Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be considering private school at reception?

133 replies

Aramist · 21/10/2023 08:35

We live in a small village which happens to have a really good private school 5 minute walk away. We've looked round, talked with the teachers, done our research. Loved it.

We've also looked around the nearest state school, which is a 5 minute drive away. Also a nice school, headteacher brilliant. Lots of recommendations.

The thing is, even though we can comfortably afford it, the class sizes at the private school are tiny. We're talking maybe 6 or 7 kids per year group. I think there are something like 20 (if that) kids in the whole of key stage 1. I can see that being a lovely thing, family feel and the attention my DD will get would be great, but I worry about her socially as I can see her being a quiet and sensitive child at school.

With the state school, each year group has about 30. Big classes. I work in state and have a class of 30 and it's hard work, can be chaotic and I just can't give every child the attention they deserve. I'd also worry with her potentially being quite quiet she'd get a bit 'lost' in a big class like that, but at least she'd have local friends (not necessarily in same village though).

The other issue is if we moved house. Our house isn't necessarily our forever home but we're happy for now.

I'm torn. Any words of advice?

OP posts:
Zanatdy · 21/10/2023 09:12

I wouldn’t send my child to such a small school. I personally wouldn’t waste money with a private primary either. If you want a private education I’d start at year 7. Fortunately I’ve got outstanding schools on my doorstep and my kids couldn’t have done any better results wise if they’d have gone private. I know that’s not the only reason parents pay for private but 20k ish a year for secondary is a large sum of money

Saschka · 21/10/2023 09:04

Aramist · 21/10/2023 08:51

No idea but judging from social media it seems quite mixed.
Our DD always seems to play with boys anyway!

They do at Reception age, but in Y1/2 that stops abruptly (no idea why, and it is annoying for me as I happen to be better friends with the girls’ mums).

Aramist · 21/10/2023 09:04

SprogTakesAQuarry · 21/10/2023 09:00

Do you mean adult attention? Can you explain why you find that so valuable? Especially in EYFS, but also in KS1, I would feel that quality interactions with peers was more important.

Im interested that as a teacher, you are considering this. Im a teacher, have taught private and state primary. Would def opt for state in this situation. Though the short walk would be v v tempting!

Forgive me, I am a key stage 2 teacher. I'm not experienced in EYFS.
I think I'm just so frustrated in my own class of 30 children where so many need way more support and attention that I just can't give them. I don't want that to be my daughter.

I guess in reception this is less important, of course.

OP posts:
SylvieLaufeydottir · 21/10/2023 09:02

Six children is way too small a class. It's harmful for their education on top of being socially very difficult.

Aramist · 21/10/2023 09:01

@Saschka thanks that's reassuring.

I think the right choice is the state school. I guess I'm just a bit biased as I'm very frustrated with the whole education system currently. It's such a mess.
The reception class I walked into on the open day at the state school just felt so claustrophobic and chaotic and the teachers looked shattered !

OP posts:
Thebigblueballoon · 21/10/2023 09:00

Me and my brother were sent to the local state school with classes of 25 people.
My two younger sisters were sent to an expensive private school exactly as you have described.
Guess who fared better in the long run?
Of course, I’m offering one example. But like a previous poster said, it’s far easier to move from a bigger school to a smaller one if the fit isn’t right.
I’d save my money and go for the highly rated state school.

SprogTakesAQuarry · 21/10/2023 09:00

Aramist · 21/10/2023 08:52

I think the reason I'm torn is because of the amount of attention academically she'll get in a small class. I feel like that's so valuable.

Do you mean adult attention? Can you explain why you find that so valuable? Especially in EYFS, but also in KS1, I would feel that quality interactions with peers was more important.

Im interested that as a teacher, you are considering this. Im a teacher, have taught private and state primary. Would def opt for state in this situation. Though the short walk would be v v tempting!

MariaVT65 · 21/10/2023 09:00

I would say send DD to state for now. As long as she is able to keep up with good reading skills, which i’m sure you’ll have more invovlement in anyway, reception is mostly still play.

In my personal experience, I would say save your money for private for either the later years of primary school and/or secondary school.

Saschka · 21/10/2023 08:58

30 in a year is still pretty small! That would still only be 15 girls. In terms of friendships, I’d worry that 6 children is a tiny cohort. I would run a mile from that honestly.

There are 50 in DS’s year (2x25 classes), and he knows everyone, has plenty of friends, the teachers and headteacher all know him by name (the headmaster came up to say hi to him in the park over summer). He really hasn’t been lost at all, and he is a shy gentle boy who wouldn’t push himself forwards.

Aramist · 21/10/2023 08:57

shouldhavetakenmorenotice · 21/10/2023 08:54

It really depends on what your village is like. If the school will be the only chance of making friends then it could be an issue. But if the village has other options to be social then you don't need to worry so much.

