Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be considering private school at reception?

133 replies

Aramist · 21/10/2023 08:35

We live in a small village which happens to have a really good private school 5 minute walk away. We've looked round, talked with the teachers, done our research. Loved it.

We've also looked around the nearest state school, which is a 5 minute drive away. Also a nice school, headteacher brilliant. Lots of recommendations.

The thing is, even though we can comfortably afford it, the class sizes at the private school are tiny. We're talking maybe 6 or 7 kids per year group. I think there are something like 20 (if that) kids in the whole of key stage 1. I can see that being a lovely thing, family feel and the attention my DD will get would be great, but I worry about her socially as I can see her being a quiet and sensitive child at school.

With the state school, each year group has about 30. Big classes. I work in state and have a class of 30 and it's hard work, can be chaotic and I just can't give every child the attention they deserve. I'd also worry with her potentially being quite quiet she'd get a bit 'lost' in a big class like that, but at least she'd have local friends (not necessarily in same village though).

The other issue is if we moved house. Our house isn't necessarily our forever home but we're happy for now.

I'm torn. Any words of advice?

OP posts:
mynameiscalypso · 21/10/2023 09:42

My main concern would be the viability of the private school with such small classes and the potential scrapping of VAT if Labour win the next election. I'd be worried about scrabbling to find a new school in a couple of years. For what it's worth, my summer born, quite and speech delayed reception starter has absolutely thrived in his state school albeit they seem to have quite a few staff so he gets lots of individual attention too.

Writingwrite888 · 21/10/2023 09:42

JMSA · 21/10/2023 09:40

@Aramist

The composite classes at such an early stage would be a hard no from me.

Why? There’s been a lot of research about how they’re really great for children. I’ll dig some out.

Aramist · 21/10/2023 09:41

jeaux90 · 21/10/2023 09:38

From what you just said I will say this to you, I think she will sink in a class of 30. If she's quiet and delayed. Mine did and I wish I'd pulled the trigger on private school earlier. She is now flourishing.

I'm inclined to agree. I had the exact thought before posting this.

I feel like she'll be in that 'coasting middle' part of the class. Quietly gets on while the teacher sits with and deals with the disruptive or those with SEN.

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 21/10/2023 09:41

Shame there isn’t a middle ground. One school sounds too big and chaotic the other too small and intense. Personally would prioritise a nice deep friendship pool.

The teaching at my village primary school was pretty shit yet many ex pupils have done incredibly well Oxbridge etc always made me wonder how valuable those early years actually are educationally.

jeaux90 · 21/10/2023 09:40

Is behaviour out of control in a lot of schools? http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4836123-is-behaviour-out-of-control-in-a-lot-of-schools

Read this OP. I'd go private, I do go private.

JMSA · 21/10/2023 09:40

@Aramist

The composite classes at such an early stage would be a hard no from me.

jeaux90 · 21/10/2023 09:38

Aramist · 21/10/2023 09:30

@jeaux90 it's difficult. Our DD is quite a quiet, sensible sort. She doesn't seem to be academically behind or ahead but her speech has been a bit delayed.
I can see her being the sort of child who is 'left out' easily but I also can't see her being the sort to have a big friendship group. I can see her sticking to 1 or 2 good friends, very much like I was at school.

From what you just said I will say this to you, I think she will sink in a class of 30. If she's quiet and delayed. Mine did and I wish I'd pulled the trigger on private school earlier. She is now flourishing.

Writingwrite888 · 21/10/2023 09:37

Aramist · 21/10/2023 09:32

Honestly deep down I think that's how I feel as well.
It's why I'm so torn ! I want to do what's right for my DD.
I have spoken to someone who has a son in year 2 at the private school and has been since reception and has absolutely thrived.

Honestly go for it. You’ve seen them both, go for your gut feeling.

She’s really little. You can move her later if it doesn’t work for her. The added bonus is that it’s your local school!

Better they start somewhere gentle when they’re little, in my opinion.

Aramist · 21/10/2023 09:36

@Writingwrite888 cross posted a bit there !

OP posts:
Aramist · 21/10/2023 09:36

WaxingGibbon · 21/10/2023 09:34

Exactly this. And I've seen it so many times.

Yea good points. Part of me thinks though that surely bullying would be far more noticeable in a small group and would be stamped out quicker?

Not necessarily OP, unfortunately. In your position I'd start off at the larger state primary and review after a few years.

I would argue though that at big schools bullying can quite easily happen under the radar and can be far more challenging to deal with with fewer resources to do so.

OP posts:
Writingwrite888 · 21/10/2023 09:34

Oganesson118 · 21/10/2023 09:25

I think small class sizes are a bit of a risk. Academically it sounds lovely but if the child finds themself bullied, not quite fitting in then they're isolated with no opportunity to find a new group of friends. My daughter is in a one form entry of 25 and even that's too small for my liking given some of the issues we can see emerging.

It’s worse when you’re bullied in a class of 30 with over stretched teachers who don’t know how to handle it.

You can’t bullet-proof a bullying scenario. And - in theory - a small, nurturing school would be able to deal with it better purely because they have the resources to.

