Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Online delivery - how often do supermarkets give you substitutes?

108 replies

Partyinfrance · 21/10/2023 16:49

I've not been getting shopping delivered for that long, but I've found that every time I've had 2-3 things substituted, which is fine. However I've just received an email for today's delivery with 2 things substituted for something completely different, not even close to the original.
I just wonder what goes through their mind. I can send them back but I'm not able to choose something else in their place, so I'll have to go out and buy them, which defeats the whole object. Has anyone else had these problems?

OP posts:
BeeJeezUs · 22/10/2023 07:15

Our Tesco delivery driver told us that someone ordered a bottle of factor 50 suntan lotion. Because it was out of stock it was replaced with two bottles of factor 25 !!!!

WaitingfortheTardis · 22/10/2023 07:05

@CasperGutman Yes Tesco have started doing this and I find it useful to know in advance what is definitely coming.

WaitingfortheTardis · 22/10/2023 07:03

Fairly rarely and I've never had a weird substitute, it's always been quite boringly sensible. I like that when Tesco substitute for a more expensive item they don't charge the difference, which I think some others do.

Dontknowmusic · 22/10/2023 07:02

I use Ocado and almost never get substitutes

CasperGutman · 22/10/2023 06:53

The other good thing about Ocado substitutions is you get a notification via the app (and/or a text or email depending on account settings) in advance to let you know about any substitutions, which usually comes early afternoon for my regular evening delivery slot. Presumably their system generates this when the order has been picked. It means I'm not put on the spot to accept or reject subs on the doorstep, and could* pop in somewhere on the way home from work if a crucial item wouldn't be coming. At least in theory - this has never happened!

rocknrollaa · 22/10/2023 06:52

cheapskatemum · 21/10/2023 19:57

We use online ordering & delivery from Asda at work (residential children's home). Some of the substitutions really annoy me. For example, one week's menu had spaghetti bolognaise & chilli con carne on it & all the beef mince ordered was substituted with pork mince. When you consider all the different beef mince products (different weights, different provenance, different fat %) a supermarket stocks, I felt this was taking the piss. We cater for several people who are lactose intolerant, so order lactose free cheddar. Grated vegan "cheese" was substituted. No one ate it, because the taste & texture are completely different to cheddar, so it got to its use by date & had to be thrown away. When I accept a delivery, I always ask, "Are there any substitutions?" & get fobbed off with comments like, "None that I'm aware of" and "I don't know, they don't tell me, you have to check your emails." It's not in my emails because it's not me that does the order. If we stipulate no substitutions we could end up with nothing to eat for dinner on the evening of the delivery, so they've got us over a barrel.

I agree on things like the mince, that's rubbish because they will have had other beef mince in stock.

I find Asda do this whereas Waitrose would give you the next brand up or smaller weights to make up what you ordered.

Obviously Asda are cost cutting and they are the cheaper supermarket so I guess you get what you pay for (we use Asda atm but thinking of switching back and paying the extra!)

rocknrollaa · 22/10/2023 06:49

Asda are terrible for substitutes, we get loads - I can't remember ever getting a shop from them without any substitutes or items missing.

Ocado and Waitrose are a lot better, but obviously more expensive!

CasperGutman · 22/10/2023 06:46

Ocado. Rarely get substitutions, and when I have they've always been sensible ones - different brands of the same item, or two smaller packs to replace a larger one of the same thing.

I wonder if this is because Ocado items are picked from a warehouse where everything sold has gone through their ordering system. This should make stock control easier than e.g. Tesco or Sainsbury's where items are picked in stores and members of the public can just wander in without warning and take the last six garlic baguettes or whatever.

colinthecaterpillars · 22/10/2023 06:38

Yes all the time with asda, I ordered tuna and pasta bake sachets,substituted for chicken chasseur.

ReginaTheEvilQueen · 22/10/2023 06:34

BitchImTheSecretIngredient · 21/10/2023 18:24

Im an online shopper and the subs are suggested. We are on such a tight time frame that we often dont have time to think about the sub too much. But sometimes the system does throw up a ridiculous suggestion that i will override :)

Snap! Or at least i used to be 😂 the customer ordered Quorn 'ham' slices it was not in stock & the suggestion was actual ham! Quickly overrode that and gave them Quorn 'chicken' slices, it was the only suitable option, no way was i going to swap a vegetarian item for an animal product

GoingUpUpUp · 22/10/2023 06:28

Morrison’s very rarely have subs (I’d say 3 times a year and we order weekly) or stuff not available. The subs are mostly sensible too.

The exception being when I ordered prawn crackers and got cream crackers instead!

autiebooklover · 22/10/2023 06:27

Asda 2-3 every time. They do this thing where they substitute something of equal value but lower quantity. So if I order 1l of Asda oil they will give me a branded oil but 500ml ands it's the same price! That's not equal I'm getting half my order for the same money.

I've had a lettuce substituted for a cucumber. There was already a cucumber on the order so I got two.
Chia seeds for poppy seeds. I guess they look the same??
Decaf coffee for normal coffee. If I'm buying decaf I don't want the caffeine version.

I find Tesco and Sainsbury's expensive and I can't get the Morrisons app to work so I just suffer it for now.

SorryWorry · 22/10/2023 05:08

I stopped using Tesco after several years of weekly deliveries because of poor stock availability and constant substitutions. I have been using Ocado every week for the last three months and have yet to have an out of stock/substituted item.

I use Morrisons for work and also find that they are very good and rarely have to substitute items.

MassageForLife · 22/10/2023 05:00

I love a substitution!

It depends which shop you use - I think some charge you for what you get. But Taco charges you the cheapest of what you ordered or what you get.

I've scored so many times with getting more or better quality (24 eggs instead of 15, sweet peppers instead of the cheap ones. One time they subbed my strawberries for the same weight of blueberries. I sent the blueberries I had ordered back as I got so much more for the same price with the sub).

Dustyblue · 22/10/2023 04:37

There was a thread on this years ago that sticks in my mind. One Mumsnetter had ordered a fruit/nut loaf type thing, and it was subbed with a whole octopus.

She posted the delivery note, it was hilarious 😂

mondaytosunday · 21/10/2023 22:12

About half the time I might get a sub for one item or more. But only 10% of the time is it unacceptable.

Cocomelt · 21/10/2023 22:03

Very rare with Tesco. I do mine the night before though. When I've had a substitute it's always been a more expensive/bigger product. Once it was a different cut of pork, but was a lot bigger.

mrsfeatherbottom · 21/10/2023 22:00

Weekly Sainsburys online here and usually get between 2-6 substitutions but usually a more expensive version of what I ordered and then I get a voucher for the difference. It's great!

Diversion · 21/10/2023 21:58

I stopped using Morrisons because of substitutions which they charge for if they sub for something more expensive and out of stock items. Back to using Tesco, you can tick a box for subs and leave a note for individual items or say that anything can be subbed and they do not charge extra if the subbed item is more expensive. No subs on today's order but three out of stock items.

Mummumgem · 21/10/2023 21:35

I use Tesco, have for years. I get maybe one or two sub’s every week or two, you need to tick the sub box and you can leave a message for your shopper, like if sr flour not in stock send plain sort of thing, I’ve found this works most of the time. Mind you I only ever put a message on the odd thing, like bananas, I like them under ripe if possible

I’ve also found if you ask for things to be after a date, got a party Sunday so all party food must be dated after Sunday, or girls party, only sub things suitable for girls. Never let me down yet

Borborygmus · 21/10/2023 21:30

Being a bit of a nerd I actually keep a record of how many subs I get each week. With Asda (155 deliveries) it averaged 7.6%. However, since switching to Tesco (32 deliveries so far), it's a much better 0.7%. I wish I'd changed sooner!

Yearsyonder · 21/10/2023 21:29

Asda, every week. Often for smaller packs that cost just a little less so the unit price is higher.

Now shop with Morrisons who use the same warehousing and picking technology as Ocado, hardly ever at all.

KnottyKnitting · 21/10/2023 21:26

I do a Tesco online shop pretty much every week. Very very rarely get subs. When I do I make sure they are what I want. I am very specific in my notes- I always specify what I will and will not accept-

eg I like the Tesco brown bread but hate the Neville's crap , so always specify " Not Neville's" that way they sub with something decent like hovis or warbrtons. If I like Helmans light mayo- I will specify - any light hellmans .

Takes a bit longer but the notes really seem to work.

IDidntKnowMyOwnStrength · 21/10/2023 21:15

The subs are mostly auto generated, some customers are able to list what sub they prefer when ordering, the pickers need to pick faster than the speed of light so won't take much notice if replacement is not similar to original item.

Iphianassa · 21/10/2023 21:10

I wish Sainsbury's allowed comments on the substitutions, rather than just yes or no.

This week I ordered a 3l bottle of Cravendale semi-skimmed, which was on offer. The substitute was a 2l bottle of Cravendale semi-skimmed for only 20p less. I would have preferred a 3l bottle of Cravendale skimmed or full-fat for the same price - or 2x2l - but I suppose their system didn't think that.

@Pertangyangkipperbang wrote, about Sainsbury's,
"l never mind a substitute because its always something more expensive and they don't charge extra."
That doesn't happen round here, at least not lately. Like the milk, they substitute with one bottle, jar or packet of something smaller. This means I don't get the full amount I ordered and what they do send costs more per gram/ml as well.

I prefer Tesco's system for substitutions, where you can add a note.

Swipe left for the next trending thread