Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset she brought it up AGAIN

183 replies

MILwoes1 · 21/10/2023 10:37

DH and I have a great relationship. We’ve both been in shit relationships before and genuinely have a happy marriage. Have our disagreements don’t get me wrong but on the whole we’re happy.

i’m DH’s 2nd wife, he got divorced 9 years ago. He also had another 4 year relationship before that. We know each other’s pasts and have accepted them etc so that’s fine. I was in a long term relationship as well before I met him.

the problem is my MIL CONSTANTLY brings up his exes despite my husband constantly berating her for it. He just says to her that’s not relevant anymore, no need to bring it up. It’s even if she’s telling a story where there’s no need to mention his exes, she will anyway.

so last night we’re all out for dinner (all the girls just) and my DH said to me if his mother says anything about the past just ignore her because it has got to the point where it’s annoying/upsetting me and that he would say on the quiet to his sister (who was also at the dinner) to make sure his mother didn’t bring up the past.

so everything was going fine and we were talking about wedding numbers for an upcoming family wedding and she says ‘sure when DH and ‘Ex wives name’ got married…’ looked at me and then changed the subject then was laughing to herself about her obvious faux pas.

i made my excuses about having a headache and went on home to DH. He’s angry that she brought it up again and so am I. We live about 30 mins away from MIL so just young to give her a wide berth from now on. I feel a bit bad doing that but I feel like she’s nearly doing it deliberately now

AIBU?

OP posts:
PhantomUnicorn · 21/10/2023 12:32

Considering you say you accept he has a past, why does it bother you that his exes are bought up?

Stop saying you accept it if you dont.

Both my ExH and my brother have been married twice, i've been married once and am now in a relationship.. my partner has had past relationships.. we all talk about each other exes, past marriages, relationships...etc without any of it being taboo or anyone being weird about it like they have to be hushed up, they're included in conversation like anyone else we know from the past would be.

I suggest you address with yourself WHY it bothers you to the point your MIL is expected to be quiet.

I get she is being a horror having being asked to NOT talk, and that does need addressing, but if it didn't bother you, her behaviour would be a non issue.

billy1966 · 21/10/2023 12:31

Give her the widest berth.

Completely avoid her.

Tell your husband that how and when he sees his mother is completely his business and you would rather not be included as you need a break from her persistent rudeness.

Don't say anymore.

Sit back and see how much effort he makes.

Do not respond to any contact from her.

She has chosen to be unkind, she can accept the consequences.

Oganesson118 · 21/10/2023 12:25

My in laws used to live abroad. The first time I met them was on a visit out there. We went out for lunch the day we arrived and pretty much the first questions she asked were "Are you going to meet up with Ex1 whilst you're here?" and "Have you been in touch with Ex2?" followed by his brother saying "What about girlhelikedbutdidntgettogetherwith?"

They pretty much set out their stall there and then that I wasn't what they hoped for.

Lovelyweatheragain · 21/10/2023 12:21

I bet she was nasty to the exes too, when they were with your DH

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 21/10/2023 12:19

How long were they together? Were they close? Do they have kid together? If they were together years then it can be quite difficult to not mention someone that was a big part of your life for years, and pretty much impossible not to if they have kids.

I get on with my ex SIL, we spent a lot of time as two couples, and although I don't talk about her directly to my brother, she is my nephews mum and of course she comes up in the odd conversation eg discussions of past holidays, celebrations etc.

Unless you think she is doing it more frequently than she otherwise would, just to annoy you, or is doing it needlessly 'oh nice hair, reminds me of the time when ex wife had a hair cut'. But in a discussion about weddings it would be weird of her not to mention her sons first wedding surely

NoTouch · 21/10/2023 12:19

theduchessofspork · 21/10/2023 12:04

The OP has said her MIL constantly brings up his exes, it’s not the odd reference. This is unusual. She’s been asked to stop. A normal person would reduce the references.

Don’t be obtuse.

A different opinion does not equate to obtuse. You have every right to disagree but there is no need to for insults.

The only example op gave was there was a discussion on weddings, reference to a previous wedding that the whole family was probably heavily involved in and was a shared experience in the past is absolutely normal and op, imo, overreacted in this example.

Wildhorses2244 · 21/10/2023 12:15

I’d go for “It’s odd that you keep bringing up Exw as though you were close when she and dh were married- she’s always maintained that the best bit of divorcing was getting some space. Maybe absence does make the heart grow fonder. Funny that really. “

TheNoodlesIncident · 21/10/2023 12:12

You were talking about weddings and she mentioned a previous significant wedding, her sons, she had been to.

Surely the more recent wedding of her son's to OP would have been more significant than a previous one many years ago which ended in divorce?

TBH I'd be more rolling my eyes and saying "Oh yes MIL, I saw DH Ex the other day and she said "Watch out for MIL, she's a pain!" Guess what I said..?" Just really making a joke of it and showing her you don't actually care about her opinion - it'll take the sting out of her tail if you don't look as though you care (whether you do or not). People who say things for a reaction are disappointed when you thwart them by not providing any (or one that is clearly humorous and poking fun at them).

NoTouch · 21/10/2023 12:11

Poppydieu · 21/10/2023 11:57

You seriously think it’s appropriate to talk about OP’s dh first wedding to the OP?

I "seriously" do not see the issue and would not expect family to have to check or censor conversations. Op obviously has some issues still with her dhs past.

CruCru · 21/10/2023 12:10

Vitriolinsanity · 21/10/2023 11:31

I think you have to do this one directly yourself.

Straight in the eye "MIL every time I see you you mention DH's ex wives. There really can be only two reasons spite or dislike to me. It's time now to either stop, and for good, or keep on. If you keep on, it will mean that I will need to stop seeing you as I would anyone that continued when you've been told many times that you upset me."

Then stop talking. Her reaction will tell you everything you need to know to take it from there.

I like this - sometimes it’s more polite to be direct. When I have to be direct, I pretend that I am an English speaking German / Swede / Dutch person. Someone who is not squeamish about plain speaking.

OhComeOnFFS · 21/10/2023 12:09

Did she do the same to his ex girlfriend? Did she particularly get on well with her previous DIL? Did the women like her?

KCandtheSunlightBand · 21/10/2023 12:07

Just get the ex wife conversation in first, ‘I know when DH married Samantha they had several hundred to the wedding, didn’t they MiL?’ Takes all the sting out of it. Show her you know DH has a past, everyone knows, and no one cares.

2chocolateoranges · 21/10/2023 12:06

I’d be going low contact with her however I would also be tempted to ask her in front of everyone, the next time she mentions an ex ,

Did you dislike her as much as you dislike me?
Did she see sense and leave dh because of you?

theduchessofspork · 21/10/2023 12:04

NoTouch · 21/10/2023 11:53

Agree with this. You were talking about weddings and she mentioned a previous significant wedding, her sons, she had been to.

What is the big deal? It seems you want the topic to be taboo, or you have an issue with it? Why can't it be mentioned? Do you have jealousy issues either around you dhs past relationships, or his families relationship with a previous DIL or perhaps his previous wedding?. I can't understand why this is a problem in the context of generally taking about weddings.

YABVU to try to ban anyone from taking about significant periods of their life and you need to reflect why this is such a big issue for you (as you are the one with the problem) that you are willing to risk fracturing your and your dhs relationship with his family over it.

We mention my brothers ex wife regularly, I still see her a few times a year, and his current wife doesn't even flinch, she even initiates the conversations sometimes because she feels secure in her relationship and herself.

The OP has said her MIL constantly brings up his exes, it’s not the odd reference. This is unusual. She’s been asked to stop. A normal person would reduce the references.

Don’t be obtuse.

AmandaHoldensLips · 21/10/2023 12:04

Yeah, she's not a very nice person. Give her a wide berth and emotionally detach from her completely. Look up Grey Rock Technique and use it whenever you are forced to be in her company. Leave her entirely to your DH to deal with and communicate with. Don't bother answering the phone to her either.

theduchessofspork · 21/10/2023 12:00

ForfarBridie · 21/10/2023 10:48

I would just say - DH is very weary of you constantly bringing up the past and because I’m so fond of you I feel it’s my duty to explain that his patience is running out and you’re in danger of him not seeing you so often going forward.

This is very sensible

As you don’t seem to want to reduce contact, it’s worth one last shot

Brefugee · 21/10/2023 11:58

I wouldn't have made an excuse like a headache though (because i am bolshy) - I'd have stood up, rolled my eyes and said "not this tripe again, MIL, why not invite ex instead of me next time?"

Give her an extremely wide birth. She's not worth the headspace

Poppydieu · 21/10/2023 11:57

NoTouch · 21/10/2023 11:53

Agree with this. You were talking about weddings and she mentioned a previous significant wedding, her sons, she had been to.

What is the big deal? It seems you want the topic to be taboo, or you have an issue with it? Why can't it be mentioned? Do you have jealousy issues either around you dhs past relationships, or his families relationship with a previous DIL or perhaps his previous wedding?. I can't understand why this is a problem in the context of generally taking about weddings.

YABVU to try to ban anyone from taking about significant periods of their life and you need to reflect why this is such a big issue for you (as you are the one with the problem) that you are willing to risk fracturing your and your dhs relationship with his family over it.

We mention my brothers ex wife regularly, I still see her a few times a year, and his current wife doesn't even flinch, she even initiates the conversations sometimes because she feels secure in her relationship and herself.

You seriously think it’s appropriate to talk about OP’s dh first wedding to the OP?

Poppydieu · 21/10/2023 11:55

Next time just ask
Did dh’s ex’s leave because you were their mil?
I’ll have to have a chat with them about you.

NoTouch · 21/10/2023 11:53

Spinet · 21/10/2023 11:29

Honestly the best thing you can do is accept that your DH had a past life/wife and exes and speak of them as easily as your mil does. That way she can't upset you with it can she? With somebody who will talk about forbidden subjects to upset you it's best not to have any forbidden subjects, unless you can just go NC.

Agree with this. You were talking about weddings and she mentioned a previous significant wedding, her sons, she had been to.

What is the big deal? It seems you want the topic to be taboo, or you have an issue with it? Why can't it be mentioned? Do you have jealousy issues either around you dhs past relationships, or his families relationship with a previous DIL or perhaps his previous wedding?. I can't understand why this is a problem in the context of generally taking about weddings.

YABVU to try to ban anyone from taking about significant periods of their life and you need to reflect why this is such a big issue for you (as you are the one with the problem) that you are willing to risk fracturing your and your dhs relationship with his family over it.

We mention my brothers ex wife regularly, I still see her a few times a year, and his current wife doesn't even flinch, she even initiates the conversations sometimes because she feels secure in her relationship and herself.

Spinet · 21/10/2023 11:51

I think the MIL is very probably being an absolute cow. But it's a good time to practise that 'you can only control what YOU do' thing and work on not being bothered about your DH's past. People throw the idea of going NC about on here but it's seldom straightforward and never without a sacrifice of some sort.

Vitriolinsanity · 21/10/2023 11:49

Frasers · 21/10/2023 11:44

Honestly I think the answer here is not to white wash out his past, why does it bother you if she mentions it, if it didn’t she would likely stop.

But OP isn't whitewashing. She knows perfectly well about her husband's relationships, given he's a grown up it'd be jolly odd if he hadn't any.

The point is that MIL seems to either have one foot stuck in the past, or is a goady fucker.

Either way it doesn't much matter when she's been asked by her own children to knock it off.

dottiedodah · 21/10/2023 11:47

She sounds like she enjoys your reaction to this .TBH I think she is very petty.odds on she liked upsetting first wife too! I would just be cool with her and let SIL take her to task . Your own DH is upset by it too. She must be pretty cold to keep on with it

Frasers · 21/10/2023 11:44

Honestly I think the answer here is not to white wash out his past, why does it bother you if she mentions it, if it didn’t she would likely stop.

MarathonBarbie · 21/10/2023 11:44

If she’s just mentioning her in a factual way, relevant to the conversation I wouldn’t have a problem with it. The past is the past and isn’t in competition with the present. If she’s comparing unfavourably that’s a different thing though and I’d be pissed off as the intent behind that is very different.
Either way though, if she’s been asked not to and is consciously doing so anyway that’s a different story.

Swipe left for the next trending thread