Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you believe in manifestation?

214 replies

Thewal · 21/10/2023 23:49

I watched ‘The Secret’ today. It seemed to be mostly waffle with some random quotes thrown in, but from what I can gather it suggests that positive thinking and asking for things from the universe is what leads to ‘success’ and essentially getting what you want.

So I’d love to hear if you have ever manifested something into reality? How did you do it and how long did it take? Do you believe in it? And does the banishing of negative thoughts ever stress you out?

I just want to know what day to day life is like for people who practice this and if people have actually had something happen they put down to it?

OP posts:
Missingmyusername · 22/10/2023 08:56

Binfire · 22/10/2023 00:08

I think you attract whatever you focus on, so if you’re thinking about new job opportunities you’re more likely to spot them whenever and wherever you find them but I don’t think you can just ask the universe for a pony.

I agree with this^
I also think being positive, no matter what life throws at you helps with your stat of mind.

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 08:55

Mehmeh22 · 22/10/2023 08:49

I really wanted to get pregnant in July so I'd have a March baby and be able to be far enough along to announce it to people at my wedding. I was shocked when that happened.

Same for a May baby...but I wanted to have a boy. This also happened except it was a girl. But since she's grown up, she is a complete tomboy.

I was very lucky with both pregnancies and was very much had disappointment every month trying to get pregnant, but I ended up getting pregnant when I expected. I'm not sure if that was manifested but I was 100% sure it would happen.

You'd been having sex and got pregnant. That's standard. Yes, a minority struggle, but for most people it's fine. Had you been trying for over 12 months with no success?

>I manifested a boy and got a tomboy
Hmm

Mycatshandbag · 22/10/2023 08:54

I don't think there's anything magic or mystical in it. I think it's another word for focusing. In that respect I do think manifestation is a positive thing. But I believe it's you that makes it happen.

If you want something you are subconsciously, or consciously, looking out for that thing, probably talking about it to others and hyper focused on things relating to it.

If/when it happens it's because you made it your (and if you talk about it, others around you) focus and made decisions based on this, or it was a pure coincidence. I don't believe the universe made it happen because you 'manifested it'.

fruitstick · 22/10/2023 08:53

I find it really offensive.

Obviously if you focus on something or have a defined goal you are more likely to achieve it.

My child died from cancer. Do you think any of us manifested that? Do you think we didn't think or wish hard enough to keep him alive?

It's toxic bullshit wrapped up in positivity.

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 08:51

themothergoose · 22/10/2023 08:44

I am a bit lost. Why would you manifest a tragedy?

The philosophy is that you draw things towards yourself like spiritual energy. Everything that happens is because you drew it towards yourself. And if you spend £9.99 on their book (or go on their retreat/online course...) they will teach you how to do it to get good things.

So that means other people have drawn tragedies towards themselves.

Mehmeh22 · 22/10/2023 08:49

I really wanted to get pregnant in July so I'd have a March baby and be able to be far enough along to announce it to people at my wedding. I was shocked when that happened.

Same for a May baby...but I wanted to have a boy. This also happened except it was a girl. But since she's grown up, she is a complete tomboy.

I was very lucky with both pregnancies and was very much had disappointment every month trying to get pregnant, but I ended up getting pregnant when I expected. I'm not sure if that was manifested but I was 100% sure it would happen.

themothergoose · 22/10/2023 08:44

Lonesomefetter · 22/10/2023 00:28

Nah it's bollocks, do you think anyone who has terrible tragedy happen to them deserve it and brought it upon themselves? Because that's basically the end point of that idiotic line of thinking.

I am a bit lost. Why would you manifest a tragedy?

Thewal · 22/10/2023 08:39

Wolfen · 22/10/2023 08:20

Maybe we should do an experiment and give it a go?
Let's try manifesting something and see if we get it?
I'm happy to try Smile
I'll report back one day to let you know if it worked or not.

Ooh yes, I’ll do this! Although I have no idea how you do it and I’m so cynical it probably wouldn’t work for me even if it were real! What will you go for?

But what I don’t get is, if I manifest say, a new house plant, do I go out and buy one and that is the manifestation successful?

OP posts:
Thewal · 22/10/2023 08:31

Lochness1975 · 22/10/2023 08:17

I made a dream board, and succeed in 4 of things off my board- a job (I was on disability), a new home, a new car and getting engaged.

So how did you do it? Did you put those things on a board and look at them every day? And was it that you got a job and it led to the other 3?

OP posts:
Wolfen · 22/10/2023 08:20

Maybe we should do an experiment and give it a go?
Let's try manifesting something and see if we get it?
I'm happy to try Smile
I'll report back one day to let you know if it worked or not.

Sparklesocks · 22/10/2023 08:18

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 00:27

The flip side is victim blaming. So you manifested your cancer, SA, abuse, bankruptcy.

Yes, if you make a detailed plan, you're more likely to achieve it. If you focus on your goals you'll find more opportunities. That's all there is to it.

This - or did you not ‘manifest’ enough to stop them/make them end?

I don’t believe in manifestation but like others have said I believe having very detailed focus on a goal, and having the confidence/resilience to achieve it, can sometimes be a winning combination in terms of making things happen.

Lochness1975 · 22/10/2023 08:17

I made a dream board, and succeed in 4 of things off my board- a job (I was on disability), a new home, a new car and getting engaged.

Thewal · 22/10/2023 08:11

MassageForLife · 22/10/2023 04:29

Yes, it works. But not in some 'woo' way.

It works because people focus on what they want, and take the steps they need to take to get there.

