Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Need some reassurance that I'm not crazy...

263 replies

ScaredMamaLondon · 21/10/2023 20:33

Hello,
I am a Jewish mum of two small children.
I think I'm posting on here to get a reassurance that there are some good people in this world. I am terrified to be openly Jewish in this country at the moment and I am terrified for my children's future here. This week I was told by a nanny agency 'it will be very difficult to get a nanny to work for a jewish family'. The security patrolling makes me feel nauseous; my neighbour's son attends a jewish school and was kicked on the bus for his obviously jewish school uniform. We aren't obviously Jewish 'looking' - we are not religious but yet I don't feel at all safe. The pro-Palestinian rally today threw up pictures of burning stars of davids (the antizionism isn't antisemitism thing is basically an excuse for saying what you like about jews and getting away with it). Red paint splattered over local jewish primary schools (again if it's not antisemitism, what do we have to do with it) and on top of all of this, the sinking, dismal feeling that in Israel, the only place as a Jew I would imagine feeling safe, 1300+ civilians were massacred in their beds/kidnapped/gang raped/worse.

I feel sick. I feel we are utterly hated here and unsafe there.

When I see videos of TFL tube drivers joining in with palestinian chants as if its a football anthem and flags of Jihad being waved in London I do wonder if I've missed something here. At the recent vigil for the Israeli victims people stood in silence. Singing. Crying. Praying for peace. And today I witness the complete opposite. I didn't see one mention of peace. I only saw hatred.

Half my family are NHS doctors and surgeons. Teachers. Proud of our Jewishness and proud of our Britishness. Why is it as a Jewish person in the UK i feel so utterly isolated and depressed? Many clients and non jewish friends have sent wonderful messages of support so perhaps it is just the vocal minority but it's a scary one nonetheless. AIBU in thinking that life is completely terrifying right now?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
honestlyseriously · 23/10/2023 12:26

I'm not Jewish. I have sympathy for the Palestinian people in Gaza. I am outraged at the behaviour of some parts of the pro-Palestine communities in this country and cannot believe it is being condoned. I am so sorry you are experiencing this.

Peaceful protest is one thing but to effectively openly bring extremism to the streets is quite another.

Exasperateddonut · 23/10/2023 08:22

Sadly the gobshites tend to make the most noise.

I don’t do religion- firmly believe the world would be a better place without it. What I do stand for is peace, fairness and society. None of those things are in abundance right now.

I hope your family has a trouble free week. I couldn’t care less what you follow or where your roots lie- your children deserve an education free of hassle and you a life free of worry. I’m disgusted at how people are behaving at every level.

No matter which side you are on, the victims are someone’s child, mother, brother. The poor poor civilians being caught up in this is inexcusable. My heart goes out to everyone affected by the actions and choices of others.

ScaredMamaLondon · 23/10/2023 07:22

@MooFroo Again when we talk about murders you could also be talking about Israelis being murdered in their beds last weekend. but you’re not. The rest has been a targeted retaliation. Hamas knew by committing such atrocities its own people would be collateral.
your “but” has provided me with all the justification I knew I would hear at some point on this thread.

OP posts:
IrishLondoner · 23/10/2023 05:34

MooFroo · 23/10/2023 04:01

I saw the same quote and thought it referred to the innocent Palestinians civilians being openly murdered and forced out of their homes and country?

horrific situation for all the innocents involved, but none more so than those being bombed and persecuted out of their homeland

IrishLondoner · Today 05:31

“horrific situation for all the innocents involved, but none more so than those being bombed and persecuted out of their homeland”

The problem is the “but” … it turns a sympathetic response into a competition about which innocent civilian has suffered more . Why is it so difficult for you to empathise with the fears of the OP without the “but”
Did you include the “but” when discussing atrocities else where? An atrocity is an atrocity. Your “but” seems an attempt to down play it .
Shameful.

IrishLondoner · 23/10/2023 05:31

“horrific situation for all the innocents involved, but none more so than those being bombed and persecuted out of their homeland”

The problem is the “but” … it turns a sympathetic response into a competition about which innocent civilian has suffered more . Why is it so difficult for you to empathise with the fears of the OP without the “but”
Did you include the “but” when discussing atrocities else where? An atrocity is an atrocity. Your “but” seems an attempt to down play it .
Shameful.

Finlesswonder · 23/10/2023 04:29

YANBU . How did our tolerant country get to this place

Very high levels of immigration from traditionally antisemitic nations?

MooFroo · 23/10/2023 04:01

Isthisexpected · 22/10/2023 06:38

I saw a quote that summed up my sentiments "we said never again just one lifetime ago, how short our memories are".

^ this is very powerful.

I'm sorry OP. I can't begin to imagine the pain and fear and sadness. I hope for an end to this awful time. I hope for tolerance and safety for all including you and your family.

