Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quite simply- AIBU?

91 replies

forjustnow · 22/10/2023 10:12

Background-

2 siblings and a DM.

Sibling 1- public sector job earns 50k, has 1 DC and is the sole provider for them, has a mortgage on an average house. Has a strained relationship with DM, sees them approx 5 times a year.

Sibling 2- built up property, no DC, has 5 mortgage free properties rented out (these are not the main income source). Has a very positive and supportive relationship with DM, sees them multiple times a week.

DM- has MH struggles and has relied on DC off and on their whole lives. DM has always lived in rented housing.

Siblings have an amicable but not close relationship, stay in contact via message etc. Talk if they bump into each other but rarely call/don't spend birthdays & Christmas together etc. Siblings and DM all stay in the same city within about 5 miles of each other.

Sibling 2 has decided (no conversation with sibling 2) that they are giving DM one of their flats. Sibling 1 thinks this is lovely. Sibling 2 then calls (only phone call this year) Sibling 1 to explain the rent they will lose will be approx 1200 a month. This point is laboured over 2 phone calls. DM then also mentions this to Sibling 1.

Sibling 1 is starting to feel under pressure to offer to make a monthly contribution to the lost rent. However, they a) can't comfortably afford it. b)don't want to c) don't think they should as there was no discussion/joint decision making process d) the lost rent is not a main source of income e) would rather use spare money to build security for their DC.

I am Sibling 1. Am I BU?

OP posts:
Datgal · 22/10/2023 11:37

Cheeky fuckers!! I'd be laughing my head off if they did ever ask.

Thebigblueballoon · 22/10/2023 11:34

It was your sibling’s decision to gift your mother a flat. You had no say in the decision, and are under no obligation to offer a contribution towards the lost rent. They have four mortgage-free properties already, ffs! I’m sure they’ll live with the “loss”.

If your sibling is literally gifting the property to your mum - as in transferring the deeds - you could always suggest that this is reflected in any inheritance further down the line.

forjustnow · 22/10/2023 11:32

BouncyBallBall · 22/10/2023 11:07

You all sound over invested to know your siblings financial situations

If you mother is on low income then is she eligible for rent support? This is possible even if renting from a relative if the rent is market rate.

I’m not over invested at all. They have always been very open with their financial ventures Etc

Sibling has no interest in charging DM rent or asking DM to claim any kind of benefit. I think their view is they are contributing by giving DM the priority rent free and I should be offering to cover a portion of the rent they are losing.

OP posts:
abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz12 · 22/10/2023 11:30

No you are in no way unreasonable. Your sibling can't make a unilateral decision and expect you to pay for it

NoSquirrels · 22/10/2023 11:23

If or when they ask, just say no. That’s it.

BouncyBallBall · 22/10/2023 11:07

You all sound over invested to know your siblings financial situations

If you mother is on low income then is she eligible for rent support? This is possible even if renting from a relative if the rent is market rate.

Perthsmurf · 22/10/2023 11:07

YANBU. Your responsibility is to your DC and yourself. You are not responsible for your DM, and certainly not responsible for this lost rent. It’s ridiculous of your sibling, especially as effectively you’d be contributing to their mortgage!

You owe them nothing, and don’t feel guilty. This situation is of their own making.

Paltrypam · 22/10/2023 11:00

You hardly see them or have any interception with them op

so what if it causes tension by you saying “not a possibility”. Not like you have much to do with each other anyway

forjustnow · 22/10/2023 10:52

meganorks · 22/10/2023 10:50

She hasn't actually asked you for anything so I would just say if they mention it again 'that's very generous of you and will make mum's life a lot easier' and leave it at that. It might not be that she wants any money from you, just wants you to know how much she is giving up, how generous she is being. How does your mum pay rent now? If she gets some kind of housing benefit surely she would still be entitled and could pay that to your sister. If not, its not your problem. Do not offer anything.

They've not asked yet but I can sense it's coming.
DM rent is currently paid for by pension/PT work.

OP posts:
meganorks · 22/10/2023 10:50

She hasn't actually asked you for anything so I would just say if they mention it again 'that's very generous of you and will make mum's life a lot easier' and leave it at that. It might not be that she wants any money from you, just wants you to know how much she is giving up, how generous she is being. How does your mum pay rent now? If she gets some kind of housing benefit surely she would still be entitled and could pay that to your sister. If not, its not your problem. Do not offer anything.

forjustnow · 22/10/2023 10:50

GrumpyOldCrone · 22/10/2023 10:48

This is not actually a generous act. Your sibling is viewing it as a business transaction. You have no contractual obligation here!

This has crossed my mind. They are very, very financially aware in every aspect of life and don't make ANY decision without knowing the financial benefit/cost.

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 22/10/2023 10:49

And if they ask outright for a contribution say ‘No, I can’t afford to.’

MyCircumference · 22/10/2023 10:48

do nothing op,
apart from may be ask sis Are you Sure this is wise?
but dont feel you have to offer

GrumpyOldCrone · 22/10/2023 10:48

This is not actually a generous act. Your sibling is viewing it as a business transaction. You have no contractual obligation here!

forjustnow · 22/10/2023 10:46

MyCircumference · 22/10/2023 10:43

how will she manage the bills?

Not a question I've asked. I'd assume the same way she pays for them in her private let- pension and PT work.

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 22/10/2023 10:46

Of course you’re not being unreasonable.

If your sibling keeps mentioning the £1,200 just say “It’s really generous of you to do this for Mum.”

If your mum mentions it say “It’s really generous of Sibling to do this for you, Mum.”

MyCircumference · 22/10/2023 10:43

how will she manage the bills?

ShagratandGorbag4ever · 22/10/2023 10:43

The only words you need are 'what exactly is your point?' and 'no'.

forjustnow · 22/10/2023 10:42

felisha54 · 22/10/2023 10:38

Why is sibling 2 wanting to do this? Is your mums current lease ending?

If I were sibling 1 I wouldn't offer to contribute. Sibling 2 seems to have enough properties to be able to do them so let them. Your mum may not be able to claim housing benefit as she's moving into a relatives home.

No I'm not actually sure why it's happening now.

OP posts:
MyCircumference · 22/10/2023 10:40

far better to stay out of it,
unless you offer to furnish it, buy a freezer or new bed?

MyCircumference · 22/10/2023 10:38

she has chosen to do this, without prior discussion.
puts you in a predicament.

felisha54 · 22/10/2023 10:38

Why is sibling 2 wanting to do this? Is your mums current lease ending?

If I were sibling 1 I wouldn't offer to contribute. Sibling 2 seems to have enough properties to be able to do them so let them. Your mum may not be able to claim housing benefit as she's moving into a relatives home.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/10/2023 10:37

Every time it's mentioned agree yes, it is very generous of DSibling and they're very fortunate to be able to afford to do that. Leave it at that. You live within a few miles of your mom and rarely see her so it's not like this is a conversation that's going to be coming up weekly

LittleMonks11 · 22/10/2023 10:37

Not your problem OP. If they ask say no.

forjustnow · 22/10/2023 10:35

Rainbowqueeen · 22/10/2023 10:31

Your sibling and your mum have made this decision. Any regrets should be theirs alone. It has absolutely nothing to do with you

I assume the reason for this is so your mum can live a more comfortable retirement.

Thats very generous of your sibling and if it comes up I would let them know that and also add that you are grateful that they are in a position to do this.

I have. As much as as we have strained relationships, I'm not uncaring towards them and do think this is very generous. I've said this to both of them.

OP posts: