Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Need some reassurance that I'm not crazy...

263 replies

ScaredMamaLondon · 21/10/2023 20:33

Hello,
I am a Jewish mum of two small children.
I think I'm posting on here to get a reassurance that there are some good people in this world. I am terrified to be openly Jewish in this country at the moment and I am terrified for my children's future here. This week I was told by a nanny agency 'it will be very difficult to get a nanny to work for a jewish family'. The security patrolling makes me feel nauseous; my neighbour's son attends a jewish school and was kicked on the bus for his obviously jewish school uniform. We aren't obviously Jewish 'looking' - we are not religious but yet I don't feel at all safe. The pro-Palestinian rally today threw up pictures of burning stars of davids (the antizionism isn't antisemitism thing is basically an excuse for saying what you like about jews and getting away with it). Red paint splattered over local jewish primary schools (again if it's not antisemitism, what do we have to do with it) and on top of all of this, the sinking, dismal feeling that in Israel, the only place as a Jew I would imagine feeling safe, 1300+ civilians were massacred in their beds/kidnapped/gang raped/worse.

I feel sick. I feel we are utterly hated here and unsafe there.

When I see videos of TFL tube drivers joining in with palestinian chants as if its a football anthem and flags of Jihad being waved in London I do wonder if I've missed something here. At the recent vigil for the Israeli victims people stood in silence. Singing. Crying. Praying for peace. And today I witness the complete opposite. I didn't see one mention of peace. I only saw hatred.

Half my family are NHS doctors and surgeons. Teachers. Proud of our Jewishness and proud of our Britishness. Why is it as a Jewish person in the UK i feel so utterly isolated and depressed? Many clients and non jewish friends have sent wonderful messages of support so perhaps it is just the vocal minority but it's a scary one nonetheless. AIBU in thinking that life is completely terrifying right now?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
CLCB07 · 22/10/2023 18:17

I feel for you. People ripping down the pictures of hostages (some children) in London shocked me. The Israeli govt are awful and rightfully get criticised. But Hamas are the government of Gaza and have an appalling human rights record on their own people. Egypt lock their border with Gaza because of Hamas. Qatar, Iran and Turkey harbour the Hamas leadership. It isn't all down to Israel.

UpaladderwatchingTV · 22/10/2023 17:51

FlamingoFloss · 22/10/2023 00:54

I’m so sorry this is happening to you and so many other good people in the world. it is wrong in every single level. I, like many other people, am a live and let live person. I dont understand this hatred towards others. I honestly just do not get it and I wish it would stop. I can’t imagine how scared you must be feeling right now but I know it isn’t right

I completely agree with this

Tomatina · 22/10/2023 17:46

ScaredMamaLondon · 22/10/2023 09:25

You don't need to do anything. We already accept we only hear Jewish voices speaking loudly defending Jews. We don't have those expectations on our non jewish friends and neighbours. You only need to tell your jewish friends that you support their right to feel safe in England and you are there for them. That's it. xx

Just my opinion but I actually think you should have high expectations of the non-Jewish population in the UK. I think we should all speak up loud and vigorously against antisemitism whenever and wherever it tries to creep out, which it does with sickening regularity and under many guises.

One thing that really struck me just after the Hamas atrocity happened was that before the bodies had even been counted in Israel, let alone buried and mourned, we were watching big crowds out on the UK streets waving their 'Free Palestine' flags. It seemed tone-deaf at best. Personally I had not even begun to process the horror of the stories coming out of Israel at that point, and I wondered where were the demonstrators (not just Jewish) showing solidarity with the Israeli victims and shaming Hamas.

This whole conflict seems to attract people who take a binary, simplistic view on moral questions - people who don't see that it is quite possible to criticise the Netanyahu government while supporting Israel's right to exist and defend itself, or be prepared to condemn Hamas without reservation while insisting that the human rights of Palestinian civilians are prioritised in any counter attack against Hamas and its supporters in other countries.

PurpleBugz · 22/10/2023 17:26

I'm sorry you feel like this. I'm sorry the world is making you feel like this.

I've worked as a nanny and I'm not Jewish. I'd happily work for a Jewish family can't think of any nannies I know who would have a problem with it. It's disgusting you were told it would be a problem

tsmainsqueeze · 22/10/2023 16:25

I am not Jewish - i am disgusted that your community feels threatened in this / or any country in 2023.
There is nothing i can do to help you but i want you to know i really care and if its any comfort there is not one person i know that would behave in such an offensive way .
I am ashamed with what is happening , the world has a very strange vibe at the moment , i hope there are better times to come.

Ramalangadingdong · 22/10/2023 16:21

Burnoutwhat · 22/10/2023 16:19

I really feel for Jewish people in the uk and all over. It won't solve anything to hurt and intimidated Jewish civilians here. I do unfortunately think that recent events have stirred up anti semitic hate. Which is unacceptable. I'm sorry you de scared. It's awful to think we could be getting to a pre ww2 place where people are this open in hatred.

But I think you are wrong to then assume everyone who is supporting hates Jewish people and to equate anti zionism with anti senitism.

While the actions of hamas are disgusting I don't think you can seriously compare their postage taking to the actions (genocide) of Israel over years.

Agree. I hate being made to feel bad/wrong for supporting the plight of the Palestinian people.

itsmylife7 · 22/10/2023 16:21

Bunda · 22/10/2023 02:13

As a Muslim in a Jewish area we stand together now more than ever. This war is a political one, not a religious one. That's the part we must remember.

As it should be. 👏

AgnesX · 22/10/2023 16:20

I'm so sorry you're being made to feel like this.
Not everyone sees individuals as Jewish people or as a homogeneous lump and hates them.

Bettycrocker7 · 22/10/2023 16:19

Can i just ask all the posters whose " friends" are protesting/supporting the Free Palestine thing or have joined marches themselves, why did the beheading of babies and rapes of women not compel you or your friends to march ? You love a good ol march against bad governments don't you? But not the Palestinian government right? Asking for a "friend".

Burnoutwhat · 22/10/2023 16:19

I really feel for Jewish people in the uk and all over. It won't solve anything to hurt and intimidated Jewish civilians here. I do unfortunately think that recent events have stirred up anti semitic hate. Which is unacceptable. I'm sorry you de scared. It's awful to think we could be getting to a pre ww2 place where people are this open in hatred.

But I think you are wrong to then assume everyone who is supporting hates Jewish people and to equate anti zionism with anti senitism.

While the actions of hamas are disgusting I don't think you can seriously compare their postage taking to the actions (genocide) of Israel over years.

LoobyDop · 22/10/2023 16:17

It breaks my heart that you feel like this, OP, and that I can’t say that that I think that your fears are completely unfounded. I grew up with Jewish friends and have never considered Jewish people to be anything other than British people who happen to have a different religion. I’ve been hugely shocked and sickened over the last few years to see the increasing evidence that antisemitism never went away.

I don’t think it’s fair that Jewish people are expected to distance themselves from the Israeli government and put that disclosure in front of everything. You are entitled to hold your own views without your existence being threatened. And unlike many groups who claim that their very existence is threatened with little justification, it has happened before. It is crashingly stupid not to empathise with your fear that history could repeat itself.

But you asked for reassurance that not everyone is prepared to ignore, excuse or condone antisemitism, and not everyone sees you as the enemy. They don’t. There is love, and respect, and solidarity out here. I hope that this time passes quickly and that you and your family are safe, and feel safe again 💐

StarTrek6 · 22/10/2023 16:14

It's crazy - people are easily led.

TeaGinandFags · 22/10/2023 16:02

I don't understand what's going on but please accept love and hugs from me and probably Mumsnet as a whole.

The situation in the Middle East has been stirred up by some very accomplished spoon wielders. Why people over here feel the need to act like swine is beyond me.

CaroleSinger · 22/10/2023 15:44

I just feel many people might feel safer if all the public support wasn't all so publicly weighted toward only one demographic in this awful conflict. With shows of solidarity only coming from one side it's inevitable people will feel intimidated and afraid.

Gingercreams · 22/10/2023 15:40

My mother, who was an Irish Catholic, was a nanny for several Jewish families in the 1940s. It didn't concern her in the slightest. I am sorry you are feeling scared.

CaroleSinger · 22/10/2023 15:37

I hear you OP. My partner is a non religious Jew by birth. Even though he doesn't follow the faith he would still feel more comfortable if there was as large a public show of support coming from his own demographic, but there just isn't. Among all the massive pro Palestine demonstrations bringing out hundreds of thousands of people, what neither of us can understand is the relative silence from the peaceful pro Israel demonstrations. I think a few hundred turned up to the last one? Where are they? Where are the tens of thousands of peaceful pro Israel supporters? The imbalance is so overwhelmingly in one direction that the silence is becoming deafening.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 22/10/2023 15:27

@ScaredMamaLondon , I think you’ve mixed my comment up with someone else’s. For the record the Palestinians are governed by a terrorist organisation, if I told you graphically what I would do with Hamas MN would likely remove my comment. 🙏🏻

pandarific · 22/10/2023 11:08

@ScaredMamaLondon honestly. Hamas are pricks. No sane person thinks otherwise. However. The Israeli government are also pricks - for what they have been doing to Palestinians for decades.

If a ruling power targets and suppresses any group, that ruling power directly feeds the rise of terrorism within that group - that’s just how it works with human being.

Peace talks ARE required, because otherwise this cycle of violence and revenge will simply continue, because the people in charge on both sides are the people with guns. NOT normal people who just want to go about their daily lives and live a life free from violence and oppression. It’s not at that point yet - obviously. However, that is the only way out of this -countries and groups of all kinds funamentally need to get on with and respect their neighbours.

Re: the cycle of revenge and violence, one of the common slogans in the northern Irish peace process was ‘not in my name’, where the families of the dead made it clear they themselves and their loved ones would not condone further violence and killing.

I know it’s hard for you right now and my heart goes out to you - as it does also to the poor families stuck in areas which are being bombarded.

ScaredMamaLondon · 22/10/2023 10:53

@Lovepeaceunderstanding Thank you so much for your message, it means a lot. My only close Muslim friend posted on Instagram last week that Jews have a web of influence, wealth and power in high appalled me and I blocked him.
I think there is one main thing I want to ask you. You say you abhor the actions of the Israeli government. I don’t like the Israeli government much either.
but how do you feel about the Palestinian government who I and most of western civilisation would consider to be barbaric terrorists? Because you don’t mention abhorring them. This whole round of fighting came through their disgusting attack. They don’t care about their own civilians, that much is a fact. So I ask that when you condemn the Israeli government you think about why you don’t condemn the Palestinian government too (yes, their elected government!)
im sure it wasn’t on purpose. But it’s absolutely missing from your post. The Palestinians need a new government too.

OP posts:
Lovepeaceunderstanding · 22/10/2023 10:17

@ScaredMamaLondon , I support unequivocally the right of allJewish people to feel safe wherever they are including England. Like the majority of decent people I am here for you.
There’s a fairly consistent 20/25% of respondents who vote on this subject who in my opinion are clearly antisemitic. I note with interest that on this occasion they have left their vote but not had the courage to comment. They sicken me and you are right to be fearful of them and their propaganda tactics. ‘Where’s the proof’? They ask while repeating unsubstantiated claims from The Palestinian Authority as fact. Jew hatred has always puzzled me but it can be traced back through time.
I’m so sorry that you are feeling so scared. X

jolies1 · 22/10/2023 10:15

I am not commenting on this conflict, it is far too complex and emotive and there are far too many innocent victims suffering because of the actions of Hamas and the Israeli government.

However I would hope anyone who is protesting against the Israelis and repeating anti semitic rhetoric also protested against the US / UK government during the War On Terror in Afghanistan and Iraq after 9/11. A huge number of civilians were killed in those conflicts too.

pieinthesky10 · 22/10/2023 09:46

trampoline123 · Today 07:12

I'm really sorry you feel like this, I totally get why you're feeling worried about the future.

I for one, am not anti anyone unless they hurt people - live and let live as long as you don't hurt people is what I try and live by. I'm saying this as a white British woman living in the UK outskirts of London if that's relevant.

I can speak for all of my friendship group too who are like me.

I hope things get better for you OP.

THIS ^ l too am Christian British as are many of my friends we don't hate any race/nationality/religion as long as they live peacefully and promote peace..... please do not think you are hated in the UK by all.

Rabbitcar · 22/10/2023 09:42

I am so sorry for you going through this. It’s horrendous and those perpetrating this antisemitism should be ashamed of themselves. Jewish schoolchildren should not be held accountable for the actions of Israel.

I don’t think the marches should stop though. There are real reasons why people are appalled by Israel punishing ordinary Palestinians for the acts of the barbarous terrorists of Hamas. Those individuals who burn Stars of David etc definitely need to be dealt with/arrested etc but people should be allowed to protest against Israel and how the country has been treating Palestine for decades.

We are Muslims and I am disgusted by any Jewish people being terrorised or abused and will always speak up against this and call out anti semitism. We are all human beings. My husband checked on our Jewish neighbours to offer them condolences and we go out for dinner with our Jewish friends. But I still abhor the actions of Israel.

fwiw my openly Muslim, headscarf wearing relatives are getting lots of abuse too, though not physical yet. They always have since 9/11 though - looking different is not great, and there is a lot of racism against brown people in many parts of the country, esp Muslims.

I really hope you and your community can be safe and well, OP.

IDriveMySupernova · 22/10/2023 09:41

I'll also add that when people call for a Ceasefire they do not mention the 201 hostages Hamas is holding.

I’ve noticed this, and made the same point to my friend yesterday. It’s as if they’ve forgotten. Deliberately, perhaps, because when you ask them what the Israeli gov are supposed to do about this, they don’t have an answer. Just buzzwords. Or something something ‘but oppression led to this!!1!’

I’m so sorry you’re experiencing this level of fear just going about your life. It’s such a sad situation all around.

FortunataTagnips · 22/10/2023 09:40

YANBU at all, OP. I hate that my daughter’s school has to have security, while also worrying that it isn’t enough.

Swipe left for the next trending thread