Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you see actual images in your head?

142 replies

pontipinemum · 24/10/2023 09:44

Sorry not really an AIBU but I wanted the voting buttons.

I was watching a reel earlier and they were joking that their dad cannot see images in his head.

I can't see images in my head. When I close my eyes it's black (or red if it's bright!) DH said the same.

I know what things look like, and when I am asked to visualise a beautiful beach, I can remember places I have been but I don't 'see' them in my head. I can get a good 'sense' of what it is like in a book but I don't see the characters.

I'm not sure I am explaining this right at all.

YABU - I can actually see the things I am visualising in my head
YANBU - I see black

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bananazebra · 26/10/2023 14:19

Thank you to those who have tried to explain it! Sorry I don't know how to tag people. I think I'm developing an understanding now of what it's like. I just think it's so interesting how different people's minds work.
I can visualise things quite well but I'm not good at spelling or directions. It takes me a couple of seconds to think which is left or right. And if someone spells something out loud to me or gives me a phone number I really struggle to take that info in.

Newrumpus · 26/10/2023 14:11

GoodOldEmmaNess · 24/10/2023 14:28

YABU - I can actually see the things I am visualising in my head
YANBU - I see black

The poll options aren't mutually exclusive. Naturally I 'see black' in my head. The visualisations are only metaphorically 'in the head'. Visualisations aren't literally located, any more than (say) anger or love or memories are.
I wonder whether the sharp differences between people whenever this issue comes up are as much to do with different understandings of approximations such as 'in the head', 'mind's eye', etc as they are to do with fundamentally differing experiences.

There is evidence that our experiences are fundamentally different. For example, there are people who used to have internal imagery that have lost the capacity and vice versa. As these people are comparing their own previous and current experiences surely it suggest that there this phenomenon is real and not merely different descriptions of common experiences.

Newrumpus · 26/10/2023 14:07

Bananazebra · 25/10/2023 08:48

I just don't understand how someone can know what something looks like and describe it without seeing it on some level.

Edited

Imagine that you have saved a document
on your computer. Now imagine that the monitor can’t be switched on. You still
know that the document exists, you know what is contains and you could describe it. But you can’t see it.

That’s what non-visual memories are like. I know what an apple is, I could describe it to you but I can’t visually imagine it as the monitor that is my minds eye is switched off.

TheBirdintheCave · 25/10/2023 08:56

Bananazebra · 25/10/2023 08:48

I just don't understand how someone can know what something looks like and describe it without seeing it on some level.

Edited

It's hard to describe. I think the words 'red' and 'apple' for example instead of seeing a picture of one.

Bananazebra · 25/10/2023 08:48

I just don't understand how someone can know what something looks like and describe it without seeing it on some level.

ilovespinach · 24/10/2023 19:28

I see pictures of words/letters in my head if I'm talking of thinking something through...

longtompot · 24/10/2023 19:21

That's a great idea @Normalsizedsalad I have quite a few here which I haven't even started.
As well as my various crochet and knitting projects... Zero concentration as I say :( but colouring should be an easier thing to pick up and put down as not remembering what stitch or hook/needle size

TheHawkisHowling · 24/10/2023 19:19

junebirthdaygirl · 24/10/2023 17:17

This is common in people who have dyslexia and really hinders them in school with comprehension work. Sometimes they can read well but have actually no idea what they are reading about so find it difficult to then answer questions. They can slip through the net as their reading gives a false impression. I work with these children and teach them to make movies in their head.

I can imagine that. I can literally see the spelling of a word in my head, which is very handy.

I can also memorise all the answers to multiple choice questions by just remembering what they look like. It doesn't mean I actually know the answer though!

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 24/10/2023 18:32

junebirthdaygirl · 24/10/2023 17:17

This is common in people who have dyslexia and really hinders them in school with comprehension work. Sometimes they can read well but have actually no idea what they are reading about so find it difficult to then answer questions. They can slip through the net as their reading gives a false impression. I work with these children and teach them to make movies in their head.

How can you teach people to make movies in their heads if they have no images? Honestly, I would just nod along if you suggested a movie, but I can’t make any images and certainly not merging them together to make a movie.

junebirthdaygirl · 24/10/2023 17:17

This is common in people who have dyslexia and really hinders them in school with comprehension work. Sometimes they can read well but have actually no idea what they are reading about so find it difficult to then answer questions. They can slip through the net as their reading gives a false impression. I work with these children and teach them to make movies in their head.

SkySecret · 24/10/2023 17:04

@Chelsea26 wow, the brain is so baffling! So is it just like an innate knowledge? You can’t see it, you just know what it was like? I can’t comprehend it

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 24/10/2023 16:54

It's not like behind your eyes.
But if you think of an apple, can you compound and image of what an apple is?