I saw the same quote and thought it referred to the innocent Palestinians civilians being openly murdered and forced out of their homes and country?

horrific situation for all the innocents involved, but none more so than those being bombed and persecuted out of their homeland

BannedfromChristmas · 23/10/2023 03:25

I hate what Hammas are doing to Jewish people but I also feel that it's not okay to starve and bomb Palestinian people from their homes. Despicable humans of any persuasion will use religion as an excuse to persecute others. I have to believe that as humans as much as we have the capacity for self destruction, we all have the capacity to thrive together. We should feel safe going about our daily lives whether we are Jewish, Muslim, Christian etc. Its rough OP and I'm sorry you feel unsafe.

Changednamesforthis22 · 23/10/2023 01:17

I'm really sorry for what you're going through.
For what it's worth I'm from a white christian background and my family/friends have expressed strong opinions about the politics of the conflict over the last week or so, but they always acknowledge that innocent people are suffering on both sides. I don't see how anyone couldn't know that deep down.

Trulywonderful · 23/10/2023 00:53

Burnoutwhat · 22/10/2023 16:19

I really feel for Jewish people in the uk and all over. It won't solve anything to hurt and intimidated Jewish civilians here. I do unfortunately think that recent events have stirred up anti semitic hate. Which is unacceptable. I'm sorry you de scared. It's awful to think we could be getting to a pre ww2 place where people are this open in hatred.

But I think you are wrong to then assume everyone who is supporting hates Jewish people and to equate anti zionism with anti senitism.

While the actions of hamas are disgusting I don't think you can seriously compare their postage taking to the actions (genocide) of Israel over years.

The population growth rate for Israeli and Palestinians has been roughly the same for the last 50 years. In fact in recent years the Palestinian rate has been move.
If Israel has been commiting genocide all this time pigging bad at it!

Maybe learn the meaning of genocide and lot at the facts. Also stop repeating stuff you see people say on social media or whatever until you know if it is true.

Trulywonderful · 23/10/2023 00:21

Bettycrocker7 · 22/10/2023 16:19

Can i just ask all the posters whose " friends" are protesting/supporting the Free Palestine thing or have joined marches themselves, why did the beheading of babies and rapes of women not compel you or your friends to march ? You love a good ol march against bad governments don't you? But not the Palestinian government right? Asking for a "friend".

Edited

Or why they didn't add to their march tributes to the pogrom victims?

Or why they didn't add to their march signs asking for the hostages (30 of which are children) to be released?

If people are genuinely wanting peace and concerned about all innocent people those things would appeared on the march. Else people should have all been calling that out on Saturday.

fuckssaaaaake · 23/10/2023 00:16

If anyone asks me what I'm doing for Xmas , normally I say "not a lot as I'm Jewish but we will do xyz like we always do" now I'll just lie

Aria999 · 22/10/2023 23:55

OP I agree with you. I am not Jewish but have been appalled at the attitude of so many in the face of such atrocities.

This thread makes me feel a bit better.

Stay safe out there 😢

Dilbertian · 22/10/2023 23:41

However when the OP sees an out pouring of support for ordinary Palestinian citizens or criticism of the Israeli government she seems too see this as an out pouring of hate against the Jewish people and this is not the case at all.

That is because it is always accompanied by an outpouring of hatred against Jewish people. Even if those demonstrating aren't expressing hatred of Jews, others piggyback their hatred onto it.

mollyfolk · 22/10/2023 23:11

Dilbertian · 22/10/2023 08:12

I would just ask you to consider that many people - including Jewish people around the world and Israelis themselves- are anti the occupation and critical of the current Israeli government and not against Jewish people in any way. I think you need to seperate the people being vocal about what Israel is doing wrong - which includes the UN, the WHO and human rights organizations- from people who use this moment to be antisemitic.

I would just ask you to consider that many people are nonetheless attacking Jews over this.

We're horrified that schools in America need security guards and police presence, yet not that the only schools in the UK that need the same are the Jewish schools. Why not?

Don't ask me to separate these people when they are not separating us. Don't dismiss a genuine fear based on the experience of Jewish people, just because you are able to separate the issues. The people who are behaving this way are not separating the issues.

i 100% agree with you. Some People are clearly behaving this way and attacking Jews. And this is completely wrong and that seems to be a point that we can all agree on. However when the OP sees an out pouring of support for ordinary Palestinian citizens or criticism of the Israeli government she seems too see this as an out pouring of hate against the Jewish people and this is not the case at all.

mollyfolk · 22/10/2023 22:59

Bettycrocker7 · 22/10/2023 16:19

Can i just ask all the posters whose " friends" are protesting/supporting the Free Palestine thing or have joined marches themselves, why did the beheading of babies and rapes of women not compel you or your friends to march ? You love a good ol march against bad governments don't you? But not the Palestinian government right? Asking for a "friend".

Edited

the Marches and acts of solidarity are strategic. They are organized activism - the goal (of the organisers) is to put pressure of the EU, the Uk and the US governments to stop clapping on the Israeli authorities as they blatantly disregard international law. There is little support for Hamas - they aren’t even considered a government by western leaders - they are designated a terrorist group.

Gifgirl · 22/10/2023 21:59

I'm so sorry that you are feeling like this.

Just to reassure you on one of your points; I am a nanny. I have been a nanny for over 25 years and I know and have known LOTS of nannies. I can tell you that I honestly and truly believe that not one of those nannies would ever, ever refuse to work for a Jewish family. The agency that told you that none of their registered nannies would work for you are talking the biggest load of crap. It would be good to know which agency it was!

Sending so much love.

ScaredMamaLondon · 22/10/2023 21:08

Just to say thank you to you all. After seeing the hate in the streets and on social media I;ve been on the verge of tears for days. This has made me think there are some really good people in the world. Maybe we just keep hearing from the violent, loud minority. xx

OP posts:
Mydogmybestfriend · 22/10/2023 20:53

It's always the innocent people that suffer in wars

Littlelucas · 22/10/2023 20:38

Just posting in solidarity OP.

Several cars surrounding trafalgar square with people shouting 'free free Palestine. Fuck you Jews'. Met police obviously utterly useless.

Please try to remember though that this is a small minority of vile people, the vast majority would never think like this an would denounce this behaviour. Unfortunately a vigil for the Jewish hostages is going to attract a few disgusting anti-Semitic people, same as a feminist march will attract a few rabid TRA types.

Not proposing to understand how you must be feeling at the moment at all but please don’t think this is how the general public think or feel. Everyone I’ve spoken to about it (all non-Jewish, white Brits) think that the Hamas terrorist attack was an atrocity.

roarrfeckingroar · 22/10/2023 20:13

Very very sorry you're going through this OP. Many of us support the Jewish community 100% - including the right of Israel to defend its borders against constant terrorist onslaught.

disneyprincess87 · 22/10/2023 19:36

I am so sorry that this is happening to you. We are standing next to you in support xx

AbbeyGailsParty · 22/10/2023 19:36

It’s awful that anyone has to be scared for their safety and that of their family, anywhere. I can’t think of any nationality or religion, or it’s followers, that I hate or even mildly dislike. I do hate violence, war and cruelty. I really think if all the men in the Middle East could be locked up for a month the woman would get it all sorted, fairly and sensibly. Pity that can’t happen.

ScaredMamaLondon · 22/10/2023 19:34

@Tomatina You are so right. I think that's what blew my mind. Israel had not even done anything besides figure out how many people had been murdered/injured/gang raped/beheaded and within a few hours there are Pro Palestinian rallies cheering, jeering and handing out sweets to their kids.
Honestly, I'm pretty left wing. As I said above I think anyone is better for the (majority secular/left wing) country that is Israel. But oh my goodness this has nothing to do with Bibi Netanyahu. You are kidding yourselves if you think that's why people are jeering the deaths of Israelis outside the Israeli embassy the NIGHT of these attacks. They just hate Jews. One Jewish death is one too few for them.
And for anyone who seems to think an Israeli left wing government would be responding all too differently - the whole country is lost at the idea their security proved to be utterly useless and Hamas isn't suddenly going to change its charter - calling for the international genocide of all Jews - if the Israelis suddenly had a more tolerant prime minister. Come on! There are just no negotiations to be had. How do you negotiate with someone who wants all your people dead?! What's worrying Israel is a democracy, there will be a new leader very very soon with a new tack. But Hamas isn't going anywhere.

Anyway, this wasn't meant to be a rant about the Middle East. It was more about how shocked I am when it spills into this country and people wave jihadi flags and talk about throwing jews into the bin. Our government is useless, TFL are useless, the London is mayor is useless. Losing faith, but you all have helped me restore it through your very kind and supportive words. xx

OP posts:
ScaredMamaLondon · 22/10/2023 19:27

@Burnoutwhat I don't think anyone is making you feel bad about the plight of palestinians. if you think that's the point i was making i wasn't.
I merely asked why pro palestinian marches can't be about palestinian leadership...ever. They have to be so anti Israel and in the case of about 20% of the people there/chants this then turns into utterly objective anti-jewish slurs, words, chants, posters and ill feeling. It is a disgrace.
I don't know where 'feeling bad' for palestinian children comes in. Why do you/anyone feel the need to make this so binary? Today there was a vigil for Israelis asking for the 200+ hostages back and mourning the murder of so many babies/children/young people. There was no anti muslim hate. There was no screaming. There was no burning flags. The plight of the Palestinian children was mentioned several times in speeches. The only singing was a song for peace.
And you know what broke the silence? Several cars surrounding trafalgar square with people shouting 'free free Palestine. Fuck you Jews'. Met police obviously utterly useless.
But there you go. No one feels bad about your feeling for Palestinian civilians. Most jews agree. All Jews want is some recognition for their own horrific trauma over the past two weeks which many people seem to have oddly neglected. I'll rephrase that. It isn't odd. There's a lot of people in this country very very comfortable with a touch of Jew hate.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread