Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Need some reassurance that I'm not crazy...

263 replies

ScaredMamaLondon · 21/10/2023 20:33

Hello,
I am a Jewish mum of two small children.
I think I'm posting on here to get a reassurance that there are some good people in this world. I am terrified to be openly Jewish in this country at the moment and I am terrified for my children's future here. This week I was told by a nanny agency 'it will be very difficult to get a nanny to work for a jewish family'. The security patrolling makes me feel nauseous; my neighbour's son attends a jewish school and was kicked on the bus for his obviously jewish school uniform. We aren't obviously Jewish 'looking' - we are not religious but yet I don't feel at all safe. The pro-Palestinian rally today threw up pictures of burning stars of davids (the antizionism isn't antisemitism thing is basically an excuse for saying what you like about jews and getting away with it). Red paint splattered over local jewish primary schools (again if it's not antisemitism, what do we have to do with it) and on top of all of this, the sinking, dismal feeling that in Israel, the only place as a Jew I would imagine feeling safe, 1300+ civilians were massacred in their beds/kidnapped/gang raped/worse.

I feel sick. I feel we are utterly hated here and unsafe there.

When I see videos of TFL tube drivers joining in with palestinian chants as if its a football anthem and flags of Jihad being waved in London I do wonder if I've missed something here. At the recent vigil for the Israeli victims people stood in silence. Singing. Crying. Praying for peace. And today I witness the complete opposite. I didn't see one mention of peace. I only saw hatred.

Half my family are NHS doctors and surgeons. Teachers. Proud of our Jewishness and proud of our Britishness. Why is it as a Jewish person in the UK i feel so utterly isolated and depressed? Many clients and non jewish friends have sent wonderful messages of support so perhaps it is just the vocal minority but it's a scary one nonetheless. AIBU in thinking that life is completely terrifying right now?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
babetyouknow · 23/10/2023 14:14

You denied things that we know have happened, that is not showing respect. Israeli soldiers have routinely killed Palestinian children. They have shot them in the back. They have shot them for throwing stones. In June this year, Israeli soldiers shot and killed a two year old.

I have no anger for you. I have anger for the Israeli soldiers that kill children and their government which allows them too. Palestinian children are dying today, in large numbers.
Forgive me if I have more concern for them than for you, in your safe home in your safe country where your children will come home to you safe tonight, unlike many palestinian children.

ScaredMamaLondon · 23/10/2023 14:07

@babetyouknow after everything you've read from me on here and what my concerns are I think it's fair to say I'm not closing my eyes to anything. Your response isn't a 'good look' as you call it. Please have some respect. I have shown immense respect for civilians dying on both sides (you clearly didn't read my posts). The Human Rights Watch's latest report was written by Omar Shakir who heads the BDS movement and doesn't mention Hamas's regular barrages of rockets nor its attacks on its own people. It is a pile of rubbish in most academics' eyes.

What an aggressive response. Wow. Take that anger out on someone else. Would advise a pro-Palestinian rally. Everyone screams and shouts against Jews there. Then we can talk about what's a 'good look'.

Telling me to read some facts. Jesus.

OP posts:
babetyouknow · 23/10/2023 13:58

I'd be interested to find your evidence that the attacks on these palestinians are indiscriminate (you are wrong) and Israelis are shooting palestinian children in the back (what on earth are you reading).

Ask Amnesty International , and Human Rights Watch. Ask the UN.

I'm reading facts, you might want to try it. Closing your eyes to atrocities while complaining how unsafe you feel, thousands of miles away from those dying, is not a good look.

etmoietmoietmoi · 23/10/2023 13:54

Worddance · 23/10/2023 13:39

I'm really sorry for what you're going through. That's not right. What happened in Israel was appalling.

Can your community please exert whatever influence you have to end the atrocious acts occurring in Gaza - this is the only response that I think will have an impact on what you're experiencing as the situation is truly dire for Palestinians and this is driving the hate. You should not have to - but there's a lot going on that shouldn't be happening right now.

Can your community please exert whatever influence you have to end the atrocious acts occurring in Gaza

FFS.

etmoietmoietmoi · 23/10/2023 13:53

@RubyGemStone Sorry about the experience you've had with your neighbour. I identify with so much of what you've written, including similar conversations at work. I actually avoided a work gathering last week because, as you say, the squirming.

Ethnically Jewish but have never practised and have a non-Jewish DH and kids but am feeling very, very uncomfortable and have this sudden urge to pack-up and move to one of the unsafest countries in the world - a country whose current political regime I despise, a country I've never actually considered visiting, let alone move to. I do feel I'd like to reconnect in some way with a Jewish community after the last couple of weeks, and it's not a feeling I've really had before. My DH asked me the other day if I would feel safer in London, closer to an actual Jewish community (apart from family I'm not part of one at all really). But going by some of the stories from London-based Jewish MN'ers, it doesn't sound like somewhere I want to be just now, although have lived there in the past and genuinely love the city. We also talked about France (am half-French) but ethnic and racial tensions are even worse there and have been for some time, including antisemitic murders. There was a story in the French press at the weekend of an attempted arson attack on an 80 year old Jewish couple in Paris - they literally set fire to the entrance of the couple's flat. It's really floored me.

So, where to go...? It just feels quite precarious for us in the UK and I'm not sure what the actual tipping point will be.

ScaredMamaLondon · 23/10/2023 13:51

@Whatifitallgoesright This is an utterly bizarre response. Knew there would be a few of these today. I'm hoping it's down to ignorance rather than entrenched antisemitism.

Can my 'community' please exert its 'influence' over the 'atrocious acts in Gaza'. And then we will stop being punished here?Because we are only the victims of antisemitism because of the Israeli government?

I am appalled.

What a statement. I wouldn't even know where to begin. Would I - a Jewish teacher from North London be able to singlehandedly manage a ceasefire.
Let me put it a different way.

Could the millions and millions of Muslims around the world exert their influence and tell Hamas to release hostages, stop shooting at jewish people day in day out with their f*ing rockets? While they're at it could they tell Hamas they've broken every ceasefire ever and maybe that might be why Israel won't be bothering with one anytime soon - not until they've destroyed the brutal murderers who massacred as many civilians as possible. You don't mention this. Would that combat Islamophobia too?

So before I, that very very influential Jewish person from North London, starts exerting my influence over the IDF, why don't you start holding Muslims accountable for their terrorists and war crimes too?

That last question was rhetorical by the way. I wouldn't expect Muslims here to feel they need to condemn the actions of Hamas every eight seconds. But hopefully highlights the utter disgrace of this comment.

As I said, I hope this is comment is just down to ignorance. Disgusted.

OP posts:
IrishLondoner · 23/10/2023 13:48

I only came on here to say to the OP and other Jewish people that many non Jews see and hear the anti semitism and we are so sorry and horrified.
I’m coming off now because there are some people who just want to use the horror to make a political point. no one is going to be persuaded on a forum like this and I don’t want to get sucked into pointless exchanges .

Echobelly · 23/10/2023 13:45

I'm Jewish and while it's a bad situation and depressing, I wouldn't see it as terrifying and I don't feel unsafe in this country. If we were 'visibly' Jewish, like orthodox or kids at a Jewish school (mine were at a Jewish primary but not secondary, though oldest may join a Jewish 6th form next year), I would feel more concerned I am sure, but still not 'escaping the country' sort of worry.

I don't at all feel most or even many people hate Jews - I feel a lot of people don't know us and don't understand us, but the hate is a vocal few and does not at all reflect the majority feeling. I think most people do understand that being Jewish doesn't mean you support what's being done to the Palestinian people - but there is a minority who will take that anger out on Jews, sadly.

ScaredMamaLondon · 23/10/2023 13:44

@babetyouknow an interesting response.

  1. when Israel withdrew from Gaza in 2005 it left everything - the most ridiculous resources for the Palestinians to self govern. Instead Hamas were 'elected' a year later and spent all the money (and continue to spend UN/WHO money on terror tunnels, rockets etc). Egypt forms 50% of the blockade - the Raffah gate is closed 99.9% of the time, whereas the Israeli gates are opened to Gazans can enter Israel with work permits where they are paid by law the same wage as Israelis. Indeed, when bodies were collected in a few of the kibbutzes after the attacks on October 7 they found a few of these work permits (I'm sure their Israeli employers are thrilled at the thought of this)
  2. Hamas did this knowing their people would be collateral. The Palestinian women and children have the most tragic of lives. Their own leadership couldn't care if they live or starve and die. Their lack of medical infrastructure and lack of education is 100% down to their leadership. It is not the same in West Bank or East Jerusalem where proper schooling and medical aid exists. Hamas hates his own people. Indeed just this week the UN reported that 20-25% of Hamas's constant stream of rockets falls short and lands on their own civilians in Gaza. How utterly pathetic and tragic. Imagine knowing the people who are meant to protecting you hate you that much.

So feel their plight and believe me I do too. But to say this is all 'israel's fault' is beyond me.
I'd be interested to find your evidence that the attacks on these palestinians are indiscriminate (you are wrong) and Israelis are shooting palestinian children in the back (what on earth are you reading).

I don't really care for me or anyone else on this thread being called 'idiotic' as you did above. There is no need to be rude.

This was about the conflict spilling over into this country and how scared I am about it to which your response is - 'who cares? think about how bad it is for the palestinian children?' What a bizarre argument to make. Your lack of compassion and basic humanity (and basic politeness) is noteworthy. Good luck to you!

OP posts:
Whatifitallgoesright · 23/10/2023 13:40

I'm so sorry you are feeling such fear. It is so wrong. I feel like writing to the local Jewish organisation and just saying I support them and feel sympathy but it feels such a useless thing to do. It must be so stressful and frightening for your family and Jewish friends and my thoughts are with you. Please keep posting on here. People ARE with you.

Worddance · 23/10/2023 13:39

I'm really sorry for what you're going through. That's not right. What happened in Israel was appalling.

Can your community please exert whatever influence you have to end the atrocious acts occurring in Gaza - this is the only response that I think will have an impact on what you're experiencing as the situation is truly dire for Palestinians and this is driving the hate. You should not have to - but there's a lot going on that shouldn't be happening right now.

TeeedleDum · 23/10/2023 13:35

I'm really sorry you feel unsafe and unsupported. Sending lots of love

GreyhpundGirl · 23/10/2023 13:33

It is awful. My grandfather and his family left Germany in the 30s - they were secular Jews. They anglicised their name when they came here. I wasn't aware of his background until my mum sat us down and told us (he'd died years before when I was about 10). As a history teacher, I am keenly aware of what discrimination can lead to. I'm so sorry you are experiencing this, the human race can be really cruddy at times.

girlwhowearsglasses · 23/10/2023 13:31

Sorry for all of this OP.

I was concerned that a nanny agency felt they could say it would be ‘difficult to get a nanny for a Jewish family’ - surely they can’t be allowed to say things like that.. barefaced racism. I don’t know who oversees childcare agencies but racism must be well against any code of conduct.

Fernticket · 23/10/2023 13:31

junbean · 22/10/2023 01:41

I'm not Jewish or even a part of any type of oppressed people group (besides being a woman) and that sounds utterly terrifying. It makes me very sick to read. I'm literally crying just reading your post. I'm so sorry you're going through this and I hope it ends very soon. There are a LOT of people who want peace. You aren't alone and you aren't hated by everyone. I wish there was something I could do, I would do it. I've always felt this way- ever since I first learned about antisemitism as a child. No one should be afraid to exist.

This. We need to be united against all the hatred going on at the moment in this country. OP my thoughts and prayers 🙏 are with you. XX

babetyouknow · 23/10/2023 13:29

IrishLondoner · 23/10/2023 12:58

It’s the context . Absolutely fine to criticise Israeli actions but if you choose to criticise Israel after an atrocity like October8th it sounds as if you are an apologist for Hamas.

There is NO Justification for Hamas’ actions on October 8th . Hamas knew what they were doing. They don’t care about the Palestinians . They knew that kidnapping children would inflame the situation to unbearable proportions.
Hamas are to blame for the current suffering of the Palestinians.

It's just not that simple. It's idiotic to suggest it is. As if that happened, out of nowhere, and not caused by everything that went before. As if 16 years of Israels illegal blockade of Gaza and the atrocities they have commited against innocent children didn't lead right here.

I'm not an apologist for Hamas. I'm one of the people who are stating the truth: that Israel is committing war crimes. Talking about the hostages while glossing over the indsicriminate attacks on civilians and the systematic wiping out of entire families.

October 8th was horrific. But so was the many years leading up it, when Israeli soldiers repeatedly shot children in the back and got away with it every time.

You can't shut your eyes to the reality. You feel unsafe in the UK? How have Palestinian children felt their entire lives living in Gaza, knowing they could be killed at any time?

PurpleChrayne · 23/10/2023 13:22

Now is the time to spend amongst your own people

This.

I'm embracing Shul life and my Jewish friends. My non-Jewish friends - some of whom I've known for decades - have been silent. No messages of support, no questions about how my friends and family in Israel are doing (shit, as it happens. One of our friends is a hostage in Gaza after being kidnapped from the music festival; almost everyone we know has a family member who has gone back into the army to serve.)

For me, gone are the days of religiously (ha) attending interfaith events and giving people the benefit of the doubt when they make Anti-Semitic remarks. Gone are the days when I'll apologise for being a religious Jew.

From now on its just me and my fellow Jews. And I'm not sorry about it.

IrishLondoner · 23/10/2023 13:18

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 23/10/2023 13:11

What tolerant country?

Attacks against all protected minorities went up after Brexit.

OP - you are not being unreasonable. And how anyone can claim that attacking a school isn't anti-semitic, I don't know.

I say tolerant because my family has experience of sectarian violence from Northern Ireland. London used to feel tolerant to me…

Bonjovispjs · 23/10/2023 13:17

So sorry op, it must be terrifying for you and others right now. I'm surprised at the nanny agency comment though, I'm a nanny and work for a Jewish family and would have no qualms about working for another Jewish family if i was job hunting right now, even though I'm not Jewish.

IrishLondoner · 23/10/2023 13:14

I am so sorry. There are lots of us who are horrified by the anti semitism of which disguises itself as concern for Palestinians . I feel heartbroken for the dreadful plight of those in Gaza. But Hamas knew this would happen and wanted it to happen.They don’t care about Palestinians. Maybe start criticising Hamas ?

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 23/10/2023 13:11

IrishLondoner · 22/10/2023 00:13

YANBU . How did our tolerant country get to this place? It is terrifying. I’m so so sorry you feel like this. I also have family who are NHS doctors , teachers etc.Your values are my values . I wish I could do more to support your community. I’m not Jewish my heart is with you .

What tolerant country?

Attacks against all protected minorities went up after Brexit.

OP - you are not being unreasonable. And how anyone can claim that attacking a school isn't anti-semitic, I don't know.

StBrides · 23/10/2023 13:08

Yanbu and I'd like you to know that many of us who not Jews are appalled by the anti semitism. I stand with you - as I stand with all victims of this war.

RubyGemStone · 23/10/2023 13:01

@ScaredMamaLondon You need to lower your expectations of people. I hate to say this but as a Jew, I know, that you should know better. Theres a reason many of us were taught not to be openly Jewish. We know the time will come when it's a problem, the time always comes and the British are no different. You're in London like me so there is also a large muslim population to contend with that are contributing to this as it seems to be seen as an islamic issue.

Now is the time to spend amongst your own people, I've been asked at work at least 3 times in the past week very pointed questions are the conflict and my views on Israel. Not one person has had anything sympathetic to say about the Israeli victims, everything is about how awful it is in Gaza. I avoided central on Saturday but yesterday I met up with friends near Soho, again this comes up, again much hand wringing and squirming to not offend me but also the need to point out how horrific it is for Gaza, as if I of all people would be unaware?!

My muslim friends and I have been conveniently avoiding each other.

My neighbour has stopped speaking to me. He is muslim but we've known each other for years, our children have grown up together, would describe us as family friends and neither of us are particularly religious. As of last week he's started blanking me and my DH (who is not Jewish) and on Saturday a large Palestinian flag appeared at the window. DC go to a school with large muslim contingent and generally keep quiet about being Jewish, but feedback from them is not good. I've spent the past few days contemplating a move to Israel, which even under current circumstances seems like a better option.

IrishLondoner · 23/10/2023 12:58

babetyouknow · 23/10/2023 12:32

I'm not anti-semitic, in the slightest and (it's a cliche but true) I have Jewish friends.
But I'm a long term vocal critic of what Israel has been doing to Palestinians and getting away with for many many years, and I'm sick of being told I'm anti-semitic because I'm critical of the atrocities committed by Israel.

It’s the context . Absolutely fine to criticise Israeli actions but if you choose to criticise Israel after an atrocity like October8th it sounds as if you are an apologist for Hamas.

There is NO Justification for Hamas’ actions on October 8th . Hamas knew what they were doing. They don’t care about the Palestinians . They knew that kidnapping children would inflame the situation to unbearable proportions.
Hamas are to blame for the current suffering of the Palestinians.

babetyouknow · 23/10/2023 12:32

I'm not anti-semitic, in the slightest and (it's a cliche but true) I have Jewish friends.
But I'm a long term vocal critic of what Israel has been doing to Palestinians and getting away with for many many years, and I'm sick of being told I'm anti-semitic because I'm critical of the atrocities committed by Israel.

Swipe left for the next trending thread