Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Need some reassurance that I'm not crazy...

263 replies

ScaredMamaLondon · 21/10/2023 20:33

Hello,
I am a Jewish mum of two small children.
I think I'm posting on here to get a reassurance that there are some good people in this world. I am terrified to be openly Jewish in this country at the moment and I am terrified for my children's future here. This week I was told by a nanny agency 'it will be very difficult to get a nanny to work for a jewish family'. The security patrolling makes me feel nauseous; my neighbour's son attends a jewish school and was kicked on the bus for his obviously jewish school uniform. We aren't obviously Jewish 'looking' - we are not religious but yet I don't feel at all safe. The pro-Palestinian rally today threw up pictures of burning stars of davids (the antizionism isn't antisemitism thing is basically an excuse for saying what you like about jews and getting away with it). Red paint splattered over local jewish primary schools (again if it's not antisemitism, what do we have to do with it) and on top of all of this, the sinking, dismal feeling that in Israel, the only place as a Jew I would imagine feeling safe, 1300+ civilians were massacred in their beds/kidnapped/gang raped/worse.

I feel sick. I feel we are utterly hated here and unsafe there.

When I see videos of TFL tube drivers joining in with palestinian chants as if its a football anthem and flags of Jihad being waved in London I do wonder if I've missed something here. At the recent vigil for the Israeli victims people stood in silence. Singing. Crying. Praying for peace. And today I witness the complete opposite. I didn't see one mention of peace. I only saw hatred.

Half my family are NHS doctors and surgeons. Teachers. Proud of our Jewishness and proud of our Britishness. Why is it as a Jewish person in the UK i feel so utterly isolated and depressed? Many clients and non jewish friends have sent wonderful messages of support so perhaps it is just the vocal minority but it's a scary one nonetheless. AIBU in thinking that life is completely terrifying right now?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Lolapusht · 23/10/2023 16:00

I admit that I hadn’t ever really researched Israel/Palestine as it seemed too big a task. I knew the basics and was maybe more inclined to have sympathy for Israel. After 7 October, I saw the responses and was gobsmacked. Instead of people taking to the streets demanding Hamas be brought to justice or to call for peace, people were out shouting revolting antisemitic abuse. I always wondered how the Holocaust actually occurred and now I know.

What got me most I think was when the horrific reports of brutality against children came out and the calls of “Prove it” started. People wanted pictures of it was just “usual” Israeli propaganda. I’ve seen calls for the really horrific footage (that Hamas themselves took and live-streamed in some cases) to be released to prove to pro-Palestinian factions what happened. I think that’s a bad idea as they wouldn’t believe it. The families, many of whom will never get their relatives back, owe the world nothing. I have a horrible feeling that there is nothing Israel/Jewish people can say that will be believed by too large sections of society.

I started looking at various sources to find out how things started and how we’ve ended up here. The narrative from the Pro-Palestine supporters doesn’t match history but that’s not going to stop them. The conditions in Gaza are horrendous. People live in poverty and suffer unimaginably. Why has Hamas not provided for them? If Hamas stopped using resources to attack Israel, it could ease the suffering of the people they’re meant to be governing. Instead of living in 5* hotels, maybe help your people.

If you condemn October 7th then caveat it with a “but”, you are effectively saying those people deserved it. Those children were not the Israeli government just like the dead children in Gaza are not Hamas. That is what the pro-Palestinian rallies are saying. Israeli deaths are justified because look what they’ve done. Look at the suffering they’ve inflicted. Instead of calling for Jihad, maybe call for Hamas to be ousted. They have caused untold suffering on their own people and yet are not held to the same standards people seem to expect from Israel. Hamas knew exactly what would happen after their attack so they have sacrificed every Palestinian life lost since October 7th.

OP, I’m so sorry that you’re experiencing this. I have no idea what it must be like but please know you are supported.

Trulywonderful · 23/10/2023 15:58

The organisers of the Saturday march are such nice people, they only want peace and love for Palestinians and Jews...........(Sarcasm)

"The Friends of al-Aqsa is led by Leicester-based activist Ismael Patel. An outspoken supporter of the disgraced academic David Miller, who was sacked by Bristol University after being accused of antisemitism, Patel has visited Hamas’ leader Ismail Haniyeh in Gaza.

Patel was filmed at a rally in 2009 saying: “Hamas is no terrorist organisation.”
He added: “We are all Hamas,”.

Palestinian Forum for Britain, is led by Zaher Birawi, who met Haniyeh and other leaders of the terror group in Gaza in 2012. On a later visit, he was photographed with both Haniyeh and the former Hamas military chief Mahmoud Zahar, along with the former Respect MP George Galloway.

An extremist group that triggered fury after its members were filmed shouting 'jihad' at a pro-Palestine demonstration in London is led by a man who said Hamas were 'heroes' for killing Israelis.

Luqman Muqeem, the leader of Hazib ut-Tahrir said the Hamas attack on October 7 'made us all very, very happy'.

He described the terrorists as 'heroes' for having 'broken through the enemy lines of yahood (Jews)'.

Muqeem has shared several other shocking posts on his Instagram and Tiktok accounts, including mocking Jewish statehood and saying that their promised land is Jahanam, the Islamic name for hell.
In another post he appeared to endorse a quote from Imam Abu Haraira suggesting that the 'last hour' would come when the 'Muslims fight the Jews' and 'kill them'. "

I could go on and do the rest of the organisers of the march but I think just these two says enough. Personally I want all this of innocent people killing to stop on both sides. However to go on a march organisers by people like this is sick and not justifiable in anyway. All these people want is to start civil unrest and cause hurt to Jews. Half the people these marches know this and the other half are to blind to see the truth. Just sickening behaviour. Look at how gleefully most the people at Saturdays were, sick violence loving scum.

ganondoof · 23/10/2023 15:50

Nervousandexcitedd · 23/10/2023 15:40

Why is it not wildly reported that Jewish schools and temples need security? Probably the same reason it's not reported how many mosques have needed security throughout the years. But hey cares about those people right. Let's only give a shit about the people of a religion that aligns more with your values.

And no-one had time to protest against Hamas/ for the Jewish victims because as always, Israel was quick to attack the innocents in Palestine in the ugliest most disproportionate way.

Whataboutism at its finest.

LoobyDop · 23/10/2023 15:41

Whatifitallgoesright · 23/10/2023 13:40

I'm so sorry you are feeling such fear. It is so wrong. I feel like writing to the local Jewish organisation and just saying I support them and feel sympathy but it feels such a useless thing to do. It must be so stressful and frightening for your family and Jewish friends and my thoughts are with you. Please keep posting on here. People ARE with you.

I wanted to do that, or send a message to the local synagogue. I tried to find an email address or contact details for them, and found they don’t publish them. The likely reason for that is just awful.

Nervousandexcitedd · 23/10/2023 15:40

Why is it not wildly reported that Jewish schools and temples need security? Probably the same reason it's not reported how many mosques have needed security throughout the years. But hey cares about those people right. Let's only give a shit about the people of a religion that aligns more with your values.

And no-one had time to protest against Hamas/ for the Jewish victims because as always, Israel was quick to attack the innocents in Palestine in the ugliest most disproportionate way.

Lolapusht · 23/10/2023 15:27

babetyouknow · 23/10/2023 13:29

It's just not that simple. It's idiotic to suggest it is. As if that happened, out of nowhere, and not caused by everything that went before. As if 16 years of Israels illegal blockade of Gaza and the atrocities they have commited against innocent children didn't lead right here.

I'm not an apologist for Hamas. I'm one of the people who are stating the truth: that Israel is committing war crimes. Talking about the hostages while glossing over the indsicriminate attacks on civilians and the systematic wiping out of entire families.

October 8th was horrific. But so was the many years leading up it, when Israeli soldiers repeatedly shot children in the back and got away with it every time.

You can't shut your eyes to the reality. You feel unsafe in the UK? How have Palestinian children felt their entire lives living in Gaza, knowing they could be killed at any time?

*October 7th.

At least get the date right.

otnot · 23/10/2023 15:27

I am so sorry, I have been absolutely disgusted by the overt antisemitism witnessed over the past couple of weeks. I had no idea Jewish schools and temples needed security, why is this not widely reported?! Pretty sure if it was any other community it would be front page news and vast resources would be spent trying to fix it. We arrest people for saying women have vaginas but allow people to cheer for jihad, rip down photos of missing children and laugh at Jewish rape and murder? It's beyond belief. I'm indigenous British and even I don't feel I want to be here - I don't want to pay taxes to a country where Jews need armed security at their fucking schools.

I am furious that these marches are allowed - there may be some mind-numbingly stupid people who genuinely believe they're purely to show solidarity with Gazans and who are equally horrified by the attacks on Jews, but most don't seem to be even pretending anymore that they're promoting anything other than rampant antisemitism. Why not an anti-Hamas march? Or just a peace march where Jews, Muslims and everyone else can get together and lament the suffering of all those affected by Hamas' actions. I really hope that the tide will start to turn now people are becoming aware of how things are for Jewish communities; I'm not a huge Starmer fan but was very impressed by his unambiguous support for Israel, I really hope he doesn't backtrack as Labour genuinely standing strong against antisemitism gives a clear signal that it is not welcome in this country.

crimsonfleet · 23/10/2023 15:26

Coyoacan · 23/10/2023 14:37

Most Jewish people support a state of Israel

Most is not all.

Zionists want us to hate Jews and that is a very dangerous game.

So every single person who supports thr existence of the State of Israel wants "us" (who's us btw) to hate Jews? Why?

Lolapusht · 23/10/2023 15:21

ScaredMamaLondon · 23/10/2023 14:34

@ganondoof gutted I don't have Bibi's direct phone number. I'll DM him instead, then I'll urge him to sit down at a negotiating table with Hamas.

That’s a great idea! They’ll definitely turn up. This time. Like they’ve always done in the past.

Nervousandexcitedd · 23/10/2023 14:57

Your privilege is showing OP. You're living with the same fear most Muslims in UK have been living with for the last 20 years after 9/11. Some even before that. Yet if we complain we're told to go back to where we came from and stop being a sensitive snowflake, so we grin and bear it and constantly go on about how grateful we are to be 'British'. I'm so sorry you're scared and scared for your loved ones. No-one should have to live like that in a place they consider home. Trust me, as an Asian headscarf wearing Muslim in London I get it. But you're very clearly looking at this from a me me me pov. As someone who was in the protest and is surrounded by people who are 'pro-palestine' NO-ONE hates you. Infact we feel sorry for the Jewish people who are being painted with the same brush as the Israeli government/IDF. Again, I know exactly how that feels. What Hamas did was awful. Only a psycho would cheer it on. And I know some have from what the news loves to tell me. But you know what else I've seen? Israelis cheering on attacks on Palestinians. Israelis spitting on and talking awfully about the Palestinians as if theyre animals. I've been to Palestine. I've seen it firsthand. I've seen an IDF prick smack an old man to the ground because he wanted to go through the door. So while I feel sorry for you and I wouldn't wish this fear on anyone, I feel an even greater need to protest for the freedom of the Palestinian people. For the PALESTINIAN hostages (many of whom are children) to be released. For a little boy not to be killed by an IDF soldier just because he threw a stone at him.

What happened on October 7 was awful, but notice how Palestinians have no special date appointed to their trauma? It's because this has been their life for years. That one day (7 Oct) is their every day. So please, gain some more perspective and understand that while Israel and the Jewish people have the support of the most powerful countries and their governments behind them, the Palestinian people need us the public to scream and shout for them because the powers that be don't give a shit.

Chiaseedling · 23/10/2023 14:54

ganondoof · 23/10/2023 14:31

Yeah OP, just phone up Benjamin Netanyahu and ask him to do you a quick favour and please stop the war, k thanks.

@ganondoof some people are clueless -

@Worddance I’ll get my rabbi (who is quite eminent) to call up Bibi and make sure he backs down shall I? He only lives a few houses up so I could even pop in 🤦‍♀️ in fact he does acknowledge the plight of the Palestinians in his weekly newsletters and I’m sure in synagogue (although I’m not a regular) too.

Echobelly · 23/10/2023 14:47

'Support for Israel' is a complicated thing. It can mean supporting the existence of Jewish state; it can mean believing whether or not Israel should be there, it is there and has a right to exist; it can mean believing it is entitled to do anything to defend itself; it can mean believing there are limits to what it is entitled to do to defend itself; it can mean hating Palestinians and wanting them all gone (rare but not non-existent as a viewpoint); it can mean wanting a just solution for Israelis and Palestinians with everyone having a safe and stable home.

People need to understand that a lot of Jews down to my generation (in my 40s) and beyond have been brought up with the idea that 'Should anything happen, God forbid, Israel is there for you'. Now I wasn't brought up with that line of thinking, but you have to understand this is has been really drilled in to many of us. People don't generally believe 'God gave us Israel' or any religious reason... they see it as the one place free from persecution and therefore I would say quite a lot of Jews (wrongly in my opinion) feel that is entitled to do absolutely anything in the name of 'defending itself' and tend to minimise the impact on Palestinians. They don't feel that way because they inherently hate Muslims or Palestinians - I don't excuse their views but I also want people to understand that, as you can see from this thread, Jews have a strong sense of fear about persecution and a fear of losing Israel as a refuge from that.

Personally, I feel no need to leave the UK or anything like that on account of the actions of a few - our government and politicians are bending over backwards to protect us and condemn antisemitism and to my mind the only time to consider upping sticks is if you are living in a country where the powers that be are joining in and encouraging antisemitism, which I see no sign of here.

Notmetoo · 23/10/2023 14:46

I'm sorry you are going through this. There is no excuse for the behaviour you describe.
But being pro Palestine and /or criticising the Israeli Government is not the same as being anti Jewish or pro Hamas.
Sadly we seem to be less tolerant than we were but I think there is probably more anti Muslim sentiment in the West than anti semitism. I think both are abhorrent

Chiaseedling · 23/10/2023 14:46

Whatifitallgoesright · 23/10/2023 13:40

I'm so sorry you are feeling such fear. It is so wrong. I feel like writing to the local Jewish organisation and just saying I support them and feel sympathy but it feels such a useless thing to do. It must be so stressful and frightening for your family and Jewish friends and my thoughts are with you. Please keep posting on here. People ARE with you.

Please do write to them - we appreciate all the support we can get!

petuniasandpetals · 23/10/2023 14:40

@Coyoacan
?
That doesn't make any sense.
Zionists are usually Jewish.

WingingItSince1973 · 23/10/2023 14:39

This is absolutely horrendous for you and the many others caught up in this. So sorry OP. I'm religious and I know the Bible talks of being peaceful even with our enemies. It's crazy what man can do to man. We should all try and live with each other. I'm so sorry xxxx

Coyoacan · 23/10/2023 14:37

Most Jewish people support a state of Israel

Most is not all.

Zionists want us to hate Jews and that is a very dangerous game.

ScaredMamaLondon · 23/10/2023 14:34

@ganondoof gutted I don't have Bibi's direct phone number. I'll DM him instead, then I'll urge him to sit down at a negotiating table with Hamas.

OP posts:
20notices · 23/10/2023 14:33

I'm so sorry you're going through this OP.

Re (the antizionism isn't antisemitism thing is basically an excuse for saying what you like about jews and getting away with it)

It seems that because Israel's Declaration of Independence referred to it being a Jewish state, people cannot disassociate the two.

ganondoof · 23/10/2023 14:33

babetyouknow · 23/10/2023 14:14

You denied things that we know have happened, that is not showing respect. Israeli soldiers have routinely killed Palestinian children. They have shot them in the back. They have shot them for throwing stones. In June this year, Israeli soldiers shot and killed a two year old.

I have no anger for you. I have anger for the Israeli soldiers that kill children and their government which allows them too. Palestinian children are dying today, in large numbers.
Forgive me if I have more concern for them than for you, in your safe home in your safe country where your children will come home to you safe tonight, unlike many palestinian children.

How dare OP be concerned that Jewish schools in the UK are under threat. Doesn't she know that no one is allowed to be worried about anything if someone somewhere has it worse?

ganondoof · 23/10/2023 14:31

Worddance · 23/10/2023 13:39

I'm really sorry for what you're going through. That's not right. What happened in Israel was appalling.

Can your community please exert whatever influence you have to end the atrocious acts occurring in Gaza - this is the only response that I think will have an impact on what you're experiencing as the situation is truly dire for Palestinians and this is driving the hate. You should not have to - but there's a lot going on that shouldn't be happening right now.

Yeah OP, just phone up Benjamin Netanyahu and ask him to do you a quick favour and please stop the war, k thanks.

Chiaseedling · 23/10/2023 14:23

Coyoacan · 22/10/2023 03:06

I agree with @brightmoons and @mollyfolk. I hate to see what is being done to the Palestinians by the Israeli government and army, but I do not blame Jews, I blame Zionists. Zionists are adults who adhere to a political philosophy, whereas Jews belong to a race and or a well-respected religion.

Most Jewish people support a state of Israel, which is what Zionism is, so you’re incorrect there. Vile references to Zionist conspiracies is just Jew-hate in disguise.

ScaredMamaLondon · 23/10/2023 14:21

@babetyouknow and yet you still can't even bring yourself to mention Hamas might have played a part in their own people's demise.
If you think I was comparing my own plight to that of starving Palestinian children you are perhaps confused. wow wow wow. I know very well how lucky I am. I am still allowed to mention how unwelcome I am starting to feel in my own home, the country that I love.
From the overwhelmingly lovely messages I've received on here I would say most people have realised I am absolutely not sitting feeling sorry for myself (or comparing myself to a child in the war town middle east 😳)
Have a good week all x

OP posts:
Chiaseedling · 23/10/2023 14:18

I couldn’t agree more tbh. I have more grown-up DCs at uni and worried re them being on campus, but they both go to
unis with quite a high Jewish population comparable to some.
id love to see some more support from the non-Jewish community about this and I can’t believe I actually agree w Braverman about something re the ‘Jihad’ comment. I usually can’t abide the woman! The law is an ass.

petuniasandpetals · 23/10/2023 14:17

You are not crazy.
There are crazy people here whose heads are full of daydreams about standing with 'the oppressed' and not having the brains to think things through.
I am thoroughly sick of do gooding lefties who are unwittingly enabling terrorists.