Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What amount of money would you give to help another mother?

214 replies

ShrigleyInc · 23/10/2023 20:32

What amount of money would you give to a single mother / mother of one/two child(ten) who is actually facing huge destitution this month because pay has come in late, bills have risen, demands on finances (debt repayments and utility bills increasing)have risen (due to age of child and time of year) despite only able to live on basics for over two years?

The person is in your circle, maybe close, maybe distant. You may or may not like them. Your children may or may not like their child/ren.

Yet, on the principle of helping, where you can, you would, if asked (not that this is likely as the person in poverty has extreme shame in being in this situation, but is somehow connected to you) - would you do the following, if at asked?

Help by giving:
£100...because you can with no knock on effect to your life
£300...because you can with no knock on effect to your life
£500...because you can with no knock on effect to your life
£Even more because you can....

I ask this for the following reasons: does the help have to be close to home / not too close - ie you need distance if you were asked.

or, does help just have to be needed in the outside world?

What are your actual principles on giving financial help?

I pay a monthly fee to UNICEF, because I believe it is good to do. But I got to thinking, there are many closer to us who need it, so what would you do?

Really interested.

OP posts:
FlamingBlue · 24/10/2023 10:39

No, I wouldn't give money to a random single mother and your bitchy replies won't help you get what you are trying to achieve.

Goneforaride · 24/10/2023 10:09

If this person was a family member (who I liked!), or a close friend, I would probably give them a small amount of cash (£100 - as this is the smallest on offer on your list) - and help in other practical ways, such as buying groceries or other essentials (clothing/shoes for child etc) as required.

We are not wealthy people, like many on here - pensioners living on modest pension income - but if I can help someone in need, then I will.

Riverlee · 24/10/2023 09:36

ShrigleyInc · 23/10/2023 22:01

And that's commendable. But it depends on variables of the woman's circumstance. What if she can feed her kids with lentils and rice (perfectly acceptable) but can't pay bills / debt / travel needs / new school shoes?

If I provide food, then that would free up money to pay some debts etc.if I knew the child needed school shoes, I may take her out shoe shopping or order some of the internet for her.

I haven’t got the funds to sort out major financial problems. If she can’t pay her debts, bills etc, then she needs to ring social services to get the necessary help, or woman’s refuge, or Shelter etc. She needs to contact the companies that she owes money to to explain the situation and get help. Most companies nowadays have funds, schemes etc for those in need. She may even have to declare herself bankrupt.

Ididntknowuntiliknew · 24/10/2023 09:10

I tied myself in knots to find a way to pass some 'no strings' money, to someone in a financially abusive relationship.
She had repeatedly let me know about her terrifying financial situation, without ever requesting so much as a loan.
She was defaulting on debts, couldn't afford transportation or food. Really sad.
I didn't want to embarrass her.

I eventually found a way to give her £50 in a way that didn't seem suspicious, or treating her as a charity case.
She immediately used it to buy something unnecessary for the abusive partner.

She still tells me regularly how scared she is, and how poor she is.
Unfortunately I could donate my entire salary, and I don't think it would ultimately help her.
It would just enable the situation to continue.

Giving money to someone who didn't qualify for food banks or benefits is often well meaning enabling.
Not always, but often.
There are lots of ways to improve your financial situation, if you value yourself enough to improve it. Personal responsibility is huge (I speak from experience).

IncompleteSenten · 24/10/2023 09:00

For someone who has asked people to be honest and who is just curious, and I think said something about not judging but I'd have to go back and double check - your replies are interesting. Insulting those who wouldn't just hand money over regardless the situation and suggesting we're awful people.

So there's only one right answer to your question then and it's chuck money at this hypothetical person?

IncompleteSenten · 24/10/2023 08:53

It really depends.

If I could afford it I would have to know the person well and like them before I would give them money. I would give as much as I could afford and would go without to help someone I love who was in dire straits.

I would not give to strangers who may well be con artists,

or give to manipulative guilt trippers,

or give to unpleasant or entitled people

or give to people I've given to before who've turned out to be piss takers who expect others to constantly bail them out,

or give to people who make selfish choices then expect others to bail them out because Think Of My Children (that I didn't think of when I was spending money selfishly and unwisely)

NalafromtheLionKing · 24/10/2023 08:04

CharlotteRumpling · 24/10/2023 06:34

Depends where you give it. Many grassroots charities doing amazing work. It's developing countries.

I am even less inclined to give to someone like the OP after all the haranguing about 'principles'.

Me too. It takes no emotional toll for many to ask for money, especially these days (there are lots of begging scams) and that energy would be better channelled into improving their own circumstances rather than leaching off others using guilt trips.

Someone following me round whining about principles and begging for my hard earned cash as if they are somehow entitled to it is in no way the same as my deciding to donate to charity of my own free will or campaigning for better public services.

user1473878824 · 24/10/2023 08:02

The only redeeming quality you seem to have based on this thread is giving to UNICEF. All very weird and snotty.

Jellycatspyjamas · 24/10/2023 07:00

So if you’re not prepared to hand over cash to someone in your circle in need you have no principles?

I don’t give people money, I don’t buy random people food or shopping, I’m happy to offer practical help, help them find more structured sources of help, look at local community resources but I don’t give money.

My principles and morals are absolutely fine, before you comment, I just don’t give people money.

aloris · 24/10/2023 06:46

I have given to people directly and in my experience doing so is a case of "no good deed goes unpunished." So now I only give through charities because it puts some distance between me and the person receiving money, which protects me from being harassed by the person wanting more money or any other uncomfortable situations.

AfterWeights · 24/10/2023 06:41

Depends where you give it. Many grassroots charities doing amazing work. It's developing countries.

Some - there are also loads that are a complete waste of time - often religious backed ones, teaching people low paid self employment skills like sewing and hairdressing that won't enable the economy they live in to grow and provide better quality employment to people, meanwhile there is often a shortage of highly skilled people in these countries and expats are brought in to fill posts.

CharlotteRumpling · 24/10/2023 06:34

AfterWeights · 24/10/2023 06:28

The macro version of this op is what tends to happen when money is given to third world countries. It doesn't get used to best effect, it often simply leaks into a continuous cycle of poor financial management.

Its better to build infrastructure (schools, roads, railways, mobile phone masts), provide vaccines, sanitation & water treatment, train engineers & doctors, take steps to help poor countries limit brain drain.

Depends where you give it. Many grassroots charities doing amazing work. It's developing countries.

I am even less inclined to give to someone like the OP after all the haranguing about 'principles'.

AfterWeights · 24/10/2023 06:28

The macro version of this op is what tends to happen when money is given to third world countries. It doesn't get used to best effect, it often simply leaks into a continuous cycle of poor financial management.

Its better to build infrastructure (schools, roads, railways, mobile phone masts), provide vaccines, sanitation & water treatment, train engineers & doctors, take steps to help poor countries limit brain drain.

AfterWeights · 24/10/2023 06:08

Honestly? Giving money doesn't help.

I'd be more likely to offer financial help to restructure debts, help them find training to improve work prospects etc, make sure they're getting all the right benefits etc - look for the cause of their financial insecurity and help to fix it.

Giving money just solves the short term issue but tends to leave people reliant on handouts to make ends meet rather than trying to fix the underlying.

I also believe it doesn't help when charity starts intervening where the state should be - loads of people subsiding their mates with cash hides a problem the local councils and governments need to see the impact of to fix.

SouthShore · 24/10/2023 06:00

ShrigleyInc · 23/10/2023 22:40

WTF!! haha!! Do you not understand living by principles / a moral code which extends from personal to community to society to international people? Do you have no principles of kindness and compassion? Do you have no principles of 'there but for the grace of god'? Do you not understand the cost of living crisis? Do you not understand humanity? Maybe too much to ask from this platform. Maybe you're more comfortable of not actually thinking and are more comfortable of passing judgement on brides/mother-in-laws/how other people bring up their children?

I think you think you’re thinking but you’re not very good at it. Your argument is incoherent and your responses are illogical and inconsistent.

user1492757084 · 24/10/2023 05:23

I would help a friend or relative as much as I could.
I would give the 100 to a charity or a few so that I still had the means to help those I care for.
For me, charity begins at home. I am not responsible for the political practises and poor leadership of many corrupt nations. I will give a little but I can never be sure that it fills the right need.

twostraws · 24/10/2023 01:40

I wouldn't give cash to a random person because it would be unlikely to help them in the long run unless I regularly gave them cash. And that wouldn't be solving their problems either - that would be giving them a crutch.

