Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
WhiteHorseSpirit · 22/10/2023 13:22

dangerrabbit · 22/10/2023 12:52

Other than the whole 1984 angle, which PPs have highlightedthe extremely disturbing nature of.

Where do they find the money to do this (as it must surely be quite expensive) and why don't they put the money into actually educating children.

It’s centrally funded. Costs DfE nothing to contact a POC in another Gov Department and request a report be run on so and so and sent to them.

The fact that certain government departments do not have direct access to this intelligence, doesn’t mean they cannot access information generated by it.

WhiteHorseSpirit · 22/10/2023 13:20

Thelnebriati · 22/10/2023 13:04

Those of us who opposed the online safety bill did try to point all of this out but we were called tin foil hatters.

This country is sliding into authoritarianism.

I was one (not on MN, but other SM) and yes the “tin foil hat” response was levelled at me then too.

feellikeanalien · 22/10/2023 13:14

Sadly as the internet develops and living our lives online becomes more the norm, e.g. banking, shopping, storing photos and documents, it becomes easier for governments to monitor us. I think you would be naive to think that there are not people within government agencies/the security services whose job is monitoring social media. You only need to think of the algorithms which influence what comes up on your Twitter feed or on Facebook to realise that certain views or words will trigger interest in your posting.

All governments do this so don't think it will stop if Labour get into power. Their targets may just be slightly different.

I do however think it is appalling that this has been used to stop people from speaking at conferences if they hold ant-government views. This is definitely something people should be concerned about as it is only likely to get worse.

Don't forget that the UK has one of the highest incidences of surveillance cameras in public places in the world. You can be tracked easily by bank card spending, store loyalty cards and countless other methods.

Whilst we go about our lives normally this is not usually an issue for most people. The problems start to arise if someone does something which, although innocuous to them, flags an interest in those carrying out monitoring. This has always happened throughout the ages but it is just a lot easier to do now.

Thelnebriati · 22/10/2023 13:04

Those of us who opposed the online safety bill did try to point all of this out but we were called tin foil hatters.

This country is sliding into authoritarianism.

dangerrabbit · 22/10/2023 12:52

Other than the whole 1984 angle, which PPs have highlightedthe extremely disturbing nature of.

Where do they find the money to do this (as it must surely be quite expensive) and why don't they put the money into actually educating children.

WhiteHorseSpirit · 22/10/2023 12:47

RadioMedia · 22/10/2023 12:12

I think it’s helpful that @WhiteHorseSpirit has told us about this database and who can access it, and it’s interesting that such a level of information is routinely used to determine who gets jobs etc. especially since political information is included. What I’d like to question is whether we want to live in a society that holds this level of information about people who are really quite nice and not dangerous in any way. And do we want to live in a society where nice, sensible people can’t speak at conferences or get certain jobs because they disagree with economic policy?

I don’t want to live in such a world. Sadly the current issue with this TA is the tip of a stealthy iceberg - that’s why I have been posting info as this threat to privacy is much larger. I think we are on our way to such a world. It’s not affecting everyone yet, but is quietly being expanded to encompass more and more demographic segments of society.

WhiteHorseSpirit · 22/10/2023 12:42

‘Reasonable grounds’ to be flagged for full on investigation by DWP include being tagged by an algorithm……
https://privacyinternational.org/long-read/4397/shedding-light-dwp-part-2-long-days-journey-towards-transparency

It’s no stretch of the imagination to think that similar surveillance occurs for government employees that require DBS checks perhaps it’s “reasonable grounds” to get an updated departmental system report from the centralised system if the employee is, for example, invited as an official speaker to a conference? Where what they say could reflect poorly on the government?

WhiteHorseSpirit · 22/10/2023 12:23

Sensing a bit of denial of reality here.
https://www.wired.co.uk/article/internet-connection-records-uk-surveillance

The article also mentions “encryption back doors” which the Gov has now made law:
Do you know the recently passed Online Safety Bill has clauses that limit end to end encryption. End to end encryption has been standard on even free emails like gmail, or msn etc for decades to protect personal information. The same with accessing shopping online, banking online. This bill puts that into jeopardy all with “child safety” as the excuse.

https://www.theregister.com/2023/09/20/uk_online_safety_bill_passes/

Although it remains to be seen if they can actually enforce the law…either way it is a green light for software added on that would scan everything we do online- pictures, text, bank transactions, shopping and oh, my a contract was let to BAE last year to potentially do that although a FOIA asking about it resulted in “can neither confirm nor deny” and “national security”.

Oh, on DWP investigating “reasonable grounds” is very very subjective and given Sunak declaring benefits claimants as public enemy #1 in his latest speech, the fact you claim benefits could be reason enough to be “checked” as it is up to the decision authority what is reasonable grounds and the Tories are as hostile towards benefits claimants as they are to immigrants.

The UK’s Secretive Web Surveillance Program Is Ramping Up

A government effort to collect people’s internet records is moving beyond its test phase, but many details remain hidden from public view.

https://www.wired.co.uk/article/internet-connection-records-uk-surveillance

RadioMedia · 22/10/2023 12:12

I think it’s helpful that @WhiteHorseSpirit has told us about this database and who can access it, and it’s interesting that such a level of information is routinely used to determine who gets jobs etc. especially since political information is included. What I’d like to question is whether we want to live in a society that holds this level of information about people who are really quite nice and not dangerous in any way. And do we want to live in a society where nice, sensible people can’t speak at conferences or get certain jobs because they disagree with economic policy?

OP posts:
cakeorwine · 22/10/2023 11:44

WhiteHorseSpirit · 22/10/2023 11:36

There is a minimum rank that can access the info or request it from the centralised system. I said both are probably done- query the system and download plus track through SM because the system will have information that has been deleted. E.g posts on MN or to X that have been deleted you wouldn’t see by checking SM via the public page. But you’d get all of it, including deleted posts and version history of edits via your query to the central government database.

DfE isn’t only department that can access this info…DWP can too and have hired 2,000 investigators to start looking into benefits claimants using this access as well as looking at public access SM activity.
https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/cost-of-living/dwp-could-monitoring-your-bank-27956034

I think you need tin foil.

They can look at your social media - and don't need to download anything. A bit of research is all there is.

DWP does have the right to investigate bank accounts if they suspect benefit fraud.

But that is carefully controlled

Benefit Fraud Investigation Process - St Pauls Chambers

Officers can only make enquiries into benefit fraud where they have reasonable grounds to do so. During the benefit fraud investigation, they can:

  • Undertake undercover surveillance
  • Communicate with your place of employment
  • Monitor your social media accounts
  • Interview people that you know
  • Check your bank statements to find information that may be useful to their investigation.
  • Take photographs or videos for evidence
  • Can DWP check your Facebook?
Yes, the DWP can look over your social media accounts, including Facebook. Whilst checking your social media, the DWP will be looking at your tagged pictures, any location check-ins or any posts that may incriminate you for benefit fraud.

What they don't AND can't do is simply go on to a database and say "Pull up CakeOrWines" social media and internet use and have that all there in an instant

Benefit Fraud Investigation Process - St Pauls Chambers

Discover the benefit fraud investigation process in this step-by-step guide which helps you understand what to do if you're being investigated.

https://www.stpaulschambers.com/benefit-fraud-investigation-process/

noblegiraffe · 22/10/2023 11:44

So you have no evidence that these DfE officials did anything other than read twitter.

WhiteHorseSpirit · 22/10/2023 11:42

FWIW, I haven’t voted because I think it pointless. We live in a surveillance state.

WhiteHorseSpirit · 22/10/2023 11:40

noblegiraffe · 22/10/2023 11:34

And what do they need to do to get the access? If you could possibly provide more information than a winky face, that would be great.

And if you could explain why they would access a database of all internet activity but then only discuss information publicly available on twitter, that would also be helpful.

You can read about the process if you take the time to read UK.gov policy documents and manuals. Its too long to summarise here.

The reason only publicly available information would be published to the public domain is GDPR. Do not mistake this limit on what can be publicly released for all the information that a government department would have in their possession about a person from which to make employment and other decisions.

WhiteHorseSpirit · 22/10/2023 11:36

noblegiraffe · 21/10/2023 23:54

There’s a difference between “it all gets saved” and “lowly govt officials can access it whenever they like” you know?

There is a minimum rank that can access the info or request it from the centralised system. I said both are probably done- query the system and download plus track through SM because the system will have information that has been deleted. E.g posts on MN or to X that have been deleted you wouldn’t see by checking SM via the public page. But you’d get all of it, including deleted posts and version history of edits via your query to the central government database.

DfE isn’t only department that can access this info…DWP can too and have hired 2,000 investigators to start looking into benefits claimants using this access as well as looking at public access SM activity.
https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/cost-of-living/dwp-could-monitoring-your-bank-27956034

DWP could be checking your bank and social media accounts in fraud crackdown

A DWP team is said to be checking benefit claims deemed at risk of being incorrect, including suspicious cases which entered the system during the pandemic

https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/cost-of-living/dwp-could-monitoring-your-bank-27956034

cakeorwine · 22/10/2023 11:34

WhiteHorseSpirit · 22/10/2023 11:30

That’s the list from 2015. It has quietly expanded from there to any department that requires DBS checks on employees 😉

Did you even read the bit about the permissions needed to access the data?
Do you even know what data is collected?

noblegiraffe · 22/10/2023 11:34

And what do they need to do to get the access? If you could possibly provide more information than a winky face, that would be great.

And if you could explain why they would access a database of all internet activity but then only discuss information publicly available on twitter, that would also be helpful.

WhiteHorseSpirit · 22/10/2023 11:30

noblegiraffe · 22/10/2023 00:14

I looked at the list of who can access this and the DfE isn't on it.

That’s the list from 2015. It has quietly expanded from there to any department that requires DBS checks on employees 😉

ACGTHelix · 22/10/2023 00:59

Valerianandfoxglovesoup · 21/10/2023 15:52

Why are people keeping files on TAs. I've only ever encountered mums who want a term time job, hardly MI5 types 😀

they did do a recruitment drive on here a while ago

noblegiraffe · 22/10/2023 00:14

I looked at the list of who can access this and the DfE isn't on it.

cakeorwine · 22/10/2023 00:00

And as for who can access them

Those records can include which websites a customer visits, when, and how much data they download, as well as the relevant IP (internet protocol) addresses - but not what pages or exactly what content they read on those sites.
But that so-called "metadata" can still reveal a lot about a person's habits - from what political sites they visit to their use of pornography. There are, however, restrictions on who can access the ICRs and for what reasons

Laptop

Will UK spy bill risk exposing people's porn habits?

The UK government wants internet companies to log which websites their users visit, raising questions about how safely that data will be guarded.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-34719569

cakeorwine · 21/10/2023 23:58

I think that @WhiteHorseSpirit is confused by the powers under the Act

Home Office tests web-spying powers with help of UK internet firms - BBC News

Difference between websites visited and everything posted, said, bank accounts, purchasing history...

An eye in extreme-close-up looks through cascading lines of computer code

Home Office tests web-spying powers with help of UK internet firms

A Home Office trial with two UK internet providers has logged user activity on websites.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-56362170

noblegiraffe · 21/10/2023 23:54

WhiteHorseSpirit · 21/10/2023 23:38

Probably the latter, but they can access the former too. It all gets saved.

There’s a difference between “it all gets saved” and “lowly govt officials can access it whenever they like” you know?

cakeorwine · 21/10/2023 23:44

And you also think that anyone at the DFE can simply call up the social media of any person in the country at the press of a button and the file of any teacher and their postings appear magically?

cakeorwine · 21/10/2023 23:43

WhiteHorseSpirit · 21/10/2023 23:38

Probably the latter, but they can access the former too. It all gets saved.

And you think it's ok for the DFE to withhold funding from a conference because the speaker criticised Government policy?

And why mention a speaker and secondary schools?

WhiteHorseSpirit · 21/10/2023 23:38

noblegiraffe · 21/10/2023 23:33

the info is centrally kept by the intelligence agencies of U.K. Gov and DfE is simply accessing and downloading it to a file

Do you understand that you’re implying that dweebs at the DfE can simply ‘access and download’ anyone they fancy’s web activity for no good reason?

Are you sure that they’re not just going on twitter and reading it? Because that seems far more likely…

Probably the latter, but they can access the former too. It all gets saved.

Swipe left for the next trending thread