Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rishi considers tax cut for top earners

83 replies

Vocaladvocaat · 21/10/2023 09:06

I am really trying to stay neutral here. But, faced with massive by election defeats, from a nation slammed with mortgage rises, cost of living, and inflation, The Tories are thinking about how they can reward the top earners???

Really?

Not the millions doing 60 hour weeks and struggling to pay their bills. It's this lack of awareness that is the whole problem...

Rishi Sunak considers tax cut for top earners after byelection defeats (msn.com)

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/rishi-sunak-considers-tax-cut-for-top-earners-after-byelection-defeats/ar-AA1iAFYB?ocid=msedgntp&pc=SCOOBE&cvid=904d4e5b280b4f1eaf25f9eb91a10d39&ei=14

OP posts:
YouJustDoYou · 21/10/2023 10:09

France tried increasing tax on higher earners and they just left the country. When you earn enough to be able to just jump ship, you just jump ship. When you're already having almost half your earning taken and a Government wants to take even more, it's all well and good if the country is actually being run well but when it's a shit show then no, of course you're not going to put up with having even more taken off you. Keeping the wealthy in your country is a benefit, though those who don't earn as much always seem to think milking people as much as possible is the way to go, though I seriously doubt were they in the same position they wouldn't be singing the same tune when you have to lose most of your pay to live in a country with high crime rates, shit police, crap medical care, and to top it all off a fascist Government that has you arrested for saying a man isn't a woman.

Hibambinos · 21/10/2023 10:08

It’s actual middle earners that will benefit, as the 40% higher rate of tax starts on earnings too low . It’s no good helping the nurses etc out of poverty only to hit them with high tax. wages have risen overall but too many people go straight into higher tax despite not being able to pay their bills.

Legendairy · 21/10/2023 10:06

I totally agree that the 40% tax bracket needs to be higher, from the OP I assumed you meant the top rate which I would disagree with in principle.

The rate for 40% tax hasn't changed for years and as its used for the CB calculations it's not enough esp as not based on household income, this would include single parents. If you live in London or the South as much as people on MN love to race to the bottom it is not a big household salary. A small 2 bed house where I live would not be affordable on a single parents £55-65k salary currently as obviously everything has increased in cost now so to not realign the tax brackets accordingly is wrong.

MarathonBarbie · 21/10/2023 10:06

It (as all the ‘policies’ the Tories will float over the next year) is bollocks. They know they won’t get in so will never have to implement them.
The focus for them now is trying to reduce party infighting, gain enough votes through these ‘promises’ to avoid complete wipe out and have something to throw at government from the opposition benches. It’s a lame duck government from now until the election focussing on party not country, not good for anyone.

FrangipaniBlue · 21/10/2023 10:04

If he wants to win the election, he needs to cap profits for the energy companies and supermarkets. He needs policies that will make everyone believe, if only for the 18 months until the election, that he is in touch and does care. That he understands what it's like to choose between heat or food.

A million % this!!!

FrangipaniBlue · 21/10/2023 10:04

I'm on the fence with this one.

Of course the Tory's will do everything they can to keep the votes if the wealthy, why are you surprised?

HOWEVER, it's the 40% tax bracket they are talking about increasing so it's those earning between £50k - £125k that will benefit.

I'd argue that £50k doesn't necessarily put someone in the super rich/wealthy bracket, especially if they are the main breadwinner and they have a partner who is a SAHP. So in reality, it is the average working family who need it and will see the most benefit.

They are still only doing it for votes though!!!!

Annoyingfly · 21/10/2023 10:01

halfthesun · 21/10/2023 09:35

Tried to post a picture of the Laffer Curve 

The Laffer Curve has been much criticised by many economists. It isn't an automatic argument winner .

Annoyingfly · 21/10/2023 09:58

Overthebow · 21/10/2023 09:17

It’s the 40% threshold they’re thinking of raising, not the additional rate, so it’s people on normal salaries that will benefit. I’m being dragged into this tax band even though I work part time as the threshold has been frozen for a while now and inflation is high. Our group rarely get any help and no longer get child benefit either. This will help a lot of people.

They've bought your vote, then? Hmmmm.

KnickerlessParsons · 21/10/2023 09:57

The threshold for higher tax needs to be increased, £50-ish k is not what it was 10 years ago, the CB threshold also desperately needs changing.

Completely agree. There's not much incentive to move from £49k pa to over £50k pa unless the payrise is massive as so much of the extra pay is lost to tax.

ExtraOnions · 21/10/2023 09:46

I’m on £70k … I don’t want a tax cut, I would like the tax I pay to be spent to benefit the whole community (not just cronies of the Tories).

The one thing that really gets me is paying benefits to people in work (and working bloody hard), because the companies they work for don’t pay a living wage … but can afford to pay millions to shareholders. Using public tax to subsides shareholder payouts for private companies. Whoever sorts that out will get my vote (along with renationalising water companies & energy companies, providing affordable childcare, building council houses, and bringing in rent caps with greater protection for tenants) happy to pay tax … even higher tax.. for that

Overthebow · 21/10/2023 09:45

Yes child benefit limit should definitely be increased too.

JustFrustrated · 21/10/2023 09:37

SlipperyLizard · 21/10/2023 09:28

It would make sense to scrap the withdrawal of the personal allowance over £100k, as it causes people to pay the excess into their pension, so no tax at all is collected. I’d be happy for the 45p rate to start at 100k, but while there’s an effective tax rate of 60% only my pension benefits, not the treasury.

The child benefit limit should also be increased (or preferably scrapped, as I think it should be universal).

I agree with you

JustFrustrated · 21/10/2023 09:36

Actually, cutting/changing the tax band from 50k to higher would make a world of difference to the squeezed middle.

Without hurting the bottom line. And it would be plunged straight back into the economy. Those earning the 50+60k mark will have a disposable income again, and will want to spend it.

Also, I know a few people earning around 55k who know there is no point in getting a higher paying job unless it's a 20-30k raise, because after tax it doesn't make the extra stress and pressure worth their time.

And actually, not everyone on those salaries are spoilt rich people you know. Many of them come from backgrounds of abject poverty.

Blarn · 21/10/2023 09:36

It would benefit us. I am on a very low salary in the Civil Service but my DP earns over £50. It would not encourage either of us to vote Tory though.

baileybrosbuildingandloan · 21/10/2023 09:36

Of course he does.
"I have friends of all classes. Oh, not WORKING class though!"

B12B12 · 21/10/2023 09:35

Well I’m in the 40% bracket and I’m a humble civil servant. I would like to pass less tax but I would never ever vote Tory. It’s easy to see this for what it is - a never never bribe that few would be stupid enough to fall for.

halfthesun · 21/10/2023 09:35

Tried to post a picture of the Laffer Curve 

halfthesun · 21/10/2023 09:34



cakeorwine · 21/10/2023 09:34

I wonder what effect that will have on inflation?

Bank of England has been raising interest rates to reduce money people have.
Tax cuts increase money some people have.

bevelino · 21/10/2023 09:32

There will be all sorts of goodies promised by the government before the next election, in the hope of extra votes. If they get in again there is nothing to stop them changing their mind.

Vocaladvocaat · 21/10/2023 09:30

Ok well let me spell it out.

The Tories' core voters are middle class people in their millions and retired people. The middle class are being pinched hard, the retired have lost their faith after Covid, partygate, lies and ppc nepotism scandals. The Tories desperately need to establish they are a stable, sensible choice that appeals to EVERYONE (because MC voters do also care about WC and don't want others to suffer) whilst making choices that will favour the MC as well. They need to be in touch, to repair the damage done. To soothe wounds.

Rishi has a stable marriage and seems sensible but his wealth is very off putting. People think he is an out of touch rich person who only cares about rich people. Rishi keeps validating this by pulling stunts like the one above.

If he wants to win the election, he needs to cap profits for the energy companies and supermarkets. He needs policies that will make everyone believe, if only for the 18 months until the election, that he is in touch and does care. That he understands what it's like to choose between heat or food.

Even with this, the lack of faith is so strong that people are unlikely to believe again in a party that has cheated them and lied to them. The disillusionment is very strong.

OP posts:
SlipperyLizard · 21/10/2023 09:28

It would make sense to scrap the withdrawal of the personal allowance over £100k, as it causes people to pay the excess into their pension, so no tax at all is collected. I’d be happy for the 45p rate to start at 100k, but while there’s an effective tax rate of 60% only my pension benefits, not the treasury.

The child benefit limit should also be increased (or preferably scrapped, as I think it should be universal).

Reallybadidea · 21/10/2023 09:26

The headline is misleading because it's not the highest earners but those on the 40% band, which is middle earners really. Loads of ordinary people have been pulled into this bracket over the years because of freezing the bands.

Ffsnotaconference · 21/10/2023 09:25

That’s article is shit. Very unclear.

at least find some decent Information on it

bombastix · 21/10/2023 09:21

When are they going to do this? Before the election or promise it after?

Really. I am affected by Sunak and his freezing of tax bands but I think unless this is done before the election most people will properly say this is just rubbish. Base rate taxpayers would be outraged.

Swipe left for the next trending thread