If they wanted, I'd be happy to sit down with them to help them do a budget, check they were getting the benefits they were entitled to, sign post them to relevant charities and even to help them with declaring bankruptcy if that was the best option.

kebunim · 24/10/2023 01:29

I wouldn't give any money. I've been a single mum on benefits and I know that there are enough statutory and charitable sources of support out there that could help because, because I have accessed them. So I'd expect them to do a bit of legwork and look into getting support for themselves, not expecting individuals to help them.

TheBlueandtheGrey · 24/10/2023 01:14

I would never give or lend money to anyone ever.

I have done my bit for community by volunteering a lot of time to more than one charity over 3 decades.

Forgottenmypasswordagain · 24/10/2023 00:21

I will not give money to any begging posts or go fund me. Ever.

BannedfromChristmas · 24/10/2023 00:19

Too many variables but id buy food and support with budgeting or access to services to help but I wouldn't be able to cope with someone potentially relying on me. It was close family it'd be different.

ShrigleyInc · 24/10/2023 00:04

Merseymum992 · 23/10/2023 21:15

No idea what your post may (or may not 🙃) be all about.
Just tell us what you actually want to ask instead of writing in riddles

Just what your principle/moral position is if someone asked you for money. Why would it be different if they asked you for food/bed/spare shoes for their kids/ etc? If you could afford cash, the why would you/would you not?

Would you want to control what you gave them, and if so why? Why would it not be unconditional? Would you need to like them to give, or could it be someone in your community you may not like but who has a need?

Principles dictate what one does on a personal, community and on a larger level. Surely you've heard of those people? Those who, on principle, fought for worker's rights, for rights for pensions, for education, for equal pay, for free access to a health service? Those people didn't question need, they acted on principle. My question is simply about principle.

And it seems that if actual money is involved, then most say 'no way'. When, in fact, in this cost of living crisis, that is what many people who need help need to tide them over until the next month.

This was a philosophical thread, but realised it is completely the wrong format for actual chat. Judgement and unpleasantness is what is needed for a punchy post here!

OP posts:
ShrigleyInc · 23/10/2023 23:47

HowToSaveAWife · 23/10/2023 23:38

It's interesting you weigh up someone's "principles" based on the financing they can offer.

Generosity in other areas is not a "principle" according to you. Hmmm.

Not true. Didn't say that. Based partly upon a story I heard on LBC James O'Brien when a person, who saw his child's friend's family needed a bed, donated the spare bed to the family. And then the person saw the bed for sale, and when he confronted the mother, she said 'thankyou', but whilst she needed the bed, she needed food and supplies for her children more.

So, kindness on any level is good. But sometimes, it is just hard cash that a family needs to pay hard bills/travel/items whilst they can 'get by' on beans/bread/lentils/rice.

And if in that circumstance, someone in your circle - close or distant - asked you for financial help, what would you do? It is a point of principle as far as I can see. If you could afford it - without any detriment to you - would you? Or would you not, even if you could afford it? Knowing that it has taken them a huge amount of emotional toil to ask? Would you want someone to beg? Is that why some people walk by The Big Issue people? Just interested in principles one lives by.

OP posts:
Mamai90 · 23/10/2023 23:46

I'd I had tbe financial resources to help a friend then I would. In fact I have in the past. I gave one friend £500 to help her with Xmas.

My parents always helped less fortunate friends or family and I'd do the same. At the moment I'm not in a position to do so though.

You can't take it with you.

Fionaville · 23/10/2023 23:44

No I wouldn't and couldnt afford to start. I give to the local children's hospice and a local club for disabled people. Because I know the people that run them and I know they go without themselves to give the best to their service users. We live in a smallish town and people often post on the local Facebook group asking for household items, clothes and toys for people who are struggling. If I have anything they need going spare, I will give it and there are lots of people who do the same. This is how you help your local community.

Swipe left for the next trending thread