Normalsizedsalad · 24/10/2023 16:53

longtompot · 24/10/2023 16:51

I used to be able to visualise things in my 'minds eye' but can't seem to anymore. I think it's because I can't focus on things as well. I'm trying to get back into reading so this might help me.

More complex adult colouring books helped me massively with concentration. 10-15min a day. It's also relaxing because you have to think about not going over the lines so your brain can't run away to stressy things

longtompot · 24/10/2023 16:51

I used to be able to visualise things in my 'minds eye' but can't seem to anymore. I think it's because I can't focus on things as well. I'm trying to get back into reading so this might help me.

DrinkingMyWaterMindingMyBiz · 24/10/2023 16:51

I don’t feel like I can vote either. When I close my eyes it’s just black, and when I try to visualise something I can “see” it but not from my eyes - it’s like the vision is elsewhere in my brain. My eyes stay black.

Normalsizedsalad · 24/10/2023 16:51

Is this similar to how some people don't have "inside voice" ?

Normalsizedsalad · 24/10/2023 16:50

BridgetJonesDaiquiri · 24/10/2023 09:49

Yes I can see images in my head if I imagine them. It's not just memories. If you described to me a scene, I'd picture my interpretation of it. Everything I think of is visual - it's how my brain works.

Same. I only wish my hands were actually artistic to paint it😂
I hope to live long enough for mind printer.
Dh is opposite so he trusts me with thimgs like house decor etc because I just see how it would loom as I stand in an empty room

Chelsea26 · 24/10/2023 16:47

Yes so I don’t think you and I will ever understand how the other thinks/sees/remembers 😂

But there are people upthread who say they have to close their eyes and really try to remember so I wondered how they would do if they couldn’t.

EBearhug · 24/10/2023 16:44

Chelsea26 · 24/10/2023 16:37

I suppose the only thing that can come close to being similar is those of you that need to close your eyes to visualise things.

If you think of an old family photograph and then DON’T close your eyes to remember it, so you just have to describe it from the last time you saw it rather than conjure it up again - what does that feel like? Because I guess that’s what I have to do…

I don't have to close my eyes to do thst. I could describe it while still looking out of the train window. I don't have the same focus on the outside as if I were really looking at it, but I'm seeing the trees and fields we're passing as much as seeing the 1920s dress and hairstyle.

TheHawkisHowling · 24/10/2023 16:40

I've had this discussion recently with someone who can't see their memories or picture them at all.

They said something interesting which is that they could recall smells. I have absolutely no smell memory or imagination whatsoever.

Chelsea26 · 24/10/2023 16:37

I suppose the only thing that can come close to being similar is those of you that need to close your eyes to visualise things.

If you think of an old family photograph and then DON’T close your eyes to remember it, so you just have to describe it from the last time you saw it rather than conjure it up again - what does that feel like? Because I guess that’s what I have to do…

EBearhug · 24/10/2023 16:35

Seeing in your mind's eye is not the same as imagining.

It is for some of us. Just not all of us.

Chelsea26 · 24/10/2023 16:32

@SkySecret I’ve been trying to explain this to my boys recently - it’s really hard to explain but I’ll try with your sunset.

So I’ve seen the sunset with my actual eyes and created a memory of it in my brain but that memory isn’t an image so to describe it to you I would remember it and be able to describe it to you but I wouldn’t see it in my head. I wouldn’t see words either I just see nothing. But I would be able to say oh it was beautiful, orange melding into pink and down to blue or whatever because I have seen it. I just don’t see it again.

With the horse - I can’t see him at all but again I could describe him to you because I have seen him, I could also describe a generic horse to you because I’ve seen plenty but I don’t see them again.

Going back to your sunset I could also, if we’d both been to Lapland and you showed me a photograph of your sunset, tell you if and how it was different to my sunset but I still wouldn’t see it if I closed my eyes.

Interesting to hear a lot of people struggle with memories - I don’t at all, have really good memories of lots of things I’ve done and can describe them all well.

SkySecret · 24/10/2023 16:17

@pontipinemum see this is the part I need some help with ….. how do you know what it was like if you can’t recall it visually? Are there words in your head saying “the grass was green, the sky was blue, the building was orange “ etc? That baffles me totally.

I can describe a Lapland sunset pastel sky to you because I can conjure the image in my head from the memory. I’ve no idea how to do that without being able to see it….

Flissz · 24/10/2023 15:28

seeing in your mind's eye is not the same as imagining.

You can imagine without visualised images, but you can also imagine with them, I think? Is that what you mean? So, someone with aphantasia could imagine am animal with duck feet, the body of a tiger, the tail of a pig, head of a horse, and the wings of an eagle but it will be just words? Concepts? In their mind. Whereas someone without aphantasia will put that image together in their head as they imagine it, I suppose and visualise it., they will "see" that imagined animal.