Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you believe in manifestation?

214 replies

Thewal · 21/10/2023 23:49

I watched ‘The Secret’ today. It seemed to be mostly waffle with some random quotes thrown in, but from what I can gather it suggests that positive thinking and asking for things from the universe is what leads to ‘success’ and essentially getting what you want.

So I’d love to hear if you have ever manifested something into reality? How did you do it and how long did it take? Do you believe in it? And does the banishing of negative thoughts ever stress you out?

I just want to know what day to day life is like for people who practice this and if people have actually had something happen they put down to it?

OP posts:
hecameoutroaring · 22/10/2023 17:44

Imho, it's an example of confirmation bias. I used to follow 1 lady who was into the loa, till I realised she just tended to gloss over the parts of her life that hadnt gone to plan and only focused on the good bits "the universe" had given her.

Some people feel a need for control and have trouble accepting the random, sometimes cruel nature of life. It helps them to feel that they can believe in something that might give them the power to change things.

I think this kind of thinking is very pervasive, but can be quite harsh. As someone with infertility, I read a recent thread where a woman was struggling to get pregnant and was having issues with her partner. Cue loads of "the universe is trying to tell you something" and "you haven't got pregnant because the universe doesn't want you to have a baby with this man."

As if the universe is some kind of moral contraceptive force withholding pregnancy till you're in the "right" relationship. If that were true, there would be no divorced/ separated parents. But people ignore this logic in favour of their bias.

No-one on the thread batted an eyelid at these comments. Which is why I think this kind of thinking is more pervasive than a lot of ppl realise. I also remember a recent poster with cancer asking people not to comment that unkind people getting cancer was "karma" which she'd seen on a couple of recent threads. 😞

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 17:11

PonyPatter44 · 22/10/2023 17:07

It's rubbish. I manifested a pony for 14 years as a child - wished for one, begged for one, tried to negotiate for one... never got one.

Just like how Santa brings the best presents to the kids with rich parents.

PonyPatter44 · 22/10/2023 17:07

It's rubbish. I manifested a pony for 14 years as a child - wished for one, begged for one, tried to negotiate for one... never got one.

paradoxicalfrog · 22/10/2023 17:04

No. It's irrational.

CornishClott · 22/10/2023 16:55

@alwaysmovingforwards .

I just meant that positive people are luckier than average and a lot of things go their way .

RantyAnty · 22/10/2023 16:49

SallyWD · 22/10/2023 16:25

Before I'd ever heard of manifestation I'd noticed from a young age that people created their own little world around them. Their own lives, their own worlds reflected them as a person. Obviously there are things that just happen no matter how wonderful you are (cancer, tragedy, infertility etc) but generally I could look at everyone I know and see how they had come to live the lives they were living.
So I can certainly see how manifestation as a result of positive thinking can work.
However, I think some people can take it too far. I have a friend who sees manifestation as her sending out a plee to the universe and the universe responding. There are several things she plans to manifest for herself that just seem impossible to me.

This is largely true even without calling it a manifestation.

That quote about being the average of the 5 people you are around the most and the crabs in a bucket saying.

You hang out with lazy, druggie, slackers the chances of you becoming like that is fairly high.

If you decide you've had enough of the drugs, slacking life and decide to go to school and get a career, you simply won't be able to stay around these people as they'll try to pull you back into the bucket with them or they'll shun you for suddenly being too good for them.

That's just how life and social networks work.

SallyWD · 22/10/2023 16:49

Gidrich · 22/10/2023 16:29

Of course people create their own worlds to some extent.

That isn’t the result of manifesting, positive thinking or negative thinking- it’s the result of the decisions people have made in the circumstances they exist within.

Yes I agree but it goes further than just the decisions they make. It relates to their personalities, their outlook on life, how they treat other people etc.

Ramalangadingdong · 22/10/2023 16:33

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 00:27

The flip side is victim blaming. So you manifested your cancer, SA, abuse, bankruptcy.

Yes, if you make a detailed plan, you're more likely to achieve it. If you focus on your goals you'll find more opportunities. That's all there is to it.

I met someone who thought this. I was struck by how lazy a thought process it is. Her thinking was that those illnesses were a manifestation of the person’s evil behaviour or something.

Gidrich · 22/10/2023 16:29

SallyWD · 22/10/2023 16:25

Before I'd ever heard of manifestation I'd noticed from a young age that people created their own little world around them. Their own lives, their own worlds reflected them as a person. Obviously there are things that just happen no matter how wonderful you are (cancer, tragedy, infertility etc) but generally I could look at everyone I know and see how they had come to live the lives they were living.
So I can certainly see how manifestation as a result of positive thinking can work.
However, I think some people can take it too far. I have a friend who sees manifestation as her sending out a plee to the universe and the universe responding. There are several things she plans to manifest for herself that just seem impossible to me.

Of course people create their own worlds to some extent.

That isn’t the result of manifesting, positive thinking or negative thinking- it’s the result of the decisions people have made in the circumstances they exist within.

Festivemoose · 22/10/2023 16:26

My friend believes in all of that. She believes she manifested her baby by making a mood board and doing affirmations every day and willing it to happen. It was her first pregnancy and everything ran smoothly. At the same time I had just suffered my 5th missed miscarriage and had to listen to her bang on about her stupid little baby collage she did which apparently magicked her a healthy baby.

SallyWD · 22/10/2023 16:25

Before I'd ever heard of manifestation I'd noticed from a young age that people created their own little world around them. Their own lives, their own worlds reflected them as a person. Obviously there are things that just happen no matter how wonderful you are (cancer, tragedy, infertility etc) but generally I could look at everyone I know and see how they had come to live the lives they were living.
So I can certainly see how manifestation as a result of positive thinking can work.
However, I think some people can take it too far. I have a friend who sees manifestation as her sending out a plee to the universe and the universe responding. There are several things she plans to manifest for herself that just seem impossible to me.

RandomButtons · 22/10/2023 16:15

It’s total Confirmation bias.

”manifest” something and it happens? “See it works!”

”manifest” something and it doesn’t happen? Oh well you didn’t manifest hard enough, try harder tomorrow.

Gidrich · 22/10/2023 16:11

@themothergoose

I most certainly do not do those things-

I don’t need to have a life plan on a grand scale (beyond the day to day stuff)- I enjoy just seeing what life turns up.

I have never uttered a single affirmation- they are so unnecessary as to be meaningless.

I don’t push myself to ‘achieve’ things every day- there is no need, I’m grand as I am.

I don’t engage in toxic positivity, congratulate myself if I meet nice people or blame myself if I happen to meet some dickheads. I don’t have any issue with having some bad/unpositive feeling days- that is the unavoidable human condition. It’s healthy.

The outcome of my life is ongoing, as is everyone’s- you don’t follow this step by step plan to reach an ‘objectively successful life and then stop- that isn’t how the world works.

I’ve got a happy marriage, secure home, happy kid, money in the bank and good friends- I’m also a survivor of SA, chronically ill, and disable- none of it, good or bad is due to any kind of magical thinking or the universe rewarding me or withholding reward.

And if you don’t know that peddling ‘manifestation’ rubbish is a brilliant money spinner for unscrupulous people who take advantage of vulnerable people, then I suggest you go and find out about it before your naïveté becomes painful.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 22/10/2023 16:10

It's just the power of prayer rebranded.

So no. I don't believe in it. Anything that comes to be that I've wished for is coincidental.

CurlewKate · 22/10/2023 15:30

@Thewal-it's not a belief system- it's a bit of magical thinking that scammers have been making money out of the gullible with for ages. Google Louise Hay-she of you can cure your cancer if only you want to enough, and earlier Norman Vincent "if you're poor it's your own fault" Peele. Mock away!

Thewal · 22/10/2023 15:10

I w gone away and reflected a bit on this thread and actually feel really bad for starting it - because this is a bit of a belief system and I wouldn’t start a thread mocking anyone for their religious or spiritual beliefs.

But the reason why I started it was to see if there was any anecdotal evidence from the ‘common’ person rather than rich people who are being paid for be part of a documentary for a system that has made a lady very rich. It seems like there is manipulation going on surrounding this belief system.

OP posts:
themothergoose · 22/10/2023 14:47

Essenceofpetunia · 22/10/2023 14:28

If you drive around a car park for a while, there is an excellent chance a space will eventually become available. I don’t think it makes any difference what you’re thinking or saying while you drive round; or whether you’re being positive/negative. For example, I would usually be muttering ‘for FUCK’S sake, why can’t I just get a fucking space? I haven’t got time for this shit’, and lo and behold, one usually turns up shortly thereafter. 😂

Perhaps I could flog a range of books suggesting that people can make things happen by being irritable and negative?

It simply not how it works. It's not magic. You won't magic a car park space or anything for that matter.

themothergoose · 22/10/2023 14:46

Gidrich · 22/10/2023 12:41

🤦‍♀️

This is the rhetoric used to obscure the negativity and damage of ‘manifestation’ being peddled by mlms, self help gurus, instagrammers etc, who make enormous amounts of money from this rubbish.

There's no rhetoric - it's what most people do on a daily basis. Whatever you want to call it. praying, manifestation, meditation . . . most people don't buy books or pay for courses. I bet you do most of the above you just won't admit it.

Essenceofpetunia · 22/10/2023 14:28

If you drive around a car park for a while, there is an excellent chance a space will eventually become available. I don’t think it makes any difference what you’re thinking or saying while you drive round; or whether you’re being positive/negative. For example, I would usually be muttering ‘for FUCK’S sake, why can’t I just get a fucking space? I haven’t got time for this shit’, and lo and behold, one usually turns up shortly thereafter. 😂

Perhaps I could flog a range of books suggesting that people can make things happen by being irritable and negative?

LylaLee · 22/10/2023 14:22

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 22/10/2023 14:19

I will close my eyes and ask for what I want in as much detail as possible, so for example with the house I said out loud (just to myself) I want a two bedroom house in this area, it needs to have a garden and good neighbours' I said that every night for a several months before the house turned up though!

I also find asking the universe for small favours works as well, things like finding a parking space or your keys 😁 if I'm ever driving around a car park loosing the will because there is no where to park I'll say out loud 'please universe help me find somewhere to park' and it always works!

Funny how the universe does parking spaces, but the pleading of millions of suffering children (SA/war/cancer/etc.) and the pleading of their parents does nothing. Probably visualised the wrong thing.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 22/10/2023 14:19

uavdp · 22/10/2023 13:20

@Girliefriendlikespuppies how did you do this though? Did you imagine the exact house you wanted? Did you draw it, write about it? The same with the job, do you just ask out loud once or what? Genuinely interested!

I will close my eyes and ask for what I want in as much detail as possible, so for example with the house I said out loud (just to myself) I want a two bedroom house in this area, it needs to have a garden and good neighbours' I said that every night for a several months before the house turned up though!

I also find asking the universe for small favours works as well, things like finding a parking space or your keys 😁 if I'm ever driving around a car park loosing the will because there is no where to park I'll say out loud 'please universe help me find somewhere to park' and it always works!

alwaysmovingforwards · 22/10/2023 13:44

CornishClott · 22/10/2023 13:28

I do believe that happier positive people get treated better so they are more likely to get doors opened for them and people will help them more . Also I've noticed stuff that is out of control such as the weather etc favours them too ,

Sorry... you think the weather favours certain people?!?

😂😂😂

alwaysmovingforwards · 22/10/2023 13:40

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 22/10/2023 09:03

No of course it doesn't work. It's utter bollocks peddled to gullible fools, like all woo stuff. If feeling that you're 'manifesting' something makes you more focussed on your goal and makes you do things to achieve it, then of course that might make the thing more likely to happen, but that will be as a result of your efforts and changed attitude, not because you've persuaded the universe to magically produce what you wanted!

Agreed.
The sort of people suckered into this sort of thing normally lack decent anchor points in their own life and have their pockets picked buying these books or generating ad revenue by clicking on their links.
Direction and effort, coupled with self awareness and accountability with a dash of knowing how to maximise opportunities that present themselves is normally a better road to having the life you want 😂

CornishClott · 22/10/2023 13:28

I do believe that happier positive people get treated better so they are more likely to get doors opened for them and people will help them more . Also I've noticed stuff that is out of control such as the weather etc favours them too ,

uavdp · 22/10/2023 13:20

@Girliefriendlikespuppies how did you do this though? Did you imagine the exact house you wanted? Did you draw it, write about it? The same with the job, do you just ask out loud once or what? Genuinely interested!

Swipe left for the next trending thread