Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this was wildly irresponsible?

111 replies

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 18:37

I have a friend, "Ann". We used to be close but lost touch.

She and her partner have a 5 year old and she's just had a new baby.

She had put her 'birth journey' on Facebook. (Text, not video/pictures)

She and her partner have a third person in the relationship, "Carol", a woman who is her partner Bob's girlfriend. It was the three of them in the bedroom. (The 7 y/o was with a nanny in another part of the house).

She wanted a birth with no medical professionals, just the universe, incense etc.

Bob delivered the baby with Carol helping.

They wanted a lotus birth (where you don't cut the umbilical cord). But the placenta was not detaching, so after a few hours after the baby was born, they went to hospital (baby outside the body, placenta inside, umbilical cord still attached.)

None of the three are medical professionals. She's an artist, he's a musician and I don't know what the Carol does but Ann said she'd not a nurse/doctor/midwife when I asked.

There's nothing wrong with having a baby at home. Nothing wrong with the 7 year old being there.

But to have no medical person present is disgusting. She could have died, the baby could have died.

I said congratulations, but I feel disgusted by her selfishness. They could have left the 5 yo motherless.

FFS.

AIBU to be appalled? On mobile so I can't enable voting.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
charlotte361 · 09/11/2023 13:27

An unassisted birth is legal, but to assist when you are not qualified to do so (except in an emergency ) is not i believe.

sillibilli2 · 23/10/2023 22:21

I understand people wanting a natural birth experience but labour/birth can go wrong and needs a medical professional there to ensure the safety of mother and baby.

And for those who say plenty of women give birth /have given birth without medical intervention.

Yes but often not by choice and do we really want to aim for circumstances where statistically women and babies are more likely to die?

YesThatsATurdOnTheRug · 23/10/2023 22:05

I was very lucky to have a midwife led unit at my local hospital with three water birth rooms, which I was able to be in both times. The great thing about them is big reduction in unnecessary intervention but if you need a doctor they are a minute away at all times. I just cannot see the sense in wanting to distance yourself from possible life saving care at such a dangerous time.

vipersnest1 · 23/10/2023 21:58

As a PP said, trusting in your body 'knowing what to do' is very foolish. Mine had no fucking clue with my first-born. Back to back labour lasting over thirty six hours, pushing for over two, ultimately resulting in me being forced to squat for contractions (I've been paying the price for the damage caused for years) and having a large episiotomy. I don't know for sure, but strongly suspect I would have died (and my DC) if my situation had occurred at home with me refusing medical intervention.

LylaLee · 23/10/2023 21:53

overwhelmed2023 · 23/10/2023 21:14

People are absolutely bonkers!!! I'd love to have listened in to the midwife / dr conversation on their arrival.

Ikr

OP posts:
overwhelmed2023 · 23/10/2023 21:14

People are absolutely bonkers!!! I'd love to have listened in to the midwife / dr conversation on their arrival.

Dutch1e · 23/10/2023 21:07

Sunmoonstars33 · 23/10/2023 19:11

@Dutch1e the homebirth midwives carry the blood clotting drugs and have suturing kits don't they? They do where I am anyway.. so they could handle most bleeds until an ambulance arrives. Altho tragedies do always sometimes happen its true.

Iam planning a homebirth and tbh here they seem extremely well equipped to deal with most common things which might go wrong at least until they could get u to a hospital.

Suturing kits definitely, but I don't think blood-clotters, no. As far as I'm aware they're not authorised to administer any meds (apart from the Lidocaine they rub on before that suturing kit comes out! (To be clear I'm in the Netherlands as my username probably shows but I don't want any confusion).

In fairness it's extremely rare that anything happens as any at-risk pregnancies tend to be booked in for a hospital birth from the get-go.

And the midwives have so much emergency training that I really couldn't have felt safer. The opposite actually, I was so comfortable and relaxed from being in my own home with such amazing support, I wish the OPs friends could have had that option.

