Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this was wildly irresponsible?

111 replies

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 18:37

I have a friend, "Ann". We used to be close but lost touch.

She and her partner have a 5 year old and she's just had a new baby.

She had put her 'birth journey' on Facebook. (Text, not video/pictures)

She and her partner have a third person in the relationship, "Carol", a woman who is her partner Bob's girlfriend. It was the three of them in the bedroom. (The 7 y/o was with a nanny in another part of the house).

She wanted a birth with no medical professionals, just the universe, incense etc.

Bob delivered the baby with Carol helping.

They wanted a lotus birth (where you don't cut the umbilical cord). But the placenta was not detaching, so after a few hours after the baby was born, they went to hospital (baby outside the body, placenta inside, umbilical cord still attached.)

None of the three are medical professionals. She's an artist, he's a musician and I don't know what the Carol does but Ann said she'd not a nurse/doctor/midwife when I asked.

There's nothing wrong with having a baby at home. Nothing wrong with the 7 year old being there.

But to have no medical person present is disgusting. She could have died, the baby could have died.

I said congratulations, but I feel disgusted by her selfishness. They could have left the 5 yo motherless.

FFS.

AIBU to be appalled? On mobile so I can't enable voting.

OP posts:
Juicyjuicymango · 23/10/2023 06:37

Sounds to me like they made an informed choice, were educated on what could happen and made the appropriate decision to seek help when things were showing signs that she needed help.

People don't free birth for fun without any planning or education on it. And in a straightforward pregnancy, uninterrupted birth is perfectly safe. It's a normal physiological event not a medical event, and they sought help when needed.

If she insisted on pursuing her plans for a lotus birth despite the placenta not coming away then yes, wildly irresponsible.

MidnightOnceMore · 23/10/2023 06:32

Yes it was a risk, no it is not 'disgusting'.

They were within the law. They made a choice you wouldn't make but unless we know the inside of someone's head it's not good to judge.

MayThe4th · 23/10/2023 06:30

They sound like weirdos and they’re bringing their children up in a completely fucked up dynamic where daddy has a girlfriend who is presumably part of the setup.

I think the birth is the least of it, but is clearly a demonstration of the kind of people they are.

I feel sorry for the children in this fucked up environment.

happylittlesloth · 23/10/2023 06:21

P.s I believe it is called a "freebirth" rather than a home birth.

happylittlesloth · 23/10/2023 06:19

Had she had any midwife appointments leading up to this?

Incredibly risky but ultimately her choice.

mikado1 · 23/10/2023 06:19

They played a game of Russian Roulette and they're lucky it worked in their favour. I looked up a HB for my second but the indemnity form brought me out in a rash. As it happens, I had an unplanned, unassisted one as the labour progressed quite quickly despite midwife on the phone telling me I was fine and to stay put. We had our own Carol, a neighbour who ran in, and thankfully all went well as the fire brigade (!) arrived after the event. I felt guilty for days afterwards when I considered what could have happened.

MrsJamin · 23/10/2023 06:07

How many of us here have had babies in hospital and know that there would have been an undesirable consequence had they not had any medical assistance? Myself and DS1 would have most likely died with my first birth (breech). To intentionally decide to give birth without medical assistance is to go back to the medieval times, and putting them all (mother, baby and previous child) at risk of very negative outcomes. Of course YANBU!

IvorTheEngineDriver · 23/10/2023 02:47

How is any of this your business OP?

Fionaville · 23/10/2023 00:32

I had a post partum hemorrhage within half an hour of giving birth to my first due to some retained placenta. I'd have died within a quick medical response and a big blood transfusion. I was young, fit and healthy.
With my second it was shoulder dystocia and he got stuck. It was horrific. He'd have died if I was at home. I'm sure Bob and his girlfriend wouldn't have coped well with either of those births.
I'm not against home births, but there needs to be an actual midwife there.

FirstFallopians · 23/10/2023 00:07

Bonkers, but what annoys me in these scenarios is that the health or the baby is obviously way, way, waaaay down the list of priorities for these parents.

Give birth whatever way you want to- doped up on as many pain meds as possible in hospital (like me), a water birth at home or anything in between. Up to the mother. But ffs having a trained and licensed medical professional there is the bare minimum.

I’d view actively planning an unassisted birth the same as not using an infant car seat- yeah, things might turn out ok but if they don’t the consequences could be catastrophic.

LightSpeeds · 22/10/2023 23:47

Ponoka7 · 22/10/2023 23:01

We, as in the women down the maternal line,tend to give birth without complications and without stitches. So my DD opted for a HB (water) for her first. The midwives don't come until labour is well established. The second we, me and her delivered in the bath. We were waiting for the midwife. This isn't really any different. It sounds as though you are against HB. The reasons why women died in child birth was connected to a lack of hygiene, nutrition, knowledge and no antibiotics/blood thinners etc. They sought treatment when needed.

I would have thought that the deaths and injuries to mums and babies in the past were caused by the labour not progressing, baby's position, baby getting distressed, uncontrolled bleeding, need for Caesarian, etc. You haven't mentioned ANY of these things even though so many women even on MN will have had difficult labours requiring intervention or emergency procedures for these issues. Without today's medical care (monitoring, equipment, pain relief and surgery), a lot of women and babies really would have died or sustained life-changing injuries.

TeenLifeMum · 22/10/2023 23:40

I would never comment on someone having a home birth because I have strong views and I know they’re unlikely to be welcome. If I’d had a home birth with dd1 (low risk text book pregnancy) I would likely have died. You never know if you’ll haemorrhage and getting an ambulance there in time is a massive gamble. Some people do assume birth is natural so there’s no way it’ll go wrong for them.

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 23:39

Clafoutie · 22/10/2023 23:32

But why mention her at all? I think that is what I mean.

So there was Bob and Ann. And there was another person.
Who?
Carol
Who is Carol?
Bob's girlfriend.

Or: Bob, Ann, and Carol, Bob's girlfriend.

OP posts:
chachachachangesoolala · 22/10/2023 23:39

Winnipeggy · 22/10/2023 21:20

Well, I'm thinking that if anything went badly wrong they would have called an emergency ambulance? It wouldn't be my choice but if they were my friends I certainly wouldn't feel disgusted by them. Are you actually friends?

Have you not seen the multitude of news reports where about people having to wait hours for an "emergency" ambulance?

OP I agree with you. This was totally irresponsible. A home birth in the presence of trained midwives and a back up plan is one thing, this kind of "free birth" is quite another.

Clafoutie · 22/10/2023 23:32

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 22:29

I'm explaining why Carol was there. She was not there as medical support but as Bob's girlfriend.

But why mention her at all? I think that is what I mean.

2jacqi · 22/10/2023 23:29

the three adults are all just idiots!! sounds like they are the definition of hippies!

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 22/10/2023 23:16

All the cool girls out in force tonight, OP. 😎

But none of them seem to be thinking what might have happened to the poor baby if the weather had been as it was two days ago, and you couldn’t just jump in the car ant get the ‘dreadful ‘( according to these posters) NHS A&E staff to deal with the perfectly predictable results of the parents’ ( and the father’s extra shag) irresponsibility.

let’s hope the poor baby has not suffered some irreversible birth damage as a result of the parents’ blind, self centred incompetence. Why do I think that if this has occurred it will be Ann who is left to cope?

LakeTiticaca · 22/10/2023 23:10

It might be legal but it doesn't make it not batshit

Hankunamatata · 22/10/2023 23:09

I laboured in natural labour room with minimal intervention, the baby's heart rate dropped massively so he had to come out. The midwives knew by monitoring and got me on a birthing stool to move process along.
If their baby had been starved of oxygen or she hemorrhage....

Hankunamatata · 22/10/2023 23:06

Stupid imo. So many complications on birth that a good midwife can deal with successfully but novice wouldn't have a clue.
Have they not watched call the midwife!!

Ponoka7 · 22/10/2023 23:01

We, as in the women down the maternal line,tend to give birth without complications and without stitches. So my DD opted for a HB (water) for her first. The midwives don't come until labour is well established. The second we, me and her delivered in the bath. We were waiting for the midwife. This isn't really any different. It sounds as though you are against HB. The reasons why women died in child birth was connected to a lack of hygiene, nutrition, knowledge and no antibiotics/blood thinners etc. They sought treatment when needed.

TeaGinandFags · 22/10/2023 23:00

Totally not being unreasonable.

Birth is very very dangerous for mother and baby. In the past 25% - that is a quarter - of women died because of childbirth.

No one wants to be in hospital but it's a wonderful place in a medical emergency.

Fionaville · 22/10/2023 22:42

YANBU they sounds like a bunch of irresponsible pricks.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/10/2023 22:38

caban · 22/10/2023 20:51

Most births, especially second + births, don't require medical assistance and aren't going to become emergencies though.
If she was low risk and had a normal first birth it's not a huge gamble.

Post partum haemorrhage?

Cord around neck?

Shoulder dystocia?

Undiagnosed footling breech?

All can happen out of the blue in any labour - including a second/third/fourth/fifth (my mother had a PPH with her 4th following him being delivered blue 20 minutes previously, so they were busy trying to keep him alive when she suddenly haemorrhaged - and I wasn't in much better condition when I was born due to the cord being wrapped three times around my neck). I lost loads of blood when I had my second despite being actively cared for and monitored throughout - no reason for it, no anaemia, no obvious cause at all, I just started bleeding more heavily than expected.

It's hugely risky to not have anybody who actually knows what they're doing with someone in labour.

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 22:29

Clafoutie · 22/10/2023 22:23

I’m not clear how the fact that there is a third person in the relationship is relevant to the concern here, which is presumably about the potential health risk to mother and baby. People’s relationships are entirely their own business, whatever we might think of them.

I'm explaining why Carol was there. She was not there as medical support but as Bob's girlfriend.

OP posts: