Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tips for a school appeal

112 replies

Hotandsunny · 21/10/2023 17:58

I'm trying to get my DD into a different school than she was offered. The appeal is coming up soon. Has anyone done one and can give me an idea of what to expect, any preparation I should do or any tips. Thanks ☺️

OP posts:
ChocolateTea · 22/10/2023 11:46

We had an appeal years ago, for a grammar school. We had lots of evidence of primary school failures, and DC’s natural talent, but we also said how affected they were by their siblings autism, and how that had disadvantaged them compared to others.

im not sure what part won our appeal but we did it

it was incredibly stressful though, and I cried more than once in the appeal hearing as it was so overwhelming sitting opposite four people adament your child isn’t good enough and you’re being there is pointless

and our appeal years on proved right, DC is definitely in the right school for them and the school agrees

Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 11:34

Itwasamemo1 · 22/10/2023 11:08

I 100% understand. We thought we had a very solid reason for our appeal .
Appeal panel were awful,there was a reverend asking very dodgy questions about my daughters bedroom …yes really!
We lost our appeal but we were bloody determined because we had evidence that people had used false addresses and our daughter 100% deserved this GS .
Went to ombudsman and we bloody won 💪
It destroyed me mentally for many years TBH !
Hopefully your appeal will be ok .X

I'm so sorry to hear about your experience. It was amazing you won in the end but such a shame you had to go through all that.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 11:32

Sticktoyourguns · 22/10/2023 00:57

I’ve been to school appeal 4 times, won 2 and lost 2. My advice would be do as much research as possible. @AvaCallanach‘s post is a good one, look at their arguments. Look at the Pan numbers and previous admissions and results. Study class numbers. It feels very daunting, I am a lone parent as well but the panel will try and put you at ease, the school or council will be arguing against you. I had 2 secondary appeals, won 1, lost one. I was thrown at the one I lost by them asking about the school that I had been offered. I was only made aware the day before that I had actually been offered a different school 🤦🏼‍♀️.It surprised me as everyone always says you are arguing as to why the school you want is suitable. Just be aware they can ask why you think the offered school is unsuitable.

My other appeal was for a religious school and I am not religious but my child was previously at a religious school. As a pp mentioned, there are 2 phases. I almost won at the 1st stage because they didn’t do a very good job of providing evidence that they were full. Unfortunately, it was accepted and it went to the second phase. I actually wasn’t happy with some of the questions, as they seemed to be enquiring, in a very roundabout way, whether I had been married to my child’s father. My arguments were very specific to my child’s needs and I received a call later that day to say that I had been successful.

it sounds like you have a good chance with your supporting evidence and get any more that you can. If you wished to you could also mention your health as well as your DC’s, the affects this has on your DD, and the fact that you believe this school will be able to offer her the pastoral support she needs. Sorry this has been so long and Good luck!

Thank you so much for all the advice. I had no idea until I read replies that I would be arguing against the school. It sounds like a court case where I'm representing myself. So daunting!

Do I get a copy of the school's arguments before the appeal so I know what I'm arguing against?

OP posts:
Itwasamemo1 · 22/10/2023 11:08

BeringBlue · 21/10/2023 20:56

I can't speak for every panel, but the ones I had for my daughter were more emotionally traumatic than my divorce hearings. In those, I at least felt the judge wanted to hear both sides, whereas I felt universally hated in the appeal panels and ended up in tears.
I can't give you any advice on what to say as I lost, despite following the advice of professionals.
It was a hideous process and I wish you luck.

I 100% understand. We thought we had a very solid reason for our appeal .
Appeal panel were awful,there was a reverend asking very dodgy questions about my daughters bedroom …yes really!
We lost our appeal but we were bloody determined because we had evidence that people had used false addresses and our daughter 100% deserved this GS .
Went to ombudsman and we bloody won 💪
It destroyed me mentally for many years TBH !
Hopefully your appeal will be ok .X

Sticktoyourguns · 22/10/2023 00:57

I’ve been to school appeal 4 times, won 2 and lost 2. My advice would be do as much research as possible. @AvaCallanach‘s post is a good one, look at their arguments. Look at the Pan numbers and previous admissions and results. Study class numbers. It feels very daunting, I am a lone parent as well but the panel will try and put you at ease, the school or council will be arguing against you. I had 2 secondary appeals, won 1, lost one. I was thrown at the one I lost by them asking about the school that I had been offered. I was only made aware the day before that I had actually been offered a different school 🤦🏼‍♀️.It surprised me as everyone always says you are arguing as to why the school you want is suitable. Just be aware they can ask why you think the offered school is unsuitable.

My other appeal was for a religious school and I am not religious but my child was previously at a religious school. As a pp mentioned, there are 2 phases. I almost won at the 1st stage because they didn’t do a very good job of providing evidence that they were full. Unfortunately, it was accepted and it went to the second phase. I actually wasn’t happy with some of the questions, as they seemed to be enquiring, in a very roundabout way, whether I had been married to my child’s father. My arguments were very specific to my child’s needs and I received a call later that day to say that I had been successful.

it sounds like you have a good chance with your supporting evidence and get any more that you can. If you wished to you could also mention your health as well as your DC’s, the affects this has on your DD, and the fact that you believe this school will be able to offer her the pastoral support she needs. Sorry this has been so long and Good luck!

Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 00:02

PanelChair · 21/10/2023 23:48

I’d be grateful not to be tagged now on school appeals threads. There are several regular posters who give sound advice and I long ago ran out of new things to say, so have ‘retired’ as PanelChair.

That said, I agree with Lougle, Meditrina and prh47bridge.

OP - I understand why you feel the requirement to demonstrate regular church attendance is unfair, but (the school will argue and the panel will probably agree) it’s less unfair than any other judgment of an applicant’s Christian commitment, because it’s objective and measurable. By all means point out that you can’t regularly attend church because of your family situation and your son’s needs, but focus on all the other things that your daughter needs and which this school can provide.

The panel should try to put you at ease and listen to everything you say. They then have to weigh up whether your daughter needs a place at this school more than the school needs to stick to its published admissions number. If your friends can’t be there during the Zoom call, could a volunteer from your church?

Thank you for the help. And that's a good idea about a volunteer, thank you.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 00:01

Russoooooo · 21/10/2023 23:48

Is she currently attending school? The allocated school?

No, she is at home.

OP posts:
PanelChair · 21/10/2023 23:48

I’d be grateful not to be tagged now on school appeals threads. There are several regular posters who give sound advice and I long ago ran out of new things to say, so have ‘retired’ as PanelChair.

That said, I agree with Lougle, Meditrina and prh47bridge.

OP - I understand why you feel the requirement to demonstrate regular church attendance is unfair, but (the school will argue and the panel will probably agree) it’s less unfair than any other judgment of an applicant’s Christian commitment, because it’s objective and measurable. By all means point out that you can’t regularly attend church because of your family situation and your son’s needs, but focus on all the other things that your daughter needs and which this school can provide.

The panel should try to put you at ease and listen to everything you say. They then have to weigh up whether your daughter needs a place at this school more than the school needs to stick to its published admissions number. If your friends can’t be there during the Zoom call, could a volunteer from your church?

Russoooooo · 21/10/2023 23:48

Is she currently attending school? The allocated school?

Hotandsunny · 21/10/2023 23:20

LolaSmiles · 21/10/2023 22:59

The school she was offered wouldn't make any reasonable adjustments as she doesn't have a diagnosis as of yet.
There doesn't have to be a diagnosis to make the adjustments. Even with EHCP, for example, it's needs driven not diagnosis driven.

I don't intend for that to sound unsupportive by the way. I'm just thinking about what might come up at panel or what arguments might be made.

Oh, no that's very helpful. But yes, at the school she was offered they told me they would need proof of her needs.

At this school's open evening the head had clearly prepared nothing for his talk. In the couple of minutes ramble he made a joke about bullying...the school ha just had an Ofsted saying bullying was an issue!! When she was offered the place I tried to engage with the school as to how her needs could be met and they were just horrible. And I thought if they're this horrible to parents how horrible are they to the children?

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 21/10/2023 22:59

The school she was offered wouldn't make any reasonable adjustments as she doesn't have a diagnosis as of yet.
There doesn't have to be a diagnosis to make the adjustments. Even with EHCP, for example, it's needs driven not diagnosis driven.

I don't intend for that to sound unsupportive by the way. I'm just thinking about what might come up at panel or what arguments might be made.

Hotandsunny · 21/10/2023 22:53

prh47bridge · 21/10/2023 22:34

SIF = Supplementary Information Form - a form that applicants could send to the school to evidence their entitlement to priority on faith grounds.

There is already good advice on this thread. Assuming this is a secondary school, you need to show that the disadvantage to your child from not being admitted outweighs any problems the school will face from having to cope with an additional pupil. You've been given some good pointers towards things you can put forward to help with that.

Ok, thank you.

Why do they not tell you any of this when you appeal?

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 21/10/2023 22:51

Lougle · 21/10/2023 22:23

Do you have a friend or family member who can help you to stay calm if you think you aren't being listened to?

The panel will have your written representation and they will only want you to tell them anything that adds to that - they will read your papers thoroughly.

No. It's at a time when my friends will be at work.

OP posts:
prh47bridge · 21/10/2023 22:34

SIF = Supplementary Information Form - a form that applicants could send to the school to evidence their entitlement to priority on faith grounds.

There is already good advice on this thread. Assuming this is a secondary school, you need to show that the disadvantage to your child from not being admitted outweighs any problems the school will face from having to cope with an additional pupil. You've been given some good pointers towards things you can put forward to help with that.

Lougle · 21/10/2023 22:23

Do you have a friend or family member who can help you to stay calm if you think you aren't being listened to?

The panel will have your written representation and they will only want you to tell them anything that adds to that - they will read your papers thoroughly.

Hotandsunny · 21/10/2023 22:16

Lougle · 21/10/2023 22:11

The panel will listen to you @Hotandsunny . You can also take someone with you to support you.

That's good. It's not in person it's on Zoom. I did ask for it to be in person as I find Zoom very hard to follow, but they obviously don't do them in person. I don't really have anyone to support me as my support worker and care coordinator both left and haven't been replaced.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 21/10/2023 22:11

Charlingspont · 21/10/2023 22:09

@AvaCallanach's post is really helpful. You could say that your DD has been negatively impacted by her brother's autism in that you could not attend church, and that that impact continues to be felt as you are having to homeschool and you do not feel that you can give her nearly as good an education through homeschooling as your preferred school can. Explain that this is tough on your own mental health, and that you need to be functioning in the best possible manner to support your family with the undoubted challenges they face. Check facts and figures as @AvaCallanach has too. And use your documentary evidence.

Thank you, that's very helpful.

OP posts:
Lougle · 21/10/2023 22:11

The panel will listen to you @Hotandsunny . You can also take someone with you to support you.

Charlingspont · 21/10/2023 22:09

@AvaCallanach's post is really helpful. You could say that your DD has been negatively impacted by her brother's autism in that you could not attend church, and that that impact continues to be felt as you are having to homeschool and you do not feel that you can give her nearly as good an education through homeschooling as your preferred school can. Explain that this is tough on your own mental health, and that you need to be functioning in the best possible manner to support your family with the undoubted challenges they face. Check facts and figures as @AvaCallanach has too. And use your documentary evidence.

Hotandsunny · 21/10/2023 21:49

AvaCallanach · 21/10/2023 21:28

We won our appeal for my DD.
We did base our appeal in part on her brother's needs - also autistic and had recently been through a very severe depression. We successfully argued that DD had been impacted by her brother's depression and how this had meant we had naturally had to prioritize his needs to keep him safe, so DD's needs had taken second fiddle, akin to a young carer she had to look after herself a lot more than we would have wanted. We argued she had become very reliant on the familiar parts of her life - her friends, her community - as resilience factors and that in taking her away from these factors we would be increasing her own risk of mental ill health in a temporamentally predisposed child and family. We also pointed out that the intake each year was a few above the given PAN and yet the school had maintained and improved exam results. We also showed that they chose to use larger classes in the higher sets in order to keep the lowest set small, so a small class size wasn't imperative for their good results. Overall we said the risk to her mental wellbeing by taking a child who has had a hard couple of years away from everything and everyone they know, was much higher compared to the risk to the school who showed they could still get good exam results and function and get a good OFSTED with numbers slightly over PAN.

I'm not sure what swung it, but they had 2 days of appeals hearings, and only 2 appeals were granted.

I'm so glad it worked out for you. We have been through some very difficult times and it just feels so hard DD not getting the school that will meet her needs. Her closest friends got places at this school. I'm having to home educate her now and I don't know how much my mental health can take.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 21/10/2023 21:45

Charlingspont · 21/10/2023 21:16

It sounds to me like you have good paperwork (letter from pastor, letter from ex-social worker) to back up your case. I still think going in all guns blazing accusing the school of discrimination won't win your case - it's a church school (which is one of the reasons you say you want it) and so they must therefore apply their faith requirements stringently, otherwise everyone would just lie. But you have extrapolating circumstances, and a letter from the pastor.

(As a caveat, I personally don't agree with schools excluding children on any basis at all, be it religion or academic capability, or wealth, but I am trying to help you.)

Yes, I understand. I suppose I'm not really saying they are being discriminatory but it feels like it. Like it feels a lot when you have a child with autism. At the end of the day if I'd been able to attend church she would have been given a place 😞
And yes, you have been very helpful, thank you.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 21/10/2023 21:41

Lougle · 21/10/2023 21:02

@Hotandsunny are you a lone parent? DD1 can't be left alone and can't cope with church so DH and I take it in turns. Would that be an option for you, so you don't miss out all the time?

Yes, I'm a lone parent.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 21/10/2023 21:39

Thank you so much and I'm so sorry to hear that. I'm very nervous as I have Emotionally Unstable Personality Disorder and awaiting assesment for autism too. If I'm not listened to I will get extremely upset. I don't know how I'm going to cope honestly.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 21/10/2023 21:36

MrTiddlesTheCat · 21/10/2023 20:48

I used to sit on appeal panels. They have two steps (assuming the process hasn't changed). The first stage is 'is the school full' so will be about space, facilities, planned admission numbers, were places allocated according to criteria etc. If they can't prove they're full you win regardless of your circumstances. I've only sat on one appeal where the LEA failed to prove it.

The second stage is about the impact of having an extra child in a school that is already full. You have to argue why the need for your child to go to that school is greater than the need for the existing kids not to have another in their class. So just as an example, why should the other children have less teacher time and their education impacted in order for your DD to be a faith school when you're not actively practising that faith? That's not a judgment on your reasoning, I'm just using it as an example of what you'll be up against.

I am actively practicing, I just don't attend church. However, many DC got places that do not practice Christianity atall.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 21/10/2023 21:34

FFSWhatToDoNow · 21/10/2023 20:46

There’s a specific board for this where you can get expert advice, OP.

I'll have a look, thank you

OP posts: