Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you see actual images in your head?

142 replies

pontipinemum · 24/10/2023 09:44

Sorry not really an AIBU but I wanted the voting buttons.

I was watching a reel earlier and they were joking that their dad cannot see images in his head.

I can't see images in my head. When I close my eyes it's black (or red if it's bright!) DH said the same.

I know what things look like, and when I am asked to visualise a beautiful beach, I can remember places I have been but I don't 'see' them in my head. I can get a good 'sense' of what it is like in a book but I don't see the characters.

I'm not sure I am explaining this right at all.

YABU - I can actually see the things I am visualising in my head
YANBU - I see black

OP posts:
HappyToSmile · 24/10/2023 12:26

My daughter cannot visualise things in her head. For example, if she has something physically in front of her, she can draw it. If you say "draw a flower", she can't because she just cant picture it

Lurkylurks · 24/10/2023 12:21

TheBirdintheCave · 24/10/2023 10:16

I don't think I can. I also have no inner monologue. My head is totally silent unless I'm reading or playing a song in there. My husband always thinks I'm talking to him 😂

This sounds really peaceful to be honest. My inner monologue is my tormentor sometimes.

TheSoapyFrog · 24/10/2023 12:18

It's aphantasia, and is fairly common for those with ADHD. I can't bring a picture to mind either. I have ADHD.

TheseLegsDefinitelyUsedToBeLonger · 24/10/2023 12:18

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 24/10/2023 12:16

That is really interesting!

I can do it all, but I can't see it all, completely clearly, all the time and to the exclusion of all else. I can know what it looks like, rather than see it I guess. Or rather, if I try to grab it too hard it melts away. But my brain makes it more, too, without me deciding.

So, my table is wood. The ball is red. Then as soon as I wanted to imagine someone walking into the room, suddenly it's on a grey plush carpet, in a white room, with a grey corner sofa with a cream throw on too. And the way in isn't a door, it's an archway. I can see the hallway and stairs through the arch. The person is a white man, in chinos and a check shirt with a brown belt and shoes. He has short dark hair and a thin face with a large nose. He's not someone I've ever met. I didn't decide any of that, I just thought 'person walks into room' and that's what I got.

That's fascinating to read... and as I read it, I could picture everything. Wouldn't it be cool if we could both somehow print an image of everything we could see, and see how close they were to each others?

amusedbush · 24/10/2023 12:16

No, I have aphantasia. I can't see anything in my head if I try to create a scene from imagination but sometimes if I try to recall an actual memory, I see a sort of imprint in the dark, then it fades. Like when you turn off an old TV and you see an imprint on the screen for a few seconds.

I also have zero sense of direction and horrendous face blindness. I'm autistic and these things all appear to be linked.

DH can conjure up detailed images in his mind, like watching a film in his head. When he needs to spell a word, he says the word scrolls through his mind like a banner and he just "reads" each letter aloud. I physically can't spell out loud and have to write the word down first, so I'm now attributing it to aphantasia.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 24/10/2023 12:16

OnlyFannys · 24/10/2023 11:18

Now this is interesting because I can absolute visualise all of the objects but when you said about the person coming into the room and picking up the ball I struggled with that, my brain struggles to visualise actual movement. I had never notice that before but I can easily picture memories and objects as images but movement just doesn't come easily to me, my memories are like a series of photographs but not a film

That is really interesting!

I can do it all, but I can't see it all, completely clearly, all the time and to the exclusion of all else. I can know what it looks like, rather than see it I guess. Or rather, if I try to grab it too hard it melts away. But my brain makes it more, too, without me deciding.

So, my table is wood. The ball is red. Then as soon as I wanted to imagine someone walking into the room, suddenly it's on a grey plush carpet, in a white room, with a grey corner sofa with a cream throw on too. And the way in isn't a door, it's an archway. I can see the hallway and stairs through the arch. The person is a white man, in chinos and a check shirt with a brown belt and shoes. He has short dark hair and a thin face with a large nose. He's not someone I've ever met. I didn't decide any of that, I just thought 'person walks into room' and that's what I got.

yellowsmileyface · 24/10/2023 12:14

Yes, I have a very vivid memory and can see things in my head quite clearly. Same with sound, touch, taste, and smell. It's a blessing and a curse really!

On a similar note, I find it fascinating that not everyone has an internal dialogue. I quite clearly hear myself think in actual words (this can get quite exhausting as I have multiple trains of thought... yay adhd!) and I was flabbergasted when I found out not everyone experiences this.

I wonder if there are parallels between people who hear themselves think and people who can clearly visualise things in their head?

lilyblue5 · 24/10/2023 12:14

I can’t see faces - most of everything else I can

pontipinemum · 24/10/2023 12:13

@NortieTortie yes I can make Morgan Freeman talk in my head. I have full blown conversations in my head with myself, DH, the dog!

OP posts:
HappilyContentTheseDays · 24/10/2023 12:13

I see images in my head, they aren't literally in front of my eyes but inside my head. But they're there, in full colour and lots of detail. I can make up an image or I can recall things I've seen. If I've seen something I can go 'back' to the picture in my head and examine it in detail....eg. a car I saw earlier, I can check what state the tyres were in or what colour the seat covers were. Obviously only details I actually saw at the time!

I'm also good at interior design, I can change things in my head. Eg. I 'image' my bedroom, then, in my head, move the furniture, paint the walls a different colour, change the curtains and I can "see" whether it looks OK or not.

I used to think everyone could do this but after a while I found they couldn't, my sister can't. I have a very visual memory though, if someone just tells me something I have to visualise it to remember it.

Catza · 24/10/2023 12:03

BrioNotBiro · 24/10/2023 10:40

So people who aren't able to see things 'in their mind's eye'; how are you able to create say, a painting/needlework/pottery etc?

Do you do it on the fly, as you can't create in your mind before starting it physically?

Basically, yes. I respond to what is in front of me by making decisions as I work. I may have an idea (i.e. "flower in the style of") and a lot of reference images for the initial sketches, then I just adjust as I draw. Most artists will use reference of some kind and then use their knowledge of adjacent fields to complete the picture (e.g. understanding facial anatomy when drawing a portrait).

Newrumpus · 24/10/2023 12:03

Mmhmmn · 24/10/2023 09:56

Maybe you’re trying too hard and expecting to see a well-defined image right in front of your eyes? I see things in my minds eye but in an amorphous way. You can’t grab onto the image and inspect it as such, it’s just something that pops up if you think of things.
I bet you can see things in your minds eye really. Think of the fridge in your kitchen or the crisps and snacks aisle of your supermarket… or a person you know…
what happens?

Aphantasia is a proven condition. There is a spectrum but some people have no internal
imagery at all. Regardless of how much or how little they try.

Catza · 24/10/2023 11:59

I can't form mental images of any kind. It's more common than you think.

Notquitegrownup2 · 24/10/2023 11:59

The horse thing is helpful. I can just about visualize the blaze - ie number 3 - but not the whole horse.

The table, ball exercise is really interesting. I can see the table and the ball but not the person at all!! They are just a blur of movement which o have to work really hard at getting into the scene.

TheseLegsDefinitelyUsedToBeLonger · 24/10/2023 11:56

This is fascinating to read 🙂 I've always been really good at spelling. If my OH asks me to spell something, I always look up (like at the ceiling or a plain wall) and I can see the word there and then I spell it. Reading this makes me wonder whether it's more a case of having a visual memory (which I do) and remembering the words and seeing them before spelling them, rather than being inherently good at spelling. Great to read other people's experiences!

Notquitegrownup2 · 24/10/2023 11:45

I can't see pictures and have a rubbish visual memory. I have to repeat words and remember the sounds eg "Turn left at the pub. It's then the second on the right " Can't visualise it unless I've been there before . . .

I know that I'm in the minority but also know there are a few of us like this . . .

NortieTortie · 24/10/2023 11:42

I can make someone's voice in my head say things too, e.g. get Morgan Freeman to read these comments to me. Or play a full song I've memorised. Can people who can't visualise do that?

I don't visualise as I read a book. Sometimes there are flashes if I'm mulling over a scene. I don't see a movie in my head. I guess I could if I really concentrated, but it doesn't come naturally to me as it seems like it does to prev. posters.

With the horse pic, when it was fresh in my memory I could see it in my mind's eye exactly as it was on the screen. Now it's been a few mins, it's a lot more hazy.

Sticktoyourguns · 24/10/2023 11:41

It is strange, I can see things in my minds eye but my DS can’t. He is very good at art and did GCSE in it. I can’t understand how you can be good at art but unable to visualise but he is much better than me so it must work somehow. Although he does think that it’s a disadvantage in regards to his art. He also has a lot of autistic traits, never been referred, and a sibling with ASD.

gabsdot · 24/10/2023 11:35

I have a friend with this condition. She only recently realised it. If you tell her to think of a tree she doesn't see a picture of a tree. I don't know what she does see though. i must ask her.
I see things in my mind like a photograph

SirenSays · 24/10/2023 11:33

I can still see the horse after 10 minutes and imagine giving its head a little scratch. The only thing I struggle with is faces - people I love and know well, I can see their faces as still images and can't add movement. Every one else's face is just very blurry in my head.

Jacopo · 24/10/2023 11:19

Everything inside my head is visual, whether it's planning on doing a task as described by AlltheFs above, planning for a future event e.g. an interview, having an imaginary conversation with a celebrity, or thinking over recent or distant past events. They are all clear images and also the sound is there too, to the extent that I can remember the exact tone of voice someone used.
Not so pleasant when it's a memory of a sarcastic teacher or similar.

MrsSkylerWhite · 24/10/2023 11:19

Yes. Our eldest can’t.

NancyJoan · 24/10/2023 11:18

My visual recall is patchy, I can’t exactly remember what my children look like, for example.

I do, though, have really good aural recall. I can remember conversations, word for word, and it’s like I can hear them playing in my head, with tone/accent etc exactly. I also have to write speeches at work, and as I write them I can hear the person’s voice in my head, so I know if it sounds like something they would say.

OnlyFannys · 24/10/2023 11:18

Mauhea · 24/10/2023 09:56

It's absolutely wild to me that some people just can't do it. When I first heard about it I was told about an exercise of picturing a table in your head. Then adding a ball in the middle of the table, colouring the ball a specific colour then picture someone walking in to the room the table is in and picking the ball up. I can see all of that in my mind as if it's happening and it boggles me knowing that some can only go so far and others not at all. And then there's people who don't have a voice inside their head!

Edited

Now this is interesting because I can absolute visualise all of the objects but when you said about the person coming into the room and picking up the ball I struggled with that, my brain struggles to visualise actual movement. I had never notice that before but I can easily picture memories and objects as images but movement just doesn't come easily to me, my memories are like a series of photographs but not a film

Cumbrianlife · 24/10/2023 11:18

I didn't realise it was unusual until trying visualisation techniques in therapy. I can't 'see' my late parents, I envy those who can.

Swipe left for the next trending thread