Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Quite simply- AIBU?

91 replies

forjustnow · 22/10/2023 10:12

Background-

2 siblings and a DM.

Sibling 1- public sector job earns 50k, has 1 DC and is the sole provider for them, has a mortgage on an average house. Has a strained relationship with DM, sees them approx 5 times a year.

Sibling 2- built up property, no DC, has 5 mortgage free properties rented out (these are not the main income source). Has a very positive and supportive relationship with DM, sees them multiple times a week.

DM- has MH struggles and has relied on DC off and on their whole lives. DM has always lived in rented housing.

Siblings have an amicable but not close relationship, stay in contact via message etc. Talk if they bump into each other but rarely call/don't spend birthdays & Christmas together etc. Siblings and DM all stay in the same city within about 5 miles of each other.

Sibling 2 has decided (no conversation with sibling 2) that they are giving DM one of their flats. Sibling 1 thinks this is lovely. Sibling 2 then calls (only phone call this year) Sibling 1 to explain the rent they will lose will be approx 1200 a month. This point is laboured over 2 phone calls. DM then also mentions this to Sibling 1.

Sibling 1 is starting to feel under pressure to offer to make a monthly contribution to the lost rent. However, they a) can't comfortably afford it. b)don't want to c) don't think they should as there was no discussion/joint decision making process d) the lost rent is not a main source of income e) would rather use spare money to build security for their DC.

I am Sibling 1. Am I BU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
justwatchingtelly · 24/10/2023 09:35

@Teddleshon wow. Your siblings are nuts.

My SIL told me once that she would inherit everything from PIL's estate as she had nothing and her brothers both had good jobs.

I said nothing...

Fionaville · 24/10/2023 00:29

No, I wouldn't pay anything. They knew they'd take a hit on 'profit' when they offered.

LifeExperience · 24/10/2023 00:10

Nobody has the right to spend your money except you.

billy1966 · 23/10/2023 23:53

Teddleshon · 23/10/2023 18:11

Thanks billy1966, I actually snuck a look at her will and she’s left half of it to them but of course legally she can’t do that as it’s not hers! It’s difficult when you work hard all your life and then are guilt tripped into feeling bad about siblings who have made dramatically different choices in life. It is sad though as I love seeing my nephews and nieces but I know my brothers will be so angry with me when I don’t give them anything. All they can see is the $$$$ increase in property value.

Money is so poisonous in families.

That they have chosen to run with this batshit idea would be hilarious if it wasn't so completely delusional and self serving.

They never contributed to their mothers care and yet somehow think they are entitled to a share in an asset you so generously allowed her the use of for 25 years.

Batshit entitled is what they are.

This generosity has cost you and your family many, many thousands.

They are absolutely CF's and you should increase your self preservation regarding your CF mother.

Make zero effort to assuage them.

The type of entitled people they are, you would be wise to step back.

Paltrypam · 23/10/2023 18:14

@Teddleshon how close are you to your brothers? Do you see them regularly?

Teddleshon · 23/10/2023 18:11

Thanks billy1966, I actually snuck a look at her will and she’s left half of it to them but of course legally she can’t do that as it’s not hers! It’s difficult when you work hard all your life and then are guilt tripped into feeling bad about siblings who have made dramatically different choices in life. It is sad though as I love seeing my nephews and nieces but I know my brothers will be so angry with me when I don’t give them anything. All they can see is the $$$$ increase in property value.

Money is so poisonous in families.

billy1966 · 23/10/2023 16:22

Teddleshon · 23/10/2023 09:45

@Paltrypam I do own the flat (obviously as I bought it) but given the fact that it has gone up so much in value in the past 25 years she wants to "leave" some of the proceeds to my brothers. She is 94 and dying of cancer so clearly I am not going to have a big row with her about it. She doesn't seem to understand that it isn't hers to leave and my 2 brothers somehow feel entitled to a share as they are broke and obviously have no inheritance whereas we are relatively well off and as they see it we have had a free ride on the back of a rising property market.

I didn't "emigrate", I travelled back and forth for holidays and long weekends when possible. There are a large number of low tax domiciles within a 7 hour flight from Britain.

Humour your dying mother if you must.

But your brothers must be smoking the whacky backy if they think they have any entitlement to a home that you provided for your mother for free for 25 years.

A pair of entitled CF's, not unlike your mother.

You have been an exceedingly generous daughter.

It ends on her death.

Tell your brothers to get proper jobs.

Motomum23 · 23/10/2023 16:21

Just be upfront. Sibling 2 I think you are being incredibly generous loosing income to help mum. I wish I could do the same but unfortunately I'm not in a position to even offer to cover half of that lost income. Sibling 2 might not actually be hinting for reimbursement but just rubbing your nose in how absolutely fabulous and generous they are (although when reading your post my first thought was who the hell owns several properties but doesn't offer to rent one to their parent even just at a cost covering basis).

Paltrypam · 23/10/2023 16:18

paintingvenice · 23/10/2023 11:15

Without discussion your sibling has signed you up to take on half your mums housing costs to the the on £600 a week? Errrr no you are not being unreasonable.

No

They've not asked yet but I can sense it's coming.

Paltrypam · 23/10/2023 16:17

@peebles32

They've not asked yet but I can sense it's coming.

Paltrypam · 23/10/2023 16:16

paintingvenice · 23/10/2023 11:37

How do you figure. They’ve offered their mum a property (without discussion); made contact for the first time in a long while and dropped in that they want a contribution; when the hint hasn’t been taken the mother then also takes up the baton to ask for a contribution?

No the op has said she “thinks” that they will ask and they are “hinting”

TeaGinandFags · 23/10/2023 12:08

peebles32 · 22/10/2023 10:35

No way! Sibling 2 made that choice!

This is actually nothing to do with you.

1 It wasn't your flat.
2 Your involvement wasn't required.
3 You can't affect this happening.

Ergo you have no responsibility to compensate other sibling for loss of income.

Make non commital noises over phone and leave it at that.

paintingvenice · 23/10/2023 11:37

Paltrypam · 23/10/2023 11:21

The sibling has done no such thing

How do you figure. They’ve offered their mum a property (without discussion); made contact for the first time in a long while and dropped in that they want a contribution; when the hint hasn’t been taken the mother then also takes up the baton to ask for a contribution?

Paltrypam · 23/10/2023 11:21

paintingvenice · 23/10/2023 11:15

Without discussion your sibling has signed you up to take on half your mums housing costs to the the on £600 a week? Errrr no you are not being unreasonable.

The sibling has done no such thing

Paltrypam · 23/10/2023 11:21

Teddleshon · 23/10/2023 11:12

@Paltrypam yes I am, family means a lot to me which is why I sacrificed so much to avoid my mother being homeless (she does not live in a country which has council homes or equivalent).

Any sibling that will go NC with another because they won’t give them money - is a sibling well shot of

but you own the flat, so your concerns about not being able to pay off your mortgage on current family home - no need for them. Your original post indicated your mother was going to give the house to your siblings leaving you out of pocket

paintingvenice · 23/10/2023 11:15

Without discussion your sibling has signed you up to take on half your mums housing costs to the the on £600 a week? Errrr no you are not being unreasonable.

Teddleshon · 23/10/2023 11:12

@Paltrypam yes I am, family means a lot to me which is why I sacrificed so much to avoid my mother being homeless (she does not live in a country which has council homes or equivalent).

Pollyputthekettleonha · 23/10/2023 10:31

Your sibling has made this decision without you, and only discussed it with your mum. So this is nothing to do with you. If your sibling is missing the rent she/he can ask your mum to pay some same as she does now to whoever she rents from.Your mum has her own income.

Your sibling shouldn't have made this decision unless they were okay with losing the rent or receiving less. I don't think you've got anything to feel guilty or responsible for here.

wildwestpioneer · 23/10/2023 10:27

It is your siblings decision to give a flat to their dm, if they can't afford the loss in rent or require financial assistance from their sibling the shouldn't be entertaining the idea.

You've two choices, to ignore the guilt trip. Or face it head on and discuss with sibling.

Either way, the end result will be the same, you can't afford it so won't be contributing financially

tabulaisrasa · 23/10/2023 10:23

It's nothing to do with you, let your mum and sibling get on with whatever arrangement they've made between themselves. You were nothing to do with any of the decisions made here (your sibling buying multiple houses, deciding to give one to your mum, etc) and you need feel nothing about it because as you say, your sibling can afford it and made the decision independently.

Paltrypam · 23/10/2023 10:11

This is all very odd @Teddleshon

you are sad about your siblings not wanting to have anything to do with you if you don’t give them money after your mother passes?

Paltrypam · 23/10/2023 10:09

Teddleshon · 23/10/2023 10:08

@Aldicrispsareshit yes I know but I also know I will no longer have any relationship with my siblings which does make me sad.

They will go NC with you because you won’t give them money?

Aldicrispsareshit · 23/10/2023 10:09

Teddleshon · 23/10/2023 10:08

@Aldicrispsareshit yes I know but I also know I will no longer have any relationship with my siblings which does make me sad.

Do you really want a relationship with them if they have the attitudes towards you and your mother that they currently hold?

Teddleshon · 23/10/2023 10:08

@Aldicrispsareshit yes I know but I also know I will no longer have any relationship with my siblings which does make me sad.

WideLegPant · 23/10/2023 09:57

OP you had no input into your sibling's decision. I'm struggling to see how they could present any case that it's anything to do with you?