Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rishi considers tax cut for top earners

83 replies

Vocaladvocaat · 21/10/2023 09:06

I am really trying to stay neutral here. But, faced with massive by election defeats, from a nation slammed with mortgage rises, cost of living, and inflation, The Tories are thinking about how they can reward the top earners???

Really?

Not the millions doing 60 hour weeks and struggling to pay their bills. It's this lack of awareness that is the whole problem...

Rishi Sunak considers tax cut for top earners after byelection defeats (msn.com)

MSN

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/rishi-sunak-considers-tax-cut-for-top-earners-after-byelection-defeats/ar-AA1iAFYB?ocid=msedgntp&pc=SCOOBE&cvid=904d4e5b280b4f1eaf25f9eb91a10d39&ei=14

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 22/10/2023 10:43

Same as pp above. The high rate tax band needs to be reviewed as well as the CB threshold. I am a single household and 50k is not what it was years ago. I hope Labour review it as hell would freeze over before I voted Tory.

GoldenKiwi · 22/10/2023 10:23

sekift · 21/10/2023 09:16

The threshold for higher tax needs to be increased, £50-ish k is not what it was 10 years ago, the CB threshold also desperately needs changing.

That said, whilst it would benefit me and I hope Labour consider looking at the tax thresholds for those around £50k, it wouldn't make me vote Tory.

This

bombastix · 22/10/2023 10:19

It's probably not a bad idea but this group also rely on public services like schools and healthcare. Those are in crisis. They don't care about smoking bans, A level reform or wokism sufficiently to change their day to day concerns.

The Conservatives have forgotten who they are for. High tax and bad public services is not a good offer. They need to change it but looks like they have run out of time.

DdraigGoch · 22/10/2023 10:15

Fandangoes · 21/10/2023 14:27

I wonder how this would translate to Scotland where we have to pay 42% on anything over about £43.6k That is far too low a threshold and really does make it incredibly hard justify pushing to earn over £43.6k!

You're paying a lot more than that when you factor in the lower rate of NI not coming in until £50k (as per England), so you're paying something like 55% between £43k and £50k.

DdraigGoch · 22/10/2023 10:09

CesareBorgia · 21/10/2023 10:13

I'd argue that £50k doesn't necessarily put someone in the super rich/wealthy bracket, especially if they are the main breadwinner and they have a partner who is a SAHP. So in reality, it is the average working family who need it and will see the most benefit.

Quite - you wouldn't say two people earning £25k each were a high income household, yet they will take home much more than a single parent household on £50k.

This is why I think that we should have the French system where the tax can be considered across a household rather than individually.

newmama311 · 22/10/2023 06:38

Overthebow · 21/10/2023 09:17

It’s the 40% threshold they’re thinking of raising, not the additional rate, so it’s people on normal salaries that will benefit. I’m being dragged into this tax band even though I work part time as the threshold has been frozen for a while now and inflation is high. Our group rarely get any help and no longer get child benefit either. This will help a lot of people.

Agreed. In that bracket, live in shared ownership, drive a seat, live out the freezer for half the month etc.

Fightyouforthatpie · 21/10/2023 18:07

DonnaBanana · 21/10/2023 14:58

There aren’t enough top earners by a long long loooooong way to swing any vote for them

Yeah only about 5 million people earn over £50k which wouldn’t move the needle

Depends where they are - the election will be mostly decided outside of safe seats - the "electorate" that actually makes the difference can be 50-60K (people).

RudsyFarmer · 21/10/2023 16:49

I don’t know enough about this but it seems an unpopular idea right before an election.

Barrythetimesprout · 21/10/2023 16:48

How can I put this politely?
I'm a 40% tax payer. Rishi Sunak could attempt to buy my vote by reducing my tax bill to zero and I still wouldn't vote for the slimy bastard and his party of incompetent, corrupt, self serving morons.
Sorry - I've clearly failed to find a polite way of saying that.

Fahbeep · 21/10/2023 16:44

And also the disaster of Child Benefit clawbacks at £50k to undermine the principle of universal benefits. A threshold that has never moved since that tax charge was introduced... it should be north of £65k at this point.

Fahbeep · 21/10/2023 16:42

Of course as others have said, it was Sunak's decision as Chancellor to freeze personal allowances in 2021 as inflation took off that was the real mistake. It deliberately reversed what the Coalition did to increase them in the first place between 2010-15.

Woollyguru · 21/10/2023 16:41

I wouldn't vote Tory but it makes sense to raise 40% threshold. £50k is not a high wage anymore.