WaxingGibbon · 21/10/2023 09:34

MidnightOnceMore · 21/10/2023 08:43

I would never send my kids to a tiny school. Any bullying problems are amplified and it is socially limiting. Private schools are more socially limited in general.

I specifically chose a bigger primary to give a big range of possible friends. It worked very well.

Exactly this. And I've seen it so many times.

Yea good points. Part of me thinks though that surely bullying would be far more noticeable in a small group and would be stamped out quicker?

Not necessarily OP, unfortunately. In your position I'd start off at the larger state primary and review after a few years.

Aramist · 21/10/2023 09:33

JMSA · 21/10/2023 09:32

OP, do I understand that there are composite classes? I've worked in those and no way would I be paying for it!

Only at the bottom. Single year groups from year 2 up to year 11.

OP posts:
JMSA · 21/10/2023 09:32

OP, do I understand that there are composite classes? I've worked in those and no way would I be paying for it!

Aramist · 21/10/2023 09:32

Writingwrite888 · 21/10/2023 09:29

I disagree. I’d choose the private. It sounds lovely and small class sizes are great.

You wouldn’t believe the amount of older children I know who have problems at state. Of course lots of children are happy, but if you can afford it and it’s a five min walk away, go for the lovely private. A walk is better than a drive, and a small class is better than a big one.

Honestly deep down I think that's how I feel as well.
It's why I'm so torn ! I want to do what's right for my DD.
I have spoken to someone who has a son in year 2 at the private school and has been since reception and has absolutely thrived.

OP posts:
Aramist · 21/10/2023 09:30

@jeaux90 it's difficult. Our DD is quite a quiet, sensible sort. She doesn't seem to be academically behind or ahead but her speech has been a bit delayed.
I can see her being the sort of child who is 'left out' easily but I also can't see her being the sort to have a big friendship group. I can see her sticking to 1 or 2 good friends, very much like I was at school.

OP posts:
Writingwrite888 · 21/10/2023 09:29

Aramist · 21/10/2023 09:01

@Saschka thanks that's reassuring.

I think the right choice is the state school. I guess I'm just a bit biased as I'm very frustrated with the whole education system currently. It's such a mess.
The reception class I walked into on the open day at the state school just felt so claustrophobic and chaotic and the teachers looked shattered !

I disagree. I’d choose the private. It sounds lovely and small class sizes are great.

You wouldn’t believe the amount of older children I know who have problems at state. Of course lots of children are happy, but if you can afford it and it’s a five min walk away, go for the lovely private. A walk is better than a drive, and a small class is better than a big one.

jeaux90 · 21/10/2023 09:27

My DD14 went to a small private school after year 6. I really wish I'd sent her to private prep now too.

The key thing though is about your child what she is like.

My Dd has hugely benefited from the small classes and it being single sex and is flourishing but I feel she played two years of catch up after being in classes of 30 at state primary.

My DD is ND though she has ADHD so the small classes are a massive benefit.

Aramist · 21/10/2023 09:25

OneLittleFinger · 21/10/2023 09:24

Do they teach one year per class or are they combined? I went to a private school and have worked in schools where the year sizes are tiny and I think a combination of the two would be terrible, especially if the clad sizes are actually that tiny. I've known a class with only one girl which was possibly better than the one with two who were liable to fall out at any second. The only saving grace was that they were taught with other year groups so there were other girls to socialise with.

Combined.

This year it's reception/year 1. About 12 in the class I think.
Then a year 2 class next door with maybe 8 or 9 I think.

I think they come together alot for playtimes etc.

OP posts:
Oganesson118 · 21/10/2023 09:25

I think small class sizes are a bit of a risk. Academically it sounds lovely but if the child finds themself bullied, not quite fitting in then they're isolated with no opportunity to find a new group of friends. My daughter is in a one form entry of 25 and even that's too small for my liking given some of the issues we can see emerging.

OneLittleFinger · 21/10/2023 09:24

Do they teach one year per class or are they combined? I went to a private school and have worked in schools where the year sizes are tiny and I think a combination of the two would be terrible, especially if the clad sizes are actually that tiny. I've known a class with only one girl which was possibly better than the one with two who were liable to fall out at any second. The only saving grace was that they were taught with other year groups so there were other girls to socialise with.

Aramist · 21/10/2023 09:19

@Saschka yea that's true.
I think deep down she'd be fine at the state school.
Something just seems to be clawing at me about the private school.

OP posts:
PutWoodInHoleDuck · 21/10/2023 09:19

Aramist · 21/10/2023 08:51

No idea but judging from social media it seems quite mixed.
Our DD always seems to play with boys anyway!

It'll be luck of the draw with her year group though. I had a class of 20 once that had 2 girls; in one of the year groups there were none at all.

Saschka · 21/10/2023 09:12

The reception class I walked into on the open day at the state school just felt so claustrophobic and chaotic and the teachers looked shattered!

I think that is just what looking after a group of four year olds is like! I looked like that after DS’s birthday parties, and that was only ever 15 kids for two hours.

DS’s reception class also always felt like managed chaos with kids running about everywhere, but he finished the year reading on blue book band (could just about recognise and copy his name when he started) so they were obviously doing something right.

coodawoodashooda · 21/10/2023 09:12

State school with extra money for tuition