Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this was wildly irresponsible?

111 replies

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 18:37

I have a friend, "Ann". We used to be close but lost touch.

She and her partner have a 5 year old and she's just had a new baby.

She had put her 'birth journey' on Facebook. (Text, not video/pictures)

She and her partner have a third person in the relationship, "Carol", a woman who is her partner Bob's girlfriend. It was the three of them in the bedroom. (The 7 y/o was with a nanny in another part of the house).

She wanted a birth with no medical professionals, just the universe, incense etc.

Bob delivered the baby with Carol helping.

They wanted a lotus birth (where you don't cut the umbilical cord). But the placenta was not detaching, so after a few hours after the baby was born, they went to hospital (baby outside the body, placenta inside, umbilical cord still attached.)

None of the three are medical professionals. She's an artist, he's a musician and I don't know what the Carol does but Ann said she'd not a nurse/doctor/midwife when I asked.

There's nothing wrong with having a baby at home. Nothing wrong with the 7 year old being there.

But to have no medical person present is disgusting. She could have died, the baby could have died.

I said congratulations, but I feel disgusted by her selfishness. They could have left the 5 yo motherless.

FFS.

AIBU to be appalled? On mobile so I can't enable voting.

OP posts:
Pumpkingnome · 22/10/2023 22:27

caban · 22/10/2023 20:51

Most births, especially second + births, don't require medical assistance and aren't going to become emergencies though.
If she was low risk and had a normal first birth it's not a huge gamble.

That's not true at all

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 22:24

Why am I so exercised?

It's just the cavalier attitude to life/death.

I know someone who recently died of cancer. They would have done anything for more time.

I know someone who has lost a baby, and seen the devastation it caused in that family. And to risk that for no reason?

I know someone who lost their mother at a young age. If the 5yo was left without a mother, the whole trajectory of their life would change.

I know the terror of a delivery suddenly going wrong.

But Ann and the gang know they are playing with death/ life-changing disability, and just carry on blithely.

You can have an NHS home birth, but I appreciate the resources might not be available. You can pay for a private midwife at home. Even a doula who had attended many births would have been better. But they just ran through that minefield. Yes, it's expensive but so is a funeral.

OP posts:
Clafoutie · 22/10/2023 22:23

I’m not clear how the fact that there is a third person in the relationship is relevant to the concern here, which is presumably about the potential health risk to mother and baby. People’s relationships are entirely their own business, whatever we might think of them.

SwingTheMonkey · 22/10/2023 22:22

How do people think a problem with baby during labour would be detected at home with no assistance?

cadburyegg · 22/10/2023 22:22

The whole setup sounds utterly bonkers

And (unpopular opinion I know) I don't agree with planned home births so YANBU on that front.

thecatinthetwat · 22/10/2023 22:17

Perhaps she had an awful experience in hospital her first time. Second births are safer at home, and she could call out a midwife at any point or an ambulance as she did do.

your reaction is ott. There was an issue, she went to hospital. You wouldn’t dream of choosing that yourself and that’s fine.

CaroleSinger · 22/10/2023 22:03

I suppose it does seem a tad irresponsible but the relationship itself is weird as fuck and smacks of the old man getting to have his cake and eat it. Has he considered castration? Is she allowed to have another boyfriend in the marital bed too or is only he allowed to do that?

theduchessofspork · 22/10/2023 22:01

It’s irresponsible but people do daft things all the time. I think you are a bit over invested in this.

Thesearmsofmine · 22/10/2023 21:59

Yeah I know a few people like this(home ed circles have some people very into this kind of stuff). I wouldn’t say it disgusts me but it does give me the fear, maybe because of my own birth experiences.

AuraBora · 22/10/2023 21:54

Hmm.. I think I'd actively 'lose touch- with her again if were in your shoes!
I am just not on the same wavelength as someone who chooses a set up like this.. including having your partner's girlfriend (!) deliver your baby.. that'll be an interesting story to tell the child when they're older!🙄
Yeah each to their own and all that but we are all entitled to our own views.

Lookingatthesunset · 22/10/2023 21:50

caban · 22/10/2023 21:40

You read stories about investigations and inquiries fairly regularly where hospitals have failed to monitor probably and didn't pick up fetal distress, didn't respond quickly or appropriately due to unsafe staffing levels etc - being in hospital is absolutely no guarantee of safety.

The majority of maternity units in England are inadequate or unsafe - going in to hospital is a risk too.

It's having the damn commonsense to manage the risk.

Lookingatthesunset · 22/10/2023 21:49

UpUpUpU · 22/10/2023 21:43

I am a student midwife and it never ceases to amaze me how quickly and heavily a woman can bleed after birth. She could bleed to death in a matter of minutes without medication and trained staff. I have seen beautiful births with an unresponsive baby, shoulder dystocia, a cord prolapse, a snapped umbilical cord etc. You have to be a special kind of midwife to do home births as the things that can go wrong are literally life threatening to mum and baby. Anybody choosing to do this without a midwife is braver than me!

Thankfully someone talking sense!!

Nobody is dissing home birth per se - it's the fact it wasn't supervised by a medical professional that's shocking and neglectful.

Plus my vag would have sealed tightly with Carol in the equation so there wouldn't have been a baby anyway...

UpUpUpU · 22/10/2023 21:43

I am a student midwife and it never ceases to amaze me how quickly and heavily a woman can bleed after birth. She could bleed to death in a matter of minutes without medication and trained staff. I have seen beautiful births with an unresponsive baby, shoulder dystocia, a cord prolapse, a snapped umbilical cord etc. You have to be a special kind of midwife to do home births as the things that can go wrong are literally life threatening to mum and baby. Anybody choosing to do this without a midwife is braver than me!

caban · 22/10/2023 21:40

SwingTheMonkey · 22/10/2023 21:24

How would they know things were going badly wrong until it was too late? My first was in distress during labour. He was born via c section, within 10 minutes, with me under general anaesthetic. There was no way I’d have known he was in distress if I’d selfishly decided to birth at home with no medical professional present.

You read stories about investigations and inquiries fairly regularly where hospitals have failed to monitor probably and didn't pick up fetal distress, didn't respond quickly or appropriately due to unsafe staffing levels etc - being in hospital is absolutely no guarantee of safety.

The majority of maternity units in England are inadequate or unsafe - going in to hospital is a risk too.

caban · 22/10/2023 21:35

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 21:11

>What actually is the risk?

Probably about the same as before modern medicine. As pp said there, if was a group of ten pregnant women, one wouldn't survive. I'm not sure the stats for the baby surviving.

It won't be anything like the same as before modern medicine. We now have better hygiene. better nutrition, better general health, better antenatal care.
The risk of the mother actually not surviving would be very low.

Winnipeggy · 22/10/2023 21:31

@LylaLee you seem cross....I find it confusing. Getting worked up over relative strangers birth story is not a productive way to spend a Sunday night.

Sunmoonstars33 · 22/10/2023 21:28

I don't see what the problem is actually. What they did was perfectly legal and they did actually seek medical assistance when needed so.... it's not like they continued with the plan at all costs. They went to the hospital when they needed to.

SwingTheMonkey · 22/10/2023 21:24

Winnipeggy · 22/10/2023 21:20

Well, I'm thinking that if anything went badly wrong they would have called an emergency ambulance? It wouldn't be my choice but if they were my friends I certainly wouldn't feel disgusted by them. Are you actually friends?

How would they know things were going badly wrong until it was too late? My first was in distress during labour. He was born via c section, within 10 minutes, with me under general anaesthetic. There was no way I’d have known he was in distress if I’d selfishly decided to birth at home with no medical professional present.

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 21:23

Winnipeggy · 22/10/2023 21:20

Well, I'm thinking that if anything went badly wrong they would have called an emergency ambulance? It wouldn't be my choice but if they were my friends I certainly wouldn't feel disgusted by them. Are you actually friends?

As I said, we used to be friends.

So an ambulance takes 5 - 15 minutes to get to you (best case scenario). Do you know how quickly a person can bleed out?

OP posts:
Winnipeggy · 22/10/2023 21:20

Well, I'm thinking that if anything went badly wrong they would have called an emergency ambulance? It wouldn't be my choice but if they were my friends I certainly wouldn't feel disgusted by them. Are you actually friends?

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 21:18

MariaLuna · 22/10/2023 21:17

^>women have been giving birth for millennia. Yes, and it's been the leading cause of death in women for millennia. Now we survive childbirth and die of cancer, stroke or heart disease instead.

Yea, you could be run over tomorrow, or collapse at home. What is the point of this thread?

Death is inevitable. Make sure you live a great life. All up to you.

Statistics

OP posts:
MariaLuna · 22/10/2023 21:17

^>women have been giving birth for millennia. Yes, and it's been the leading cause of death in women for millennia. Now we survive childbirth and die of cancer, stroke or heart disease instead.

Yea, you could be run over tomorrow, or collapse at home. What is the point of this thread?

Death is inevitable. Make sure you live a great life. All up to you.

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 21:11

caban · 22/10/2023 21:02

What actually is the risk though? Nothing in life is risk free, there are risks to pain relief and medical procedures during pregnancy and birth so it's not like you can never take a risk at all.
Planned home births for low risk women have better outcomes than hospital births, so are we saying that any woman choosing unnecessarily to have her baby in an unsafe hospital is taking too much risk?

Anecdotally I know two women who had second babies at home (unplanned) and unassisted and they were both healthy and happy. Anecdotes don't tell us very much.

>What actually is the risk?

Probably about the same as before modern medicine. As pp said there, if was a group of ten pregnant women, one wouldn't survive. I'm not sure the stats for the baby surviving.

OP posts:
LePetitChat · 22/10/2023 21:08

Im not sure there’s enough information to say whether she was unreasonable or not.

as pointed out, straightforward first birth, textbook pregnancy, then I’m not sure I would be having kittens about it as when they needed medical help it was sought and it worked.

would I take that risk? No. Would I recommend anyone else to do it? No. However, I’ve had five kids and all of mine I needed medical assistance so my view is probably coloured. If someone else has had nothing but positive experiences I can see why you would want that lovely soothing home birth. I would in an ideal world.., but as it will never happen, give me all the drugs and let me enjoy someone else making me tea and toast after 🤣

caban · 22/10/2023 21:02

Dramatic · 22/10/2023 20:57

Anecdotally I know someone who's second baby was born at home with very little medical assistance and her baby was born not breathing. He is now very severely disabled. It probably could have been prevented had she been in hospital. It's not ever worth the risk.

What actually is the risk though? Nothing in life is risk free, there are risks to pain relief and medical procedures during pregnancy and birth so it's not like you can never take a risk at all.
Planned home births for low risk women have better outcomes than hospital births, so are we saying that any woman choosing unnecessarily to have her baby in an unsafe hospital is taking too much risk?

Anecdotally I know two women who had second babies at home (unplanned) and unassisted and they were both healthy and happy. Anecdotes don't tell us very much.

Swipe left for the next trending thread