Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this was wildly irresponsible?

111 replies

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 18:37

I have a friend, "Ann". We used to be close but lost touch.

She and her partner have a 5 year old and she's just had a new baby.

She had put her 'birth journey' on Facebook. (Text, not video/pictures)

She and her partner have a third person in the relationship, "Carol", a woman who is her partner Bob's girlfriend. It was the three of them in the bedroom. (The 7 y/o was with a nanny in another part of the house).

She wanted a birth with no medical professionals, just the universe, incense etc.

Bob delivered the baby with Carol helping.

They wanted a lotus birth (where you don't cut the umbilical cord). But the placenta was not detaching, so after a few hours after the baby was born, they went to hospital (baby outside the body, placenta inside, umbilical cord still attached.)

None of the three are medical professionals. She's an artist, he's a musician and I don't know what the Carol does but Ann said she'd not a nurse/doctor/midwife when I asked.

There's nothing wrong with having a baby at home. Nothing wrong with the 7 year old being there.

But to have no medical person present is disgusting. She could have died, the baby could have died.

I said congratulations, but I feel disgusted by her selfishness. They could have left the 5 yo motherless.

FFS.

AIBU to be appalled? On mobile so I can't enable voting.

OP posts:
Neodymium · 22/10/2023 21:00

’women have given birth for millennia’ 🙄

you realise 1 in 10 births the mother died? Not 1 in 10 women. 1 in 10 births. In a time with no birth control. Go back through your family tree and see how many in your family died.

I just love how people paint this rosy picture of yesteryear like humans did so much better and modern times have messed everything up. Couldn’t be further from the truth . At the height of smallpox in some countries children weren’t even counted as members of the family until they had smallpox and survived because so many died.

Dramatic · 22/10/2023 20:59

Dramatic · 22/10/2023 20:55

Have you ever been on AIBU? She's come on to see if she's being unreasonable about her opinion on this situation and to see if others think the same way.

Replied to the wrong person 🤦

Dramatic · 22/10/2023 20:57

caban · 22/10/2023 20:51

Most births, especially second + births, don't require medical assistance and aren't going to become emergencies though.
If she was low risk and had a normal first birth it's not a huge gamble.

Anecdotally I know someone who's second baby was born at home with very little medical assistance and her baby was born not breathing. He is now very severely disabled. It probably could have been prevented had she been in hospital. It's not ever worth the risk.

Dramatic · 22/10/2023 20:55

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 19:14

Yes, I'm on AIBU.

You came onto AIBU to cast judgement on a situation.

Have you ever been on AIBU? She's come on to see if she's being unreasonable about her opinion on this situation and to see if others think the same way.

caban · 22/10/2023 20:51

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 20:48

Yes, they are lucky it worked out.

It just seems like a massive gamble.

I could shoot a gun at myself and be lucky it wasn't loaded. Is it worth the risk if I'm not actually actively hoping to die.

Most births, especially second + births, don't require medical assistance and aren't going to become emergencies though.
If she was low risk and had a normal first birth it's not a huge gamble.

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 20:48

Yes, they are lucky it worked out.

It just seems like a massive gamble.

I could shoot a gun at myself and be lucky it wasn't loaded. Is it worth the risk if I'm not actually actively hoping to die.

OP posts:
caban · 22/10/2023 20:45

There's certainly risks with going into hospitals at the moment to give birth.

There are risks to giving birth at home without medical assistance.

Personally I don't have enough medical knowledge and statistics to judge exactly how much the risk increased for Ann.

But as someone else has said, they sought medical assistance when needed and everything seems to have worked out.

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 20:40

Goldbar · 22/10/2023 20:11

Intuitively I agree with you...

But within the last week we've been told that 2/3 of maternity units in this country provide dangerously substandard care to women and babies. We talk about "birth choices" but the reality is that women are frequently disenfranchised and mistreated during childbirth. It's not really surprising that some women are so mistrustful that they attempt to take back control by giving birth outside "the system".

I suppose that for me a shitty hospital trumps 'Bob and Carol'. Unpleasant/traumatic experience Vs staying alive. The hospital deaths would likely have unfortunately happened to someone staying at home with no medical care.

OP posts:
nancypowers1983 · 22/10/2023 20:18

@LylaLee you aren't being unreasonable, it sounds like the adults involved were irresponsible. As someone else said it's parents making a choice that suits them rather than their baby, and that isn't a great start for any child. They are only very lucky their baby is ok. And I'm not sure why some folk are jumping on you for daring to anonymously ask something on AIBU when it's exactly what everyone does on AIBU threads the world over.

Goldbar · 22/10/2023 20:11

Intuitively I agree with you...

But within the last week we've been told that 2/3 of maternity units in this country provide dangerously substandard care to women and babies. We talk about "birth choices" but the reality is that women are frequently disenfranchised and mistreated during childbirth. It's not really surprising that some women are so mistrustful that they attempt to take back control by giving birth outside "the system".

CherryMyBrandy · 22/10/2023 19:26

Completely irresponsible. The whole "it's natural, my body will know what to do" crowd seem to forget that childbirth was the biggest killer of women before modern medicine. I am all for birth choices (home birth, midwife led, Caesarian, hospital etc etc) but free birthing is ridiculously dangerous.

And as an aside, i know it was a typo but I love the reference to Carol as "the Carol". Lol.

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 19:14

WhateverMate · 22/10/2023 19:08

You're not just 'talking' about it you're inviting a judgemental bitch fest.

That's something quite different.

Yes, I'm on AIBU.

You came onto AIBU to cast judgement on a situation.

OP posts:
LylaLee · 22/10/2023 19:13

WhateverMate · 22/10/2023 19:07

You've told us that both she and the baby could've died and you're asking if we think that's no big deal??

Well there are people on this thread saying it is no big deal.

OP posts:
LylaLee · 22/10/2023 19:12

MariaLuna · 22/10/2023 19:05

Women have been giving birth for millenia. In nature.

I am glad I can access hospital treatment when needed (as I did), but not sure why this has to be put on a mumsnet forum.

It's more about your judge-ey pants being hauled up and being superior.
Thank fuck you're not my neighbour.....

>women have been giving birth for millennia

Yes, and it's been the leading cause of death in women for millennia. Now we survive childbirth and die of cancer, stroke or heart disease instead.

OP posts:
FindingMeno · 22/10/2023 19:11

When they needed medical help, they went and got it.
I can't see the issue.

Comedycook · 22/10/2023 19:10

Women have been giving birth for millenia. In nature

And dying

WhateverMate · 22/10/2023 19:08

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 19:07

Because there would be no point saying it to them. We are not close. They had already done it.

There are thousands of threads here every day with people talking about things. That's literally what AIBU is.

You're not just 'talking' about it you're inviting a judgemental bitch fest.

That's something quite different.

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 19:07

WhateverMate · 22/10/2023 19:04

So why are you saying it to Mumsnet?

It's like you've munched popcorn all through the Facebook updates, but couldn't bring yourself to say what you really think.

That would be fine if you kept it to yourself, but here you are on an open internet forum slagging them off.

Why?

Because there would be no point saying it to them. We are not close. They had already done it.

There are thousands of threads here every day with people talking about things. That's literally what AIBU is.

OP posts:
WhateverMate · 22/10/2023 19:07

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 18:56

That's why I didn't say anything to them. That's why I'm on AIBU to find out if everyone else thinks this is bonkers or everyone else is like, "no big deal".

You've told us that both she and the baby could've died and you're asking if we think that's no big deal??

MariaLuna · 22/10/2023 19:05

Women have been giving birth for millenia. In nature.

I am glad I can access hospital treatment when needed (as I did), but not sure why this has to be put on a mumsnet forum.

It's more about your judge-ey pants being hauled up and being superior.
Thank fuck you're not my neighbour.....

ACGTHelix · 22/10/2023 19:04

from a medical point that's very high risk.

WhateverMate · 22/10/2023 19:04

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 18:52

I just said congratulations. I didn't say the wtf part.

So why are you saying it to Mumsnet?

It's like you've munched popcorn all through the Facebook updates, but couldn't bring yourself to say what you really think.

That would be fine if you kept it to yourself, but here you are on an open internet forum slagging them off.

Why?

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 19:04

KnowledgeableMomma · 22/10/2023 18:57

If everything they did was legal, then your opinions are just that.....your opinions. Especially as this isn't someone who is a close friend any longer. I'd shrug it off and let it go.

Yes, that's what AIBU is. Opinions.

OP posts:
NuffSaidSam · 22/10/2023 19:02

They've actively chosen something that isn't in the best interests of their baby. When your approach, right from birth, is to do what is best for you, disregarding the safety of your child, you're often not a very good parent.

SwingTheMonkey · 22/10/2023 18:58

Of course it’s irresponsible and selfish, I don’t see how anyone can deny that.