Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU if I expect my husband to work more days than me so I can stay at home with our child?

425 replies

Newmumma123 · 21/10/2023 20:32

I am currently 38 weeks pregnant and I am due our first baby in ten days. Me and my husband have been together nearly seven years after meeting online when we were in our late teens.

My husband is an engineer and works 5/6 days a week with a 45 minute commute each way. I am a primary school teacher and I currently work four days a week after cutting down my hours two years ago to support my mum who was diagnosed with BPD but I am now off on MAT leave until June next year. We used to car share to work as we both worked in an area 45 minutes from where we currently live, however when I fell pregnant I decided that I will move to another school closer at the end of my MAT leave so that one of us is close by for our baby who will be in nursery three days and looked after by grandparents two days at that point.

Originally, we discussed the option of me going back five days a week after MAT leave but after talking with other friends and family who are teachers, lots of them have said how stressful it is balancing motherhood and full time work. Over the last few weeks, I have been considering when taking a new job getting a three or four day contract so that I can actually spend sometime looking after the child that I have grown for nine months.

Tonight, I said to my husband that I'd like to go back to work four days after MAT leave instead of five and he said that he would like to only work five days instead of six and that I should go back to work five days so that he can do five days too and doesn't have to work 7 to 12 on a Saturday morning to help bring in a bit more money (cost of living!). If I did four days we would pay one day less a week for childcare and my wages alone pays for childcare/ plus covers my percentage of bills too(this is without the funding that should be coming into place in September 2024) so we should financially be fine if we are careful with money. My husband said to me that our child will miss out on the development but honestly, I feel that I am well equiped to fill that gap as I am early years trained and an educational professional myself plus being the mum (I also don't feel like I should be justifying myself as the mum). My husband is coming across very jealous as he feels we should both work five days so we can both be with our baby on the weekends however I feel that its best for our baby to be with one of us three days out of seven rather than two of us two days out of seven.

My husband has always had this attitude that I get a 'week off' every 6/7 weeks and quite honestly, it annoys me as being a teacher is HARD work physically and mentally. I can't just switch off when I get home. I also don't want to work five days and have someone else look after the child that I have grown and will birth. I want to be with him whilst he is young. My husband has attacked my work ethic and has described me as being 'soft' because I want to be at home.

Alot of this rides on me being able to get a contract for specific days but my husbands attitude is really annoying me. He said why should he have to scarifice time with our baby so I can have more time with him. My answer back was I have scarificed a year out of my career, my pension contributions and my body plus the mental toll of looking after a baby in order for us to have a child. I feel that he should work a bit extra so that I can spend more time with our baby as I am his mummy. We have ended up having an argument as I am very upset as I don't feel like he understands just how important I will be in our childs life and I feel that he is a bit jealous of how much I will be needed more than him by the baby.

AIBU with my feelings of wanting to stay at home with our baby one day a week ? Should I go back to work five days after MAT leave so that we both have an equal amount of time with our ten month old ?

Please help!

OP posts:
notthesteak · 23/10/2023 18:21

Alot of this rides on me being able to get a contract for specific days but my husbands attitude is really annoying me. He said why should he have to scarifice time with our baby so I can have more time with him. My answer back was I have scarificed a year out of my career, my pension contributions and my body plus the mental toll of looking after a baby in order for us to have a child. I feel that he should work a bit extra so that I can spend more time with our baby as I am his mummy. We have ended up having an argument as I am very upset as I don't feel like he understands just how important I will be in our childs life and I feel that he is a bit jealous of how much I will be needed more than him by the baby.

Having just realised i missed this part...... is this a joke? If it was such a sacrifice for your time, career, pension contributions and body.. are you really sure you should be having children. I fear i can already hear the guilt trips you are going to subject them to later in life. Start saving for their therapy now!!

notthesteak · 23/10/2023 18:12

your are totally being unreasonable. Coming from a parent who worked more than their partner, itis far more fair to both work equal and equal time with little one. Otherwise if you expect your husband to work more for you to drop day/s, he may potentially come to resent you for this. His time with little one is just as precious as your is, its so unfair to think your are more important!

Fiona142 · 23/10/2023 17:57

I think this totally depends who is doing more housework; childcare and all the other little things like Christmas shopping; holiday and days out planning. I have 3 children and work 2.5 days a week but I do nearly everything else. My husband earns well and this suits us perfectly. I did work full time for a while but it was way too difficult for me I was so tired and depressed as he still did very little and weirdly he does more now as he works from home and sees how much I do everyday and that my days off work are not days off and it allows our weekends to be mainly family time. You need to make it clear if you are working the same hours everything is divided equally.

Sennelier1 · 23/10/2023 17:46

I think you are véry unreasonable. Your husband is becoming a parent too, it is absolutely normal he would like to spend his week-ends with his child. You treat him as if he was only a spermdonor, the one who got you pregnant but does not have the right to be involved in his child's life?

SleepingStandingUp · 23/10/2023 17:45

SpringHexagon · 23/10/2023 16:37

I don't think you're unreasonable in what you want to do, since my partner has his own business and works 6 days a week (7 sometimes when he gets away with it) and I dropped from working 5 days to 2.5 days, as we both felt it was important for our daughter to be raised by a parent, not a grandparent or nursery worker.
BUT, it was a very mutual feeling and agreement between us. My daughter is 19 months old and still breastfeeds, so there wasn't the option for it to be my partner really.
You may be unreasonable if you keep pushing for something that your partner doesn't agree with though.

He works six days but 7 when he gets away with it? So you mean he works 7 when you let him? How much does he see his child?

GreatGardenstuff · 23/10/2023 17:28

I don't feel like he understands just how important I will be in our childs life and I feel that he is a bit jealous of how much I will be needed more than him by the baby

Honestly, if you’ve told him that, I’m not surprised he’s pissed off with you. What a load of crap. Unless you’re still EBF when your maternity leaves ends, both parents are of equal importance and need to a child. Yuck.

Springforward1 · 23/10/2023 16:47

Coffeerum · 23/10/2023 16:21

This is a really odd response to a man who wants to spend more time with his child.
'oh people are obsessed with 50/50 - it will lead to discontent' what does that have to do with this at all?
Will it not lead to discontent to prioritise one parent spending significantly more time with their child at the direct expense of the other spending time with DC?

Again noted but as a previous poster said its not just about spending time with his child. It's about playgroups, clinics, illness, unexpected emergencies & everything else that child rearing brings. I still believe there should be one of the parents taking more of a lead therefore more time spent the child. Whether that's the mother or father makes no difference. I just can't see how a 50/50 time wise can work unless both parents work exactly the same hours and the child goes to a nursery or childminder to be dropped off & collected by each parent alternately. Then this 50/50 attitude might work. I see nothing wrong with OP DH doing a few extra hours to allow his child continuity of care. It's not as if they are seperated, or he works away from home when every minute spent with his child would be even more precious.

SpringHexagon · 23/10/2023 16:37

I don't think you're unreasonable in what you want to do, since my partner has his own business and works 6 days a week (7 sometimes when he gets away with it) and I dropped from working 5 days to 2.5 days, as we both felt it was important for our daughter to be raised by a parent, not a grandparent or nursery worker.
BUT, it was a very mutual feeling and agreement between us. My daughter is 19 months old and still breastfeeds, so there wasn't the option for it to be my partner really.
You may be unreasonable if you keep pushing for something that your partner doesn't agree with though.

Springforward1 · 23/10/2023 16:27

Islandgirl68 · 23/10/2023 16:25

It is unfair for him to say you are soft to work 4 days. You have to remember contributions are not only financial. Why can't he work 5 days and you work 4 and just tighten your belts. It this attitude where predominantly men get nippy when women do less paid work than they do and they moan that you are not contributing enough if you don't work full time. Being a parent is a job, you just don't get paid and it is a hard job.

Well said 💯

boobies1234 · 23/10/2023 16:26

I haven't read the whole thread but one thing I would point out. When my girls were little we would go to mum and baby groups, weigh in clinics at the health centre, as they grew things like special tots sessions at the soft play, etc. when my husband got ill, and I went to work full time, he didn't feel able to go to any of these and so our girl missed out.
He is currently thinking what he thinks is fair for you and him but not what's best for baby

Islandgirl68 · 23/10/2023 16:25

It is unfair for him to say you are soft to work 4 days. You have to remember contributions are not only financial. Why can't he work 5 days and you work 4 and just tighten your belts. It this attitude where predominantly men get nippy when women do less paid work than they do and they moan that you are not contributing enough if you don't work full time. Being a parent is a job, you just don't get paid and it is a hard job.

Coffeerum · 23/10/2023 16:21

Springforward1 · 23/10/2023 15:44

Noted, at the same time I believe nowadays there appears to be an obsession about 50/50 with childcare & household tasks. IMO this can only lead to discontent & arguments if one of the couple dares to not contribute their 'fair share' Eg I filled the dishwasher therefore you must empty it etc or sparks will fly. That is purely an example of something far greater as far as I can see. This is why I stick by everything I've said to OP on this thread.

This is a really odd response to a man who wants to spend more time with his child.
'oh people are obsessed with 50/50 - it will lead to discontent' what does that have to do with this at all?
Will it not lead to discontent to prioritise one parent spending significantly more time with their child at the direct expense of the other spending time with DC?

AliceDownTheRabbitHole · 23/10/2023 16:11

I don't think it's unreasonable to want to work less to have that extra time with your child but I think it is unreasonable to do it to the detriment of your husband. Working 6 days a week is horrible. Where's his time with the child and his down time too? He'll be run ragged and I don't think it would be sustainable in the long term. If you can manage financially on you doing 4 days and him doing 5 days that would work but to expect him to pick up the slack and do the extra day to make up the money is unfair

LolaSmiles · 23/10/2023 16:02

Noted, at the same time I believe nowadays there appears to be an obsession about 50/50 with childcare & household tasks. IMO this can only lead to discontent & arguments if one of the couple dares to not contribute their 'fair share' Eg I filled the dishwasher therefore you must empty it etc or sparks will fly.
That is purely an example of something far greater as far as I can see. This is why I stick by everything I've said to OP on this thread.

I don't think there is an obsession with a 50/50 tick list of tit for tat, though it might end up that way if someone realises they've been taken for a ride.

The 50/50 is generally about having a fair allocation of domestic load over the whole household.

The problem is that two situations occur that screw women over:

  1. Women do a double shift where they end up doing more than their share at home, being default parent, carrying the mental load, all whilst working full time. This women ends up feeling frustrated because she's carrying more than her fair share (and worse she comes on MN and has the martyrs of the world telling her she should make her poor hubby a sticker chart for his chores because unless she spells out to him that the dishwasher needs loading the poor darling isn't to know that it needs switching on).
  1. Women end up arguing that they're more important to baby, they should get to unilaterally drop their days because they're a mummy, baby wants them more, and they create a situation where they carve themselves out as top dog parent. They come online and get told you do you hun, they're only little once, baby needs their mummy. Definitely tell DH you're not going back to work full time because you're saving the household on childcare. Oh and definitely don't be starting to do housework. Your job is to do wonderful child things only and DH should be lucky if you get anything done in the house. You're not a skivvy. Then down the line when it's not coffee dates and baby cuddles they find themselves resentful and frustrated that they want to go out, but their 12-18 month won't settle with Dad, or the child gets really upset, or they can't get anything done with a 3 year old around (and they'll come on MN and similar posters with the you do you hun, baby needs mummy, of course you can't load the washing machine you're too busy being mummy, will be acting like the other parents who manage 20 minutes of tidying a day have naturally perfect children so don't understand)

A situation where both parents are engaged and involved from the start means that there are two active parents who are involved in day to day domestic life, which is better for women.

The patriarchy does a number on women when there's countless women encouraging women to act against their best interests.

Spacecowboys · 23/10/2023 15:50

Springforward1 · 23/10/2023 12:23

Keep in mind OP there are 2 camps in this thread & that's ok. There is absolutely nothing wrong with even being a full time mum(the toughest job if done properly) never mind requesting you do 4 days instead of 5. There are plenty of men (&women) who have to work shifts which include weekends. A few DH extra hours won't interfere with your family life if it means continuity of care for your child. My father being self employed worked all hours of the day & night while my mother did one night a week as a nurse. My father didn't miss out on family life and I'll always be grateful my mother was there for us more or less 24/7. If finances allow it I'd stick to your plan 😁

Op sticking to ‘her’ plan will result in an unhappy marriage and probably one that eventually breaks down. Both parties need to be happy with an arrangement where one parent takes on more of the financial burden, to accommodate the other working reduced hours. But op will probably get her way and be posting in five years about how she deserves a larger share of the marital assets because she ‘sacrificed’ her career to go part time. It’s a no win for men sometimes.

Springforward1 · 23/10/2023 15:44

Coffeerum · 23/10/2023 14:56

@Springforward1 My point is if there are families where mum does the majority of childcare etc and dad does the majority of earning money for the family from my experience growing up it works.

What is the relevance though? This father has made it clear he doesn't want to work 6 days a week at the expense of being with his child.

Noted, at the same time I believe nowadays there appears to be an obsession about 50/50 with childcare & household tasks. IMO this can only lead to discontent & arguments if one of the couple dares to not contribute their 'fair share' Eg I filled the dishwasher therefore you must empty it etc or sparks will fly. That is purely an example of something far greater as far as I can see. This is why I stick by everything I've said to OP on this thread.

LolaSmiles · 23/10/2023 15:31

Springforward1
The two camps on this thread aren't about whether it's reasonable/unreasonable for any parent to want to work part time or full time.

The two camps are whether it's:

  • reasonable that one person gets to unilaterally decide that they want to go part time and the other parent should increase their hours to facilitate it
  • unreasonable for any parent to decide they have a monopoly on household working arrangements

One group thinks that being mummy trumps everything and therefore a husband should accept losing time with his child because mummy has spoken.

The other group think that BOTH parents should be able to spend time with their child and BOTH parents have a day in making arrangements about working patterns in the family.

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 23/10/2023 15:19

Wow you are being SERIOUSLY unreasonable and selfish.

Coffeerum · 23/10/2023 14:56

@Springforward1 My point is if there are families where mum does the majority of childcare etc and dad does the majority of earning money for the family from my experience growing up it works.

What is the relevance though? This father has made it clear he doesn't want to work 6 days a week at the expense of being with his child.

Springforward1 · 23/10/2023 13:48

To add,
Obviously if mums earning potential was far greater than dads then the opposite would also work. Its all about compromise.

Springforward1 · 23/10/2023 13:44

Coffeerum · 23/10/2023 12:26

@Springforward1 My father being self employed worked all hours of the day & night while my mother did one night a week as a nurse. My father didn't miss out on family life

Those two things are just objectively incompatible with each other, you can't work all hours of the day and night and not miss out on family life.

A few DH extra hours won't interfere with your family life

By that very logic neither will a few extra hours for OP.

He actually didn't miss out on family life snd neither did we. He made sure he was around for the school run, meal times & Sundays. His extra work was in his at home office room when we were sleeping. When he worked full weekends on projects he made sure to make up for it. Thats self employment. My point is if there are families where mum does the majority of childcare etc and dad does the majority of earning money for the family from my experience growing up it works.As always though each to their own.

GloriousCats · 23/10/2023 13:40

My DH and I both opted to take a hit so that we could spend more time with the kids. In our case we both went down to 4 days, and just tightened the purse strings. Is this possible for you both at all? I think you cannot insist he works more so that you can do what you want. Clearly you both want more time with the baby and as a family and that is what us crucially important here. His Saturday sounds like it’s 7-12 and is for some extra cash. Could you feasibly cut that as well as you drop to 4 days and make it work somehow? I suspect you’d both get a lot out of that arrangement.

MrsB74 · 23/10/2023 13:19

I haven’t read the whole thread, but can understand where you are coming from. Going back to work full time when you would rather be with your baby is horrible. That said you need to think of your DH and family time too. Can he feasibly drop his weekend working if you only work 4 days, apologies if you have answered this elsewhere? If you cutback elsewhere maybe? As he isn’t working 5 full days in the week you would be a lot closer in working hours. I know teachers hate it being pointed out (I’m related to several teachers), but you will get regular holidays with your little one that he won’t get. You will need to compromise for all your sakes.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/10/2023 12:55

Both parents are absolutely equal but I don’t think that this situation is about that really. If he doesn’t work the weekend (which he has the option not to do anyway) your dc will still be home with you. If you drop a day, it’s one less day for your child to be in childcare. Surely any parent can see the benefit for a child of an extra day with a parent rather than in childcare, not to mention the difference in cost/benefit when you aren’t having to pay for that day. It really doesn’t matter if it’s the father who is home or the mother, but it is about what is best for the child, not what’s best for your dh.

Coffeerum · 23/10/2023 12:26

@Springforward1 My father being self employed worked all hours of the day & night while my mother did one night a week as a nurse. My father didn't miss out on family life

Those two things are just objectively incompatible with each other, you can't work all hours of the day and night and not miss out on family life.

A few DH extra hours won't interfere with your family life

By that very logic neither will a few extra hours for OP.