Sunmoonstars33 · 23/10/2023 19:11

@Dutch1e the homebirth midwives carry the blood clotting drugs and have suturing kits don't they? They do where I am anyway.. so they could handle most bleeds until an ambulance arrives. Altho tragedies do always sometimes happen its true.

Iam planning a homebirth and tbh here they seem extremely well equipped to deal with most common things which might go wrong at least until they could get u to a hospital.

Dutch1e · 23/10/2023 19:00

LylaLee · 23/10/2023 18:05

As PP said, if you have a trained professional there, they have knowledge, training, monitoring, equipment and medication with them to deal with some of the most common emergencies.

It's a million times better than what went on here.

Yes I know, I had a homebirth although they're quite common here and the midwives are extremely good. But they don't drive ambulances and in theory a swift bleed-out could happen at home.

LylaLee · 23/10/2023 18:05

Dutch1e · 23/10/2023 17:58

That makes it sound like you're against ALL homebirths, not only unassisted homebirths. Or am I reading it wrongly?

As PP said, if you have a trained professional there, they have knowledge, training, monitoring, equipment and medication with them to deal with some of the most common emergencies.

It's a million times better than what went on here.

OP posts:
Dutch1e · 23/10/2023 17:58

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 21:23

As I said, we used to be friends.

So an ambulance takes 5 - 15 minutes to get to you (best case scenario). Do you know how quickly a person can bleed out?

That makes it sound like you're against ALL homebirths, not only unassisted homebirths. Or am I reading it wrongly?

LylaLee · 23/10/2023 17:37

Guibhyl · 23/10/2023 08:36

And yes as @Frasers points out, one of my pet peeves is when people say “you need to do your own risk assessment”. Lol. Many people struggle to interpret basic scientific information. What makes anyone think that your average member of the general public is in any way better equipped to do this than a medical professional because they’ve spent a few hours on Google and a few hugely biased Facebook groups or Reddit threads? Most people are hugely susceptible to confirmation bias and are not in a position to make an objective decision.

Agreed.

OP posts:
RudsyFarmer · 23/10/2023 08:52

Just unfollow. You can do that and still show as friends on Facebook.

Mrsm010918 · 23/10/2023 08:51

It does sound a bit bonkers that they didn't even call anyone for assistance. That's not a risk I would have taken.

That being said my 4mth old was a spontaneous home birth and by the time an ambulance got there (45 minutes later) he was out and all they had to do was cut the cord. With that sort of wait time if anything had gone wrong we could have both been dead. And the 999 operator assured us it was on a blue light response level too.

Midwife team came and cleaned up and then just left us at home anyway.

Beargrumps22 · 23/10/2023 08:49

obviously they have an alternative lifestyle anyway but it really depends how much support they had during the pregnancy from Drs Midwifes etc. Plus of course how her other birth was as that is usually what they advise on if someone is high risk or not.
it is high risk in this case but obviously it was their choice not mine but if that is what they wanted to do that is their problem.

Guibhyl · 23/10/2023 08:36

And yes as @Frasers points out, one of my pet peeves is when people say “you need to do your own risk assessment”. Lol. Many people struggle to interpret basic scientific information. What makes anyone think that your average member of the general public is in any way better equipped to do this than a medical professional because they’ve spent a few hours on Google and a few hugely biased Facebook groups or Reddit threads? Most people are hugely susceptible to confirmation bias and are not in a position to make an objective decision.

Guibhyl · 23/10/2023 08:32

YANBU and I can’t believe the number of people who think it’s just “their business” and you should not have an opinion. This is an innocent baby. It’s not just the parents affected if something goes wrong. There’s a newborn and also a 5 year old indirectly at risk of their decision.

Sadly though I expect it’s not the first and not the last time these parents will put their “freedoms” at the top of their priority list instead of the best interests of their children.

Frasers · 23/10/2023 08:12

CatherinedeBourgh · 23/10/2023 07:56

Freedom is about everyone being able to make their own choices based on their own values and their own risk assessments.

