Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tips for a school appeal

112 replies

Hotandsunny · 21/10/2023 17:58

I'm trying to get my DD into a different school than she was offered. The appeal is coming up soon. Has anyone done one and can give me an idea of what to expect, any preparation I should do or any tips. Thanks ☺️

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 17:03

DragonFly98 · 22/10/2023 16:23

You need your old minister to write a supporting letter stating you attending weekly for x number of years until you could no longer attend due to your ds autism. For others reading this you should really have had them fill in the form at the time stating zero attendance but with the supporting letter. They then would have likely awarded you points based on historical attendance.

Oh, I didn't know that. I really struggled with the admission process.

I do have a supporting letter from the pastor.

OP posts:
Raera · 22/10/2023 16:55

As you mention your own mental health issues, can you provide any evidence of this as well? You don't need to provide private information, maybe an appointment letter for a MH clinic or if you take medication, a copy of your prescription, that sort of thing.
The extra evidence needs to be sent to the admissions department, not the school as they will be sending the information to the panel in advance of the hearing.

Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 16:54

Lougle · 22/10/2023 15:38

@Hotandsunny it's really hard when you find a school that sounds perfect and you just know your child will thrive there. However, the panel's job at an admissions appeal is to:

  1. Hear any representation that the admissions policy for the school is not in accordance with the admissions code.
  1. Establish if the school is full. If the school is nominally full, establish if the school can reasonably take any additional pupils.
  1. If the school is full, establish if a mistake has occurred during the admissions process that means that this child has missed out on a place that would fairly be theirs if the mistake had not occurred.
  1. If no mistake was made, establish if an individual appellant's case is stronger than the school's case that they are full.
  1. If the panel has decided that a school can take extra pupils, decide which pupils have the strongest case for admission.

That means that your case has to be really strong and really clear. For example, the school 'specialises in art' is great to hear. As an ex-panelist, I would have wanted to hear what difference that makes. What does this school offer that she couldn't get at another school? What evidence is there that art is significant to the child?

All schools have to be assumed to be suitable for educating children - a panel can't say 'oh yes, x school is dreadful, let's give the child a place at this school'. So what is special about this school, and what evidence is there that your child needs it? For example, there may well be a learning mentor, but what evidence is there that your DD will need it? Do you have evidence that she has needed extra support at primary school?

Bullying is again assumed to be dealt with similarly in all schools. If you raise the 'no bullying' point, what evidence do you have that your DD needs this particularly?

What I'm saying is that you need to make sure you're not just saying that this is a great school with a great ethos, but that this is the school your DD needs and this is why she needs it.

Thank you for that explanation it is very helpful.

The school specialises in Art and therefore their facilities are much better than the offered school. I have asked her play therapist to put in writing how important Art is to her. It has helped her deal with the trauma she suffered from being separated from me when I had a mental breakdown. It is also her special interest which is important to her due to autistic traits. I can't get evidence from school about this as they are not allowed to support an appeal. I could show some of her artwork?

My DD will need a learning mentor to help with the transition to the school as she struggles with that due to anxiety and autistic traits. She had to have a lot of pastoral support at school but again I can't evidence that as school isn't allowed to help us.

Re:bullying. The school she was offered has an Ofsted report saying the school has a bullying problem and the pupils are too scared to report it and are afraid when in unsupervised situations. My DD finds it hard raising issues with a teacher as it is. She had to have a sign on her desk that she could signal if there was a problem. But again I can't evidence this as school can't help.

My DD is particularly vulnerable due to trauma when I was unwell, her own mental health problems from Long Covid and her autistic traits. She needs a particularly supportive school with good pastoral care and according to the Ofsted report, my own experience speaking to the school as well as the head teachers talk and experience of touring the school, the school she was offered is not strong in this area.

OP posts:
MrTiddlesTheCat · 22/10/2023 16:42

Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 14:26

@MrTiddlesTheCat Can you give me more information about the school being full. I have found out that that the capacity is 1060 and the number of pupils is 967 on .gov.uk

Does that count as the school is not full or could they say Y7 is full?

It's a bit of both. You need to know why the numbers are different. They can still argue that there are only 30 computers in the computer room so 31 students means sharing and therefore less computer time for existing students. But they can't argue that the corridors are congested or that there aren't enough seats in the canteen.

LolaSmiles · 22/10/2023 16:24

Anything else I should ask?
It's probably going to come down to whether (assuming Year 7 is full) the case not to go over-full is stronger than the case to admit your child.

In reality this means demonstrating that the school you're appealing for is able to offer something your child needs that couldn't reasonably be provided elsewhere.

For example, many secondary schools have pastoral mentors/learning mentors/student support workers (titles differ). The existence of the team doesn't mean an individual student would automatically be allocated one of those staff, nor does it mean that one school is better than another in terms of evidence that a particular child should be at School A over School B.
But if School A has a comprehensive art therapy/Lego therapy/enhanced intervention within their SEN base, School B doesn't and a parent had evidence that their child needed the intervention so much that it would be detrimental to the child to go to School B (and that School B were unlikely to be able to provide that intervention) then the parent's case would be stronger.

DragonFly98 · 22/10/2023 16:23

You need your old minister to write a supporting letter stating you attending weekly for x number of years until you could no longer attend due to your ds autism. For others reading this you should really have had them fill in the form at the time stating zero attendance but with the supporting letter. They then would have likely awarded you points based on historical attendance.

Sticktoyourguns · 22/10/2023 16:16

Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 15:22

So questions for the school:

How many pupils are there and specifically how many in year 7 and how many classes?

Anything else I should ask?

Yes, and also ask for a breakdown of each class by numbers to see if any are over and any are full or under. You may be able to make some points based on the numbers.

Lougle · 22/10/2023 15:38

@Hotandsunny it's really hard when you find a school that sounds perfect and you just know your child will thrive there. However, the panel's job at an admissions appeal is to:

  1. Hear any representation that the admissions policy for the school is not in accordance with the admissions code.
  1. Establish if the school is full. If the school is nominally full, establish if the school can reasonably take any additional pupils.
  1. If the school is full, establish if a mistake has occurred during the admissions process that means that this child has missed out on a place that would fairly be theirs if the mistake had not occurred.
  1. If no mistake was made, establish if an individual appellant's case is stronger than the school's case that they are full.
  1. If the panel has decided that a school can take extra pupils, decide which pupils have the strongest case for admission.

That means that your case has to be really strong and really clear. For example, the school 'specialises in art' is great to hear. As an ex-panelist, I would have wanted to hear what difference that makes. What does this school offer that she couldn't get at another school? What evidence is there that art is significant to the child?

All schools have to be assumed to be suitable for educating children - a panel can't say 'oh yes, x school is dreadful, let's give the child a place at this school'. So what is special about this school, and what evidence is there that your child needs it? For example, there may well be a learning mentor, but what evidence is there that your DD will need it? Do you have evidence that she has needed extra support at primary school?

Bullying is again assumed to be dealt with similarly in all schools. If you raise the 'no bullying' point, what evidence do you have that your DD needs this particularly?

What I'm saying is that you need to make sure you're not just saying that this is a great school with a great ethos, but that this is the school your DD needs and this is why she needs it.

Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 15:22

So questions for the school:

How many pupils are there and specifically how many in year 7 and how many classes?

Anything else I should ask?

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 15:20

Lougle · 22/10/2023 15:09

It needs to be year 7 that has places to argue that they aren't full. However, you can weaken their general arguments about crowding in corridors, etc., if they are 93 places under capacity.

Ok, great, thank you. I did think that and also access to lunchtime clubs there should be space if they under occupancy.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 15:17

prh47bridge · 22/10/2023 15:07

Ask the school. They are required to answer any reasonable questions you ask to help you prepare for your appeal.

The numbers on gov.uk may be out of date. If the school is well under capacity, it makes it hard for them to claim that it is overcrowded, but they will still say that Y7 is full and that admitting another pupil will cause problems.

PAN = Published Admission Number, i.e. the number of pupils they admit in the normal admissions round.

You can always add to your case. However, if you have any new documentary evidence, submit it as soon as you can. If you try to use documents you haven't submitted in advance of the hearing, the panel may refuse to consider them or adjourn the hearing to another day. You don't want that.

@prh47bridge - ok, great, so I can email the school with questions. It did say on the .gov.uk it was updated in Sep 2023 so assume those figures are reasonably accurate.

In terms of adding to my case do I need to send that in writing to the school?

Thank you so much for all the help. I've struggled to find information for so long (hence my appeal being late) I should have asked here before!!

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 15:12

So from looking at the Ofsted report and the school's website, the school would meet my DD's needs:

It is welcoming, inclusive, calm, relationships between staff and pupils are positive, bullying is rare and if it happens staff deal with it.

It specialises in Art which is DD's special interest. There is a wide range of enrichment and extra curricular activities. Pupils with SEND follow a broad and ambitious curriculum. Leaders know how pupils with SEND are best supported to learn. Disruption to lessons is exceptionally rare.

It has strong pastoral care, for example learning mentors that can support with transition which is difficult for DD due to anxiety and autistic traits. The school has a counsellor which would be good for my DD who has had regular sessions with the play therapist at her Primary school which helped her enormously.

The headteacher says about the school 'we are family', 'we seek to nurture the individual talents, abilities and possibilities of the students', 'we enjoy a close positive relationship with our families', 'we are ambitious for every young person'

OP posts:
Lougle · 22/10/2023 15:10

X-posted with prh.

Lougle · 22/10/2023 15:09

Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 14:26

@MrTiddlesTheCat Can you give me more information about the school being full. I have found out that that the capacity is 1060 and the number of pupils is 967 on .gov.uk

Does that count as the school is not full or could they say Y7 is full?

It needs to be year 7 that has places to argue that they aren't full. However, you can weaken their general arguments about crowding in corridors, etc., if they are 93 places under capacity.

prh47bridge · 22/10/2023 15:07

Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 12:07

Does anyone know how I find out how many pupils there are at the school and what the capacity is?

Ask the school. They are required to answer any reasonable questions you ask to help you prepare for your appeal.

The numbers on gov.uk may be out of date. If the school is well under capacity, it makes it hard for them to claim that it is overcrowded, but they will still say that Y7 is full and that admitting another pupil will cause problems.

PAN = Published Admission Number, i.e. the number of pupils they admit in the normal admissions round.

You can always add to your case. However, if you have any new documentary evidence, submit it as soon as you can. If you try to use documents you haven't submitted in advance of the hearing, the panel may refuse to consider them or adjourn the hearing to another day. You don't want that.

Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 14:38

After getting all your advice I think I have further grounds for appeal. The appeal is in a couple of weeks. Would I be able to ask to add to the form and give in the letter I get from DD's play therapist?

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 14:36

@Sticktoyourguns - ok, thank you. I guess I could just ask the school?

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 14:33

@Sticktoyourguns - what does PAN mean please?

OP posts:
Sticktoyourguns · 22/10/2023 14:33

AFAIK you need to look at class sizes for year 7 and if each class is full and whether they are already oversubscribed, due to appeal, and by how many. However, It’s a good thing if the school is not full.

Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 14:26

@MrTiddlesTheCat Can you give me more information about the school being full. I have found out that that the capacity is 1060 and the number of pupils is 967 on .gov.uk

Does that count as the school is not full or could they say Y7 is full?

OP posts:
Sticktoyourguns · 22/10/2023 14:26

Yes, just put your case together. You can def state that the Ofsted report mentions a calm environment and that is what is needed for your child. Part of my argument was that pastoral care and the way the school operated in a family type environment was what was needed to support my DC. It is quite well known that religious schools often offer better pastoral support. Also check out languages, music etc for special interests for your DC.
I seem to remember that we did get a copy of all the class numbers, pan etc prior to the appeal but it was some time ago. If you don’t have it and can’t find it online ask the council to provide it. It’s really important info.
It does sound daunting but ime you won’t be arguing directly against each other as such. They’ll state their case and you yours. Then the panel may ask questions. It very much depends on the situation and how strong the case is, if the school can’t argue that they are full you won’t even have to put your case forward. I know that doesn’t seem to happen that often but it almost happened to me.

@Itwasamemo1 well done to you! I thought I had a very strong case for the secondary school appeal that I lost. The fact that they offered me a school place elsewhere and only informed me the day before went against me as they asked questions about that school and the subjects available, which I obviously hadn’t had time to look up. We were in such a bad place back then and it almost broke us tbh. It made my DC’s situation so much worse. However, it wasn’t meant to be and school my child eventually got (again through appeal) worked out fantastically!

Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 13:14

ChocolateTea · 22/10/2023 11:46

We had an appeal years ago, for a grammar school. We had lots of evidence of primary school failures, and DC’s natural talent, but we also said how affected they were by their siblings autism, and how that had disadvantaged them compared to others.

im not sure what part won our appeal but we did it

it was incredibly stressful though, and I cried more than once in the appeal hearing as it was so overwhelming sitting opposite four people adament your child isn’t good enough and you’re being there is pointless

and our appeal years on proved right, DC is definitely in the right school for them and the school agrees

That's so good that you won. It is so daunting and completely confusing too evidenced by more than 1 person saying they are not sure how they actually won. I guess you just have to present as much information as you can and hope for the best.

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 12:17

I've found a page on gov.uk it says the school has a capacity of 1030 and 967 pupils. So the school isn't full, but would I need to argue that the year group isn't full?

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 12:07

Does anyone know how I find out how many pupils there are at the school and what the capacity is?

OP posts:
Hotandsunny · 22/10/2023 11:50

I've just been reading the recent 'school inspection of a good school' and it actually mentions that the school is calm! I'm going to carry on reading. I'm also going to ask my Dd's play therapist to write something to back up her needs for somewhere small and calm.

OP posts: