Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like I should quit my job?

33 replies

NotTHATsmart · 23/10/2023 19:45

I was headhunted last April, by a small but very successful family business who are developing a new product that has been unbelievably successful. I absolutely love the team I am working with, I love the product and I really love the work but I am having real problems with one of the family members!

The CEO (let's call him Brian) is someone I knew professionally some years ago and he approached me personally and persuaded me to leave my existing job to come on board. I was quite unsure for a while as it meant giving up a fantastic job, but it was such an exciting project and they were so keen to have me, that I decided to go for it.

My direct line manager is Brian's brother (let's call him Seth).

So right from the get-go, Seth was very hostile and made it clear he was very unhappy with me being hired as he hadn't been consulted about it. I very nearly quit there and then because I had been led to believe they were really keen to have me and this was really shocking, but I was persuaded to stay by the rest of the team and Brian.

The rest of the team told me Seth has reduced several people to tears through bullying, and even other family members refuse to deal with him because he's verbally abusive, but it was regardless very unpleasant. After a couple of months though, he realised my work was very good and he stopped being hostile and started showering me with compliments.

We went on for several months without any incidents and Seth was polite, if abrupt and was very complimentary of my work. Brian told me I was the best person they'd ever had in the role and other people said the same, so I felt very happy and relieved.

Then Brian pulled me off the job I was doing for 4 weeks to help him with a special project. Which was rewarding and fun, but when I came back Seth had seemingly decided to be unpleasant again.

He started not providing me with the information needed to complete my projects. He didn't return my emails or calls. It was more or less him refusing to let me do my job. When I finally pushed him he replied with "we don't have any work for you".

I was completely horrified, I knew I had heaps of projects to complete so had no idea why I was being clocked, so I called Brian for a chat. He apologised profusely, and colleagues comforted me and told me it was just "Seth being Seth", but I was crying and very upset.

Anyway, Brian called Seth, and within two hours I am being sent work again - a mountain of work actually. But now, instead of complimenting me, he is ripping apart everything I do and giving me poor briefs and information making it hard to complete what I need to do.

At the weekend, he sent me a really rude email, ripping my work to shreds and I was quite upset and found myself crying again and just wondering what the heck to do. Then it turns out he has been BCCing Brian on these emails ripping my work to shreds and I had no idea.

This to me feels like it's very passive aggressive and bullying behavior? I spoke to Brian and he more or less said Seth is an unpleasant person and to just "go around him", but I feel like I segued from being headhunted and told I was brilliant a a key member of the team - to more or less being humiliated and criticised :(

I am not sure what to do. Leaving my job means I will definitely have work I like less and less future prospects (this is an amazing job, one in a million) or to put up with being abused.

AIBU for feeling like I want to quit? Is this cutting my nose off to spite my face? Do I need to put my big girl panties on? Or is this just a ridiculous way to expect me to work?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NotTHATsmart · 23/10/2023 22:42

Thanks so much all. Brian and everyone else is great, so I need to have a think on this!

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 23/10/2023 21:40

I'd get on to acas. You may have a case for constructive dismissal (and inwould be dropping this hint to Brian)

Soapyspuds · 23/10/2023 21:38

I agree you need a meeting with you Seth and Brian. It sounds you are really good at your job and they can all see that aside from Seth.

If you have enough savings put aside then tell them exactly how it is! absolutely no sugar coating.

Offcom · 23/10/2023 21:37

Please don’t quit before you’ve taken Seth to task in public … I bet he won’t be able to cope at all and will back down

UpaladderwatchingTV · 23/10/2023 21:36

I used to work for a man like this OP, he was an out and out bully, and made life miserable for everyone who worked for him. He'd given me a specific project, and asked me to bring him the figures by the end of the day, which I did. He looked at them, asked me some questions, and told me they were WRONG! I knew they weren't wrong, simply that people had been telling him for months, what he wanted to hear, rather than the truth. I told him that the figures were correct, and he then said, I want you to go back in there, do this whole thing again, and bring me back the correct figures. At this point I walked out of the room, went to my office, collected my bag and put my coat on. As I walked out, he was standing in his office doorway, and demanded to know where I was going, as he'd told me to re-do the figures. I looked him straight in the eye, told him the figures were correct, and if I felt so inclined I could stay there all night and they would still be the same, however I wasn't going to do that, as it would be a complete waste of my evening. I then bade him Goodnight! I walked away and down the stairs quivering and waiting for him to ball something after me, like 'get back here, you don't go until I say you can', or whatever, but he didn't say a word. Next morning I went back into the office as normal, and waited for him to appear, fully expecting the sack. Instead, he called me into his office, told me to sit down, and then said 'So tell me, why are you so sure these figures that you've given me are right, when they don't match up with anything else I've been given?' I told him the truth, that people were too scared to tell him something that they thought would make him cross, so they fudged the figures, but had now been found out. From that point on, we got on like a house on fire, as I was able to prove my work was correct, and I think he respected me for having the guts to tell him what other people wouldn't.

So, in your shoes OP, if you're prepared to quit the job, have it out with Seth. Walk into his office and ask him straight out, why he's suddenly started picking fault with everything you do, when before you went to do the special job with Brian, you were the best thing since sliced bread? Stand up for yourself! Be confident in your work! You know you were doing it right before you got called to do the other job, so unless you've suddenly changed your way of working, he's going to have to prove that you are not up to par. Then if he threatens to sack you, or does sack you, go straight to Brian, and tell him that you will be going, but you will also be taking a stand against the company for unfair dismissal and bullying!

Nicole1111 · 23/10/2023 21:19

Next time you’re in the office leave your laptop open on this page in sight of Seth and Brian and pop to the toilet

https://www.gov.uk/workplace-bullying-and-harassment

VickyBlair383 · 23/10/2023 21:16

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

1990thatsme · 23/10/2023 21:15

pandarific · 23/10/2023 21:04

Okay - you know they love you, but they’re scared of prick face. Brian is the CEO - book a meeting for 9am with just Brian, look him dead in the eyes and say you WILL leave unless Seth stops being your manager. Say you don’t really care how that happens - they can promote you, they can give you a new title, Brian can be your line manager. But Seth is no longer your manager, or you - regretfully - go.

They won’t be surprised - he’s got form. Make it their problem op.

This is what I would do.

Weedoormatnomore · 23/10/2023 21:15

You need to get out especially now that your questioning yourself. Trust me it will drive you mad.
I handed in my notice tried to leave early got told no. Had a lot of abuse in emails telling me I am the worst they ever had etc yet couple of months ago was the opposite very happy with me.
If they are so unhappy why can't they let me go they have my replacement but want me to stay till end of next month aaaah

Daffidale · 23/10/2023 21:14

In case it’s not clear to you: Seth is a bully and an all round nasty piece of work. Not even his own family will work with him.

Only the fact that you are brilliant won him round in the first place. I am guessing he was pissed Brian “stole” you for 4 weeks for the project and now he is punishing you for that with all the shitty feedback. The fact he is BCCing Brian on it all is nasty, but probably works in your favour because Brian can see Seth’s bullying right there in front of him.

I wouldn’t have a three-way with Seth. I would go back to Brian as others have suggested , state you can no longer work for/with Seth, and discuss how to “work around” him as he suggested. But that needs to mean Seth has no oversight of your work. If there is no way to achieve that then be clear that you will have to resign.

SeaPool · 23/10/2023 21:07

Some of the worst jobs I've ever had have been for family businesses. There's often so much infighting amongst the family and it's impossible not to get caught up in it or used as a pawn. Often in family businesses completely incompetent, bullying, arsehole employees get and keep jobs and promotions to power purely because they're family members. In a regular business they'd be sacked - but if they're your brother/son/mum you can't sack them and they go on making everyone's life a misery and possibly trashing the company in the process.

Get out and get a job away from this nightmare. Life's too short to put up with it.

pandarific · 23/10/2023 21:06

Jesus @Parpadew are you okay hun? Maybe lay off the vitriol, you’ll burn yourself.

pandarific · 23/10/2023 21:04

Okay - you know they love you, but they’re scared of prick face. Brian is the CEO - book a meeting for 9am with just Brian, look him dead in the eyes and say you WILL leave unless Seth stops being your manager. Say you don’t really care how that happens - they can promote you, they can give you a new title, Brian can be your line manager. But Seth is no longer your manager, or you - regretfully - go.

They won’t be surprised - he’s got form. Make it their problem op.

Namechange800 · 23/10/2023 21:01

You would probably be doing them a favour by highlighting Seth’s workplace bullying and poor management style. If you submit a formal grievance, they would have to investigate it, and if it is upheld, it might enable them to remove Seth.

Parpadew · 23/10/2023 20:58

Based on "put my big girl panties on" I am team Seth. Do you say this at work? I couldn't bear it.

Otherwise, stop expecting rosettes for doing your job. Just do it.

Sofaz34 · 23/10/2023 20:58

The only way you can stay there long term is either for him to go (not likely) or for you to have it out with him. Just say, I know there is something wrong , whY is this all about and ask if you cab keep it an open but professional forum where you can each tell your truth. I imagine he will be surprised about the bluntness and you have nothing to lose.

Abitofalark · 23/10/2023 20:55

You were sought after for this job and I guess highly thought of in your previous one. You left there in good standing, presumably. Have you thought of contacting your old boss to put out feelers about any possibility of a return, having discovered the reality of family dynamics in a small firm? If not, look elsewhere within the industry. You never know what else might be cooking.

Ladyj84 · 23/10/2023 20:51

They know what Seth is like and they've allowed it for years so do you really think apart from verbally saying they will be bothered if you leave, I don't think so it will just be another job for another victim sadly. You wouldn't get me staying I would rather have a pay cut than have that job in my life. Hope you get sorted good luck

Merryoldgoat · 23/10/2023 20:45

There is no way on earth I’d stay there.

They are unprofessional and facilitating Seth abusing you.

I don’t understand how you’re still there.

hettie · 23/10/2023 20:38

If at all possible you need to give Brian and others clear feedback as to how and why Seth will ultimately fuck up their business.... They'll lose this be staff suppliers and customers. If they can't address his behaviour- leave

NotTHATsmart · 23/10/2023 20:33

g0at · 23/10/2023 20:02

This might be a bit too much given his personality, but could you try sitting down with Seth (with Brian there if needed) to find out what exactly his problem is? Appreciate could make the situation worse for you too, but just an idea.
Just to add, I definitely don't think you're an issue given the feedback and would agree with pp is some sort of power play between the two of the

I suppose. I think he would just deny it.

I feel a weird sense of being gaslit because before I went on the secondment for Brian I was told I was the best ever / amazing.

Then during the four weeks I was away I suddenly became the worst / terrible.

I am trying very hard not to take it personally but am finding myself really second guessing my work!

OP posts:
Sconehenge · 23/10/2023 20:24

Why does this family business give a family member that has a history of MAKING PEOPLE CRY a management role?

Tell Brian, who headhunted you, in no uncertain terms, that you will be leaving the company unless you are moved out of Seth’s team and no longer have to report him.

It’s not you and the fact that you’re even questioning that it might be indicates that you’re already letting this horrible bully impact your self esteem and confidence, which will be much more damaging to your future prospects than walking away from the opportunities in this role.

Find your strength, know your worth and give your ultimatum. At the end of the day, you putting up with the bullying is also damaging the business as well, as just think of all the great projects that are going astray and the good people they are losing because of sadistic Seth? By making a stand now you’re helping yourself and you’re also helping the business.

Ghostwritersinc · 23/10/2023 20:17

I think you need to call a meeting between yourself, Seth, Brian and any other management/owners.
Say exactly what has happened - give them a change to explain/dispute themselves.
And then mention if things do not improve rapidly, not only will you be resigning but taking the issues to an employment tribunal.
Record the conversation as well.
best of luck.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 23/10/2023 20:02

"Brian, we need to have a serious conversation.

If you don't address the issues with Seth's treatment of staff, not only will you lose me, you will also several offer staff and are at risk of bullying and harassment claims. He is costing you staff and revenue.

Obviously, I would much prefer to stay on the role because if x ,y and z but if there is an immediate and significant improvement, I will have no choice but to tender my resignation due to persistent bullying"

Only if you are prepared to walk.

g0at · 23/10/2023 20:02

This might be a bit too much given his personality, but could you try sitting down with Seth (with Brian there if needed) to find out what exactly his problem is? Appreciate could make the situation worse for you too, but just an idea.
Just to add, I definitely don't think you're an issue given the feedback and would agree with pp is some sort of power play between the two of the

Swipe left for the next trending thread