Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask step son to treat sister with a bit more respect?

66 replies

Habel · 21/10/2023 22:05

Ok so I know I’ll probably get bashed for this but basically just wanted to ask what are peoples general expectations are of how an older sibling should treat their younger sibling. I know siblings argue but it isn’t the arguing that bothers me. Just guess I’m more trying to find out if this is normal sibling behaviour?

I have been with my partner for almost 7 years, we have a 5 year old daughter and a 1 year old son. My partner also has an 11 year old son who we have to stay every Friday - Sunday. My daughter is besotted by her big brother, absolutely adores him - admittedly she can become a bit much as over excited 5 year olds can, but as soon as she does then we tell her to give him his space etc which she then does. I also get that 11 is getting to that age when they’re starting to become a bit to ‘cool’ for things. I just can’t help but let it get to me that he can’t EVER be nice to her. Not once said a nice word to her for about the last 2 years I’d say? Yet she counts down the days until he is here, absolutely cannot wait and runs to the door when I tell her he’s here - he walks in and she says hello and tries to give him a hug in which he just tells her to get off without even saying hello back to her. On the other hand though he goes to his little brother and makes a fuss of him. Then after that he goes on to his Nintendo and let’s his little brother watch him on it whilst I’m brushing my daughters hair, she looks over and see’s him having fun laughing with him and says ‘once you’re done brushing my hair I’m going to ask if I can watch too’ - I finish and so she runs over and just sits next to him in which he responds with ‘get out of my space’. I just can’t help but feel so defensive about the situation and just some guidance on if this is normal or not would be appreciated. She’s asked me in the past ‘why does he love little brother and not me’. Thing is I’m not looking at it through rose tinted glasses in the way that I think he wouldn’t dare find her annoying, but I just think to be SO cold to her all the time is surely a bit much. I did wonder if it could be a jealousy thing that she lives with their dad full time but then he isn’t like it with his little brother? I just know that tomorrow will come and they’ll say goodbye for another week and she will try hug him goodbye which won’t be reciprocated, he’ll tell her to get off and then go hug and kiss his little brother goodbye in front of her face. Just breaks my heart a bit - BUT is it normal?

OP posts:
Habel · 22/10/2023 08:56

@fgsstopbs We honestly don’t force him to spend time with her, like I said in original post I will always tell her to give him, his space. Little kids are annoying I do get that side of it! But surely it has to work both ways a little, she gets told to leave him alone but then he should be told to at least say hello when he walks through the door?
I think booking an activity like that sounds like a good idea though thank you!

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 22/10/2023 08:43

He needs to be civil but that is all, you can't force something but no he should not be rude either

AgentJohnson · 22/10/2023 08:43

Your stepson is being unkind and his father is a useless parent. If anyone needs a talking to, it’s his dad.

Housesellingnightmare · 22/10/2023 08:40

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

margotrose · 22/10/2023 08:38

My feeling is that the 5yo is very demanding of his time and attention whereas the 1yo is just "there" and not forcing himself on his brother.

It can be very difficult for adults to have patience with demanding children, let alone 11yo boys who just want to be left alone most of the time.

That's not meant as a criticism of your 5yo at all, but I do wonder if the her constant demands for hugs and attention are making him feel a bit overwhelmed and irritated, especially as you say he's a bit quieter and just likes to play his games etc.

Beezknees · 22/10/2023 08:35

Saying hello and being nice isn't too much of an ask. He should be doing that.

People talking about "siblings" though - he may not feel that sibling connection, as harsh as it sounds. I do not view my dad's other kids as my siblings, I am not close to them and never will be. It's not something you can force and unfortunately can sometimes be the case with half siblings.

fgsstopbs · 22/10/2023 08:29

Please don't try and force him to spend time with her. My eldest is now 12 and when his little sitters were born on his dads side he didn't interact with them as much as his dad and step mum wanted and it made him resent going to his dads in the end. Things are better now but my son dreaded going to his dads. Maybe try and book an activity born children enjoy and can do together.

Habel · 22/10/2023 08:24

@Frenchfancycat If I’m honest, I think you must be very switched on to gather that from my post because I could probably do a whole new post just on my DP’s parenting. He’s very much a Disney dad I would say, wanting to be their best mate and leaving all the parenting up to me - which again then leads me to be ‘evil step mum’ when I put my foot down. For example no bed times, whatever food they want, endless screen times…he’d let them do anything if I wasn’t around. He loves being the favourite and it causes problems!

DSS relationship with his mum is good, it’s mainly DP in contact with her as both me and her don’t drive and she lives 45 minutes away so DP does all the picking and dropping off, so there isn’t much need for me and her to be in contact. It’s all civil between all parties though. She’s had a few questionable partners in the past where DSS has mentioned he wasn’t a fan for different reasons but now she seems to be with someone who he really likes which is good.

I’m quite a bit younger then DP, I’m 26 and he’s 35.

OP posts:
sprigatito · 21/10/2023 23:34

Family therapy might help unpick why he feels so hostile towards her. Of course siblings squabble and he probably doesn't have much in common with her, but most siblings at these ages have some affection for each other and will get along some of the time.

I wonder whether he has subconsciously registered her arrival as marking the finality of his parents' split, and resentment has grown from this. It doesn't make sense to an adult because they split years before you had her, but children's minds are complicated. Some kids hold onto hope for years that their parents will get back together. There's probably also some jealousy that she gets to see Dad all the time. Again, he's probably not aware of why he feels that way; family therapy may really help.

Frenchfancycat · 21/10/2023 23:33

@Habel Thanks for frank response - I wasn't prying but thought you were evading the "OW" question (not that it matters really)

I think you have a DP problem not a DSS problem

From the sounds of it he is leaving you to parent "all his children" whilst you are the SAHM

There appears to be some unresolved issues that DSS may have picked up on

What is his relationship like with his DM? Are you in contact? Is it acrimonious or workable?

Can I ask ... are you much younger than your DP?

saraclara · 21/10/2023 23:33

I'm not sure why people are making excuses for him. It's not just that he's 11 and she's five and he doesn't have anything in common with her. He's being actively hurtful and unpleasant to her. Ignoring her when she greets him and constantly spurning her is deliberately cruel. He knows he's doing it and he should have been pulled up on it long ago, preferably by his father.

Siblings might quarrel or irritate each other, but his rejection is of a different level and is constant. His dad should recognise that its his job to teach his son good manners and a degree of empathy.

CoraPirbright · 21/10/2023 23:30

V few 11 year old boys are going to want to have much to do with a 5 year old girl but surely a basic level of civility is required? I think your partner is doing his son a disservice in not teaching him that a tiny bit of kindness in these situations is necessary.

cestlavielife · 21/10/2023 23:27

they broke up when DSS was around 1 and I met DP when DSS was 4!

So several ywars of being the sole attention? Then suddenly a new sibling....
You csn only finc put the why by your dp probing
Asking open ended, maybe he had siblings csn say "i remember growing up my sister was so annoying!" ....and listen to what dss has to say

needtonamechangeforthis1 · 21/10/2023 23:23

Just an idea but what about doing some family activities where they need to work together to succeed? Like family team building.
Something fun but challenging and away from screens. Perhaps high ropes, escape room for kids or even just a treasure hunt? Something a bit different that's interesting enough to keep Dss engaged and challenged. It still suitable for your Dd too.

BananaSpanner · 21/10/2023 23:19

Habel · 21/10/2023 23:13

@BananaSpanner oh I must of been being slow, didn’t realise sorry! Definitely wasn’t the cause of their break up, they broke up when DSS was around 1 and I met DP when DSS was 4!

Then I think he’s got no reasonable excuse for being so unkind. I have an older boy and a younger girl. He finds her annoying sometimes and they do fight but he doesn’t like to see her upset, will look out for her and is capable of enjoying her company. I don’t think what you describe is normal sibling behaviour.

WinterDeWinter · 21/10/2023 23:13

You need to set minimum kindness standards. It's very hard though. My DS resented my DD from the beginning and is also ND - his unkindness/'frankness' has had a terrible and lasting impact on her self-esteem.

Habel · 21/10/2023 23:13

@BananaSpanner oh I must of been being slow, didn’t realise sorry! Definitely wasn’t the cause of their break up, they broke up when DSS was around 1 and I met DP when DSS was 4!

OP posts:
IntheJingelyJangelyJungle · 21/10/2023 23:11

Good luck with it!

My last thought… I’d be careful with your terms and language when speaking to DP…

You used the expression re you SS ‘I care for him’ followed by ‘one of your own get hurt’.

DSS is one of your DPs ‘own’ (just as your shared children are) and I suspect he loves him just as he does your shared children.

Tread gently with all. Blending a family is complex!

BananaSpanner · 21/10/2023 23:10

You’re essentially being asked if you contributed to the break up of the relationship of his mother and father. In which case it may go some way to explaining the resentment towards your daughter even if he didn’t initially show it, it may have built over time. It does seem you are deliberately fielding this question.

He is being unkind though and needs to be told to make more effort. He’s punishing her for something.

Habel · 21/10/2023 23:10

@Consideringachange2023 Thank you. I do think what you have said is spot on, my view on it completely!

OP posts:
Habel · 21/10/2023 23:06

@Frenchfancycat I guess it’s hard to say, as I don’t think that’s something he would even be able to register properly at his age just yet. It could of I suppose? DD was a happy surprise and when we told him the news he was very excited at the time, actually more so then when we told him the news about our DS! They also used to get on well when they were both younger.
DP thinks it’s just siblings and doesn’t see why I let it bother me. He has spoke to him in the past briefly to just ask him to say hello when he comes through the door but nothing ever sinks in.
My partner works full time. I’m currently on a break from my university studies until our little boy is old enough to start the local preschool so now a SAHM. Partner picks DSS up every Friday on his way home from work, drops him home every Sunday - used to be every Monday but he was getting to tired before school. I do all housework during the week but we share on weekends.
I guess I’m just invested as I’m seeing it’s beginning to affect her, I’ve been staying out of it in terms of not saying anything at the time but have raised concerns over it with my partner like I said previously and he’s had a word but that’s as far as it’s fine. I don’t think I’m trying to hard when it’s something that could affect my daughters view on healthy relationships with her siblings, yet also aware that if I do try to hard then it could completely push it to far in the wrong direction.

OP posts:
Consideringachange2023 · 21/10/2023 23:03

i wouldn’t accept this, she is old enough to realise her brother doesn’t like her. He doesn’t have to “like” her and doesn’t have to spend time playing with her, but he absolutely should be kind and treat her with the same respect he’d treat a friends younger sister or a younger cousin.
Saying hi, asking how she is, letting her sit and watch games with him etc - this isn’t asking much and whilst totally get that an 11 year old isn’t interested in playing with a 5 year old, an 11 year old is old enough to know that his behaviour is mean and hurtful to a young child.

Your DH needs to talk to him, you need to spell it out that no, it’s not usual sibling behaviour. It’s actually quite unusual that he is ALWAYS unkind to her. That would worry me if it were my child - demonstrates a serious lack of empathy.

EvilElsa · 21/10/2023 22:51

I'd have no worries about telling him he was being rude and mean if I heard him treating her like crap. I'd do it with my own children, I'd certainly do it with step children as well. He is entitled to his own space and to play with who he likes, but he is clearly winding her up and being deliberately cruel and I wouldn't have that. He's old enough to be polite and say hello and be kind even if he doesn't want to hug her.

Habel · 21/10/2023 22:50

@IntheJingelyJangelyJungle Definitely agree that 5 year old girls can be more annoying than 1 year olds, but I do always always step in to let him have his space so he doesn’t actually end up interacting with her all that much -
He’s very much an electronics/gaming type of child, so it’s hard to get much out of him at times. Although definitely think what you said about car chats are a good time to talk! He lives around 45 minutes away and so will speak to my partner and see if he can try and find out if there’s anything ticking away and bothering him. And you are right, he’s not a bad kid, he’s never been physical, doesn’t get in trouble at school etc. And I do care a lot for him! I guess it’s just hard when you have to see one of your own get hurt though.
Thank you for your post, I’m going to speak to my partner and see if he can try to delve a little deeper.

OP posts:
jacks11 · 21/10/2023 22:47

I would suggest treading carefully here- not saying there is not an issue that needs to CR addressed, but I’d be careful as you could make things a whole lot worse if not handled carefully as I strongly suspect that there is a reason why he is behaving this way towards his sister. It may not be particularly nice, but there is usually a reason why children behave as they do. it seems like he resents her (as well as possibly finding her annoying/ not being particularly interested in her).

I don’t know why he might feel that way towards her- may be worth trying to figure it out (sensitively), if you can. Could he possibly associate her arrival with less time with dad, for instance? Your son, coming along much later, may not quite evoke the same feelings if that is the case. Equally, it could be that your DS is “easier” for him- little one’s are very different to 5 year old’s in terms of “input” required by an older sibling.