Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wether you breastfeed or formula feed.

114 replies

Cowlover89 · 22/10/2023 19:42

I want no arguments. Just a nice debate. Let off some steam. Basically lighthearted.

Tell me things that annoy you. I'll go first. When you state in a post what you are going to do. And say what you're not going to do. You still get comments to just do it. I stated that I will not be adding formula this time. Will be pumping so dad can help but still feeding from the boob. But some posters still mention formula...

Also like to add I respect all mamas on what you do. You feed your babas how you want to, that you've all done an amazing job. And should be proud. And to never feel guilty. I'm really not an arsehole like some on here like to make me out to be. I'm just a mama doing her best. And very hormonal atm and in a lot of pain with my PGP.

Just had to get that out 😊

OP posts:
Ssme92 · 30/10/2023 10:51

@Cowlover89 I think what @sollenwir is saying is that there is a small chance you won't be able to breastfeed or pump and may need to formula feed as a result. Like I say a small chance but something to consider and come to terms with beforehand maybe? I find we can be very hard on ourselves if things don't go the way we had planned, especially with newborn hormones thrown into the mix! Best of Luck with everything!

Cowlover89 · 30/10/2023 10:47

Ssme92 · 23/10/2023 17:44

I found it difficult whilst pregnant that nobody was willing to give me info about FF. Any midwives dismissed me when I said I had done my research and wanted to FF... "well still do the classes and see how you feel then" etc etc. Eventually the oldest midwife I'd seen didn't judge me at all, removed the breastfeeding page from my file and gave me all the information I needed. So I suppose the most annoying / hardest thing for me was not being listened to / being judged by midwives whilst pregnant. Funnily, I had absolutely zero judgement from anyone medical or otherwise once I'd had the baby and was feeding her formula (outside of Mumsnet)!

Edited

I'm sorry you had a hard time. No need for judgement. I'm glad it worked out x

OP posts:
Cowlover89 · 30/10/2023 10:46

sollenwir · 23/10/2023 18:10

Regarding the BFing thing specifically - it's quite common not to want to use formula (so either BF exclusively/mainly but with expressed bottles every now and then/at a set time), but then the BFing doesn't go to plan (for whatever reason) and so folk end up combi-feeding/exclusively FF'ing. Wanting to BF doesn't mean you will end up BFing, even if you have before. FF'ing is perfectly ok, regardless if you had hoped to BF or if you were planning to FF all along, provided you use the correct type of formula/follow instructions etc.

Regarding other questions, sometimes people give reasons for not wanting to do a certain thing, but it turns out the reason is misinformed or naive in some way, and some folk provide more info of their experience if they feel it could help.

I already know if can't breastfeed this time I'll definitely be pumping and won't be adding formula. But know what you mean. It's always good to get others experience x

OP posts:
Cowlover89 · 30/10/2023 10:44

Somethingsnappy · 23/10/2023 15:00

You're getting a hard time here op for your interest/posts/threads on the subject, but I completely understand. When I was in the thick of it, with very young children and pregnant with the next, I was completely and utterly preoccupied with all things baby/feeding related too. I found it hard to think of much else! It's the hormones I expect. Four children later, including one toddler who is still bf, and I can safely say I am now able to think about plenty of other things!

And as you asked for things that annoy us.... Mine is just when people get so worked up, upset and defensive about it all.

Sorry for the late reply. Had a break from here. Yep I know. No need for it. I am able to think of other things thats the thing. I can still love my breastfeeding journey and be proud. Yeah that annoys me too! Not allowed to say anything. Otherwise someone has a problem x

OP posts:
sollenwir · 23/10/2023 18:10

Regarding the BFing thing specifically - it's quite common not to want to use formula (so either BF exclusively/mainly but with expressed bottles every now and then/at a set time), but then the BFing doesn't go to plan (for whatever reason) and so folk end up combi-feeding/exclusively FF'ing. Wanting to BF doesn't mean you will end up BFing, even if you have before. FF'ing is perfectly ok, regardless if you had hoped to BF or if you were planning to FF all along, provided you use the correct type of formula/follow instructions etc.

Regarding other questions, sometimes people give reasons for not wanting to do a certain thing, but it turns out the reason is misinformed or naive in some way, and some folk provide more info of their experience if they feel it could help.

Ssme92 · 23/10/2023 17:44

I found it difficult whilst pregnant that nobody was willing to give me info about FF. Any midwives dismissed me when I said I had done my research and wanted to FF... "well still do the classes and see how you feel then" etc etc. Eventually the oldest midwife I'd seen didn't judge me at all, removed the breastfeeding page from my file and gave me all the information I needed. So I suppose the most annoying / hardest thing for me was not being listened to / being judged by midwives whilst pregnant. Funnily, I had absolutely zero judgement from anyone medical or otherwise once I'd had the baby and was feeding her formula (outside of Mumsnet)!

Somethingsnappy · 23/10/2023 15:00

You're getting a hard time here op for your interest/posts/threads on the subject, but I completely understand. When I was in the thick of it, with very young children and pregnant with the next, I was completely and utterly preoccupied with all things baby/feeding related too. I found it hard to think of much else! It's the hormones I expect. Four children later, including one toddler who is still bf, and I can safely say I am now able to think about plenty of other things!

And as you asked for things that annoy us.... Mine is just when people get so worked up, upset and defensive about it all.

nearlywinteragain · 23/10/2023 12:56

This is the sort of thing that seems critical when your dc is small and becomes an utter irrelevance once they are older.
Along with types of nappies, types of weaning and when they started walking.

Pepsipasta · 23/10/2023 12:50

If you don't care how other peoples babies are fed, why ask?

Seriously baffled why people are even interested in this.

My eldest is 19. How I fed them is nobody's business but I'm telling you that I have no idea which of their friends was BF or FF. I don't know who was left to cry it out, who co-slept, who was worn as a baby in a sling, who watched too much tv, who potty trained the earliest, who walked the latest. No idea. And do you know what, nobody cares about that either.

Nobody cares about the things your baby does except you.

bulletproofteatowel · 23/10/2023 12:40

Seeing as you've posted on AIBU. I'm not, never have and never will be a 'mama'. It reminds me of those pull a string and talk kind of dolls. While we are on the topic, I wouldn't call either of my children 'baba' either.

Child 1. I couldn't breastfeed if I wanted to. Was on medication after birth that had 'don't take this and breastfeed' all over the box and everything. Yes, there really are meds like that. Formula all the way.

Child 2. Breastfed for the 1st year.

Can you guess which child is the high achieving, sporty, very bright child and which child is the one with an EHCP, special school, complex autistic needs, god knows how many allergies amd a complete failure to thrive in their 1st year child.

OP, stop stressing out. Just feed the flipping baby. Whichever way feels best for you.

Greygardenz · 23/10/2023 12:31

You're a very strange poster. Constantly name changing, starting multiple threads on the same subject and changing names mid thread.

Coffeerum · 23/10/2023 12:28

It's bizarre how many threads on the one topic a single poster needs to make.

Parenting goes significantly beyond how you feed your child in the first year or so.

Slipknot89 · 23/10/2023 12:23

bakewellbride · 22/10/2023 21:56

"Tell me things that annoy you."

Being referred to as mama / 'you mamas are doing great' or anything like that.

Fair enough. Some like it. Some don't

Slipknot89 · 23/10/2023 10:37

FrazzledHippy · 22/10/2023 22:06

Fed is best. End of discussion.

I also like to say informed is best too

Cowlover89 · 23/10/2023 10:36

Mummyboy1 · 22/10/2023 22:02

Does it really matter how they're fed?
I wanted to breastfeed but I couldn't. He's in nursery now and there's no difference between him and a breastfed baby/ toddler .

Nope it doesn't matter at all.

OP posts:
Cowlover89 · 23/10/2023 10:21

Nellz · 22/10/2023 20:33

I breast feed (feeding my 6 month old right now!) and it works for us.

My bugbear is that the NHS / NCT / etc information around breast v formula verges on propaganda.

Breastfeeding is often painful and utterly relentless in the early days, with no clear way to know your baby is getting enough until they are weighed. Formula fed babies, on average, seem to sleep better. Their mums get to have their hair cut without worrying about whether they can get enough pumped so that someone else can take care of them for a couple of hours (and not everyone can pump a decent amount anyway).

Tell us that breastfeeding has drawbacks, so it's not a surprise!

I would still have chosen to breastfeed knowing what I do now, but wish I'd had all of the information in any case.

I'm glad 😊 it does. It was very painful for me as my son had tongue tie. Not always true. Its not how they feed how well they sleep. Its down to the baby. My son slept through at 11 weeks and still does. I think partly genetic imo. I'll be pumping when my daughter is here. Dad wants to do nights. Thank you for you comment x

OP posts:
Cowlover89 · 23/10/2023 10:18

Pumpkingnome · 22/10/2023 22:15

People will judge you for every single parenting decision you make from the moment they find out you're pregnant

You're better off ignoring all of it from the beginning and doing whatever you feel is best for you and your baby

Oh yeah definitely. I get judged plenty for co sleeping and putting my son in his own room before 6 months.

OP posts:
Cowlover89 · 23/10/2023 10:17

Ketzele · 22/10/2023 20:17

And yes, I did breastfeed for a long time. And have a long professional involvement. So I'm not defensive or ignorant, just keenly aware that the undoubted benefits of breastmilk can be and often are outweighed by other considerations. Which is more than OK.

On the other hand, there are problems associated with formula feeding - eg overfeeding, weaning practices - that we make worse if women feel judged or guilty or excluded from professional advice.

Yes it is. And no one should ever be made to feel guilty

OP posts:
Cowlover89 · 23/10/2023 10:01

nutbrownhare15 · 23/10/2023 09:59

No, this isn't exercises it's manual therapy. Most NhS services won't do it so you would need to go private. Mine did go away at 34 weeks pregnant because the manual therapy gets the joints moving (my left hip was stuck causing pain in my right hip which the physio unstuck) but I did need a top up appt as it came back after a few weeks. Do go if you can it was life changing for me. Have a read on the website which explains the treatment you need.

Thank you. Will definitely look in to. Id rather not be in this pain when I go in to labour. X

OP posts:
nutbrownhare15 · 23/10/2023 09:59

No, this isn't exercises it's manual therapy. Most NhS services won't do it so you would need to go private. Mine did go away at 34 weeks pregnant because the manual therapy gets the joints moving (my left hip was stuck causing pain in my right hip which the physio unstuck) but I did need a top up appt as it came back after a few weeks. Do go if you can it was life changing for me. Have a read on the website which explains the treatment you need.

Cowlover89 · 23/10/2023 09:55

Openocean · 23/10/2023 09:42

Did both, all good, I do think the level of propaganda around breastfeeding is over the top. It does have some benefits over ff, but ff has the benefit of being plentiful and the pathway to good supply is different for everybody. The risk of dehydration is underplayed IMHO.
Also I think there are things which are more beneficial to promote, such as vaccination, if they diverted more money into this I think it would be money better spent. Though thankfully because routine vaccination uptake are still pretty high the risk is relatively low at the moment for these diseases- but if you did contract them as a child the consequences can be life changing, or life ending. Vaccines are some of the best health interventions ever created with comparatively lower cost and disruption, the benefits can be quantified in lives saved, so why are they so softly softly with it?
That said I do think it’s really important to protect a woman’s right to breastfeed, and for it not to be seen as some luxurious optional extra.

Thank you for this. This is what I asked for. I agree with vaccines. I would never not vaccinate my children. They are so important. I'm interested in the chicken pox one. I had it 3 times as a child.

OP posts:
Openocean · 23/10/2023 09:42

Did both, all good, I do think the level of propaganda around breastfeeding is over the top. It does have some benefits over ff, but ff has the benefit of being plentiful and the pathway to good supply is different for everybody. The risk of dehydration is underplayed IMHO.
Also I think there are things which are more beneficial to promote, such as vaccination, if they diverted more money into this I think it would be money better spent. Though thankfully because routine vaccination uptake are still pretty high the risk is relatively low at the moment for these diseases- but if you did contract them as a child the consequences can be life changing, or life ending. Vaccines are some of the best health interventions ever created with comparatively lower cost and disruption, the benefits can be quantified in lives saved, so why are they so softly softly with it?
That said I do think it’s really important to protect a woman’s right to breastfeed, and for it not to be seen as some luxurious optional extra.

Ragwort · 23/10/2023 09:38

x2boys ... you are so right, all these issues are so irrelevant as your DC gets older .. I joined Mumsnet over 20 years ago when my DS was born and cringe at some of the things I posted ... feeding, weaning, sleeping, playschools, friendships, getting into the 'right' school etc etc etc - the vast majority of DC will end up fine.
I'm still in touch with many of the friends I met when DS was young ... you can't tell which DC was breast fed, sleep trained, weaned on organic food, did mandarin classes at 3 or whatever. Just lovely young people making their own way in the world.

Cowlover89 · 23/10/2023 09:35

Ragwort · 23/10/2023 09:33

Is there any long term research on the benefits of breast feeding? I can understand people saying it is good for small children but do the benefits last? I am 65 and was breast fed - does that mean I am healthier than my non breast fed friends? Confused
My DH was also breast fed .. his mother drank Guinness all through pregnancy and breast feeding as was the advice at the time Grin.

Its only on Mumsnet that you seem to find this militant attitude to breast feeding ... when my DS was tiny (combi fed if anyone cares) no one commented or was interested.

I only ever see it on mumsnet not IRL

OP posts:
Cowlover89 · 23/10/2023 09:33

x2boys · 23/10/2023 09:28

I think you are a little obsessed with breast feeding at the moments as you have a new baby Op hence all threads
In 16 years time ,s you won't care and might cringe a little at your superior attitude towards breast versus formula.

Edited

Hardly obsessed. I was asking for advice and experiences which I got. I haven't had my daughter yet. You can think that but I won't.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread