Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why there is an extra child in my house?

258 replies

SusanTheShocked · 21/10/2023 14:58

My daughter’s (9 years old) friend from school just turned up at my house. My DH answered the door as I was in the bath and her dad dropped her off.

My partner assumed I’d made plans and didn’t tell him…but I didn’t make plans. I assume dd did, but didn’t tell me? I don’t want to say anything as they are playing nicely and I don’t want to make the girl feel bad, though I will be having a word with dd later.

I have the mums phone number and need to message her as I’m not sure what’s happening/when she’s being picked up etc.

I need some advice on how to word the message to the mother in a way that doesn’t make it seem like I’m unhappy she is here, but letting her know that I had no idea this was happening.

(For context I am very socially awkward so worrying about how to word this probably more than I should be)

OP posts:
CharlotteBog · 21/10/2023 22:19

Pherian · 21/10/2023 22:04

No, not checking with the parents. Simply having the children inform the parents where they are. There is a difference between a 9 year old and an 11 and 13 year old child. Perhaps stop being so pedantic :)

Your reply that I questioned suggested the OP "just go with it" which I took to mean you would let a 9 (or in your case an 11) year old arrive at your house w/o you knowing in advance and that you'd be fine with it.

In fact the parents will know that child is with you because you ask the child to inform their parents. Whether it's the child informing, or you checking the parents know, the outcome is the same - you are taking some responsibility for ensuring the parents of pre-teen children know where they are.

I don't think that's pedantic.

Pooheadbumbum · 21/10/2023 22:11

@mathanxiety thank you that’s really helpful. I find most of my eldest’s friends have varying lists of dietary preferences which are annoying!

I also meal plan for the week so the idea of having to perform some sort of loaves and fishes style miracle in the coming future is daunting 🤣

So I’m right in thinking from what you’ve said (re only 2 children having friends over at a time) that it wasn’t a complete free for all? If so, how was this managed? Presumably some preplanning had to go into this?

Also, was an adult always present? What about new friends who you hadn’t met?

(sorry like I say this is new territory for both DH and I!)

TheFifthTellytubby · 21/10/2023 22:04

hadrianswallsycamore · 21/10/2023 17:17

@supersonicginandtonic me too. I hardly ever just cook for the children in my family! They either walk in and say hi or I walk in and see unknown shoes in the porch so know someone is here. I want my home to always be open to my kids friends

Our house was a bit like that when our kids were older - several of them and friends calling in all the time. To work out how many more for tea, we used to joke about counting the unknown shoes and dividing by two...😁

Pherian · 21/10/2023 22:04

No, not checking with the parents. Simply having the children inform the parents where they are. There is a difference between a 9 year old and an 11 and 13 year old child. Perhaps stop being so pedantic :)

CharlotteBog · 21/10/2023 22:00

Pherian · 21/10/2023 20:17

Yes I do, and I make sure that the parents are aware if they don’t. We live in a safe community and most kids this age will be able to roam around with friends. The “let your parents know you’re here” is a courtesy to see if they need a ride home at a certain time.

So you are checking with the parents. That's not quite just going with it.
OP wasn't sure whether she should be letting the parents know she had their child.

Tandora · 21/10/2023 21:55

wishon · 21/10/2023 17:36

@All2Well I feel that direct clarifications can actually help things sound less passive aggressive. If you think it's DD's fault, and if you don't want them to feel bad or to rush, you can state all of this directly.

Like "Oh I wasn't expecting xyz but it's on DD and not your child, and I'll have a chat with DD about it. Please don't feel bad, we don't have to be anywhere so don't rush to pick her up" just sounds a bit better than "I wasn't expecting xyz, I'll have a chat with DD about not inviting kids home without permission. Luckily we don't have to be anywhere today". To me at least.

Edited

I disagree. I don’t think this rephrasing makes the text sound any less rude, or even any less “passive aggressive”.

i think the problem is that telling the parents you were not expecting their DD is highly likely (to a NT person at least) to sound like an indirect way of communicating you are not happy with the situation / the daughter is not welcome/ the parents + children did wrong such that you feel the need to point it out. The only way to avoid that interpretation would be to send a (genuinely funny) jovial and casual text, making humour out of the situation , while emphasising what an absolutely welcome/ delightful surprise it was. And no hint either that it might not be acceptable in the future. I think this would only work if it were sincerely genuine tbh.

If I were the girl’s parents and got this text, or your rewriting of it, I’d be straight round to pick up my DD, feel so embarrassed and be avoiding OP in the future!

mathanxiety · 21/10/2023 21:55

Pooheadbumbum · 21/10/2023 19:59

@mathanxiety yes I’m more thinking of the posts re teenagers roaming the house uninvited! I mean… where do they go? Where do they sit? I’ve really no desire to spend an extra £30 at the drop of a hat on Papa Johns (just being facetious but that’s what 1 pp does who is clearly a much nicer person than me!!!)

I had five DCs at home, all of whom liked to have friends around. If anyone wanted to stay for dinner they ate whatever was in the pot. For snacks, I usually let them make popcorn. I also kept a big tub of the cheapest ice cream I could buy in the freezer. The secret to hosting kids is keeping their expectations of food and home comforts as low as possible. You have to start as you mean to continue.

As they got into the teen years, they all had a little disposable income from babysitting or other PT jobs, and they were welcome to go and get themselves a slice of pizza somewhere if they wanted more than basic fare.

Early on, when they were young and playdates were done by arrangement, I weeded out the whiny kids who complained that I didn't have the specific kind of yogurt or crackers they liked. Life is too short to deal with that kind of prince or princess on a regular basis.

They sat on the couch, chairs, and the floor. We had a PS2 and a Wii, and Guitar Hero, all in the sitting room, which they played with a lot. They also rode bikes, and played basketball in the alley. Usually, if someone came knocking, it was an invitation to come out and play. That often ended up with my DCs heading off to someone else's house or other kids ending up at mine.

Teens usually hung out in their bedrooms (I never allowed opposite sex friends to do that though). And if one of the DCs had a friend over, only one other DC could have a friend over at the same time, with allowances made for personality of the other friend and purpose of coming over (doing a homework project or studying was fine; quiet child fine).

minipie · 21/10/2023 21:42

MeridianB · 21/10/2023 21:32

I’m still confused about the girl’s dad arriving without confirming the whole thing in advance with you or DH. There’s no way I’d just turn up at someone’s house to drop off a 9yo unless it was prearranged with an adult.

Same, but maybe the dad assumed the mum had arranged it? If the parents don’t live together or the mum was out all day and child told dad it was all arranged already … I could imagine dad just going ok then and not checking with mum.

MeridianB · 21/10/2023 21:32

I’m still confused about the girl’s dad arriving without confirming the whole thing in advance with you or DH. There’s no way I’d just turn up at someone’s house to drop off a 9yo unless it was prearranged with an adult.

Pooheadbumbum · 21/10/2023 21:13

@PosterBoy (having not had this growing up due to being rural) can I just check…

these children dropping in, did they live next door/ in the same estate or whatever as you?

My children’s play dates (one of my children is 9), are all prearranged, and are all for at least 2-3 hours in the house, so fairly intense.

PosterBoy · 21/10/2023 21:08

How much things change in 10 years.

I wouldn't have batted an eyelid at this. When 9 year olds weren't dropped off I would do a quick check that their parents actually knew where they were, in case they were worried, then they'd just get on with things.

What would you rather? It's a choice really. Kids don't have friends? Kids playing out? Kids at someone else's house? How welcoming you are now shapes that over the next few years. I always loved having them at mine so I guess that's why this kind of thing made me happy.

spinspinsugar55 · 21/10/2023 20:56

Glad it all worked out in the end OP 👍

The thing about 9 year olds sorting play dates with each other and not informing parents is ok if they live in the same street or around the corner, and are just ‘knocking for each other’. This is what I did growing up, and it’s what my kids have all done and still do.
However there is a big difference when they’re organising play dates with school friends that they don’t live near so they can’t just walk over and knock on the door to play with their friend. These play dates are always done (in my experience) via parents as they involve drop offs and pick ups.
Two very different play situations between 9/10 year olds.

Spanglemum02 · 21/10/2023 20:49

Mr too. DH still does

LeakyPipes · 21/10/2023 20:31

Jammyhand

Genuine feedback: I'm someone who appreciates direct honesty, but the message comes off as very passive aggressive, not honest or direct at all.

@All2Well did say "You run the risk of them just dumping their child on you whenever they feel like it, you need to be honest but nice." So I do think the message was intended to have passive aggressive elements ("please don't send your child round like that again" – only it doesn't actually say that and just beats around the bush in an accusatory way).

"Will have a chat with her later and explain she needs to ask me first as we might not have been in and I'd hate either of them to be disappointed" – why would she need/want to know what you're chatting with DD about and why? Why should she care about what your DD gets up to, and what your home set up is – unless it involves her somehow? It sounds like you're indirectly telling the mother about the potential inconvenience her own child's presence could have caused, by claiming you would talk to DD about that.

Essentially there's no direct request / conclusion to do with the recipient parent (e.g. for the parent to check with OP in future) in the message. It's just a long random ramble about why OP's DD shouldn't randomly invite others home, and how it's lucky that OP could take the child in today ("luckily our plans today can be flexible"). The message is "be guilty and grateful".

UNLESS you have a request for her like "please check with me in future", then the background / reason (about the inconvenience) is important. But just directly and nicely tell her that it might be inconvenient as you might not be home. Don't tell her that under the indirect guise of "I've had a chat with my DD about the inconvenience".

Also, I think it's arguably fine to honestly say you weren't expecting her child, but you can do that without talking about why DD shouldn't invite random children home in the long term etc. If you go on about how DD's actions were a mistake in such a long message in such a faux tinkly laugh manner, it makes the reader wonder what point you're trying to make about their child's presence in your home.

For those who were asking, this is exactly why the text suggested much earlier isn't simply factual, and would actually be pretty offensive to most people on the receiving end.

FWIW I've been amazed to learn that there's something wrong with 9 year old children inviting friends round without making arrangements in advance through parents. Things have clearly changed enormously since I was a child!

And I'm also pretty amazed to find that some people don't know that some other people call the midday meal dinner, and would need to have that explained to them.

What a weird thread!

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 21/10/2023 20:18

After the playdate is over, say next week, drop a text to the mum and arrange to let each other know if the girls make their own plans as your DD has form for forgetting to mention plans she makes ...

Pherian · 21/10/2023 20:17

Yes I do, and I make sure that the parents are aware if they don’t. We live in a safe community and most kids this age will be able to roam around with friends. The “let your parents know you’re here” is a courtesy to see if they need a ride home at a certain time.

CharlotteBog · 21/10/2023 20:13

Pherian · 21/10/2023 19:46

My partners 11 and 13 year old sons frequently arrive back at the house with friends. All of which want feeding and drinks and snacks.

Instead of making a big deal out of it, because at some point you're going to not be so important in their lives, just go with it because when they get older and show back up at the house with friends it's a compliment. They could be anywhere, but they chose to be with you.

Do you ask the 11 year olds whether their parents know where they are? I live rurally so things tend to be less spontaneous.

Pooheadbumbum · 21/10/2023 19:59

@mathanxiety yes I’m more thinking of the posts re teenagers roaming the house uninvited! I mean… where do they go? Where do they sit? I’ve really no desire to spend an extra £30 at the drop of a hat on Papa Johns (just being facetious but that’s what 1 pp does who is clearly a much nicer person than me!!!)

Ap42 · 21/10/2023 19:51

Just go with the flow. My eldest has friends here all the time without letting me know. He's secondary school age though so arrange things between them.
All I would say is that I wouldn't allow my youngest (8) to go over to a friends house without getting the ok from the parents. I find that a bit strange, at that age play dates are normally arranged between the parents, so I can see why your miffed.

Pherian · 21/10/2023 19:46

My partners 11 and 13 year old sons frequently arrive back at the house with friends. All of which want feeding and drinks and snacks.

Instead of making a big deal out of it, because at some point you're going to not be so important in their lives, just go with it because when they get older and show back up at the house with friends it's a compliment. They could be anywhere, but they chose to be with you.

mathanxiety · 21/10/2023 19:36

@Pooheadbumbum just be sure you're the one who answers the door, and tell kids you're sorry but today isn't a good day to come in and play with little Jimmy.

Justgivemesomepeace · 21/10/2023 19:35

'Hi friend, its nice to see you! Are u having some tea? What time is your dad picking you up?

CharlotteBog · 21/10/2023 19:33

Fromthebirdsnest · 21/10/2023 19:20

I have 4 kids my older 2 are year 9 & 10 .. I have a flow of children at my house ,they do 2 large pizzas 2 sides and a drink for £29.99 at papa John's if I don't have enough dinner I just order them that ... if she's a sweet girl I wouldn't make a fuss ,social etiquette is learned over time and children can mess up its not a big deal x

Year 9 and 10 is a whole lot different to age 9. The OP's DD is 9 years old.

CharlotteBog · 21/10/2023 19:31

At age 9 there was always parent knowledge/agreement when my kids either went to someone's house or when we had kids over here.
I would never just go on e.g. "My Mum says John can come to my house after school" but would contact the parent to check.
When they started knocking for each other and having a bit more freedom round the village I would always make sure I sent a parent a text to let them know their kid was at my place.

Even now at 14 I send a text to a parent..."just checking you're expecting Steve to stay over at yours tonight".

I think being ND means you need to be a bit more lenient in how you explain it all to the children, but I would think it would be even more important to contact the parent as soon as possible.

No one did anything wrong, you don't need to tip toe around, just be honest and explain.

mathanxiety · 21/10/2023 19:27

nextdoorneighbours · 21/10/2023 15:19

The Dad dropped her off at the wrong house on his way somewhere or other and can't now be contacted. Other playdate Mum has contacted child's mum to ask why child has not arrived. Child's mum has called police and reported child missing...

YY to this ^

Swipe left for the next trending thread