Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Need some reassurance that I'm not crazy...

263 replies

ScaredMamaLondon · 21/10/2023 20:33

Hello,
I am a Jewish mum of two small children.
I think I'm posting on here to get a reassurance that there are some good people in this world. I am terrified to be openly Jewish in this country at the moment and I am terrified for my children's future here. This week I was told by a nanny agency 'it will be very difficult to get a nanny to work for a jewish family'. The security patrolling makes me feel nauseous; my neighbour's son attends a jewish school and was kicked on the bus for his obviously jewish school uniform. We aren't obviously Jewish 'looking' - we are not religious but yet I don't feel at all safe. The pro-Palestinian rally today threw up pictures of burning stars of davids (the antizionism isn't antisemitism thing is basically an excuse for saying what you like about jews and getting away with it). Red paint splattered over local jewish primary schools (again if it's not antisemitism, what do we have to do with it) and on top of all of this, the sinking, dismal feeling that in Israel, the only place as a Jew I would imagine feeling safe, 1300+ civilians were massacred in their beds/kidnapped/gang raped/worse.

I feel sick. I feel we are utterly hated here and unsafe there.

When I see videos of TFL tube drivers joining in with palestinian chants as if its a football anthem and flags of Jihad being waved in London I do wonder if I've missed something here. At the recent vigil for the Israeli victims people stood in silence. Singing. Crying. Praying for peace. And today I witness the complete opposite. I didn't see one mention of peace. I only saw hatred.

Half my family are NHS doctors and surgeons. Teachers. Proud of our Jewishness and proud of our Britishness. Why is it as a Jewish person in the UK i feel so utterly isolated and depressed? Many clients and non jewish friends have sent wonderful messages of support so perhaps it is just the vocal minority but it's a scary one nonetheless. AIBU in thinking that life is completely terrifying right now?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
wiseoldtree · 22/10/2023 09:33

I really feel for you.

I can't understand all the hate. I'm a person who doesn't care what religion or race someone is.

I'd never notice if someone was 'Jewish looking'. I once had to ask someone to move out of our student house (years ago) for loitering outside bedrooms naked and scaring other tenants, and he accused me of wanting him out because he was Jewish!
Hadn't even registered with me that he was.

Anyway, I can understand why you feel unsafe as you live in London and it's the centre of protests. Outside of London it's much less like that and even then it's a minority. People are ignorant and misinformed.

I really do think most people a can see the bigger picture it's just the ignorant few causing the trouble.

Not much help to you when you're living this though OP, but just know that the majority are with you.

ScaredMamaLondon · 22/10/2023 09:25

You don't need to do anything. We already accept we only hear Jewish voices speaking loudly defending Jews. We don't have those expectations on our non jewish friends and neighbours. You only need to tell your jewish friends that you support their right to feel safe in England and you are there for them. That's it. xx

OP posts:
ScaredMamaLondon · 22/10/2023 09:24

I'll also add that when people call for a Ceasefire they do not mention the 201 hostages Hamas is holding. Please try and even imagine what any Western country would do and how they would be expected to conduct themselves while their citizens - ranging from 90 year old Holocaust survivors to 9 month old babies are trapped with an internationally recognised terrorist organisation who also happens to rule the Gaza strip. Honestly.
Also the media is listening to 'Palestinian health authorities' as a genuine source. The health authorities there are Hamas operatives who drag homosexuals on the side of cars to kill them and who instructed their men to gang rape as many Israeli women as possible two weekends ago (but only the pretty blonde ones). Anyone can feel compassion for Palestinian children but once you start taking Hamas as a credible source you are a lost cause.

OP posts:
IrishLondoner · 22/10/2023 09:20

I am so sad that our Jewish community feel alone and threatened. What can / should we do to show our support and combat the growing anti semitism? It’s hard to know what to do as i am not a loud and confident person but I don’t want to be a bystander. Neither do I want to do anything which increases tensions.

ScaredMamaLondon · 22/10/2023 09:08

Hi,

OP here.

Just wanted to respond to some of the messages on here.
Firstly, thanks for the support and for the many DMs I received here too.
Re not looking obviously jewish - I live in a Jewish area. On Friday morning I will buy my meat in a kosher butcher and bread in a Jewish bakery. In France and in Belgium such shops have been targets of very serious terrorist attacks over the past few years. I have a constant feeling of dread and I cannot shake it.

I will explain why in recent weeks it is incredibly clear that antisemitism is inextricably linked with antizionism.
If you scream 'genocide' (factually incorrect phrasing and with two Oxbridge history degrees I'm v happy to speak to anyone on here privately about what genocide means) along with other ignorant and unsubstantiated buzzwords at a protest this has a very very direct role in the rise of antisemitism all over the world. Schools closed, synagogues defaced, etc etc. Whilst not everyone at the march wants to exterminate Jews, the fact that some DO should be enough to question your support of said rally. How many antisemites makes a march unnacceptable? Would you be happy to march alongside anti-black racists or anti-Muslim racists? And crucially, what does 'Never Again' look like to you?

When people start preaching about International Law and mentioning as an 'oh yeah terrorism is bad' too and is even trying to justify such atrocities with something about Gazan children it is clear you 1) do not understand international law 2) are entitled to feel bad for any children caught in the crossfire 3) but with any mention that in some way such terror was in some way justified and without any mention of the displaced israelis, the murdered, gang raped, kidnapped israelis because you claim this is about the israeli government... it just shows your antisemitism. sorry. Why are you so scared and tentative to call out beheadings and gang rapes? Did you speak so disrespectfully about America and Europe's foreign policy seconds after 9/11, 7/7, the bataclan? Do you honestly think Hamas represent disenfranchised, marginalised rebels who only want a slither of land to live peacefully? Ask yourself: what would it take for YOU to be 'pushed' into killing someone else's baby in their cot? If you cannot forgive the thought in yourself, why can you forgive it in others when the victims are Jews?

What do you understand by the term 'Zionism'? On here I've seen a really really shocking one about it being for 'adults only', a political ideology. If Zionism is the belief that Jews have the right to a homeland in their spiritual home, free from racism and pogroms, why are you against this? The word has been dirtied over the years (don't even get me started) and now it is used on rallies as a 'oh i only hate ZIONISTS not jews'. It beggars belief.

This was never meant to be a politics rant. However I am grateful for some of the comments here as it has really underlined some ignorance (how your words at a protest are used against jews) and how people here don't seem to care about who their bedfellows are at marches (I knew it but glad to have the proof). I too am against Netanyahu's government. I have huge compassion for the Gazan children (in case you weren't following it isn't entirely unreasonable for Israel to open their border with Gaza as the last time that border was open it led the massacre of 1400 of their civilians - it is Egypt who refused for days to open their crossing which remains shut for 99.99% of their year - didn't see any marches against Egypt?! Or the Jordanians who refuse to take a single Palestinian in..) But walking in a march with people with have posters of jewish symbols thrown into a bin (classy) and pictures of Jews with hooked noses and blood on their hands (again, classy) means you are part of that messaging and you are part of the reason why antisemitism has increased so dramatically. It is an uncomfortable truth as I really don't think people on here hate the jews as such. To the Catholic lady on here who told me that she is shocked the marchers don't march for peace it is just anti-Israel in sentiment I agree with you. It is pretty blatant. Consider that next time you go to a march. Also happy to discuss what a ceasefire means, why it is only called upon the Israelis and why over the past 20 years of conflict Hamas has broken every single crossfire first. My sister lives in tel aviv and with her two babies has been in her shelter day in day out.

It's an awful situation but we need to have balance, education and transparency. If you want to go to a march, go. But know what your actions show, and know how alone it makes Jews feel.

OP posts:
PumpkinBum3 · 22/10/2023 09:06

So many of us stand by you, more than those that don’t.

iamwhatiam23 · 22/10/2023 08:33

Op im not Jewish but the antisemitism that's being allowed to happen in this country disgusts me! Absolutely no one is allowed to be anti islamic but antisemitism is just accepted! Its vile!

Daleksatemyshed · 22/10/2023 08:25

I feel for you Op, it must be a frightening time for your family. Sadly there are people in this world who will take any chance for oppression and hate. Take care

Pinkflamingopants · 22/10/2023 08:21

OP I’m so sorry you feel like this, I’m shocked to hear about the incidents towards Jewish schools, why is there no press coverage of this? I saw a star drawn on the door of a business locally to me. I just can’t believe it.

The irony of the far left calling anyone who doesn’t adhere to their views ‘far right nazis’ over the past few years, now standing with gay-hating, Jew-hating, women-hating men chanting Jihad is not lost on me. The Met police and TFL also need to take a long hard look at themselves.

Dilbertian · 22/10/2023 08:12

I would just ask you to consider that many people - including Jewish people around the world and Israelis themselves- are anti the occupation and critical of the current Israeli government and not against Jewish people in any way. I think you need to seperate the people being vocal about what Israel is doing wrong - which includes the UN, the WHO and human rights organizations- from people who use this moment to be antisemitic.

I would just ask you to consider that many people are nonetheless attacking Jews over this.

We're horrified that schools in America need security guards and police presence, yet not that the only schools in the UK that need the same are the Jewish schools. Why not?

Don't ask me to separate these people when they are not separating us. Don't dismiss a genuine fear based on the experience of Jewish people, just because you are able to separate the issues. The people who are behaving this way are not separating the issues.

Sunflowercanvas · 22/10/2023 07:40

I hear you OP and it sounds terrifying. I am a Catholic and fail to see how Jewish school children have anything to do with what is currently happening in Gaza. It does feel like there are antisemitism undercurrents running through things.
What Isreal is currently doing is abhorrent and I absolutely do not condone that.
What I don’t understand is that people aren’t marching for Peace or stop the war, rather it’s Pro Palestine .

It’s worrying and frightening to see this all happening in our country.

pyjamalife · 22/10/2023 07:21

Another person sending love! Sorry you're going through this. I really do worry about humanity...

Hapshepsut · 22/10/2023 07:18

sending you lots of love xx

trampoline123 · 22/10/2023 07:12

I'm really sorry you feel like this, I totally get why you're feeling worried about the future.

I for one, am not anti anyone unless they hurt people - live and let live as long as you don't hurt people is what I try and live by. I'm saying this as a white British woman living in the UK outskirts of London if that's relevant.

I can speak for all of my friendship group too who are like me.

I hope things get better for you OP.

jolies1 · 22/10/2023 07:07

Reasonable, educated (ie understand what you are protesting!) Anti Zionism is one thing. Throwing paint on a Jewish school in London is nothing to do with anti Zionism, it’s absolutely anti semitism. A primary school in the UK has absolutely nothing to do with the actions of the Israeli government.

Isthisexpected · 22/10/2023 06:38

I saw a quote that summed up my sentiments "we said never again just one lifetime ago, how short our memories are".

^ this is very powerful.

I'm sorry OP. I can't begin to imagine the pain and fear and sadness. I hope for an end to this awful time. I hope for tolerance and safety for all including you and your family.

mollyfolk · 22/10/2023 06:34

'I think you need to seperate the people being vocal about what Israel is doing wrong - which includes the UN, the WHO and human rights organizations- from people who use this moment to be antisemitic.'
It doesn't look like OP is conflating the two - quite the opposite.

She literally said that antizionism is antisemitism. It’s not. Neither is criticism of the Israeli authorities. I am pointing out that she sees everyone in this March as being anti the Jewish people whether this is not the case.

Coyoacan · 22/10/2023 03:06

I agree with @brightmoons and @mollyfolk. I hate to see what is being done to the Palestinians by the Israeli government and army, but I do not blame Jews, I blame Zionists. Zionists are adults who adhere to a political philosophy, whereas Jews belong to a race and or a well-respected religion.

MargaritaHargitaysLittleSister · 22/10/2023 03:01

The world is a very scary place to be right now. I am Christian and work for a Synagogue. People are terrified and its horrific that all Jews are going through this

JacJac77 · 22/10/2023 02:52

I am so sorry that you feel like this OP, I can only imagine how frightening it must be. I didn't go on the march today, but I support the sentiment, which is that bombing Gaza is wrong, cutting supplies of energy, water, and food is wrong, and punishing two million people for the actions of Hamas is wrong. In my mind, having this viewpoint is not antisemitic, and I'm confident that the tube driver, and many, many others on the march today were there because they support the right of Palestinians to live peacefully, not because they hate Jewish people. Of course the terrorist attack itself was also wrong, and that should go without saying. However, I do think that a small minority of people have used the current situation to stir-up hatred, and unfortunately their actions are more visible and are generating the very understandable fear.

Bunda · 22/10/2023 02:13

As a Muslim in a Jewish area we stand together now more than ever. This war is a political one, not a religious one. That's the part we must remember.

NotReadyForAutumnYet · 22/10/2023 01:58

'I think you need to seperate the people being vocal about what Israel is doing wrong - which includes the UN, the WHO and human rights organizations- from people who use this moment to be antisemitic.'
It doesn't look like OP is conflating the two - quite the opposite.

junbean · 22/10/2023 01:41

I'm not Jewish or even a part of any type of oppressed people group (besides being a woman) and that sounds utterly terrifying. It makes me very sick to read. I'm literally crying just reading your post. I'm so sorry you're going through this and I hope it ends very soon. There are a LOT of people who want peace. You aren't alone and you aren't hated by everyone. I wish there was something I could do, I would do it. I've always felt this way- ever since I first learned about antisemitism as a child. No one should be afraid to exist.

Tomatina · 22/10/2023 01:32

YANBU. I'm not Jewish but am feeling worried and depressed by the resurgence of antisemitism in this country. I'm so sorry you are having to go through this. I do think (hope) that it is just a very vocal minority as you suggest, inflamed by the awful situation in Gaza. But I also know that antisemitism never really goes away, and there are people (on both the left and right politically) who will seize an opportunity to blame Jews for just about anything. One thing I'm sure of is that I don't want to live in a country where Jewish people do not feel free and safe. Perhaps we need a big demonstration against antisemitism - a demonstration which would include large numbers of non-Jews in solidarity.

nocoolnamesleft · 22/10/2023 00:57

I am so sorry. The reports that hate crimes have shot through the roof in the last days, due to anti semitic abuse, is frightening. I cannot understand the mentality that targets British Jews (still less children, for pity's sake) for events over which they have no control, and for which they bear no responsibility.

Swipe left for the next trending thread