Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What amount of money would you give to help another mother?

214 replies

ShrigleyInc · 23/10/2023 20:32

What amount of money would you give to a single mother / mother of one/two child(ten) who is actually facing huge destitution this month because pay has come in late, bills have risen, demands on finances (debt repayments and utility bills increasing)have risen (due to age of child and time of year) despite only able to live on basics for over two years?

The person is in your circle, maybe close, maybe distant. You may or may not like them. Your children may or may not like their child/ren.

Yet, on the principle of helping, where you can, you would, if asked (not that this is likely as the person in poverty has extreme shame in being in this situation, but is somehow connected to you) - would you do the following, if at asked?

Help by giving:
£100...because you can with no knock on effect to your life
£300...because you can with no knock on effect to your life
£500...because you can with no knock on effect to your life
£Even more because you can....

I ask this for the following reasons: does the help have to be close to home / not too close - ie you need distance if you were asked.

or, does help just have to be needed in the outside world?

What are your actual principles on giving financial help?

I pay a monthly fee to UNICEF, because I believe it is good to do. But I got to thinking, there are many closer to us who need it, so what would you do?

Really interested.

OP posts:
therealcookiemonster · 23/10/2023 21:44

@ShrigleyInc having been involved for many years in the international development world (from both the UK and developing country side), I am sad to tell you most large international charities are not efficacious or productive ways to help those in need (unicef falls into this category). most of the money given is passed up the wall - often funding expensive accommodation and fancy cars for their very well paid staff (almost all ex pats so...). help people closer to home or donate to community led projects in the developing world. for example donations to food banks, or helping those you know personally.

RudsyFarmer · 23/10/2023 21:39

I honestly don’t know the answer as giving money is known to destroy friendships.

Gwendimarco · 23/10/2023 21:39

I wouldn’t give anything. I could afford to give about £30, but I wouldn’t because that £30 will only last her a day and she’ll be back in the same situation. Better that she access sustainable support without delay.

PupInAPram · 23/10/2023 21:35

soxthecat22 · 23/10/2023 20:44

Eh?

It seems to be a scam thread.

Maddy70 · 23/10/2023 21:35

I wouldn't give money. I would invite them for dinner or similar

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 23/10/2023 21:35

I wouldn’t give- truthfully I wouldn’t give away from my child to someone else’s in 2023 Britain.

Theokaycokey · 23/10/2023 21:28

Is the question sort of, if you are happy to donate to a charity abroad, would you also be happy to provide charity closer to home for someone you knew? If so, my response would be rarely the latter. I feel as though people pay taxes in this country and donate to food banks to help those who need it already. So unless it was someone close who had suffered financial difficulties due to a one off incident (ill health, job loss etc) I probably wouldn't help an individual. Many people in third world countries however face such difficulties that I feel that generally they are on greater need of help.

Riv · 23/10/2023 21:24

When my family are doing OK I have left anonymous bags of shopping on the doorstep of families I know are struggling and popped untraceable envelopes of cash through letterboxes or on desks before today. I have had the same done for me when I've been strapped too. No idea who my supporter(s) are/were and I hope no one suspects me either! It's just what happens in a caring community. You have surplus and they don't so you share.

Merseymum992 · 23/10/2023 21:15

No idea what your post may (or may not 🙃) be all about.
Just tell us what you actually want to ask instead of writing in riddles

Sconehenge · 23/10/2023 21:13

I found it! Called Acts 435 - there are currently 220 needs active that you can support, can help set up a mother fleeing from DV, buy a family a fridge etc - https://www.acts435.org.uk/ no gift too big or too small.

Home - Acts 435

Acts 435 - giving to anyone who has need

https://www.acts435.org.uk/

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 23/10/2023 21:11

ShrigleyInc · 23/10/2023 20:49

But would you want to know the person before you gave, or would that be uncomfortable? Or would you give annymously via a charity, yet the person in your community doesn't qualify for the charity?

So by “community” you mean “website”. So not someone I know or am connected to as your first post asks…

That’s two very different questions, and asked in quite a disingenuous way

Squirrelblanket · 23/10/2023 21:10

I wouldn't give anything, especially to someone (from your example) who I barely know and/or don't like. What a weird question.

Sconehenge · 23/10/2023 21:09

If my friend was in that state of need then I would give them thousands, or get them to move in with me for a year, or do something else to drastically get them back on track. There would be no point giving £500 and them being back in the same position the next month.

In terms of a cash gift to a struggling parent, I would rather they didn’t know who I was so I could do it once and not have to factor in affordability or future requests or guilt if I couldn’t keep it up. There is actually an amazing charity in the UK where you can scroll the (vetted) needs and buy people things like a washing machine (or contribute £20 towards) or groceries.

MrsAllsorts · 23/10/2023 21:09

Not sure I understand your post, but why can’t you pop some money in an envelope and anonymously put it through the letter box?
Or is it because you want it back (I.e. to loan the money)?

As for the amount, only you can decide that.

As an aside, there are few charities I actually trust these days, especially the larger ones. So I do have a lot of sympathy with your idea of trying to help directly. I do feel that lots of people slip through the net, and I have often felt that I wish I was wealthy enough to be an undercover Santa, delivering gift tokens and envelopes of money 😆 wearing a big beard, Santa outfit, nipping around some of the houses where I live in the early hours of the morning 🤣🤣🤣. A lot of families where I live are struggling but they are working all hours. Some people just get by and get little or no help.

Astonymission · 23/10/2023 21:09

Pipistrellus · 23/10/2023 21:07

I'd give, and have given, to https://www.acts435.org.uk/.

Otherwise, I'd have to know the person very well, that it was long term poverty or bad luck or escaping dv or similar that put them in this situation. I would seek to help by paying for specific things.

Brilliant idea. Thanks for this link.

Pipistrellus · 23/10/2023 21:07

ShrigleyInc · 23/10/2023 20:49

But would you want to know the person before you gave, or would that be uncomfortable? Or would you give annymously via a charity, yet the person in your community doesn't qualify for the charity?

I'd give, and have given, to https://www.acts435.org.uk/.

Otherwise, I'd have to know the person very well, that it was long term poverty or bad luck or escaping dv or similar that put them in this situation. I would seek to help by paying for specific things.

Home - Acts 435

Acts 435 - giving to anyone who has need

https://www.acts435.org.uk

sweetpeaorchestra · 23/10/2023 21:04

IF I could afford it, I would be inclined to maybe pay a one-off item (one month’s utility bill/school uniform) and support with getting help from UC or food banks or job applications.
Nothing else is sustainable or appropriate really. But if it’s neither a friend nor someone actually asking, why and how would you?
There are good local charities that you can donate to.

Bex5490 · 23/10/2023 21:03

Where is this question coming from? I think it needs context. How can you make a decision based on you might like them or might not. Might know them might not…

Who is this random single parent to me? If I don’t know them then why would I choose this particular struggling person to give my money to over all the others?

So confused…

Astonymission · 23/10/2023 21:02

I have given money ranging from £20 to £250 to friends with kids. I say given because I don’t ask for it back ever. I tell them if they can afford to pay me back they are welcome to but they don’t have to.

It has mainly been to one specific person who is a childhood friend. I’m not averse to the idea of giving money to someone I don’t know well but I’m a bit more cynical the older I’ve gotten.

The friend I used to give money to wasn’t a single parent. She had a partner who smokes a lot of weed and doesn’t contribute much to the house. I realised I was effectively paying for him, so I don’t give her money anymore.

Also if I need the money back I don’t loan it, I just wouldn’t give it out at all. I only give what I can afford not to be paid back to me. So I probably wouldn’t give out any more than £500. If people pay me back it’s a bonus but FWIW no one ever has 😂

JustAnotherCheeseburger · 23/10/2023 21:01

I probably wouldn't give cash but I would absolutely help on a practical level. If the situation was reversed, I wouldn't feel comfortable receiving cash but receiving some shopping/uniform/school trip paid for etc would be gratefully received.

User767463 · 23/10/2023 21:00

ShrigleyInc · 23/10/2023 20:51

Ok. So, you would do it with 'strings'/'control' over the matter? Again, no issue, just interested.

I do not believe you are "just interested". You have definitely had some sort of discussion or argument with someone regarding this topic and are trying to find backup opinions. Or it's a reverse or you are testing the waters for someone else. Either way, the weird wording gives it away as it's strangely evasive whilst trying to ask a very direct question.

People are giving cynical answers because somewhere in all this, there is clearly some sort of intention of begging strangers for money without offering anything in return. The usage of "another mother" is irksome because it's trying to tug at people's heartstrings in a way that's too obvious yet intangible. Virtually everyone here are mothers. Some are struggling financially themselves. You are trying to gauge people's morals or principles by asking them to hand over their own hard earned money to someone who most likely didn't directly ask for it nor will they attempt to repay that amount for the greater good (eg. donating £100 doesn't necessarily mean this person's children will have a better childhood or end up happier people. Relying on charity is one of the most dangerous ways to live).

OP are you neurodivergent?

ChristmasKraken · 23/10/2023 21:00

The thing is, giving money to a friend who needs money is different in my mind to giving money to a charity that will be used to benefit many people. Yes, my charitable donation could go to someone I know instead of to a charity, but ultimately I'm then only helping one person, and very likely only in the short term - because someone who is struggling for money isn't likely to have that solved by me giving them £100+. Whereas a charity is more likely to turn the donation into more longer term support for many people.

AffIt · 23/10/2023 20:59

Experience has taught me never to give cash to people, but I will give funds in deed, i.e., buy a food shop, top up electricity etc.

And yes, a gift is a gift: if I can afford it, I give it and don't expect it back.

Spirallingdownwards · 23/10/2023 20:58

ShrigleyInc · 23/10/2023 20:46

No. Just interested in the wider principle. Concerned about responses people give.

Why concerned?

You mean nosey. Which tabloid is this for?

Astonymission · 23/10/2023 20:57

secretsupport · 23/10/2023 20:56

Without them knowing, I pay £150 per month of a friend's rent, direct to their landlord (who I also know).

I will never tell my friend.

I can afford to do this.

It meant that her children could stay at their schools and not have to leave all their friends, when she needed to move house.

That’s very kind!

Swipe left for the next trending thread