Fahbeep · 21/10/2023 16:36

It's because the Tories are now crap at politics. And crap at policy. And believe in fantasies about the way to create growth through tax cuts as opposed to economic. Cooperation with our European neighbours.

Fahbeep would benefit personally from such a tax cut, but Fahbeep don't want it. Fahbeep is happy to pay tax for better services for all.

The facts are simple, after 13 years there are no public services or areas of the public realm that the Tories have strengthened. All areas of public life are damaged in deep and unbearable ways. Yet somehow the Tories have landed us in a situation where the tax take is the highest it has ever been since 1945. It is, quite simply, the worst of all worlds.

My sincere hope is that the Tories lose so many seats come the GE that the LDs become the official opposition, and politics is dragged away from the hard right and into the centre.

We can but dream...

EasternStandard · 21/10/2023 16:35

Overthebow · 21/10/2023 09:17

It’s the 40% threshold they’re thinking of raising, not the additional rate, so it’s people on normal salaries that will benefit. I’m being dragged into this tax band even though I work part time as the threshold has been frozen for a while now and inflation is high. Our group rarely get any help and no longer get child benefit either. This will help a lot of people.

Was wondering which band was meant.

Flapjacker48 · 21/10/2023 16:32

@Fandangoes Maybe higher earners in Scotland should consider, to date, massive levels of support for the SNP?

Flapjacker48 · 21/10/2023 16:29

@Fightyouforthatpie That will never happen as pensioners don't pay NI. Sadly any government is to scared of the pensioner vote to do anything which may benefit anyone else at the expense of pensioners.

Hotchocolatemousse · 21/10/2023 16:13

They need to raise the threshold for the 40% rates to at least £70k & then close the tax avoidance loopholes to recoup the tax. There are plenty of tax avoidance loopholes that could be closed to raise additional revenues. But wait why would the Tories tax themselves when they can raise the funds by taxing us instead......

bombastix · 21/10/2023 15:42

Fandangoes · 21/10/2023 14:27

I wonder how this would translate to Scotland where we have to pay 42% on anything over about £43.6k That is far too low a threshold and really does make it incredibly hard justify pushing to earn over £43.6k!

You can blame the Conservatives for a lot, but not SNP tax policy. Assuming this "change" was done next year, Scotland would remain in the same position as now.

Mind you, Sunak froze these bands as Chancellor so really, it's actually his fault we are all paying more tax.

Fionaville · 21/10/2023 15:40

The 40% hits middle earners hard, so I do think it needs raising. Still won't make me vote Tory though.

SquirrelHash · 21/10/2023 15:39

Don't worry about it. He hasn't done anything else, he won't do this either. He has literally achieved nothing.

Papyrophile · 21/10/2023 15:27

If inflation continues at the levels of this and last year, people will be paying tax on their basic state pension before 2026. There does need to be some index-linking built into the tax thresholds which were set in 2021.

kopitiamgal · 21/10/2023 15:11

Legendairy · 21/10/2023 11:16

In the South as a single parent with 2 kids just into the 40% bracket absolutely no chance if you are paying a mortgage. Maybe if you are on the higher end of that bracket. On £70k you'd be lucky to have £1k left to save. My very normal terrace 3 bed house is around £400k now so the mortgage would be ridiculous.

Exactly. Also, how to 'not' have a mortgage? Climb the property ladder.
20 years ago even in London a starter flat was quite possible on a modest entry-level salary. People then traded up. Often, they met and married someone else who also had a flat and sold both for a house, meaning they never needed to pay such a large mortgage. Quite a comfy position by the time they've worked their way up to 50K.

Someone starting out in 2023 with a graduate salary of 30K (being generous, many roles pay less and this is the national median) takes home a grand total of £1987 a month. Out of that, 1K+ on rent and bills leaving behind very little for student loans, food, and transport. Not to mention saving for a deposit or actually having a life.

A 50K salary would put them on a more even footing with their predecessors, of being able to buy a starter property. That's all. It's not untold riches.

Equally if 50K is indeed 'high' reaching it when you are much older and in need of more than a 1 bed flat doesn't make things much better.

Libertass · 21/10/2023 15:09

Following the by-election losses, Rishi is being criticised by the Telegraph (the Tory party’s own paper) and by many of his own back bench MPs who believe the current tax burden on their readers / constituents is far too high, and is a disincentive to work harder or for entrepreneurs to invest so he’s throwing them a bone to placate them.

Doesn’t mean it’s actually going to happen.

DonnaBanana · 21/10/2023 14:58

There aren’t enough top earners by a long long loooooong way to swing any vote for them

Yeah only about 5 million people earn over £50k which wouldn’t move the needle