I am happy to live in a free society.

That assumes it’s an ideal world where every person is capable or willing of making decisions that are beneficial to and protect a child. Experience tells us that is not the case. And sadly children need protecting from their own parents in many instances. That doesn’t make our world a jail. It makes our society one that protects children.

no one needs to come over all braveheart. Running round forums shouting freedom. That baby could have died or been permanently damaged, a much higher risk than if they’d had medical attention.

so for me, yes I want a free society, but I also want protection for those who cannot protect themselves, the children, the vulnerable. To stop people posing them additional risks or harm. No one who is prioritising the child would chose to give birth with no medical assistance, and so yes, as a society we should protect those who cannot protect themselves.

CatherinedeBourgh · 23/10/2023 07:56

Freedom is about everyone being able to make their own choices based on their own values and their own risk assessments.

I am happy to live in a free society.

Frasers · 23/10/2023 07:52

I agree with you op and I’m surprised by the arsey answers you got. I guess folks just fancying a pile on. Yes women gave birth for millennia without medical assistance, yes we sent kids down the mines, doesn’t mean it’s optimal or something we should now chose.

it’s taking a heightened risk with both mother and child’s life. Now if a mother chooses to risk her life further than necessary then that’s her own decision, but I don’t think it should be legal to allow her to risk the babies.

LylaLee · 23/10/2023 07:47

happylittlesloth · 23/10/2023 06:19

Had she had any midwife appointments leading up to this?

Incredibly risky but ultimately her choice.

I don't know if she was under a midwife.

OP posts:
FunCatSunPat · 23/10/2023 07:46

The difference between having a planned home birth attended by midwives or even a surprise fast labour in Tesco attended by paramedics isn't just that the HCPs have knowledge or skills that a lay person doesn't; it's also that they have equipment. Ergometrine and gelofusin that can save a woman's life in the event of a major haemorrhage. A bag valve mask that can save a baby's life or help to prevent severe brain damage in the event that the baby is born unresponsive. Magnesium sulphate for if the woman has an eclamptic fit post-birth.

Planning an unattended home birth is naive at best and catastrophic at worst. But as PPs have said, it's legal as long as the supporting partners don't try to act as a midwife or doctor. And as long as the woman is prepared to accept liability (legally but, more importantly, in terms of her own conscience and peace of mind) for whatever the outcome might be. This is an eye-opening read (I realise the OP makes no mention of her friend being postdates, but the point is that we all think poor outcomes are things that happen to other people - when of course we all are "other people" to everyone else): https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/she-wanted-freebirth-no-doctors-online-groups-convinced-her-it-n1140096

She wanted a 'freebirth' with no doctors. Online groups convinced her it would be OK.

As Judith's pregnancy stretched past 44 weeks, she grew worried. But rather than seeking medical assistance, she turned to extreme online communities.

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/she-wanted-freebirth-no-doctors-online-groups-convinced-her-it-n1140096

ExperiencedTeacher · 23/10/2023 07:34

So I suppose this comes down to our attitude to personal risk and liberty. Is it a choice I would make? No. Did I have a good hospital experience? No. But the risk for me outweighs my rubbish experience in hospital (amazing birth, significant lack of care).

It’s a choice I wouldn’t make but a choice I’d defend their right to make.

I suppose it’s a more extreme version of whether you choose to cut out pate and soft cheese. It isn’t the law but it’s a personal risk you calculate. There will always be people on the extremes of the risk spectrum.

LylaLee · 23/10/2023 07:12

IvorTheEngineDriver · 23/10/2023 02:47

How is any of this your business OP?

This is a public forum. It's a place for people to discuss things.

Would your posting history show discussion only about scenarios you were directly involved in?

What a weird thing to say.

OP posts:
MrsJamin · 23/10/2023 06:44

I don't buy that, freebirthing is irresponsible, for many things it would be too late by the time they worked out that they needed to get to the hospital. It's a selfish choice, choosing not to have help to prevent negative outcomes for yourself or your child.