Is it 100%? Nope. You have to believe it's possible because that's what keeps people focused on the end goal so they don't get swayed by or things. For example Neil Gaiman, when he was just about making ends meet as a writer, turned down a great job offer for a well known magazine, despite having a baby on the way. He knew it would take him away from his goal. That's the kind of focus that people should be trying to harness when they try manifesting - but a lot of people think it's just putting what you want out to the universe and hoping it will come back to you somehow.

God, and what if he hadn’t made it? The thing is, what if you aren’t that good? Like, if you were manifesting having a great pop career but you can’t sing? That’s a huge risk.

I was very lost watching ‘The Secret’ it seemed to be a lot of words that didn’t say a lot. And constant positivity sounds exhausting, but I’m not a positive person!

That’s why I wanted to ask here, to see if anyone in real life had actually decided that whilst working on their minimum wage job to manifest a mansion and it had actually appeared.

OP posts:
Anyotherdude · 22/10/2023 06:28

I think that “Manifestation” as a concept, is a way of people being slightly less truthful about how they achieved their success by actually using focus…

CheerfulYank · 22/10/2023 06:21

Oh, I believe in almost anything, depending on the day 🤣

With manifestation, I feel like it might “work” in a way…surely if you’re clear with yourself about what you want, you’ll be better at seeing the opportunities that lead to your wish when they arise?

Justleaveitblankthen · 22/10/2023 06:18

Utter bollocks.
The universe? The whole of it? 😂
Surely it has better things to do than hone in on some lass wanting a boy to fancy her for example.

How arrogant are we humans to think we even matter a jot?

Lastchancechica · 22/10/2023 06:14

Manifestos worked twice for me. Incredibly. Life changing. It’s about knowing and identifying what you need from life. It’s then about focus to get there. So not so much expecting the universe to deliver but being open to the changes you need to be fulfilled. It works.

Mothership4two · 22/10/2023 05:27

No. I think people who say this has happened only remember when what they want has "manifested" and forget about/discount all the times when they were disappointed - belief confirmation bias.

Relaxd · 22/10/2023 05:14

No! Although I believe positive thinking is more effective than negative thinking in making progress in one’s life. I think a big issue with manifestation is often people really want others to change and that is not something anyone can personally change. Learn to live with others, your life and make actual steps to get the changes you want don’t just expect it to land in your lap because of making wishes!!

DysonSpheres · 22/10/2023 04:57

Aldicrispsareshit · 22/10/2023 00:18

Manifestation
Prayer
Witchcraft
Asking the universe
"Putting it out there"

All different sides of the same dice. People's natural instinct is to ask for help when they're struggling and this is just a form of that. Do I believe it works? Sceptical.

No I wouldn't say prayer and/or witchcraft are the same as manifestation (though you get these online 'business guru''s' who promote them as such). Not that I've had any dealings with the latter directly but I've had friends who were involved in witchcraft and there is structure within it, the emphasis being on 'craft.' It is more than simply just writing lists and concentrating on what you want, as a witch or wizard contrary to TV programs.

Prayer isn't the same as manifestation as the premise is presumably communication with a being with some sort of personality, in which the answer if given at all, can be yes, no, wait, or something you didn't think you needed. It isn't just a vague concept of disembodied energy that you tap into.

I have had strange coincidences that I thought were incredible at the time, but later realised actually, perhaps weren't so unusual after time had passed.

I do think there is some sort of truth regarding attraction to and between people though, and I do believe if you're in a room full of people and are trying to be successful in some way, the people with similar energy are going to find you in that room too. This works negatively too. If you've been badly abused in the past, sexually, emotionally or physically it is simply AMAZING how people with bad motives are able to sniff that out and you attract them out of seeming nowhere.

MassageForLife · 22/10/2023 04:29

I'm not saying that Neil Gaiman was using manifesting btw...

MassageForLife · 22/10/2023 04:29

Yes, it works. But not in some 'woo' way.

It works because people focus on what they want, and take the steps they need to take to get there.

Is it 100%? Nope. You have to believe it's possible because that's what keeps people focused on the end goal so they don't get swayed by or things. For example Neil Gaiman, when he was just about making ends meet as a writer, turned down a great job offer for a well known magazine, despite having a baby on the way. He knew it would take him away from his goal. That's the kind of focus that people should be trying to harness when they try manifesting - but a lot of people think it's just putting what you want out to the universe and hoping it will come back to you somehow.

junbean · 22/10/2023 03:54

It's more of making lots of little choices that lead you to a bigger life change.

Someone once told me they manifested everything in their life. They were literally given everything they owned. I was amazed as I had to work so hard for everything. It was the first time I'd seen something like that. It opened my mind to possibilities other than being overworked. I since learned that networking, asking for things, giving to others, etc. are the actual real-life ways people are "manifesting".

So to me it's more about making connections that lead you to what you want. My example was getting things for free. Since then I've been given so much it's become a burden. But other things I've gotten no results in. Like a major rift in my family- nothing can save it. I lost my faith over it. In my experience manifesting is actually you forging your own path in ways you haven't tried yet, thus yielding positive results in the direction you're trying to go.

Wolfen · 22/10/2023 02:48

My friend is so into this but still hasn't found the man she's been trying to manifest for at least 10 years

MrsTerryPratchett · 22/10/2023 02:43

It's cobblers. However, there's pretty good evidence that successful business people fail more than unsuccessful ones. The successful ones just keep going. And hoping and wishful thinking is part of that.

So it looks like it works, but not in the way it's meant. To paraphrase Granny Weatherwax, people who wish upon a star and dream a dream will be beaten by people who get up early and work hard.

Swipe left for the next trending thread