My son doesn't go to the village primary but we have a nice local pub and a cricket club so he got chance to make friends with the village kids there.

We know alot of people in the village. We go to the pub quite alot and there's a good community feel. Events on at the village hall.
Not loads of kids, but we're gradually getting to know other families.
Interestingly quite a few in the village that go to the private school, but mostly older.

We have friends who live in the next village with similar age children.

It's not too bad.

OP posts:
SprogTakesAQuarry · 21/10/2023 08:57

40 kids in Y10 is very very small. Socially, that’s very tough but also numbers like that mean that GCSE choices can be limited, opportunities for team sports, etc. In a secondary that small, you will find a lot of lessons delivered by non-specialist teachers. It just won’t be affordable.

With numbers that small across the whole school, I wouldn’t assume it was financially viable.

Ace56 · 21/10/2023 08:55

Definitely go with the state school. Do what everyone else seems to be doing and put her in the private school for secondary when the classes are bigger and the school is a bit more established.

Academics aren’t that important in KS1 - much more important is the social aspect and learning to cope in the big bad world without mummy. The state school would prepare her more for that.

Aramist · 21/10/2023 08:54

TheaBrandt · 21/10/2023 08:51

Private / state aside that class is too small. A family member had a miserable time trapped with mean girls for years in a tiny village primary as there were literally no other friendship options.

Yea I do worry about that.

OP posts:
shouldhavetakenmorenotice · 21/10/2023 08:54

It really depends on what your village is like. If the school will be the only chance of making friends then it could be an issue. But if the village has other options to be social then you don't need to worry so much.

My son doesn't go to the village primary but we have a nice local pub and a cricket club so he got chance to make friends with the village kids there.

Aramist · 21/10/2023 08:52

I think the reason I'm torn is because of the amount of attention academically she'll get in a small class. I feel like that's so valuable.

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 21/10/2023 08:51

Private / state aside that class is too small. A family member had a miserable time trapped with mean girls for years in a tiny village primary as there were literally no other friendship options.

Aramist · 21/10/2023 08:51

JMSA · 21/10/2023 08:49

Also, what's the boy:girl ratio in these tiny classes? Realistically, that could also hamper friendships even more.

No idea but judging from social media it seems quite mixed.
Our DD always seems to play with boys anyway!

OP posts:
JMSA · 21/10/2023 08:49

Also, what's the boy:girl ratio in these tiny classes? Realistically, that could also hamper friendships even more.

MintJulia · 21/10/2023 08:47

My ds went to a state primary with a yearly intake of 15. It was fine for reception and yr 1 but by year 2, the lack of choice of friends was already a restriction on ds. By yr 6 he was pretty bored and frustrated.

Aramist · 21/10/2023 08:47

MidnightOnceMore · 21/10/2023 08:43

I would never send my kids to a tiny school. Any bullying problems are amplified and it is socially limiting. Private schools are more socially limited in general.

I specifically chose a bigger primary to give a big range of possible friends. It worked very well.

Yea good points. Part of me thinks though that surely bullying would be far more noticeable in a small group and would be stamped out quicker?

OP posts:
sittinginacafe · 21/10/2023 08:46

A class of 6 is way too small. Having had my kids in a one form primary (30/class) I’d even say that’s too small. I really don’t think it helps (most) people to exist only in such tiny groups, unless they have serious sensory needs.
Without doubt I’d go for the state option!

Peachespeachesohpeaches · 21/10/2023 08:44

I wouldn't want my DD to be in a class of 6 - what if there's a falling out? What if they don't get on with the other kids? It's also very noticeable if they are behind/not as good at an area as other children. At least in a class of 30 you'll generally get a mixed bunch.

Surely an intake of 6/7 children per year isn't sustainable for the school. I'd be concerned about finances and what that means if the school closes.

MidnightOnceMore · 21/10/2023 08:43

I would never send my kids to a tiny school. Any bullying problems are amplified and it is socially limiting. Private schools are more socially limited in general.

I specifically chose a bigger primary to give a big range of possible friends. It worked very well.

Aramist · 21/10/2023 08:43

GrazingSheep · 21/10/2023 08:39

A class of 6 or 7 is tiny. Not much scope for varied friendships.
Is the school financially viable?

Weirdly I don't know. I think they get their money from the older kids. From about year 5 onwards the year groups are much bigger. A local friend has a daughter in year 10 and there's 40 in that group.
I think the lower juniors is small because everyone thinks it's too small so send their kids state until year 6 then go private.

Secondary schools around here aren't great.

OP posts:
Chalkdowns · 21/10/2023 08:42

I don’t think it’s ideal to have so few children in a reception class. My kids went private but they had 16 at the least. And they needed that many to find a few friends they really loved.

You could always move schools later