who interacted in a public place with a child he didn’t know, would be viewed as a paedophile. I don’t think you are alone in this in the UK, but I don’t think it’s a healthy view. It’s possible to be vigilant without breaking down all community interaction.

theduchessofspork · 24/10/2023 14:01

Kala24 · 24/10/2023 12:37

Yes this is the thing. I feel sad that I feel this way and wish I didn't, because I know that he was only trying to be friendly and make her laugh. I'm not accusing him of anything, I was just shocked that he did it that's all because I'm not used to seeing people act like this with strangers children. I thought everyone was in some sort of unspoken agreement that you don't do this sort of thing just to be on the safe side because people could see you as creepy.

I know male teachers that won't be alone with female students if they can help it (obv hard to avoid sometimes) or they used to be a fun jokey teacher but now they aren't and are more careful just in case anything gets misconstrued. It's not the exact same thing but I'm just making the point that even if you're a good person and your intentions are harmless, sometimes it's just better not to do something because of how it may come across or be seen. It is a shame. And it would be different in my eyes if the child had come over to him with and wanted to play. It's the fact that he went over to her unprompted that I think could be seen as a bit iffy

Also I don't know if she was 6, I don't know her age. She just looked roughly that age

Then, with kindness, could you try not thinking like this?

It’s a sad world we live in where playing with a child (in full view of her parents and a pool full of people) makes you suspicious.

There was a European survey a while ago, of a man dressed in football kit, with a bunch of little girls, also in kit, all cheering. He was obviously a coach, and most people asked (French and Germans) said he’s a coach / a teacher / a Dad - in the UK the answer was much more likely to be he’s a pervert.

I agree with you this POV is not unusual in the UK these days, but it is not normal. Of course it’s important to be aware, but a person who starts playing with a child in full public view is not suspicious.

CornishGem1975 · 24/10/2023 13:50

@ginasevern I am a woman (women paedophiles exist), and actually, yes, I WAS a complete stranger at the party. I didn't know anybody else in the room apart from my own child, who disappeared as soon as we got there. So no, my point is silly, and you don't actually know what my situation was as you weren't there.

ginasevern · 24/10/2023 13:38

@CornishGem1975

Are you a man and were you a complete and utter stranger to everyone at the party? If you are a woman and were known to at least some of the other guests you would not be viewed as a paedophile. The OP said this man was a complete stranger to a random child in a hotel swimming pool. There was no party going on or any specific reason to engage with her. The child did not invite him to play, she wasn't even near him, and she didn't speak English. Your situation was totally different and your point is rather silly.

StaringAtTheSunset · 24/10/2023 13:27

Not weird at all.
But how do you know the man didn't already know the girl and her family?

You need to read the OP again.

charlotte361 · 24/10/2023 13:25

Not weird at all.
But how do you know the man didn't already know the girl and her family?

Jacopo · 24/10/2023 13:23

He was weird. Its not difficult to think of long-term, well-known paedophiles who hid in plain sight until they were outed.

StaringAtTheSunset · 24/10/2023 13:21

I agree with you OP. It’s weird behaviour.

I also agree that some posters are going to great lengths to justify the behaviour. Maybe he was scared for her safety, maybe he felt sorry for her playing alone, maybe this, maybe that. Bullshit.

Maybe he’s needs to stop being a twat and realise he shouldn’t be inviting himself to play with little kids because it’s not appropriate.

I’m not saying this man is a danger to children, but It’s easy to see why men get away with creepy behaviour like this and a lot worse when there is bad intent, we’re never short of people to tell us it’s ok. People are queuing up to excuse male bad behaviour. Depressing.

CornishGem1975 · 24/10/2023 13:21

I spent the whole of the birthday party playing with a child that wasn't mine the other day. She just came up and asked me to play with her. It never crossed my mind that someone would think I was a paedophile.

ginasevern · 24/10/2023 13:19

@jiinglebells

I don't agree. Children don't just put a stop to something if they don't like it or don't want to continue doing it. Why do you think they are so easily groomed? At that age their entire lives have been conditioned to believing that adults know best and that they musn't be cheeky to them. They are innocent and trusting especially if "he" seems like a nice man and is offering a game/sweets/puppies. I was sexually molested in my local swimming baths when I was around 10 years old. My friends had gone off to the deep end and I stayed in the shallow end. A really lovely middle aged man swam up to me and offered to play a game because I looked lonely. I wasn't sure if he was supposed to be doing what he was doing. I thought it might be an accident or maybe part of the game. Anyway, I didn't want to cause a scene and upset this "lovely" man. To answer the OP's question, I personally would not involve myself with a random child unless it was absolutely necessary, especially if I was a bloke.

jupitermonket · 24/10/2023 13:16

Kala24 · 24/10/2023 10:05

I don't think he was being creepy. I'm saying it could look that way and asking the question SHOULD we be doing these things? Was it completely necessary or appropriate to get in the pool as a 40 year old man just to start playing with a little girl who you don't know? This time there wasn't anything sinister about it, but the parents could be teaching her about stranger danger etc so I don't think it's right for other people to take it upon themselves to start unnecessarily interacting with children in this way. I thought that was just an obvious thing that everyone thought

If you didn’t think it was creepy and it was all just friendly fun, then what an earth are you on about? I think it’s creepy of YOU to be thinking so much and fretting so much about a complete non-event. Should that poor man (and by extension, very man) have to go around policing himself in case very busybody thinks he’s a pervert? Normal interaction of any kind is totally fine. Stop clutching your pearls. Creepy and over-familiar interaction is wrong and should be called out. But you’ve admitted several times that this wasn’t that.

The only thing that was off here was you staring at them all wondering if everybody else should assume he was a pervert when he wasn’t, and the fact the parents let a 6 year old girl play in the pool on her own (risk of drowning too high for my comfort.)

theduchessofspork · 24/10/2023 13:14

While there is a lot of dark in the world, there is also a lot of light

If we live our lives on a don’t talk to strangers basis, everything becomes small and mean

Given this bloke started playing with the kid in a public swimming pool when she was obviously in full view of her parents. He didn’t do anything wrong.

From your description she played with him because she wanted to. Kids generally do want more interaction than parents often want to / can give.

It’s a positive thing, we’d live in a better society if we all took more interest in each other.

Haze193 · 24/10/2023 13:03

I agree with you OP- it should not be happening and is weird. And all those that are supporting this weird behaviour are weird too. Do you think a 6 year old child would be able to say something to a grown man if they felt uncomfortable? There are plenty of adult females who act nice to creepy men so they don’t get hurt.

Kastri · 24/10/2023 12:57

Its unusual and innapropriate for an adult male to play with a young child unprompted,especially a stranger.

Insommmmnia · 24/10/2023 12:57

HappinessForBeginners · 24/10/2023 12:53

Glancing over on a fairly regular basis

Do you know they were not. I’ve explained why them not coming over straight away doesn’t mean they weren’t watching it weren’t concerned.

And again, I have literally said I don't think getting in the pool was the right thing to do. If you think that means I am saying getting in the pool was the right thing to do then that's your issue tbh

TBH, I’m not sure what your point is. I think our conversation is done. 😅

TBH, I’m not sure what your point is. I think our conversation is done.

That's because you keep taking small snippets of my posts and picking at them out of context, or twisting them to suit you. My point is perfectly clear in my first post.

chillin12 · 24/10/2023 12:55

MinnieL · 24/10/2023 10:32

People are completely missing the point as usual. OP doesn’t think this man is weird around kids or that he’s a creep deep down. It raises the question as to why a grown man/woman would just randomly start playing with a young child who seemed more than happy to play by herself. Of course that can look weird.

It’d be different if the little girl came up to him and gave him the ball and he decided to play along. But why insert yourself in something that has nothing to do with you? Especially when you’re a man and the child is young

💯

HappinessForBeginners · 24/10/2023 12:54

or not it

HappinessForBeginners · 24/10/2023 12:53

Glancing over on a fairly regular basis

Do you know they were not. I’ve explained why them not coming over straight away doesn’t mean they weren’t watching it weren’t concerned.

And again, I have literally said I don't think getting in the pool was the right thing to do. If you think that means I am saying getting in the pool was the right thing to do then that's your issue tbh

TBH, I’m not sure what your point is. I think our conversation is done. 😅